Bentham Editor In Chief Quits after Jones article

Bentham employs more than one editor.

So to undersand your view, if there is more than one editor on an "Explosive paper" you don't have to let the every editor in the field of expertise know about said paper...

Bottom line, she quit for a reason. Ether she quit because they should have told her and they didn't (As she says) or she quit because she didn't like the paper and is lying about her reason to quit. Both reasons are bad for the paper and the journal. I don't see the difference.
 
Great bit on the New Scientist today about just how reputable and rigorous Bentham are:

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn17288-spoof-paper-accepted-by-peerreviewed-journal.html

"Davis teamed up with Kent Anderson, a member of the publishing team at The New England Journal of Medicine, to put Bentham's editorial standards to the test. The pair turned to SCIgen, a program that generates nonsensical computer science papers, and submitted the resulting paper to The Open Information Science Journal, published by Bentham."

Guess what happened next...
 
Great bit on the New Scientist today about just how reputable and rigorous Bentham are:

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn17288-spoof-paper-accepted-by-peerreviewed-journal.html

"Davis teamed up with Kent Anderson, a member of the publishing team at The New England Journal of Medicine, to put Bentham's editorial standards to the test. The pair turned to SCIgen, a program that generates nonsensical computer science papers, and submitted the resulting paper to The Open Information Science Journal, published by Bentham."

Guess what happened next...

Ha! Absolutely brilliant. Poor twoofers.
 
Great bit on the New Scientist today about just how reputable and rigorous Bentham are:

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn17288-spoof-paper-accepted-by-peerreviewed-journal.html

"Davis teamed up with Kent Anderson, a member of the publishing team at The New England Journal of Medicine, to put Bentham's editorial standards to the test. The pair turned to SCIgen, a program that generates nonsensical computer science papers, and submitted the resulting paper to The Open Information Science Journal, published by Bentham."

Guess what happened next...

:jaw-dropp

With lines like these in the paper:

In this section, we discuss existing research into red-black trees, vacuum tubes, and courseware [10]. On a similar note, recent work by Takahashi suggests a methodology for providing robust modalities, but does not offer an implementation [9].

You'd think someone would catch on!

But no....
 
Great bit on the New Scientist today about just how reputable and rigorous Bentham are:

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn17288-spoof-paper-accepted-by-peerreviewed-journal.html

"Davis teamed up with Kent Anderson, a member of the publishing team at The New England Journal of Medicine, to put Bentham's editorial standards to the test. The pair turned to SCIgen, a program that generates nonsensical computer science papers, and submitted the resulting paper to The Open Information Science Journal, published by Bentham."

Guess what happened next...

Well there you have it. I think that about says it all. Cannot say I am surprised.

nice find.

TAM:)
 
Great bit on the New Scientist today about just how reputable and rigorous Bentham are:

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn17288-spoof-paper-accepted-by-peerreviewed-journal.html

"Davis teamed up with Kent Anderson, a member of the publishing team at The New England Journal of Medicine, to put Bentham's editorial standards to the test. The pair turned to SCIgen, a program that generates nonsensical computer science papers, and submitted the resulting paper to The Open Information Science Journal, published by Bentham."

Guess what happened next...

Publish this at 911Blogger so you can get banned for spreading truth.
Like Mickey Mouse signing up as an engineer at Gages club of idiot thinkers on 911 issues; Bentham pay to publish woo journal is alive and kicking.
 
Last edited:
Well I'd say this is the final nail in the coffin for Bentham but I have a feeling a few more nails will be driven into it before its well and truly destroyed.
 
Great bit on the New Scientist today about just how reputable and rigorous Bentham are:

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn17288-spoof-paper-accepted-by-peerreviewed-journal.html

"Davis teamed up with Kent Anderson, a member of the publishing team at The New England Journal of Medicine, to put Bentham's editorial standards to the test. The pair turned to SCIgen, a program that generates nonsensical computer science papers, and submitted the resulting paper to The Open Information Science Journal, published by Bentham."

Guess what happened next...

Davis and Anderson have committed academic fraud. Amazing how the people here cheer the fraud.
 
Davis and Anderson, writing under the noms de plume David Phillips and Andrew Kent, also dropped a hefty hint of the hoax by giving their institutional affiliation as the Center for Research in Applied Phrenology, or CRAP.


:dl: :dl: :dl:
 
So that leaves an opening for a group of phony-balony vanity scientific journals? And all I have to do is create a website, charge $600/page (12pt double-spaced Courier eats up LOTS of pages), and toss onto it any cr*p someone with a valid credit card sends me? SWEET! I was looking for a second source of income. :D
 
Great bit on the New Scientist today about just how reputable and rigorous Bentham are:

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn17288-spoof-paper-accepted-by-peerreviewed-journal.html

"Davis teamed up with Kent Anderson, a member of the publishing team at The New England Journal of Medicine, to put Bentham's editorial standards to the test. The pair turned to SCIgen, a program that generates nonsensical computer science papers, and submitted the resulting paper to The Open Information Science Journal, published by Bentham."

Guess what happened next...

Excellent find! I am posting to SLC as the lead post for Friday.
 
Latest: http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn17288-crap-paper-accepted-by-journal.html

"Mahmood Alam, Bentham's director of publications, responded to queries from New Scientist by email: "In this particular case we were aware that the article submitted was a hoax, and we tried to find out the identity of the individual by pretending the article had been accepted for publication when in fact it was not."


Riiiigggghhhhhtttt.....
 
Davis and Anderson have committed academic fraud. Amazing how the people here cheer the fraud.

It is done all the time. Investigative journalism. Testing security at airports, secret cameras to catch pediphiles, you name it...it is done, it is valid, stop complaining about it, and admit that Bentham Open Access Journals are the real frauds.

TAM:)
 
"Mahmood Alam, Bentham's director of publications, responded to queries from New Scientist by email: "In this particular case we were aware that the article submitted was a hoax, and we tried to find out the identity of the individual by pretending the article had been accepted for publication when in fact it was not."

Now that's comedy.

Just to review, Mr. Alam is the exact same person who greenlit the first "Fourteen Points" paper in the Bentham Open Civil Engineering Journal, just in case anyone tries to make the claim that the above hijinks involve a totally separate Journal. He's pretty much the only guy running the show.
 
Davis and Anderson have committed academic fraud. Amazing how the people here cheer the fraud.
.

Not even close...!!

They have EXPOSED academic fraud. More than that, they have exposed gross, incompetent, blatantly obvious academic fraud.

Exactly as police run sting operations.

In this case, based on the "subtlety" of the paper, they had a "bait car" with about six cops sitting on the hood, and their patrol cars parked with their lights flashing.

And Bentham STILL stole the car...!!

Mind boggling...

tom
 
.

Not even close...!!

They have EXPOSED academic fraud. More than that, they have exposed gross, incompetent, blatantly obvious academic fraud.

Exactly as police run sting operations.

In this case, based on the "subtlety" of the paper, they had a "bait car" with about six cops sitting on the hood, and their patrol cars parked with their lights flashing.

And Bentham STILL stole the car...!!

Mind boggling...

tom

That's absolutely the point. It's also worth mentioning that one of the reasons they didn't go all the way to publication is because that would have crossed the line. That and not wanting to waste $800...

But whichever way, this is just the self-restoring nature of science in action yet again. I think it exposes beautifully the complete lack of standards Benthem Open have; it's not evident the manuscript had even been read, much less peer-reviewed.
 
I like how the intentionally phony paper is already getting more attention in the scientific community than Jones' "nano-thermite" paper ever did.
 
"On a similar note, recent work by Takahashi suggests a methodology for providing robust modalities, but does not offer an implementation [9]."

Damn that Takahashi! Methodology is NOT sufficient. We MUST HAVE implementation. :mad:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom