Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Well, now I'm curious. How many people have you converted to atheism with this method?
Why do you assume my purpose is to convert people to atheism?

Besides, people don't convert to atheism, they revert to atheism (it's the default position of all humans).
 
Last edited:
What makes an invisible deity that's just hiding from us impossible?

You say it's so "according to all current knowledge", but what specific knowledge completely, totally, and utterly rules it out?

Can you prove that Zeus didn't spark the big bang and then run off to chill in the Andromeda galaxy?
 
Last edited:
Why not just keep it simple? Why reason the obvious stupidity and impossibility of flying, fire breathing dragons when there’s no credible evidence such creatures even exist to begin with?

I have a strategy, a multi-pronged approach, and it certainly does involve throwing jokes out there, esp when we get a bit tipsy and we all open up. I throw in jokes about how God supposedly rested on the 7th day...."And he's STILL RESTING apparently!:p":D and that usually gets them loose and shaking with laughter. I mention impossible things about Noah's Ark...and most importantly to me, comparing the Biblical tales to their contemporaries like that of the Sumerians or ancient Greeks, arguing that they are cut from the same cloth.

And simply dismissing those stories as pure fantasy won't get me anywhere. And they're still my friends (and my people) conditioned to believe since early childhood in a region where about 99% of the people grew up Christian. I'm not gonna do that.
 
How were you defining "effective"? Effective at what?
Well . . .
But if you're looking to put the onus of a paranormal claim where it belongs, then I'm finding it quite effective.
Also I've debated the "old" way so much over so many years with so many theists and other paranormal believers, that I no longer find it very interesting or entertaining. So also effective at avoiding having to repeat what I've already said countless times to those that pretty much don't want to hear it.

These days when confronted by theists and their weird beliefs I usually put the ball in their court with two "simple" questions - "What do you believe?" and "Why do you believe it?". Haven't got a meaningful answer to the first question yet. When we get past the usual - "Well where do you come from then?" response, and I reply with - "What has what I believe got to do with what you believe?", they finally answer the question and say they believe in a god. I then ask them to explain what this "god" is as It's a meaningless word to me. Not only do they have great difficulty explaining what their god is, no two theists have ever given the same explanation!
 
Last edited:
Oh. Well, Venom and I are talking about effectiveness regarding the topic of the thread, "Being Reasoned Out Of Religion."

I agree that saying "prove it" effectively puts the onus on the one making the claim.
 
Last edited:
The actual existence of an invisible, magical god is as impossible as anything is impossible according to all current knowledge. Wild speculations of future knowledge that may prove the existence of invisible magical gods is currently moot.

The existence of god(s) is not dependent on our knowledge of them. Theism certainly isn't "impossible". If that is the gist of your conversion argument, any theist with just a passing knowledge of epistemology will laugh in your face, and rightly so.
 
Well . . .

Also I've debated the "old" way so much over so many years with so many theists and other paranormal believers, that I no longer find it very interesting or entertaining. So also effective at avoiding having to repeat what I've already said countless times to those that pretty much don't want to hear it.

These days when confronted by theists and their weird beliefs I usually put the ball in their court with two "simple" questions - "What do you believe?" and "Why do you believe it?". Haven't got a meaningful answer to the first question yet. When we get past the usual - "Well where do you come from then?" response, and I reply with - "What has what I believe got to do with what you believe?", they finally answer the question and say they believe in a god. I then ask them to explain what this "god" is as It's a meaningless word to me. Not only do they have great difficulty explaining what their god is, no two theists have ever given the same explanation!

"Examples of such “fine-tuning” abound. Tweak the charge on an electron, for instance, or change the strength of the gravitational force or the strong nuclear force just a smidgen, and the universe would look very different, and likely be lifeless. The challenge for physicists is explaining why such physical parameters are what they are.

...

That night in Hawaii, Faber declared that there were only two possible explanations for fine-tuning. “One is that there is a God and that God made it that way,” she said. But for Faber, an atheist, divine intervention is not the answer.

“The only other approach that makes any sense is to argue that there really is an infinite, or a very big, ensemble of universes out there and we are in one,” she said."


http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/blogs/physics/2012/03/is-the-universe-fine-tuned-for-life/

That's not some Christian wacko. Sandra Faber is an award-winning astronomer.

The theist will simply ask you to prove a multiverse of infinite universes exists, which of course you will be unable to do, and so they'll quote an authority like Faber (she's not the only scientist to have ever said that) and they'll go with the god-option.

So WHAT the theist will say is they believe in God and WHY they do is because it's either that or a humongous multiverse of different universes, and since the evidence for both is sketchy, they'll go with their intuition.
 
Last edited:
The existence of god(s) is not dependent on our knowledge of them. Theism certainly isn't "impossible". If that is the gist of your conversion argument, any theist with just a passing knowledge of epistemology will laugh in your face, and rightly so.
Knowledge of the existence of god(s) would be dependent on evidence that confirms (or even suggests) that gods actually exist.

Theism certainly is impossible according to all current knowledge and understanding of what is possible.

Glad to make theists happy. Is a happy theist like a happy medium?
 
Last edited:
So WHAT the theist will say is they believe in God and WHY they do is because it's either that or a humongous multiverse of different universes, and since the evidence for both is sketchy, they'll go with their intuition.

Do you agree that this is another "god of the gaps" argument?
 
"Examples of such “fine-tuning” abound. Tweak the charge on an electron, for instance, or change the strength of the gravitational force or the strong nuclear force just a smidgen, and the universe would look very different, and likely be lifeless. The challenge for physicists is explaining why such physical parameters are what they are.
...

That night in Hawaii, Faber declared that there were only two possible explanations for fine-tuning. “One is that there is a God and that God made it that way,” she said. But for Faber, an atheist, divine intervention is not the answer.

“The only other approach that makes any sense is to argue that there really is an infinite, or a very big, ensemble of universes out there and we are in one,” she said."


http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/blogs/physics/2012/03/is-the-universe-fine-tuned-for-life/

That's not some Christian wacko. Sandra Faber is an award-winning astronomer.

The theist will simply ask you to prove a multiverse of infinite universes exists, which of course you will be unable to do, and so they'll quote an authority like Faber (she's not the only scientist to have ever said that) and they'll go with the god-option.

So WHAT the theist will say is they believe in God and WHY they do is because it's either that or a humongous multiverse of different universes, and since the evidence for both is sketchy, they'll go with their intuition.
Regardless of the award winning astronomy status of Sandra Faber she is clearly wrong as she completely missed or ignored the simple and honest “We don’t know” option. I don’t claim that a multiverse or infinite Universe exists and don’t know why you assume I do. Although I would guess that the latter is most likely I have to accept “I don’t know” for now and that may always be my only honest answer.

Obviously you believe that your particular god is the creator of the Universe because you also believe the Universe had to have been created, regardless that there's no credible evidence for either. When asked who or what created your god creator however you will slither down your duplicitous special pleading “God is infinite” wormhole. Perhaps I should quote an authority like Faber (she's not the only scientist to have ever said that) and go with the no evidence for a god-creator-option. "I don't know" is currently the only honest answer anyone can give and it's certainly better than claiming unproven multiverse theories or Godidit are fact and the only options.
 
Last edited:
Do you agree that this is another "god of the gaps" argument?

No, because the universes the multiverse theory posits are causally disconnected from us. In other words, there will be, in principle, no way to verify whether one, two, or five quintillion other universes exist. A billion years down the road, we still won't know. The "gap" for theism will never shrink. It will always be a disjunction where both disjuncts have the same evidence going for them, namely none: it's either multiverse theory or god (or simulation theory). Scientists are in a debate about whether the multiverse even qualifies as a theory, since it's in principle untestable. Believing that a vast multiverse of universes exists is almost like theism.

There will also be no way to test how common life-permitting universes are. The consensus is the values of the constants have to be balanced on a "knife-edge" for complex structure to even be possible. Even supposing there is a multiverse with a humongous number of universes, what if none of those other universes are life-permitting? That would mean our universe is very special, which might have it's own implications. I suggested this in another thread, where we hypothetically found out we're the only life in the universe. What would the implications be? Profound, I think.
 
No, because the universes the multiverse theory posits are causally disconnected from us. In other words, there will be, in principle, no way to verify whether one, two, or five quintillion other universes exist. A billion years down the road, we still won't know. The "gap" for theism will never shrink. It will always be a disjunction where both disjuncts have the same evidence going for them, namely none: it's either multiverse theory or god (or simulation theory). Scientists are in a debate about whether the multiverse even qualifies as a theory, since it's in principle untestable. Believing that a vast multiverse of universes exists is almost like theism.

There will also be no way to test how common life-permitting universes are. The consensus is the values of the constants have to be balanced on a "knife-edge" for complex structure to even be possible. Even supposing there is a multiverse with a humongous number of universes, what if none of those other universes are life-permitting? That would mean our universe is very special, which might have it's own implications. I suggested this in another thread, where we hypothetically found out we're the only life in the universe. What would the implications be? Profound, I think.
If the multiverse theory is a load of crap it still doesn't give your god-creator belief any more credibility. It's not an either/or choice between science and god beliefs. Remove science completely there's still no credible evidence any god actually exists.

How profound would discovering life elsewhere in The Universe be? I suspect not too profound at all in relation to your god beliefs. Theism only tends to place any importance on "winners".
 
Last edited:
Regardless of the award winning astronomy status of Sandra Faber she is clearly wrong as she completely missed or ignored the simple and honest “We don’t know” option. I don’t claim that a multiverse or infinite Universe exists and don’t know why you assume I do. Although I would guess that the latter is most likely I have to accept “I don’t know” for now and that may always be my only honest answer.

Obviously you believe that your particular god is the creator of the Universe because you also believe the Universe had to have been created, regardless that there's no credible evidence for either. When asked who or what created your god creator however you will slither down your duplicitous special pleading “God is infinite” wormhole. Perhaps I should quote an authority like Faber (she's not the only scientist to have ever said that) and go with the no evidence for a god-creator-option. "I don't know" is currently the only honest answer anyone can give and it's certainly better than claiming unproven multiverse theories or Godidit are fact.

And here's where you lose the argument with the theist. The theist brings up a very credible authority (an atheist no less) to bolster their argument, and you handwave it away, relying on your incredulity based on an utterly unimpressive lack of credentials.

I don't think you've really gone up against a theist who knows their stuff. They would wipe the floor with you. As I just did. You didn't even try and counter my expert with one of your own. You did what you always accuse theists of doing: ignoring the scientists and the evidence.

In fact, I'll even formulate the argument for you, since I'm waiting for a sleeping pill to kick in:

1. Prima facie cosmological fine-tuning is a problem in cosmology that needs to be explained.
2. Coincidence does not explain prima facie fine-tuning.
3. A multiverse consisting of an extremely large number of other universes could explain prima facie fine-tuning.
4. The existence of a being capable of fine-tuning the universe could explain prima facie fine-tuning.
5. The amount of evidence that there exists a multiverse consisting of an extremely large number of other universes is the same as the amount of evidence that there exists a being capable of fine-tuning the universe.
6. Because the universes in a multiverse would be causally disconnected from each other, there would never come a time when evidence of their existence appears.
7. Therefore, (3) and (4) are equally rational explanations for prima facie fine-tuning.

That is why Faber said it's either god or a multiverse. The argument isn't perfect, which is why Faber believes in a multiverse instead of god, but it's not something you can just hand-wave away. There are real problems with asserting the existence of a huge multiverse of bazillions of other universes with no proof and no way to test whether it's true or not. Scientists are uncomfortable doing so, for obvious reasons.
 
Last edited:
The scientist wasn't stating that it was a scientific fact that it's either god or a multiverse. She just said she couldn't think of how else to explain it...which is exactly what the god of the gaps is. "I don't know, so goddidit".
 
The scientist wasn't stating that it was a scientific fact that it's either god or a multiverse. She just said she couldn't think of how else to explain it...which is exactly what the god of the gaps is. "I don't know, so goddidit".

No, "god of the gaps" is a valid criticism when there is a lack of some scientific explanation, god is invoked as an explanation, and there is the expectation that science will eventually fill in the gaps.

If this were "god of the gaps", Faber would have said, "we don't know, but we'll figure it out eventually". Notice she didn't. Nor is she the only one to have claimed it's either the multiverse or some universe designer.

This is much different. The fine-tuning problem will not get better over time. The opposite has been true: the more we learn, the more fantastically improbable our universe seems. The gap is never going to be filled in by science. That's the problem. It really does come down to either a really large multiverse (inflation theory) or some universe designer. No other explanation makes sense and nothing else besides cosmic inflation is taken seriously anymore.
 
Last edited:
And here's where you lose t. . . <snip>

That self-aggrandizing rant doesn’t deserve a response.

In fact, I'll even formulate the argument for you, since I'm waiting for a sleeping pill to kick in:

1. Prima facie cosmological fine-tuning is a problem in cosmology that needs to be explained.
So we don’t know

2. Coincidence does not explain prima facie fine-tuning.
Neither does belief in a god creator. Credible current science doesn’t explain fine tuning by way of coincidence. Regardless, we still don’t know.

3. A multiverse consisting of an extremely large number of other universes could explain prima facie fine-tuning.
Given there’s no evidence of an actual multiverse, we still don’t know.

4. The existence of a being capable of fine-tuning the universe could explain prima facie fine-tuning.
Apart from there being no credible evidence that such a being actually exists, or even could exist, such a being would create the new the problem of what fine-tuned that being. Credible explanations don't come from "could". We still don't know.

5. The amount of evidence that there exists a multiverse consisting of an extremely large number of other universes is the same as the amount of evidence that there exists a being capable of fine-tuning the universe.
Yep, zilch for either. That just makes neither credible. We still don’t know.

6. Because the universes in a multiverse would be causally disconnected from each other, there would never come a time when evidence of their existence appears. [
Just like there never comes a time when evidence of a god’s existence appears.

7. Therefore, (3) and (4) are equally rational explanations for prima facie fine-tuning.
Rubbish! To qualify as being rational they would have to be supported by rational evidence of their actual existence.

That is why Faber said it's either god or a multiverse. The argument isn't perfect, which is why Faber believes in a multiverse instead of god, but it's not something you can just hand-wave away. There are real problems with asserting the existence of a huge multiverse of bazillions of other universes with no proof and no way to test whether it's true or not. Scientists are uncomfortable doing so, for obvious reasons.
There are real problems with asserting the existence of an invisible, magical creator-god with no proof and no way to test whether it's true or not. Theists are not uncomfortable doing so, for obvious belief confirmation reasons.

Lack of a scientific explanation doesn't make a paranormal belief explanation any more credible or true.

And we still don't know . . .
 
Last edited:
Isn’t it truly amazing how the water of every puddle exactly fits the hole it sits in. That amazing fine-tuning can’’t possibly happen by coincidence, therefore there must be a fine-tuning god creator. But that god is my god, not your god. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom