Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Not believing in god(s) is agnosticism (weak atheism). Believing the universe is godless is strong atheism.

No, an atheist doesn't believe in gods. An agnostic doesn't believe it's possible to have complete knowledge of gods. You can be an agnostic atheist, an agnostic theist, a gnostic atheist, and a gnostic theist.

They are two different concepts, not degrees of one concept.

As for whether you're right or not in your assessment of what most atheists think on the subject, I'd have to see reliable figures to comment. But it is fair to say that Richard Dawkins would fall under your heading of "agnostic", and he's pretty passionate on the subject.
 
Last edited:
Ha! A lot of theists think they've concluded that god exists. Which is probably generally true, even if it's a case of "motivated reasoning."
Okay then . . .

Believing god(s) actually exist is "irrational-conclusion-theism"

Better?
 
Forgiveness only became even possible for me once I became an atheist. The naturalist perspective on free will kind of bakes forgiveness in.

Helping and stuff like that became monumentally more urgent for me once I lost faith in an afterlife and abandoned the idea of any sort of cosmic justice or a god to come help us or relieve suffering.


Yes, there's a big difference between, on the one hand, comforting the poor: 'You'll get pie in the sky when you die', the rich, the camel and the eye of the needle etc., and on the other hand, getting rid of poverty.
What is a little poverty in comparison to the rewards awaiting you in eternity?
 
I wouldn't say I believe it because it makes me happy. I'm happy to believe it because "there is a God" makes sense within a metaphysical framework that best describes a number of things I came to believe were important. I'd prefer to describe it as a "leap of faith", which is required for taking any such metaphysical position.


The word "metaphysical" is just a piece of gobbledygook that is being used to hide the real issue. And, as used here, so is the term "framework" ... that's just a way to talk in deceptive riddles.

The reason why in the 21st century people (inc. you personally) should no longer believe in a supernatural creator of the universe, is that over the last 100-200 years science has shown far beyond all credible doubt that all the things once attributed to such gods, are perfectly natural events that are nothing to do with anything supernatural at all.

And the only reason why in ancient times (e.g. biblical times) people ever thought that a supernatural God was the answer, was because at the time there was no such thing as modern science, and there was no understanding of how the world around us worked. At the time, e.g. 1st century AD, it seemed like a reasonable, and perhaps even obvious conclusion, to say that human life must have been caused by a supernatural God, and similarly also such things as thunder & lightening, floods and droughts, volcanoes, famine and disease, success or failure of the crops, the stars in the sky & day turning into night, even all life and death itself ... these were all things that no man could produce, and yet they existed, so it probably did seem logical to believe that it must have all been caused by an invisible God with superhuman powers.

But that's 2000+ years ago! And we are now in the 21st century where we know how all those things happen, and not a single one of them happens due to any invisible superhuman gods.

In particular, to state the "bleeding obvious", the discovery of evolution really is fatal to all religious beliefs such as Christianity which say that God made man ... because evolution shows that a God most certainly did not make any humans. And that belief of God creating Man, is really the entire basis of religions like Christianity - without that the religion has no foundation at all.

Of course eventually church leaders like the previous Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams began to grudgingly accept that homo sapiens had indeed evolved from earlier apes, but they then claimed that evolution itself had been deliberately created by God as his way of creating humans! Though, of course that is not what any of them said before evolution was discovered.

But you (i.e. Gdon) should know from discoveries like that, that the entire basis of such religious beliefs is now known to be no more than untrue superstitious myth-making that came from times of ignorance thousands of years ago. And for Christians like you to “reason” otherwise, is just either wilful ignorance and a dangerous denial of science and education in general, or else monumental self-delusion (which is again extremely dangerous).



That's an interesting statement. What is the "empirically true" evidence that I am ignoring? Off-hand, I can't think of anything. What have I missed?


The evidence that you are ignoring is all of the many millions of things that science has now discovered and explained about the world around us, all of which is really completely incompatible with religious belief in a supernatural creator. But of course you do know that very well.
 
Last edited:
Not believing in god(s) is agnosticism (weak atheism). Believing the universe is godless is strong atheism.


The word "Atheist" (i.e. "theist" with a leading letter "A"), just means "not theist". It means someone who does not believe in the existence of religious gods.

But regardless of what anyone can dig up from dictionary definitions etc., what in practice is universally meant by the term 'atheist", is that the person does not believe in the existence of the claimed religious God.

People here (such as me) who would describe themselves as "atheists" (on the very rare occasions that it's necessary to even bother making any such declaration), simply believe that science and/or other educational advances, have shown that it's really no longer credible to believe that invisible supernatural creatures exist (let alone ones who deliberately created the entire universe).
 
I would certainly open the box. My emotions: trepidation, excitement. But I couldn't imagine NOT opening the box.
I can imagine not opening the box. That's faith. The surety of knowledge that the heavens and earth are as you understand them, leading to the conclusion that whatever is inside the box must be wrong, therefore there's no need to find out, apart from idle curiosity. Not many people have that kind of faith, but they exist.

Personally I think most people would open the box, but find some excuse to reject whatever they find inside anyway. Not reason, not faith, just apologetics. Humans are masters of cognitive dissonance. There's limitless ways to cradle an uncomfortable fact in your head, and simply refuse to consider what it might mean. But that's just another box, isn't it?

But! My story. The full tale's more complicated (whose isn't), but this played a fairly big role in it. Imagine if you will a younger me, less cynical, full of piss and vinegar and a newfound understanding of statistics.

Unlike many of the posters here, I can't pat myself on the back and claim that I was never really all that religious. I was a Believer. Capital B. You can probably guess by my username that there's still some lingering baggage there. One of the things I believed, implicitly, without needing any liturgical justification, at a level so deep I basically took it for granted, was that God answered prayer. Not the way Minoosh described earlier in the thread, which no offense but you could get the same effect with an inspirational cat poster, but actually answering it. Miracles happened. People were healed. Not often enough to justify the kooks who insisted on praying for their kids instead of taking them to the hospital, but it did still happen.

But, remember, now I knew statistics. If it happened, there'd be an effect. If there was an effect, you could measure it. Sure, I could imagine God spoiling any given experiment, "do not put the Lord your God to the test for the Lord your God was not informed there would be a pop quiz over this" and all, but on a population level Christians should just die less. Or Muslims, or adherents of Bongo Bongo lord of the Congo, whatever. There's no getting around that. If there was someone out there with a chosen people, we should see it.

Surely people had studied this. I knew how to look up those studies. I knew how to interpret them properly. I just needed to find them, and read them.

That was my box, and with determination barely overcoming trepidation, I opened it.

I'm sure you can guess what I found. When you control for race, wealth and other non-denominational factors that might impact healthcare access (there's plenty of "studies" that compare rich white Christians to poor black Muslims), you're left with no effect. None whatsoever. I had been wrong - it doesn't happen. There's no one there answering prayers in any substantive way. Either that or for every prayer answered, God goes out and kills someone who would otherwise have lived, which is even worse, you know?

Now after that it wasn't like I went "welp, guess it's all a sham then!" and went out to buy a fedora to tip at an angle. I certainly did try to find an excuse for my little revelation. But rationalization's not for me. I'm not satisfied with a comforting lie. It doesn't matter how it makes me feel, it's still a lie. It's not true. Hearing people say they're praying for poor old Aunt Mildred's recovery (seriously, not just in the "thoughts and prayers" sense), and knowing it doesn't work like that, in fact it doesn't work at all... it wasn't long before I was questioning everything else as well. And if there's one thing religious beliefs can't tolerate, it's actual scrutiny that doesn't take "well, it's true from a certain point of view" for an answer.
 
No, an atheist doesn't believe in gods. An agnostic doesn't believe it's possible to have complete knowledge of gods. You can be an agnostic atheist, an agnostic theist, a gnostic atheist, and a gnostic theist.

They are two different concepts, not degrees of one concept.

As for whether you're right or not in your assessment of what most atheists think on the subject, I'd have to see reliable figures to comment. But it is fair to say that Richard Dawkins would fall under your heading of "agnostic", and he's pretty passionate on the subject.

The term has a lot of meanings. I was referring to the following:

Nowadays, the term “agnostic” is often used (when the issue is God’s existence) to refer to those who follow the recommendation expressed in the conclusion of Huxley’s argument: an agnostic is a person who has entertained the proposition that there is a God but believes neither that it is true nor that it is false.
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/atheism-agnosticism/#DefiAgno
 
The term has a lot of meanings. I was referring to the following:

Nowadays, the term “agnostic” is often used (when the issue is God’s existence) to refer to those who follow the recommendation expressed in the conclusion of Huxley’s argument: an agnostic is a person who has entertained the proposition that there is a God but believes neither that it is true nor that it is false.
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/atheism-agnosticism/#DefiAgno
(1884)

Oll Korrect, sure, whatever ambulates your velocipede.
 
The term has a lot of meanings. I was referring to the following:

Nowadays, the term “agnostic” is often used (when the issue is God’s existence) to refer to those who follow the recommendation expressed in the conclusion of Huxley’s argument: an agnostic is a person who has entertained the proposition that there is a God but believes neither that it is true nor that it is false.
https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/atheism-agnosticism/#DefiAgno

That's not how you defined it, and it is, as I originally said, irrelevant to the post of mine that you posted it in reply to.
 
That's not how you defined it, and it is, as I originally said, irrelevant to the post of mine that you posted it in reply to.

I defined it as
"Not believing in god(s) is agnosticism (weak atheism)"

which seems equivalent to: an agnostic is a person who has entertained the proposition that there is a God but believes neither that it is true nor that it is false.

Someone who believes "god exists" is neither true nor false (i.e., they don't know) necessarily doesn't believe in any god(s).
 
I defined it as

which seems equivalent to: an agnostic is a person who has entertained the proposition that there is a God but believes neither that it is true nor that it is false.
Sorry, but that means something very different.
 
I defined it as

which seems equivalent to: an agnostic is a person who has entertained the proposition that there is a God but believes neither that it is true nor that it is false.

It's not.

Someone who believes "god exists" is neither true nor false (i.e., they don't know) necessarily doesn't believe in any god(s).

No.

And it's still all utterly irrelevant.
 
I defined it as

uote:
"Not believing in god(s) is agnosticism (weak atheism)"

which seems equivalent to: Someone who believes "god exists" is neither true nor false (i.e., they don't know) necessarily doesn't believe in any god(s).


Your highlight just appears appears to be an unnecessarily convoluted way (and hence a misleading way) of saying that a person is "agnostic" if they have no clear or strong opinion either way about the existence of God (e.g. the Christian God in this case) ...

... IOW, it's the same as them saying they think he might exist, but they are by no means sure about.

An "atheist" is anyone who does feel pretty sure that the God does not exist. They should not say they know for certain that a God could not exist, because none of us can really be that literally "certain" about anything (perhaps the entire universe is an illusion ... though all evidence is against that), but they might reasonably say they think it's virtually certain that he does not exist ...

... they might also add by way of explanation that they think all we have now learned from modern science (and perhaps from other areas of modern education), shows why we should regard it as virtually certain that no supernatural creator of any kind exists (or even could exist, given what we know understand about the laws of physics etc.).
 
Your highlight just appears appears to be an unnecessarily convoluted way (and hence a misleading way) of saying that a person is "agnostic" if they have no clear or strong opinion either way about the existence of God (e.g. the Christian God in this case) ...

... IOW, it's the same as them saying they think he might exist, but they are by no means sure about.

An "atheist" is anyone who does feel pretty sure that the God does not exist. They should not say they know for certain that a God could not exist, because none of us can really be that literally "certain" about anything (perhaps the entire universe is an illusion ... though all evidence is against that), but they might reasonably say they think it's virtually certain that he does not exist ...

... they might also add by way of explanation that they think all we have now learned from modern science (and perhaps from other areas of modern education), shows why we should regard it as virtually certain that no supernatural creator of any kind exists (or even could exist, given what we know understand about the laws of physics etc.).

Roughly. It's an epistemological term that's been "co-opted" by religion. It means that the evidence for and against a proposition is equally compelling (or equally unconvincing), so the person reserves judgement.
 
The word "Atheist" (i.e. "theist" with a leading letter "A"), just means "not theist". It means someone who does not believe in the existence of religious gods.

But regardless of what anyone can dig up from dictionary definitions etc., what in practice is universally meant by the term 'atheist", is that the person does not believe in the existence of the claimed religious God.

....

......

An "atheist" is anyone who does feel pretty sure that the God does not exist. They should not say they know for certain that a God could not exist, because none of us can really be that literally "certain" about anything (perhaps the entire universe is an illusion ... though all evidence is against that), but they might reasonably say they think it's virtually certain that he does not exist ...

... they might also add by way of explanation that they think all we have now learned from modern science (and perhaps from other areas of modern education), shows why we should regard it as virtually certain that no supernatural creator of any kind exists (or even could exist, given what we know understand about the laws of physics etc.).

:thumbsup:Exactly.

I would add however there is evidence a caring god does not exist, because of the cruelty we can see in the world around us - in the animal kingdom as well as our own. This I maintain is evidence against the existence of a compassionate god.
 
It's a good question. Nothing big in differences, but many small things. I was a good man when I was an atheist, and I was the same good man when I was a theist (with the same bad traits either way). But a lot of small things became more important to me -- forgiveness, helping, treating others seriously. Not that I didn't believe in those things when I was an atheist, but becoming a theist put them into a solid foundation for me. I started to take other theological ideas like grace and mercy seriously also.


Am puzzled by your claim that theism put "forgiveness, helping, treating others seriously" onto a solid foundation for you. How so?

The point has been made repeatedly by atheists, that the morality of Christians, (their incentive to do good), is encouraged by a hope of a reward, (Heaven), rather that a true altruistic motive. The later being far and away the more deserving of praise. Does this come into play with you?
 
The issue here is with people who believe that there is a linear spectrum, with atheism at one end, theism at the other, and agnosticism in the middle, and people who believe that the atheism/theism axis and the gnosticism/agnosticism access cross each other. I refer to them as the one-dimensionalists and the two-dimensionalists.

Most arguments about the definitions of the words atheism and agnosticism come down to this argument - is it a one-dimensional spectrum or a two-dimensional spectrum? Personally, I'm of the two-dimensionalist camp, but I recognise that there are language difficulties when discussing the matters with one-dimensionalists.
 
Your words are welcome pearls (before swine), but this . . .
The word "Atheist" (i.e. "theist" with a leading letter "A"), just means "not theist". It means someone who does not believe in the existence of religious gods.
contradicts this . . .
An "atheist" is anyone who does feel pretty sure that the God does not exist.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom