Bentham Editor In Chief Quits after Jones article

Well, there goes another nail into the coffin of Benthem's credibility; the idea of an article being published without an editor's say-so would be unthinkable to most journals. Funny that the writers of the article couldn't get in touch with the publishers.

I've already said it on a different thread, but I'll say it again; if anyone is thinking of getting a rebuttal of Jones' work published, you could much better than to send it to that cowboy outfit. You may as well write it on the side of a cow with a sharpie for all the scientific weight it'll carry.
 
Jones is only the third author, and no, he is not part of an insideous conspiracy. You believe that, I know.

Cripes, you didn't read the article:

"The Niels Harrit co Steve Jones who has been in charge of contacts with Bentham, and so is the Danish researcher not offhand know what the editor responsible under the group have communicated with."

Ha, Harrit threw Jonesy under the bus.
 
Well, there goes another nail into the coffin of Benthem's credibility; the idea of an article being published without an editor's say-so would be unthinkable to most journals. Funny that the writers of the article couldn't get in touch with the publishers.

I've already said it on a different thread, but I'll say it again; if anyone is thinking of getting a rebuttal of Jones' work published, you could much better than to send it to that cowboy outfit. You may as well write it on the side of a cow with a sharpie for all the scientific weight it'll carry.

The article was first submitted back in August, eight months ago. It went through a rigorous peer review by four PhDs and had to be re-written three times.
 
The article was first submitted back in August, eight months ago. It went through a rigorous peer review by four PhDs and had to be re-written three times.

Who were those people with PhDs, and can we have access to their critique of the original paper?
 
Last edited:
The article was first submitted back in August, eight months ago. It went through a rigorous peer review by four PhDs and had to be re-written three times.
And they still got it wrong. Go figure. :rolleyes:
 
Bentham has a reputation for quality, not quantity.

Only amongst truthers. In real-world scientific circles, indexing services such as Thompson ISI spend half their time working out impact ratings and such like for credible journals that conform to a given level of quality and integrity. The fact that they won't go anywhere near any of Benthem Open's offerings (that I can find) speaks volumes.
 
Peer reviewers are supposed to read the article, not editors. .

Only at Bentham. It is my understanding editors normally read papers before submiting them to the reviewers, reviewers they, not the commercial publisher have chosen

The editor is not qualified to evaluate the paper

That's part of the problem:

"I can not accept that the issue is put in my journal. The article is not about physical chemistry or chemical physics, and I could well believe that there is a political point of view behind the publication. If anyone had asked me, I would say that the article should never have been published in this journal. "

She is however a leading expert in nanometerials. Saying she isn't qualified may be a polite way of avoiding saying it's crap.

, nor are you

Truthers talent for unintentional irony nver ceases to amaze me.
 
The article was first submitted back in August, eight months ago. It went through a rigorous peer review by four PhDs and had to be re-written three times.

I'd hate to have seen the initial submission in that case!

That just makes it sound even worse - most journal articles I'm aware of rarely get to go through two rounds of reviews without getting either accepted or rejected. To do so without an editor getting involved would be lunacy. It almost sounds as if the publishers capitulated for the sake of getting their page charges.
 
Only at Bentham. It is my understanding editors normally read papers before submiting them to the reviewers, reviewers they, not the commercial publisher have chosen



That's part of the problem:

"I can not accept that the issue is put in my journal. The article is not about physical chemistry or chemical physics, and I could well believe that there is a political point of view behind the publication. If anyone had asked me, I would say that the article should never have been published in this journal. "

She is however a leading expert in nanometerials. Saying she isn't qualified may be a polite way of avoiding saying it's crap.



Truthers talent for unintentional irony nver ceases to amaze me.

You would have to show that a different editor didn't read it. Peer reviewers forward the paper to the upper management when the paper is ready to be published.
 
wow you got it backwards. THE EDITOR accepts papers then FORWARDS them to the peer reviewers.

what planet are you from?
 
I'd hate to have seen the initial submission in that case!

That just makes it sound even worse - most journal articles I'm aware of rarely get to go through two rounds of reviews without getting either accepted or rejected. To do so without an editor getting involved would be lunacy. It almost sounds as if the publishers capitulated for the sake of getting their page charges.

What's your evidence?

Since the paper was of a controversial nature, it was triple-checked for accuracy. So far no inaccuracies have been found.

Nice try at weak spin.
 
Hey Galileo?

BTW, if they re-wrote their paper three times, did they have to resubmit it and repay three times as well?

Bentham does not sell their scientific journal. Other journals will sell their papers to anyone who is willing to pay for it, in pay-for-play fashion. Not Bentham.

Also, other journals will publish anything for free. Bentham charges a nominal fee to help screen out junk science. This protection against junk science should be used by all publishers.
 
wow you got it backwards. THE EDITOR accepts papers then FORWARDS them to the peer reviewers.

what planet are you from?

You have it backwards. After the editor forwards it to the peer reviewers, when the peer reviewers are done, they forward it back to the editors, before it is published.
 
Bentham does not sell their scientific journal. Other journals will sell their papers to anyone who is willing to pay for it, in pay-for-play fashion. Not Bentham.

Also, other journals will publish anything for free. Bentham charges a nominal fee to help screen out junk science. This protection against junk science should be used by all publishers.

It is my understanding that you have to pay a fee to submit a paper. If they wrote it three times, then this means they had to re-submit it three times, and pay the fee each time. Am I correct?

That's routine for peer reviewed papers. Hello? Anybody in there?

So the peer review should be available. Where is it?
 
Ok. Critical thinking challenged individual that refuses to accept any valid evidence that contradicts the conspiracy fantasy they have chosen to worship.

can you site a real scientific source for this claim, or did you just make it up as usual?
 
Only at Bentham. It is my understanding editors normally read papers before submiting them to the reviewers, reviewers they, not the commercial publisher have chosen

That's part of the problem:

"I can not accept that the issue is put in my journal. The article is not about physical chemistry or chemical physics, and I could well believe that there is a political point of view behind the publication. If anyone had asked me, I would say that the article should never have been published in this journal. "

She is however a leading expert in nanometerials. Saying she isn't qualified may be a polite way of avoiding saying it's crap.
Yes, I looked her up - http://www.chemistry.gatech.edu/faculty/Pileni/ You would expect someone in that position to be able to see what an absolute crock of crap the paper is.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom