Bentham Editor In Chief Quits after Jones article

are you a Marxist? You think $600 is hefty? That doesn't even begin to cover the costs of peer review or website maintainance.

I pay less than $5 a month for my site. Unless there is code to change every month I suspect there is little monthly cost. As far as peer review goes, admitedly I don't know what the price of a rubber stamp is these days. I would have to guess less than $600.
 
That's routine for peer reviewed papers. Hello? Anybody in there?

But it's already been established that THIS paper did not follow "routine". Hello? Anybody in there? Didn't you read the first post?
 
I pay less than $5 a month for my site. Unless there is code to change every month I suspect there is little monthly cost. As far as peer review goes, admitedly I don't know what the price of a rubber stamp is these days. I would have to guess less than $600.

No, it wasn't a rubber stamp. You may believe that. But the paper was first submitted last August and was peer reviewed for 8 months, much longer than normal, because it was such an explosive paper.
 
Only amongst truthers. In real-world scientific circles, indexing services such as Thompson ISI spend half their time working out impact ratings and such like for credible journals that conform to a given level of quality and integrity. The fact that they won't go anywhere near any of Benthem Open's offerings (that I can find) speaks volumes.

I was just going to ask for Bentham's impact ratings. Thanks. Can't say I'm surprised.
 
No, it wasn't a rubber stamp. You may believe that. But the paper was first submitted last August and was peer reviewed for 8 months, much longer than normal, because it was such an explosive paper.

So what you're saying is that this "explosive paper" was peer reviewed for much longer than the average but the editor wasn't told about it? The editor wasn't told about an "explosive paper" being published in the editors journal... It just doesn't add up. (assuming the article is true)

If you were an editor of a journal, do you think you should be told of an "explosive paper" coming out in said journal? If you weren't told, what does that say about the paper? Why would they hold that information from you?

I understand perfectly why the editor would want to focus on not being told. If she says it was the paper she gets hounded by truthers.
 
Self-contradiction with regards to the dust paper? Its not about chemistry or chemical physics but she can't judge whether the article is good or bad?
:lolsign:

Maybe she can, maybe she can't. Who knows. She didn't say enough to know. But others can, and have demonstrated why it's bad.

So why did she quit? She wasn't consulted. Of course nothing to do with the science of the paper. It does appear she wasn't too happy about the implications of the results.

It's true that she quit over not being consulted. She said as much. And you're right that she's not happy with the implications of the results. Shoddy science being used to forward conspiratorial fantasies should engender that doubt in any rational scientist. So that's good.

After all, why can't terrorists get into a building to plant thermitic materials? They truck bombed in '93.

Why you equate parking a single vehicle in a garage and walking away from it with planting incendiaries on structural elements inaccessible without major construction work is beyond me. But, the truth movement was long ago reduced to proffering such unrealistic scenarios to make their proposals "work", so I guess I shouldn't be surprised.

They were able to bypass all sorts of security measures entering and leaving the country and entering and leaving the airports, etc.

Yes... walking through metal detectors with legally permissible knives and boxcutters was truly special work. And entering an airport when they had plane tickets and identification... wow.

They were able to bypass the nation's air defense. But can't get into a building to rig it? Nobody gives these terrorists enough credit.

How many years have you been here? And you, of all people, are still trying to pass the "bypass the nation's air defense" chestnut around? Time to go back to basics, Swing:
You should remember that the search feature, as well as the sticky links at the top of this subforum, are proof against the tired tactic of bringing up long disproven myths as if they've never been refuted. I can understand a new truther not realizing this, but you've had your butt handed to you too many times to not understand the pitfalls of doing so.

New readers, new members, etc.: Feel free to search the archives and click the links I've provided. Those are some truly old myths that Swing Dangler is presenting at the end there. Understand that even experienced conspiracy peddlers like Swing here have very little new to offer. I can't think of any claim that hasn't already been addressed in some fashion at some point in the past. Don't trust me; go look for yourselves.
 
But it's already been established that THIS paper did not follow "routine". Hello? Anybody in there? Didn't you read the first post?

Nothing has been established except in your mind.

A different editor had the paper published.
 
So what you're saying is that this "explosive paper" was peer reviewed for much longer than the average but the editor wasn't told about it? The editor wasn't told about an "explosive paper" being published in the editors journal... It just doesn't add up. (assuming the article is true)

If you were an editor of a journal, do you think you should be told of an "explosive paper" coming out in said journal? If you weren't told, what does that say about the paper? Why would they hold that information from you?

I understand perfectly why the editor would want to focus on not being told. If she says it was the paper she gets hounded by truthers.

Bentham employs more than one editor.
 
more JREF drivel.

Please direct us to a peer reviewed scientific paper that shows even one "error" or "incorrect conclusion".

There's Henry62's article. This has been read and reviewed by his peers within the bloggosphere. You might claim that this isn't in a credible scientific journal. But then I could say the same about Jones' material and we'd be equally correct.

Besides, I hate to rob your of your security blanket, but even being in a peer-reviewed paper in a real journal doesn't make something fact. That is one vital step on the way to recognition. The second step is typically for someone else to independently replicate the result. Given that Jones is very unlikely to ever release his samples, I don't see it getting any further.
 
more JREF drivel.

Please direct us to a peer reviewed scientific paper that shows even one "error" or "incorrect conclusion".
Show us a real peer-reviewed paper in a respected journal that supports Jone's paper. Hint: The Bentham open journals are not in that category.
 
There's Henry62's article. This has been read and reviewed by his peers within the bloggosphere. You might claim that this isn't in a credible scientific journal. But then I could say the same about Jones' material and we'd be equally correct.

Besides, I hate to rob your of your security blanket, but even being in a peer-reviewed paper in a real journal doesn't make something fact. That is one vital step on the way to recognition. The second step is typically for someone else to independently replicate the result. Given that Jones is very unlikely to ever release his samples, I don't see it getting any further.

That so-called paper has already been debunked. No legitimate scientific journal will print it.
 
Show us a real peer-reviewed paper in a respected journal that supports Jone's paper. Hint: The Bentham open journals are not in that category.

Harrit's peer reviewed paper confirmed Jones' peer reviewed paper of 2005.
 
No, qualified scientists confirmed that it was nano-thermite, confirming that the by-products of a thermite reaction were indeed created by nano-thermite.

Hang on... did you say 'qualified'? So having a background in looking for evidence of muon-catalysed (cold) fusion based on neutron measurements makes you an authority on looking for traces of largely hypothetical explosives based on electron microscopy?

Actually, put like that...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom