Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

No, "god of the gaps" is a valid criticism when there is a lack of some scientific explanation, god is invoked as an explanation, and there is the expectation that science will eventually fill in the gaps.

If this were "god of the gaps", Faber would have said, "we don't know, but we'll figure it out eventually". Notice she didn't. Nor is she the only one to have claimed it's either the multiverse or some universe designer.

This is much different. The fine-tuning problem will not get better over time. The opposite has been true: the more we learn, the more fantastically improbable our universe seems. The gap is never going to be filled in by science. That's the problem. It really does come down to either a really large multiverse (inflation theory) or some universe designer. No other explanation makes sense and nothing else besides cosmic inflation is taken seriously anymore.
Rubbish! when no credible explanation exists the only credible and honest answer is "We don't know" Has Faber not heard of evolution?
 
A common belief of some atheists is you cannot reason someone out of something, (religious belief) they were not reasoned into.
I'm sure that the approach described here does work on some people. And there will be people it doesn't work on. It doesn't matter if they're Mormon, JW, Catholic or Hindu. People are different, and have different approaches.

Yeah, but... How many Australians have you met personally who really care about what is in the Bible? How many people that call themselves Christians that you know personally care whether the Bible is correct, or accurate, or consistent? Very few is my guess. Most would look to the Bible for inspiration rather than history, like they would towards Oprah.
I have known several. Many back when I was a churchgoer myself, but I also have a good friend who is very concerned about what the Bible says - she is a "worship leader" (ie. pastor) in a very progressive church (Uniting) and every week she delivers a sermon to her congregation on how to be inspired by the Bible in today's gay- and green-friendly society. She takes her material from both Old and New Testament.

They may be in a minority (I don't have numbers), but they definitely exist.
 
No, "god of the gaps" is a valid criticism when there is a lack of some scientific explanation, god is invoked as an explanation, and there is the expectation that science will eventually fill in the gaps.

If this were "god of the gaps", Faber would have said, "we don't know, but we'll figure it out eventually". Notice she didn't. Nor is she the only one to have claimed it's either the multiverse or some universe designer.

This is much different. The fine-tuning problem will not get better over time. The opposite has been true: the more we learn, the more fantastically improbable our universe seems. The gap is never going to be filled in by science. That's the problem. It really does come down to either a really large multiverse (inflation theory) or some universe designer. No other explanation makes sense and nothing else besides cosmic inflation is taken seriously anymore.

What % of astronomers/cosmologists say it's either god or a multiverse?
 
As an Australian myself, I'd say that is also true of most people who would call themselves "believers": they are also indifferent to religion. If they believe in God, they try not to let it interrupt their day.

In fact, I'd say that for all of human history, 90% or more of people have not really given a thought about religion. I know that there is this idea that everyone in the past were fundamentalists, and that gradually the Enlightenment has eroded fundamentalism so that people have become more liberal, but I'd suggest that most people have always been liberal about their beliefs, and the Enlightenment has been making more people fundamentalist.

I agree with the above but question your last sentence. Some stats I have seen show fundamentalists as a small minority. Do you have any statistics you could point me to?


There have been times in the past where the right kind of religious beliefs have been important, but those were times when heresy was as much or more to do with politics as with religion.

Can you give us some examples of "the right kind of religious beliefs".


Yeah, but... How many Australians have you met personally who really care about what is in the Bible? How many people that call themselves Christians that you know personally care whether the Bible is correct, or accurate, or consistent? Very few is my guess. Most would look to the Bible for inspiration rather than history, like they would towards Oprah.

No real argument with the above but do find the "inspiration" natured by the Bible dubious.

I was an atheist until I was about 30 years old, then a theist afterwards. I started posting on atheist/theist discussion boards around 2000, and to me, a lot of Australians who have converted to atheism from theism suddenly start to believe that Christians MUST believe in the Bible, despite their own former position of not really caring what was in the Bible when they called themselves Christians.

I am most interested in the above. Did you reason your way into theism? If so how did this work?


I can't speak for Americans and Brits, but for Australians there is a strange 'conversion' affect that goes on on atheist boards, whereby their beliefs about what constitutes 'true' Christianity becomes defined around the literal truth of the Bible, despite them themselves formerly calling themselves Christians and not caring how 'true' the Bible was in a historical or even factual sense.

Not to sure what the point is you are making here. "True Christianity" is or is not defined by Biblical text?

Oh and thanks for your detailed post.
 
Last edited:
No, "god of the gaps" is a valid criticism when there is a lack of some scientific explanation, god is invoked as an explanation, and there is the expectation that science will eventually fill in the gaps.


Nope. When people believed a guy in the sky opened the firmament to create rain, that was a god of the gaps. Said god has been shrinking in scope of what it does for thousands of years, but it's still the same principal of not being able to explain something and defaulting to goddidit.
 
Nope. When people believed a guy in the sky opened the firmament to create rain, that was a god of the gaps. Said god has been shrinking in scope of what it does for thousands of years, but it's still the same principal of not being able to explain something and defaulting to goddidit.

No.

"God of the gaps (or a divine fallacy) is logical fallacy that occurs when Goddidit (or a variant) is invoked to explain some natural phenomena that science cannot (at the time of the argument). This concept is similar to what systems theorists refer to as an "explanatory principle." "God of the gaps" is a bad argument not only on logical grounds, but on empirical grounds: there is a long history of "gaps" being filled and the gap for God thus getting smaller and smaller, suggesting "we don't know yet" as an alternative that works better in practice; naturalistic explanations for still-mysterious phenomena are always possible, especially in the future where more information may be uncovered."
https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps

In the inflation theory that is the dominant in cosmology now, there is no future information that is going to be uncovered regarding the existence of other causally disconnected universes. They are, in principle, undetectable by us.
 

Yes. Regular wiki is better than rational wiki on this entry:

"God of the gaps" is a term used to describe observations of theological perspectives in which gaps in scientific knowledge are taken to be evidence or proof of God's existence. The "gaps" usage was made by Christian theologians not to discredit theism but rather to point out the fallacy of relying on teleological arguments for God's existence.[1][2]

In the 80's, evangelical kids were being taught to look at "god of the gaps" type arguments as "the incredible shrinking god", because even the fundies noticed the problematic trend for them there.

You can argue that this particular god of the gaps is growing, not shrinking, but it's still a god of the gaps.
 
Last edited:
Yes. Regular wiki is better than rational wiki on this entry:



In the 80's, evangelical kids were being taught to look at "god of the gaps" type arguments as "the incredible shrinking god", because even the fundies noticed the problematic trend for them there.

You can argue that this particular god of the gaps is growing, not shrinking, but it's still a god of the gaps.

No, it's not. It's a fallacious move of using theism as an explanation for a current unknown when there's a high probability the unknown will eventually be resolved. It's also fallacious when the positing of a god has no explanatory value or is totally ad hoc.

That's not the case here. A), evidence of these other universes will never turn up, and B) a universe designer explains the problem of fine-tuning, and C) it's not ad hoc since the possibility of a universe creator (god) has been asserted before the fine-tuning problem was ever even dreamed of.

This is my last post on this particular topic, so ask yourself, why are these smart astronomers, who should know better, saying it's either the Multiverse or god? The answer is obvious: they are aware it's not a god-of-the-gaps move, for the reasons I gave.
 
Last edited:
No.

"God of the gaps (or a divine fallacy) is logical fallacy that occurs when Goddidit (or a variant) is invoked to explain some natural phenomena that science cannot (at the time of the argument). This concept is similar to what systems theorists refer to as an "explanatory principle." "God of the gaps" is a bad argument not only on logical grounds, but on empirical grounds: there is a long history of "gaps" being filled and the gap for God thus getting smaller and smaller, suggesting "we don't know yet" as an alternative that works better in practice; naturalistic explanations for still-mysterious phenomena are always possible, especially in the future where more information may be uncovered."
https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/God_of_the_gaps
ThisWhat may or may not happen in the future has no bearing on the present. You can't pre-claim possible future evidence of the existence of a god with any credibility.

In the inflation theory that is the dominant in cosmology now, there is no future information that is going to be uncovered regarding the existence of other causally disconnected universes. They are, in principle, undetectable by us.
Just like imaginary gods.
 
No, it's not. It's a fallacious move of using theism as an explanation for a current unknown when there's a high probability the unknown will eventually be resolved.

You're just making that highlighted part up without understanding history of the phrase "god of the gaps". It's a Christian argument for a god of everything-is-miraculous. Poo-pooing the mysterious as "not evidence for god" is historically coming from Christians who want everyone to totally ignore science, more or less.

Do you understand that it's very recent that atheists have picked up the phrase from Christian apologetics arguments?
 

It's not. One of the reasons multiverse theory is so popular is it resolves the fine-tuning problem.

"This picture of the universe, or multiverse, as it is called, explains the long-standing mystery of why the constants of nature appear to be fine-tuned for the emergence of life. The reason is that intelligent observers exist only in those rare bubbles in which, by pure chance, the constants happen to be just right for life to evolve. The rest of the multiverse remains barren, but no one is there to complain about that."
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/multiverse-the-case-for-parallel-universe/
 
This is my last post on this particular topic, so ask yourself, why are these smart astronomers, who should know better, saying it's either the Multiverse or god? The answer is obvious: they are aware it's not a god-of-the-gaps move, for the reasons I gave.
Or the multiverse theory may be as much a load of crap as theism apparently is.
 
Last edited:
It's not. One of the reasons multiverse theory is so popular is it resolves the fine-tuning problem.

"This picture of the universe, or multiverse, as it is called, explains the long-standing mystery of why the constants of nature appear to be fine-tuned for the emergence of life. The reason is that intelligent observers exist only in those rare bubbles in which, by pure chance, the constants happen to be just right for life to evolve. The rest of the multiverse remains barren, but no one is there to complain about that."
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/multiverse-the-case-for-parallel-universe/
Evolutionary scientists don't agree there even is any fine-tuning to be a problem.
 
Last edited:
so ask yourself, why are these smart astronomers, who should know better, saying it's either the Multiverse or god? The answer is obvious: they are aware it's not a god-of-the-gaps move, for the reasons I gave.

I'm guessing they weren't raised fundamentalist christian like I was and even aware of "god of the gaps" in Christian apologetics, for one thing.

The Christian argument against using a a "god of the gaps" sort of scientific fact ("a miracle, according to science") to support faith that god exists is complex, and involves the separation of knowledge gained from the holy spirit - spiritual wisdom - from "worldly knowledge". They think - correctly - it's bad for christian faith, because you never know what science mught, maybe, some day be able to explain, and especially that it's demanding "proof" of existence from god.

From an atheist/agnostic/skeptical point of view - the god of the gaps mysteries are some of the most legit arguments FOR a god out there. "Nobody knows, you can't prove X isn't because god" is part of the core mentality agnostics generally share.
 
Evolutionary scientists don't agree there even is any fine-tuning to be a problem.

Physicists do seem more inclined to say there's something "too improbable" going on, but I still suspect the "it's god or a multiverse" position is a tiny minority.
 
Physicists do seem more inclined to say there's something "too improbable" going on, but I still suspect the "it's god or a multiverse" position is a tiny minority.
I would say theoretical physicists.
 
In the inflation theory that is the dominant in cosmology now, there is no future information that is going to be uncovered regarding the existence of other causally disconnected universes. They are, in principle, undetectable by us.

Well, so what? It doesn't mean imaginary sky deities are needed to account for those other universes. "We don't know" and "we will never know" are perfectly valid states. There is no need (nor any reason) to invoke imaginary sky deities to fill in our deficiency in knowledge.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom