Bentham Editor In Chief Quits after Jones article

It is my understanding that you have to pay a fee to submit a paper. If they wrote it three times, then this means they had to re-submit it three times, and pay the fee each time. Am I correct?



So the peer review should be available. Where is it?

The paper has been published, its online.
 
You have it backwards. After the editor forwards it to the peer reviewers, when the peer reviewers are done, they forward it back to the editors, before it is published.

When the editors "forward it" to the peer reviewers, that is publishing!
 
The Bentham Journal published thousands of technical scientific articles every year.

Yes, and mad magazine publishes thousands of articles every year as well. What is your point?

How much Rubbish they may publish, is probably not something you want to highlight.

TAM:)
 
You have it backwards. After 1)the editor forwards it to the peer reviewers, 2) when the peer reviewers are done, they 3)forward it back to the editors, before it is published.

That's how it SUPPOSED to work but Bentham skips steps 1 & 3

Bentham does not sell their scientific journal. Other journals will sell their papers to anyone who is willing to pay for it, in pay-for-play fashion. Not Bentham.

LOL - Yes people are willing to pay for the content of these journals because they find it valuable.

Also, other journals will publish anything for free. Bentham charges a nominal fee to help screen out junk science. This protection against junk science should be used by all publishers.

Their fees are similar to journals that actually print copies. Their rather hefty fee for online only publication is to enrich the owners. How does charging a fee "screen out junk"?
 
Yes, and mad magazine publishes thousands of articles every year as well. What is your point?

How much Rubbish they may publish, is probably not something you want to highlight.

TAM:)

What's your point? The JREF forum publishes a lot of drivel.
 
That would not be a bad word to describe the responsibilities of the E-in-C given what Lenbrazil wrote above in post #13. It could also be used to describe the journal since it seemingly uncritically publish everything it receives. While the resigned E-in-C consider the journal to have flunked as a journal since it published an article she never had seen without her knowledge and approval.
 
Last edited:
are you a Marxist? You think $600 is hefty? That doesn't even begin to cover the costs of peer review or website maintainance.

They don't pay the reviewers and web hosting is cheap and so is the cost of labor in Pakistan. If European journals that actually print copies and pay their reviewers charge 23 Euros a page Benthan should be able to charge a lot less than $ 600
 
You have no respect for science.
The team I worked with in the lab was published. Science. I do science; you do delusions.

You are the opposite of science as you blindly accept lies, fraud, and junk science to form your ideas on 911. You can't tell me how much thermite was required to destroy the WTC; you can't tell me in joules the difference between the thermite scenario (never defined) and the actual office fires. You can't express in joules the heat from the jet fuel.

As you push lies from Jones you failed to take the time to check Jones work.

You don't even understand why they had to publish in Bentham; but the OP could help you understand.

Pay to publish; no publish, no pay. There is no real motive for Bentham to care if the paper is rational, or based on reality, or real science, they are paid! The more they publish, the more they make; it is a money making scam. A real CT is right in your face and you can't see it.
 
I can not accept that the issue is put in my journal. The article is not about physical chemistry or chemical physics, and I could well believe that there is a political point of view behind the publication. If anyone had asked me, I would say that the article should never have been published in this journal. Sentence, "notes the former chief.

Dumpekarakter the journal
Chief Editor's dramatic departure gives critics an extra reason to doubt the article's conclusions, but Marie-Paule Pilini points out that because the issue is outside her expertise, she can not judge whether the article itself is good or bad.

Self-contradiction with regards to the dust paper? Its not about chemistry or chemical physics but she can't judge whether the article is good or bad?
:lolsign:

So why did she quit? She wasn't consulted. Of course nothing to do with the science of the paper. It does appear she wasn't too happy about the implications of the results.

After all, why can't terrorists get into a building to plant thermitic materials? They truck bombed in '93.
They were able to bypass all sorts of security measures entering and leaving the country and entering and leaving the airports, etc.
They were able to bypass the nation's air defense. But can't get into a building to rig it? Nobody gives these terrorists enough credit.
 
Bentham is basically a money making scheme. Find a niche (unpublished, desperate to add to their resume Scientists), exploit that niche group for cash, produce a poor to modest product, make off with bundle of cash.

TAM:)
 
Self-contradiction with regards to the dust paper? Its not about chemistry or chemical physics but she can't judge whether the article is good or bad?
:lolsign:

So why did she quit? She wasn't consulted. Of course nothing to do with the science of the paper. It does appear she wasn't too happy about the implications of the results.

After all, why can't terrorists get into a building to plant thermitic materials? They truck bombed in '93.
They were able to bypass all sorts of security measures entering and leaving the country and entering and leaving the airports, etc.
They were able to bypass the nation's air defense. But can't get into a building to rig it? Nobody gives these terrorists enough credit.

Oh of course. Putting words into her mouth, surprise surprise.

Paranoia big destroya.

Understandable, as this was the first, albeit faint, glimmer the movement has had in 2 years, and now to have it fall into such ill repute (if it could get any lower that is).

TAM:)
 
Self-contradiction with regards to the dust paper? Its not about chemistry or chemical physics but she can't judge whether the article is good or bad?
:lolsign:.

I guess that is a contadiction if you are a truther. She said it is NOT about her area of expertise so she is NOT qualified to judge it. How is that a contadiction outside the "Twilight Zone"?
 
After all, why can't terrorists get into a building to plant thermitic materials? They truck bombed in '93.
Gee that's a hard one. It only takes a few minutes to drive a van in, park, set the bomb timer and leave. Yet it takes many months to place the magic thermite that can't cut vertically, wire it up and hide the evidence while the building is fully occupied and somehow not get caught. Nice fantasy. Let us know how they would pull it off and provide evidence of such.
 
Since the paper was of a controversial nature, it was triple-checked for accuracy. So far no inaccuracies have been found.

Errrr.... no, but nice try. That isn't how it works at all. If a paper was revised three times, it means it was considered unpublishable three times.

OK, real science peer review 101...

In most journals, what happens when a scientific paper is reviewed is that reviewers come back with one of four general recommendations for consideration by the editor:

  1. Accept as is
  2. Accept after minor revisions
  3. Accept after major revisions
  4. Reject

Providing the editor doesn't accept or reject it outright, the authors get to send a rebuttal of the reviews to the editor who then makes a decision on what to do, sometimes after further consultation with the reviewers. If minor revisions are made, the editor will normally send to publish once they are happy the authors have satisfied (or rebutted) the reviewers' recommendations. If major revisions are made, the editor will typically solicit another round of reviews after they receive the revised manuscript.

To sum up, the fact that it can be inferred that this paper got recommendation 3 at least twice without the involvement of an editor doesn't bode well at all.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom