Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

"I think therefore I am" is solid. I'm certain I exist.


Well what we have learned from science is that you should be extremely cautious before declaring anything to be an absolute certainty. And especially where there are, in any case, few if any circumstances in which you really need to make any such declarations of absolute certainty.

In particular, what we have learned is that just because something seems to us to be absolutely certain, i.e. just because you cannot think of any reason why it would not be exactly as it appears to be, you should not jump to the conclusion of declaring that thing is therefore an absolute certainty ... and that even includes what you say about your own existence with statements such as “I think, therefore I am”.

It's also a piece of circular reasoning when it is offered as a proof of anyones actual existence. That is – when it starts by saying “I think”, it is actually beginning with the assumption that you do indeed exist! So it cannot then immediately conclude “therefore I am do exist” (because it already started with that conclusion in the first place … in other words, as a proof, it fails).

Instead of trying to create a proof of physical existence/reality in a mere word-argument like that, it's more than sufficient for us just to say there is no known evidence to suggest that we are anything other than the thinking human animals that we appear to be. And certainly I am not going to suggest that we may not really exist, or that everything is (or “might” be) an unreal illusion (as several people here have argued in other threads).

However, when we say “I think”, what do we really mean by “thinking”? What really is that? Presumably that's what people also mean by such words as “consciousness”, “awareness” or “mind” etc. But what is “consciousness”? That's not so clear is it? I would say that it's almost certainly just the outcome-effect produced by the brain as a response to electrochemical changes transmitted from our sensory cells. And to that extent we (all living things) are just highly evolved groups of molecules (in “cells”) undergoing various chemical and physical reactions. And if you think we are much more than that, as if to believe that “consciousness” or “thinking” and “self" or “I” is something far more mysterious and intangible than that, then I suspect that what you regard as “I” and “think”, are probably not what you imagine them to be anyway.
 
Your words are welcome pearls (before swine), but this . . .

The word "Atheist" (i.e. "theist" with a leading letter "A"), just means "not theist". It means someone who does not believe in the existence of religious gods.

contradicts this . . .

An "atheist" is anyone who does feel pretty sure that the God does not exist. They should not say they know for certain that a God could not exist, because none of us can really be that literally "certain" about anything (perhaps the entire universe is an illusion ... though all evidence is against that), but they might reasonably say they think it's virtually certain that he does not exist ...
.


I don't think there is any contraction there (between the two highlighted statements). The first sentence just says that “atheists” are people who do not believe the claimed God exists. That's a “belief”. It's something they have concluded from whatever they believe to be the relevant facts/information.

The second statement statement just says the same thing – the “atheist” feels pretty sure that the claimed God does not exist … thats entirely consistent with saying they do not believe the God exists. They are not (or should not) be claiming it's a certainty that the God cannot possibly exist … they merely say they do not believe it (because they feel pretty sure about the non-existence).
 
"I think therefore I am" is solid. I'm certain I exist.


It's also a piece of circular reasoning when it is offered as a proof of anyones actual existence. That is – when it starts by saying “I think”, it is actually beginning with the assumption that you do indeed exist!


No, not really. Even "Thinking appears to be going on" implies that somebody (= you) is registering this and therefore exists. Who or what the **** that somebody is is an entirely different question, but you do know that you are.
People who are inclined to do that kind of may now come up with the brain in the vat and computer simulations, but it's an extremely boring discussion.
 
No, nothing to do with reward or punishment. It's following what I think is meaningful and true: that there is a metaphysical existence for goodness and "there is more to life than living", which I know you regard as a meaningless statement. That's the foundation upon which things like forgiveness, etc, take on importance.


Well if you were not living, then you would be in no position to think there was anything "more" (or anything "less") :D.

That is - you actually do need to be alive in order to decide what you think is important for you to do, or for you to follow as principles as ideas that you want to adhere to. And those are subjective personal decisions which any of us make (e.g. to do what we think is morally right towards others, even if it sometimes means some hardship for ourself).
 
No, not really. Even "Thinking appears to be going on" implies that somebody (= you) is registering this and therefore exists. Who or what the **** that somebody is is an entirely different question, but you do know that you are.
People who are inclined to do that kind of may now come up with the brain in the vat and computer simulations, but it's an extremely boring discussion.


Well, that does not change the fact that it is circular reasoning, or not actually a "proof", to say "I think" (which requires you to exist in the first place, otherwise there is no "I" to do any "thinking"), which is therefore identical to saying "I think exist", and then to conclude from that "therefore I exist".

IOW, in case that was not clear - the statement "I think, therefore I am" is actually just the same as saying "I exist, therefore I exist". And that's circular.
 
No, not really. Even "Thinking appears to be going on" implies that somebody (= you) is registering this and therefore exists. Who or what the **** that somebody is is an entirely different question, but you do know that you are.
People who are inclined to do that kind of may now come up with the brain in the vat and computer simulations, but it's an extremely boring discussion.

Even if I exist as part of a simulation or a brain in a vat or a character in some cosmic entity's dream, I still exist in that capacity.
 
Well what we have learned from science is that you should be extremely cautious before declaring anything to be an absolute certainty. And especially where there are, in any case, few if any circumstances in which you really need to make any such declarations of absolute certainty.

In particular, what we have learned is that just because something seems to us to be absolutely certain, i.e. just because you cannot think of any reason why it would not be exactly as it appears to be, you should not jump to the conclusion of declaring that thing is therefore an absolute certainty ... and that even includes what you say about your own existence with statements such as “I think, therefore I am”.

I'm pretty sure that "science" does not lead to the inevitable conclusion that even the fact of your own existence is beyond certainty.
 
Well, that does not change the fact that it is circular reasoning, or not actually a "proof", to say "I think" (which requires you to exist in the first place, otherwise there is no "I" to do any "thinking"), which is therefore identical to saying "I think exist", and then to conclude from that "therefore I exist".

IOW, in case that was not clear - the statement "I think, therefore I am" is actually just the same as saying "I exist, therefore I exist". And that's circular.

It's not circular. You're just being unreasonably pedantic about how logical axioms are translated into language.
 
Well, no, deciding to not open the box is not faith. Faith equates to trust or confidence. "God exists", by itself, isn't a statement of faith. "God has a plan for us even while we suffer" is a statement of faith. I'd say deciding to not open the box is an example of a closed mind trying to avoid cognitive dissonance.
Faith is belief lacking evidence. "God has a plan for us even while we suffer" is a statement of faith and also an example of a closed mind trying to avoid cognitive dissonance.

Opening the box is seeking evidence, courting temptation. Refutation or confirmation, either way undermines faith.
 
IOW, in case that was not clear - the statement "I think, therefore I am" is actually just the same as saying "I exist, therefore I exist". And that's circular.
T

The claim "I am aware, I am present" is a claim one can make without reason, faith or belief. The claim "I am aware, I am present" is NOT the same as claiming I physically exist, since physical existence has never been demonstrated.
 
T

The claim "I am aware, I am present" is a claim one can make without reason, faith or belief. The claim "I am aware, I am present" is NOT the same as claiming I physically exist, since physical existence has never been demonstrated.

Let's not mess this up. Descartes says that, despite its appearance, the relationship between thinking and existing is not a reasoning, but an intuition. By the fact that I think I immediately realize that I exist. And this is a starting point that cannot be doubted. What Descartes wants is to find some other kind of intuition as powerful as this one. I would say he didn't find it. The intuition that the world exists outside of me is also powerful, but not logically unassailable, like "cogito ergo sum".
 
Let's not mess this up. Descartes says that, despite its appearance, the relationship between thinking and existing is not a reasoning, but an intuition. By the fact that I think I immediately realize that I exist. And this is a starting point that cannot be doubted. What Descartes wants is to find some other kind of intuition as powerful as this one. I would say he didn't find it. The intuition that the world exists outside of me is also powerful, but not logically unassailable, like "cogito ergo sum".

That's my take on what he was saying, too.

I wonder if he would have approved of this?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mathematical_universe_hypothesis
 
Let's not mess this up. Descartes says that, despite its appearance, the relationship between thinking and existing is not a reasoning, but an intuition. By the fact that I think I immediately realize that I exist. And this is a starting point that cannot be doubted. What Descartes wants is to find some other kind of intuition as powerful as this one. I would say he didn't find it. The intuition that the world exists outside of me is also powerful, but not logically unassailable, like "cogito ergo sum".

Not denying this but as clarification your use of word ‘appearance’, appearance implies or only extends to that which is neither real nor unreal - like a snowflake which disappears when one grasps it. The world = perception.
 
I don't think there is any contraction there (between the two highlighted statements). The first sentence just says that “atheists” are people who do not believe the claimed God exists. That's a “belief”. It's something they have concluded from whatever they believe to be the relevant facts/information.

The second statement statement just says the same thing – the “atheist” feels pretty sure that the claimed God does not exist … thats entirely consistent with saying they do not believe the God exists. They are not (or should not) be claiming it's a certainty that the God cannot possibly exist … they merely say they do not believe it (because they feel pretty sure about the non-existence).
For what must be the millionth time . . .

Atheist (not theist) is simply a person that lacks belief in a god, as your first sentence correctly states (no reasoning or conclusion required).

To claim lack of belief is a belief is like claiming not collecting stamps is a hobby.

To “feel pretty sure god(s) don’t exist” is having a belief regarding god(s).

If you want to redefine “atheist” as being “Has no god belief and believes there is no god” then don’t say . . .
The word "Atheist" (i.e. "theist" with a leading letter "A"), just means "not theist".
 
For what must be the millionth time . . .

Atheist (not theist) is simply a person that lacks belief in a god, as your first sentence correctly states (no reasoning or conclusion required).

To claim lack of belief is a belief is like claiming not collecting stamps is a hobby.

To “feel pretty sure god(s) don’t exist” is having a belief regarding god(s).

If you want to redefine “atheist” as being “Has no god belief and believes there is no god” then don’t say . . .

Serious question: are babies atheists?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom