Bentham Editor In Chief Quits after Jones article

Assuming this story is true, it puts paid any notion of "peer reviewed," regardless of her own belief or political affiliation.

Told you guys.

ETA: If, as stated in the article, the lead author knows the names of two reviewers, this is yet another irregularity in their process. The editors should be coordinating reviews and responses, and those should all be anonymized.

Apperently there are two types of peer review open and closed. In the latter no one but the editor knows who the reviewers are in open the names are made public.

The Bentham method is a strange new hybrid (eer lowbrid) the E-in-C and readership don't know who they are but the publisher (who chooses them) and the authors (who probablly recomended) them do
 
Apperently there are two types of peer review open and closed. In the latter no one but the editor knows who the reviewers are in open the names are made public.

The Bentham method is a strange new hybrid (eer lowbrid) the E-in-C and readership don't know who they are but the publisher (who chooses them) and the authors (who probablly recomended) them do
IIRC, the author can recommend up to 4 reviewers.
 
I'm puzzled by Niels O. Andersen's role.

"We understand that the Dean of Prof. Harrit’s college, Niels O Andersen, appears as the first name on the Editorial Advisory Board of the Bentham Science journal where the paper was published."

Now he announces he's quitting. Strange.
 
The Bentham Journal published thousands of technical scientific articles every year.
 
The Bentham Journal published thousands of technical scientific articles every year.
Proof that those "thousands" of articles carry any weight in the scientific community?
 
Last edited:
Seperating the word into two, "dumpe karakter" results in "dump character", I've found that when Googlwe translator doesn't recognize a word 90% of the time it you break it down it will translate.

Even this is does not give a correct translation in this case. The correct literal translation in this case should be "dump grade". But the right word is "flunk" or "flunk out".
 
They must have, because the editor reads every single one of them.

Uh, did ya read the first post, champ?

Jones is hell bent on destroying Open Journals the same way he did the Cold Fusion and the Jesus Came to America, um, industry.
 
They must have, because the editor reads every single one of them.

Galileo, it has been established that the editor in this case did not read this article, had no awareness of it being included in the journal, and furthermore was not required to read or review ANY article in the journal bearing her shingle.

You may continue with your AI truther tests.
 
They must have, because the editor reads every single one of them.
Do you have a comprehension problem? Whether or not the editors read them is irrelevant. However, the former editor does give some insight which is stated in #15. The fact is that the Bentham open access journals are not relevant in the scientific community.
 
Uh, did ya read the first post, champ?

Jones is hell bent on destroying Open Journals the same way he did the Cold Fusion and the Jesus Came to America, um, industry.

Jones is only the third author, and no, he is not part of an insideous conspiracy. You believe that, I know.
 
Galileo, it has been established that the editor in this case did not read this article, had no awareness of it being included in the journal, and furthermore was not required to read or review ANY article in the journal bearing her shingle.

You may continue with your AI truther tests.

Peer reviewers are supposed to read the article, not editors. The editor is not qualified to evaluate the paper, nor are you.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom