Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Am puzzled by your claim that theism put "forgiveness, helping, treating others seriously" onto a solid foundation for you. How so?

The point has been made repeatedly by atheists, that the morality of Christians, (their incentive to do good), is encouraged by a hope of a reward, (Heaven), rather that a true altruistic motive. The later being far and away the more deserving of praise. Does this come into play with you?
I know you're not directing this question at me, but I'd like to interject a personal observation that I'm not sure that it really matters what motivates someone towards good behaviour. As long as good things are done, does it really matter if someone is doing them in the hope of a reward after they're dead (as opposed to someone doing it in the hope of a reward now, which is a different matter) rather than because of "true" altruism?
 
I know you're not directing this question at me, but I'd like to interject a personal observation that I'm not sure that it really matters what motivates someone towards good behaviour. As long as good things are done, does it really matter if someone is doing them in the hope of a reward after they're dead (as opposed to someone doing it in the hope of a reward now, which is a different matter) rather than because of "true" altruism?
The end justifies the means?

The point is "true altruism" doesn't expect any reward and it's done totally voluntarily.

Never having been a theists I’ve always wondered if some theists think that if they were to give up their theism then they would turn into the “nasty” people they seem to believe atheists are. Part of the "reward" of theism seems to be that you become a "better" person. As this I was good, but now I'm gooder" post demonstrates.
 
Last edited:
Seems to me that those that were “born into” theism are more likely to be reasoned out of it than those that emotionally chose to become theists in later life. And the “born into” are more likely to reason themselves out of theism in later life.
 
Seems to me that those that were “born into” theism are more likely to be reasoned out of it than those that emotionally chose to become theists in later life. And the “born into” are more likely to reason themselves out of theism in later life.

A lot of the "born into" are born into rigid dogmas, which certain personality types can't help but reason their way out of eventually. The problems with YEC, for example, were glaringly obvious to me by the time I was 9 or so.
 
Never having been a theists I’ve always wondered if some theists think that if they were to give up their theism then they would turn into the “nasty” people they seem to believe atheists are. Part of the "reward" of theism seems to be that you become a "better" person.

I absolutely assumed that, and didn't really get how absurd that is until I'd been an atheist for quite a while.

When I was Xtian, I was taught that your own conscience is god/"the holy spirit", and that atheists reject that, ergo they have no conscience.
 
I absolutely assumed that, and didn't really get how absurd that is until I'd been an atheist for quite a while.

When I was Xtian, I was taught that your own conscience is god/"the holy spirit", and that atheists reject that, ergo they have no conscience.
Thanks for the personal confirmation.
 
I know you're not directing this question at me, but I'd like to interject a personal observation that I'm not sure that it really matters what motivates someone towards good behaviour. As long as good things are done, does it really matter if someone is doing them in the hope of a reward after they're dead (as opposed to someone doing it in the hope of a reward now, which is a different matter) rather than because of "true" altruism?

The end justifies the means?

The point is "true altruism" doesn't expect any reward and it's done totally voluntarily.

Never having been a theists I’ve always wondered if some theists think that if they were to give up their theism then they would turn into the “nasty” people they seem to believe atheists are. Part of the "reward" of theism seems to be that you become a "better" person. As this I was good, but now I'm gooder" post demonstrates.


I 100% agree with you ynot..... but arth, I can hardly believe you can think this. Do you really think it is just as good for someone to do stuff, because they think there is a reward coming, as for someone who does it with no such expectation?

There is a danger here also that we are all acutely aware of. When the do- gooder does stuff like flying planes into buildings because he thinks that is what his god wants.
 
There is a danger here also that we are all acutely aware of. When the do- gooder does stuff like flying planes into buildings because he thinks that is what his god wants.
I was going to bring up the subjectivity of "good", but I seemed to run out of "ink" at the time.
 
Am puzzled by your claim that theism put "forgiveness, helping, treating others seriously" onto a solid foundation for you. How so?

The point has been made repeatedly by atheists, that the morality of Christians, (their incentive to do good), is encouraged by a hope of a reward, (Heaven), rather that a true altruistic motive. The later being far and away the more deserving of praise. Does this come into play with you?
No, nothing to do with reward or punishment. It's following what I think is meaningful and true: that there is a metaphysical existence for goodness and "there is more to life than living", which I know you regard as a meaningless statement. That's the foundation upon which things like forgiveness, etc, take on importance.
 
I can imagine not opening the box. That's faith.
Well, no, deciding to not open the box is not faith. Faith equates to trust or confidence. "God exists", by itself, isn't a statement of faith. "God has a plan for us even while we suffer" is a statement of faith. I'd say deciding to not open the box is an example of a closed mind trying to avoid cognitive dissonance.

One of the things I believed, implicitly, without needing any liturgical justification, at a level so deep I basically took it for granted, was that God answered prayer...

Surely people had studied this. I knew how to look up those studies. I knew how to interpret them properly. I just needed to find them, and read them.

That was my box, and with determination barely overcoming trepidation, I opened it.
That's good. You found out that a God who answers prayers in a substantive way doesn't exist. I agree. A God who answers prayers in a substantive way doesn't exist. I commend anyone who changes their views based on the evidence, so you did well. :thumbsup:
 
There is a danger here also that we are all acutely aware of. When the do- gooder does stuff like flying planes into buildings because he thinks that is what his god wants.


Or when the do-gooder bombs whole cities because he thinks that's what his president wants.
And the do-gooder isn't even wrong about that, and he doesn't even have to be religious.
 
Or when the do-gooder bombs whole cities because he thinks that's what his president wants.
And the do-gooder isn't even wrong about that, and he doesn't even have to be religious.
To some, patriotism is pretty much a religion.

Wonder how "anyone who changes their views based on the evidence" can do so when their views aren't based on evidence and ignore all evidence?
 
Last edited:
To some, patriotism is pretty much a religion.

Wonder how "anyone who changes their views based on the evidence" can do so when their views aren't based on evidence and ignore all evidence?

The question is not whether there are other bad things besides religion, but whether religion is one of them.

Incidentally, visceral patriotism is often accompanied by a particular religion. You know, for God and Country.
Some people may not be worse with patriotism and religion, but, as a rule, religious patriotism is scary.

What can have in common patriotism and religion that go together so easily?
 
That one's easy:



Those lyrics alone should have made them reconsider giving him the Nobel prize.
 
Last edited:
Or when the do-gooder bombs whole cities because he thinks that's what his president wants.
And the do-gooder isn't even wrong about that, and he doesn't even have to be religious.


Getting a little desperate here aren't we?

You won't score points with this kind of crap. We are talking about religion here on the "religion and philosophy" site.
 
No, nothing to do with reward or punishment. It's following what I think is meaningful and true: that there is a metaphysical existence for goodness and "there is more to life than living", which I know you regard as a meaningless statement. That's the foundation upon which things like forgiveness, etc, take on importance.


Oh well I suppose we will have to agree to disagree on this subject then, although I wonder what you think are the chances of others, who do not share you're conviction about the importance of belief in the metaphysical, finding themselves in the same place you are. I mean being right on board with the forgiveness and so on without the belief in supernatural?
 
Getting a little desperate here aren't we?

You won't score points with this kind of crap. We are talking about religion here on the "religion and philosophy" site.

We are debating religion, philosophy and science.

They are connected in the field of belief versus knowledge. Of course you can substitute knowledge with evidence, truth and so on.
In other words the question is if there is a limit to reason, logic and evidence?
Or if it is not possible to have only beliefs which are backed up with reason, logic and evidence?
So do I as an atheists have beliefs for which I can't use reason, logic and evidence?
If so, how do these beliefs compare to religious beliefs?

With regard
 
Oh well I suppose we will have to agree to disagree on this subject then, although I wonder what you think are the chances of others, who do not share you're conviction about the importance of belief in the metaphysical, finding themselves in the same place you are. I mean being right on board with the forgiveness and so on without the belief in supernatural?
Depends on how you deal with such metaphysical ideas. If you regard them as ideas that are either empirically true or meaningless, then you are okay. No conflict with philosophical naturalism. If you regard them as true in some non-empirical way, while sticking to empiricism, then you will have cognitive dissonance. I felt that I had a cognitive dissonance that I needed to resolve, and becoming a theist is how I resolved it.
 
We are debating religion, philosophy and science.

They are connected in the field of belief versus knowledge. Of course you can substitute knowledge with evidence, truth and so on.
In other words the question is if there is a limit to reason, logic and evidence?
Or if it is not possible to have only beliefs which are backed up with reason, logic and evidence?
So do I as an atheists have beliefs for which I can't use reason, logic and evidence?
If so, how do these beliefs compare to religious beliefs?

With regard

The issue of religion is broader than the opposition between beliefs and certainties: it includes morality or politics. This is to say, ideology.

Let us admit that every ideology is based on at least one belief. That does not equate theism with atheism, nor does it make every system of thought irrational, because there are rational and irrational beliefs. A belief is rational when it does not contradict facts or logic and is based on principles that can be shared by as many people as possible —among other minor criteria such as the independence or thought. Since I know something about how you think, I know that perhaps you are thinking about the existence of the outside world. Let us admit that it cannot be absolutely proven.
However, it is rational to believe that the outside world exists because it is a belief shared by an overwhelming number of human beings and fits the facts as we know them. And it is an independent idea, that is, not subject to pressure from any power group.

The problem with religion is that it is a particularistic belief and that often clashes with what we know of the facts. It is usually supported by believers who think under pressure from power groups, i.e. churches or sects, under intense emotional pressuring.

That is why religion is an irrational belief and lack of religion is a rational belief. Some exceptions are possible, but this is the general rule.
 
I 100% agree with you ynot..... but arth, I can hardly believe you can think this. Do you really think it is just as good for someone to do stuff, because they think there is a reward coming, as for someone who does it with no such expectation?

Not speaking for anybody else, but I do. Being an atheist and a materialist, I'm of the opinion that whatever goes on inside other people's heads is utterly unimportant and entirely their own business. People can think whatever they like and have whatever reasons they like for doing anything. The only thing that matters is what they do.

There is a danger here also that we are all acutely aware of. When the do- gooder does stuff like flying planes into buildings because he thinks that is what his god wants.

I'm not sure that the kind of ideology people will kill for requires a religious component. I mean, not to want to Godwin the thread, but Hitler was anti-religion and he managed to perpetrate one of the largest mass evils of the entire history of this planet.

I also think that most people think of themselves as the good guys.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom