“Johnny Karate” at JREF made and apt observation:
“I like how the intentionally phony paper is already getting more attention in the scientific community than Jones' "nano-thermite" paper ever did”
Quite true as far as I know, over two months after its release, the only attention the Harrit/Jones paper has received in the scientific community / press was in the Danish science news site
http://videnskab.dk/ when it reported on the resignation of the editor-in-chief. I think debunkers were wrong to dismiss all pay to publish open journals a small number it seems are serious. The Peter Suber blog entry includes several links to other articles. Bentham was already a a bit of a pariah among OA publishers this seems to have sealed its ill repute.
Update. Klaus Graf calls for a boycott of Bentham. See his comments in German or Google's English.
Update. Also see Paul Basken's article on the Chronicle of Higher Education News Blog. The comment section is starting to grow.
Update. JURN, the search engine for OA journals in the arts and humanities, has stopped indexing Bentham journals.
Update. Tom Wilson argues that the Bentham scandal is another reason to prefer no-fee OA journals.
Update (6/11/09). Peter Aldhous in New Scientist reviews similar hoaxes in which journals or conferences were caught accepting outright nonsense.
Update (6/11/09). Also see Norman Oder's article in Library Journal.
Update (6/11/09). The Open Access Scholarly Publishers Association (OASPA) points out several ways in which practices at Bentham Science appear to fall short of the association's code of conduct, and that Bentham is not a member of OASPA.
http://www.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/2009/06/hoax-exposes-incompetence-or-worse-at.html
See also
http://pipeline.corante.com/archive...raving_nonsense_is_slated_for_publication.php
http://www.boston.com/news/health/blog/2009/06/phony_paper_tes.html
http://libcom.org/blog/hoax-academic-articles-problems-open-access-it-exists-11062009
http://staringatemptypages.blogspot.com/2009/06/scientific-garbage-enablers.html
The total number of academics who had made negative comments about Bentham Open is probably over 50. The consensus is that there are only a small number of reputable pay to publish open journals and Bentham Open definitely is NOT among them OR that such journals (especially for profit ones) are inherently suspect. The only positive comments I’ve seen about the publisher’s “open” journals are the two on their site without links or indications as to the source. One it is true was from a Nobel laureate but the other is from one of their own, not especially well known, editors-in-chief.
Thought some truthers including ones here seem to have their heads in the sand about this the gravity of this was not lost on a few posters at 911 Blogger:
“This posting [an article about the incident] is going to be some bad news” – rebel patriot
“This is not good.” – zombie bill hicks
“It seems that none of the sites publishing this story have attacked the nano-thermite paper. That doesn't mean it isn't good ammunition for those who want to denounce it. In my opinion anyway.” – Jon Gold
“I agree. I haven't seen anyone linking this to the thermite papers, or others, but the direct implications are crystal clear. I saw it and immediately I knew this was going to be a problem.”– rebel patriot
“So much has been gained by the gaining of peer review works that question what happened, and now we have the publishing house falling into disrepute because an article got through that was a hoax.” – rebel patriot
http://www.911blogger.com/node/20378
Jones dropped in to reasure the faithful but typically deals in half truths.
Bentham Science publishes a large number of journals, a quick google search gives this info:
"Bentham Science Publishers Ltd. Home Page
"A major STM journal publisher of 92 online and print journals, 200 plus open accessjournals, and related print/online book series, "
Each journal has an a different editorial board, as far as I can see. So an error by someone on ONE of 200-plus journals has very close to zero bearing on what is published in the other 200 journals. The problem was not in the Open Chemical Physics Journal.
Further, our paper was reviewed prior to publication by the Physics dept. chair at BYU -- and he approved it for publication. His peer-review was NOT under the auspices of Bentham. (This peer-review was done because two of the authors are from this dept. at BYU... and Dr. Farrer requested the review.)
I think debunkers will look for any way to criticize the Active Thermitic Material paper without actually dealing with doing experiments or papers themselves. Our results are based on experiment, not on who published the results.
"Each journal has an a different editorial board, as far as I can see. So an error by someone on ONE of 200-plus journals has very close to zero bearing on what is published in the other 200 journals."
Not relevaant since as he is well aware the editorial boards don't really run the show Bentham's Pakistan office does. hacks with NO specialisation in the subject matter choose the referees. People in the same office they asked people to be authors in, board members of or even editor's in cheif of journals outside their specialty
"Further, our paper was reviewed prior to publication by the Physics dept. chair at BYU"
But we have no idea what sort of minimal standards they set.
"I think debunkers will look for any way to criticize the Active Thermitic Material paper without actually dealing with doing experiments or papers themselves. "
Truther love this trick. Jones has engaged in it as well. When debunkers critique the paper's data and conclusions they say 'it was peer review, any critique that wasn't doesn't count' when we point out the peer review is suspect they say 'debunk the paper'