Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Well if you were not living, then you would be in no position to think there was anything "more" (or anything "less") :D.

That is - you actually do need to be alive in order to decide what you think is important for you to do, or for you to follow as principles as ideas that you want to adhere to. And those are subjective personal decisions which any of us make (e.g. to do what we think is morally right towards others, even if it sometimes means some hardship for ourself).
But, but “there must be more”! If you “open your mind” you will “see” that physical life dies at death but metaphysical life doesn’t. This metaphysical life (consciousness/spirit/soul) resides in the invisible metaphysical realm and is eternal. This is the "more" to life that survives physical death.

When you believe a metaphysical existence actually exists and is "meaningful and true", a whole new and exciting “anything is possible” world of magic and miracles opens up and all your fantasies and desires become "possible" (YAY!). Isn’t that much better and exciting than a life that’s restricted by the boring empirical evidence of a purely physical world? Come over to the enlightened side of “metaphysical existence for goodness” (everyone wants “goodness”, right? They may not want your version of goodness though). :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Not speaking for anybody else, but I do. Being an atheist and a materialist, I'm of the opinion that whatever goes on inside other people's heads is utterly unimportant and entirely their own business. People can think whatever they like and have whatever reasons they like for doing anything. The only thing that matters is what they do.

Well I most certainly disagree with you here. I do worry about what goes on inside peoples heads, if I am in a position where I am vulnerable to the outcome of those deliberations. How many examples of atrocities committed in the name of religion would it take to convince you to be thus concerned also?


I'm not sure that the kind of ideology people will kill for requires a religious component. I mean, not to want to Godwin the thread, but Hitler was anti-religion and he managed to perpetrate one of the largest mass evils of the entire history of this planet.

I also think that most people think of themselves as the good guys.

The religiosity of Hitler has been discussed at length by many and his beliefs, or lack thereof, not that clear. Following is an example of the contradictory information on the subject from Wikki:

In his book Mein Kampf and in public speeches prior to and in the early years of his rule, he affirmed a belief in Christianity. Hitler and the Nazi party promoted "Positive Christianity", a movement which rejected most traditional Christian doctrines such as the divinity of Jesus, as well as Jewish elements such as the Old Testament.

To somehow link Hitler's "anti-religion" to his perpetration of "one of the largest mass evils of the entire history of this planet", is stretching things somewhat.
 
Something like Nazism absolutely could arise in an atheist society.
 
Well I most certainly disagree with you here. I do worry about what goes on inside peoples heads, if I am in a position where I am vulnerable to the outcome of those deliberations. How many examples of atrocities committed in the name of religion would it take to convince you to be thus concerned also?

Those outcomes are actions, not thoughts.

The religiosity of Hitler has been discussed at length by many and his beliefs, or lack thereof, not that clear. Following is an example of the contradictory information on the subject from Wikki:

You mean the man who weaponised propaganda, who the vast majority of academics agree was not religious, and who said in private that he didn't oppose Christianity and instead endorsed Christianity publicly purely as a political move even though he opposed it himself endorsed Christianity publicly? I wonder why he would have done such a thing?

To somehow link Hitler's "anti-religion" to his perpetration of "one of the largest mass evils of the entire history of this planet", is stretching things somewhat.

Now, what did I actually say on the subject? Not what you'd have liked me to say because it's easier to argue against, but what words did I actually use?
 
I think we have one of those muddled causation arguments happening here. I get the impression that is what squeegee is implying, as I wonder why he would have posted what what he did otherwise.

Although I would admit a predominately atheist society would not be immune to the rise of a nazi regime, I tend to think it less likely, although I would add the proviso that it would depend on the type of atheist society, and how it came into being.

If the society were atheist as a result of the rise of reason, (as education levels increased as we see in Europe today), then I would say a nazi movement would not flourish. A reasoning people would not go for it.

On the other hand the atheism was imposed by a draconian government, (as in the previous Soviet Union), I see no impediment, although I am at a loss to see how it would cause a rise in naziism.
 
Those outcomes are actions, not thoughts.

Actions are not the result of thoughts ........ OK then.

You mean the man who weaponised propaganda, who the vast majority of academics agree was not religious, and who said in private that he didn't oppose Christianity and instead endorsed Christianity publicly purely as a political move even though he opposed it himself endorsed Christianity publicly? I wonder why he would have done such a thing?

Must be good to be so gifted with the insight into other peoples innermost thoughts. Thoughts that have eluded so many others.


Now, what did I actually say on the subject? Not what you'd have liked me to say because it's easier to argue against, but what words did I actually use?

Have you forgotten what you wrote?
 
A reasoning people would not go for it.

It could easily happen if the worst of it was hidden from them, or news about what was happening was sufficiently cloaked in propaganda and spin. Very reasonable, educated people are perfectly susceptible to psychological denial.
 
I 100% agree with you ynot..... but arth, I can hardly believe you can think this. Do you really think it is just as good for someone to do stuff, because they think there is a reward coming, as for someone who does it with no such expectation?
If good things are done, then no, I don't think it matters why they are done.

There is a danger here also that we are all acutely aware of. When the do- gooder does stuff like flying planes into buildings because he thinks that is what his god wants.
Do you really think that's what I'm talking about???

Try again: If good things are done, why does the motivation matter? If the poor person is fed, if the kitten is rescued, if the drug addict kicks the habit, does the possibility that it was done for a religious motive really change the outcome?
 
If good things are done, then no, I don't think it matters why they are done.
If others do what they define as being "good things", but you define those things as being "bad things", does it still not matter to you, and is their motivation of no interest to you?

ETA - If a person that believes doing a particular thing is good, forces (with torture and threat of death) another person that believes doing that thing is bad, to do that thing, does it still not matter why the person was motivated to do that “good” thing?
 
Last edited:
That's my take on what he was saying, too.

I wonder if he would have approved of this?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_universe_hypothesis

Descartes argued that the nature of the world is mathematical. He tried to apply the mathematical method to philosophy and failed there. He had to recognize that knowledge of the world is based on experience.

But I believe that Descartes would stand as I did before the page you linked: stunned.
 
Not denying this but as clarification your use of word ‘appearance’, appearance implies or only extends to that which is neither real nor unreal - like a snowflake which disappears when one grasps it. The world = perception.

I was not referring here to the appearance of things (phenomenon) but to the formal structure of the famous sentence "cogito ergo sum". Since it includes the connective "therefore" it seems a reasoning. However, it is not. It is an intuition, that is, an immediate grasp of the relationship between two concepts.

On the other hand, I agree with your comment. We know only the appearance of the world: the way we see it. We don't know what it is in itself. Although certain types of knowledge strongly suggest that they are objective and other subjective. That is, if knowledge is the appearance of the object for a subject, some knowledge is inclined from the side of the object and others from the subject. I don't know if I have expressed clearly my idea .
 
Last edited:
Something like Nazism absolutely could arise in an atheist society.

If the society were atheist as a result of the rise of reason, (as education levels increased as we see in Europe today), then I would say a nazi movement would not flourish. A reasoning people would not go for it.
On the other hand the atheism was imposed by a draconian government, (as in the previous Soviet Union), I see no impediment, although I am at a loss to see how it would cause a rise in naziism.


Is any society ever totally atheist?
Is practiced Nazism ever totally devoid of theism?
Ynot asks the right questions.

Nazism and fascism, as we know them, have always arisen in societies heavily influenced by and in collusion with religion. You know, concordats, pastors with the Roman salute and stuff. We cannot know what would happen in an entirely secular society, because this is a kind of utopia.

If we want to think abstractly, a secular society would not be immune to Nazism unless it were rationalist. Such a society wouldn't presumably admit irrational dogmas such as the superiority of the Aryan race or the need of submit to a führer. I suppose so. We should also assume that all atheists are rationalists by definition, which remains to be seen. There you have Nietzsche, atheist and irrationalist... and close to Nazism in many ways
 
Ynot asks the right questions.

Nazism and fascism, as we know them, have always arisen in societies heavily influenced by and in collusion with religion. You know, concordats, pastors with the Roman salute and stuff. We cannot know what would happen in an entirely secular society, because this is a kind of utopia.

If we want to think abstractly, a secular society would not be immune to Nazism unless it were rationalist. Such a society wouldn't presumably admit irrational dogmas such as the superiority of the Aryan race or the need of submit to a führer. I suppose so. We should also assume that all atheists are rationalists by definition, which remains to be seen. There you have Nietzsche, atheist and irrationalist... and close to Nazism in many ways

So:
Strong: There is evidence that there are no gods.
Weak: It is unknown if there are any gods.

The 2 are in contradiction to each other, so one of the positions is irrational.
 
So:
Strong: There is evidence that there are no gods.
Weak: It is unknown if there are any gods.

The 2 are in contradiction to each other, so one of the positions is irrational.

Each one has its reasons. One is more rational than the other. This is a debatable point.

Irrational=has not any reason or has strong evidence against.
 
Last edited:
Each one has its reasons. One is more rational than the other. This is a debatable point.

Irrational=has not any reason or has strong evidence against.

When you have a contradiction, one of the positions is false; i.e. has strong evidence against it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom