Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Do not collect credibility (from atheists).

Are you advocating not even debating religion with theists, even your own best friend, if they don't provide proof of deities right off the bat?

Just, like, yell "NOT CREDIBLE!" at them and walk away?
 
Are you advocating not even debating religion with theists, even your own best friend, if they don't provide proof of deities right off the bat?

Just, like, yell "NOT CREDIBLE!" at them and walk away?
Yes (but not quite the way you describe).

If you had a best friend that believed in flying, fire breathing dragons would you need to say anything more than - "Dragons are scientifically impossible and there's absolutely no evidence they do exist even if they could exist". Would you debate the colour of dragons with your friend if (s)he claimed they were green with purple spots? Wouldn't you say - "Prove dragons exist first, then we might debate what colour they are".

Letting theists "Pass Go" and debating "as if" there might or could be a god (let's pretend) is only giving them oxygen for their belief and could give them a false impression that perhaps this atheist on some level believes in my god. Continuously debating The Bible gives it far more credibility than it deserves (IMO).

This is a relatively new tack for me and I think it's far more effective in practice with my theist friends (yes I have some) than the "old" method.
 
Last edited:
I have a friend who believes in chemtrails and flirted with flat-eartherism for a minute. So yes, I'm willing to try to talk a friend out of believing all kinds of crazy stuff, and it doesn't involve "giving them credibility".
 
Letting theists "Pass Go" and debating "as if" there might or could be a god (let's pretend) is only giving them oxygen for their belief

They are always debating as if it's true. Getting them to articulate how the world would be different if there was not a god is the interesting part. I actually have had success going that route with them.
 
I have a friend who believes in chemtrails and flirted with flat-eartherism for a minute. So yes, I'm willing to try to talk a friend out of believing all kinds of crazy stuff, and it doesn't involve "giving them credibility".
Hardly the same thing debating things that actually exist (contrails, Earth) and things that there is no evidence actually exist.
 
Hardly the same thing debating things that actually exist (contrails, Earth) and things that there is no evidence actually exist.

Belief in chemtrails entails believing all sorts of things which aren't real, like a massive global conspiracy, just for starters.
 
They are always debating as if it's true.
Of course, but why should atheists do that? ?

Getting them to articulate how the world would be different if there was not a god is the interesting part. I actually have had success going that route with them.
I'm not saying the "old" method is totally ineffective. I'm saying I think the "Don't pass Go' method may be more effective. It may not be as "interesting" however.
 
Belief in chemtrails entails believing all sorts of things which aren't real, like a massive global conspiracy, just for starters.
Not true. Although highly unlikely, massive global conspiracies are technically possible. Infinitely more so than the actual existence of an invisible, magical god.
 
Not true. Although highly unlikely, massive global conspiracies are technically possible. Infinitely more so than the actual existence of an invisible, magical god.

The conspiracy would necessarily involve global elites having filtered oxygen in their homes, too, supposedly in buried giant tanks.

You haven't spent much time with the chemtrail crowd, have you?
 
Talking about the existence or non-existence of a god is exactly talking about religion. No god = no religion to talk about.

The talking is person a saying "proof?" and person b not having it, the end.

This is not going to prove effective.
 
The conspiracy would necessarily involve global elites having filtered oxygen in their homes, too, supposedly in buried giant tanks.
So? Still not absolutely impossible.

You haven't spent much time with the chemtrail crowd, have you?
Wrong again! I have spent very much time debating with "the chemtrail crowd".

I'm only advocating the "Do not pass Go" method for religions, not chemtrailers or flatearthers because they get to start past "Go" given contrails and Earth are known to exist by way of credible evidence. Can you not see the difference?
 
Last edited:
So? Still not absolutely impossible

The "god of the gaps" isn't completely impossible, either. Or some trickster deity who just wants us to think it doesn't exist, etc.

Contrails exist, and chemtrails don't. There's no evidence that chemtrails exist. The "evidence" that they do is bunk or mere speculation, just like the "evidence" supporting belief in deities.
 
The talking is person a saying "proof?" and person b not having it, the end.

This is not going to prove effective.
Depends what you mean by effective. If you're looking for interesting and entertaining debates that rarely change anything then not as effective as the "old" method. But if you're looking to put the onus of a paranormal claim where it belongs, then I'm finding it quite effective.
 
Depends what you mean by effective. If you're looking for interesting and entertaining debates that rarely change anything then not as effective as the "old" method. But if you're looking to put the onus of a paranormal claim where it belongs, then I'm finding it quite effective.

Well, now I'm curious. How many people have you converted to atheism with this method?
 
The "god of the gaps" isn't completely impossible, either. Or some trickster deity who just wants us to think it doesn't exist, etc.

Contrails exist, and chemtrails don't. There's no evidence that chemtrails exist. The "evidence" that they do is bunk or mere speculation, just like the "evidence" supporting belief in deities.
The actual existence of an invisible, magical god is as impossible as anything is impossible according to all current knowledge. Wild speculations of future knowledge that may prove the existence of invisible magical gods is currently moot.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom