Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

I'd say "emotionally thought", not "intellectually thought". Essentially no different from other theists. I'd be happy to hear details of any counter-argument.


True enough, but I see the way GDon got to his theism as being unusual and his responses to questions thought out, rather than glib answers fed to him by a religious hierarchy. This is why I find his answers of interest.
 
You're the one who claimed to have reasoned your way into religion, yet, when you present us with the alleged reasons, you simply say: 'reasons', i.e. "a number (!) of things (!) I came to believe were important." You say that you don't believe "because it makes me happy." Yet, "I'm happy to believe it because ..."

There's a reason (actually there are a number of things) why cosmologists are pretty convinced that the Big Bang was an actual thing (or an actual event), and what's more, they are actually able to name those things. Same thing with evolution and Darwin. He might have said, 'Evolution is an idea I've reasoned my way into.' But he'd continue, 'Now let me show you some fossils.'

See the difference?!


To be fair I sort of put those words in GDons mouth - being reasoned into theistic belief. If you look back a few posts you will see GDon's concession that it was more a "feeling his way" into religion or a "leap of faith" as he puts it.
 
True enough, but I see the way GDon got to his theism as being unusual and his responses to questions thought out, rather than glib answers fed to him by a religious hierarchy. This is why I find his answers of interest.
I don’t see anything unusual or thought out at all (certainly not well thought out). Post an example of one of his (her?) well thought out responses to a question and you may change my mind.

Like all theists he doesn’t provide any information regarding his God belief other than claiming it’s his belief and it’s different (reminds me of Anne Elk).

Like all theists, he simply believes in a god because he wants to and it suits his emotions to do so. That he claims his particular god belief is “rational” simple because he believes and says it is, is no different from the intelligent design crowd. It's merely a pathetic way of ignoring/denying one's own cognitive dissonance.

See post #337

Nothing new here folks . . .
 
Last edited:
I'm butting into the conversation here just to report something that most atheists would probably call an irrational belief. It's this: I pray sometimes and it "works." I do not ask for specific outcomes; I pray for guidance and strength. Oh, I might slip in my own preference, but it always ends pretty much with asking for help dealing with whatever difficult reality is presenting itself. For example, I was afraid a friend was drinking himself to death, and I wasn't in a position to stop him. I didn't ask God to save him. I used the Serenity Prayer - grant me the serenity to accept the things I could not change, courage to change the things I could and wisdom to know the difference.

Immediately I got an insight that all I could really change was my own level of fear (I was in agony). Immediately I hit on the one thing I could do: Call 911 and ask for a welfare check. The cop who went to his apartment turned out to be a woman who had previously arrested me (long story). She had also been to this young man's apartment under similar circumstances. She called me to tell me he was being taken to the hospital. During the conversation the hospital called a code on someone and she told me it was not my friend. She was also happy I was doing well, at least for the moment. My friend did die, but by then I knew several people had tried to save him - there were no "if only" thoughts nagging at me. In the midst of this my beloved brother also died suddenly at age 39. I somehow managed to step up and help my parents who were too heartbroken to arrange cremation and settle his affairs. I felt there was a wellspring within me of strength I never knew I had. It felt like a gift - but of course that proves nothing.

I don't even make the claim that God exists. Nevertheless, I perceive that on some occasions, prayer has helped me. I don't do it for "comfort," I don't ask God to cure anyone's cancer. When my dad suddenly took a turn for the worse my mother asked me to drive up (100+ miles) to see him while he was still coherent. I hung up and had the exact same insight: Call 911. Which she did. My dad had cancer and he had also suddenly become insulin-dependent,, leading to the emergency. I know it might seem strange that my "revelation" involved such a common-sense step. But my mom wasn't thinking clearly, and I strongly suspected he needed insulin, and it felt like I was experiencing a higher level of clarity on the heels of the arrow-prayer I let fly while getting my funeral dress from the closet.

On the way out of town I stopped by a 12-step meeting and there were probably 15 friends there who IIRC did not even remotely mention anything about "God's will." (Some meetings probably would). When I got to my mom's, before I went to the hospital I prayed. If he was dying that day, so be it. (Thy will be done). I probably asked for strength, chiefly to help my mother. If he wasn't dying that day, I did ask, if possible, that he could still find some pleasure in the time he had left. It did turn out that way - he had many visitors, and though bedridden he was rarely in pain.

All that really changed was my internal state. But the prayer apparently helped me focus. It's different than just giving myself a pep talk, or doing affirmations, or thinking really hard about the outcome I want. I don't really know who or what I'm talking to, but for want of a better term I'm OK calling this perceived entity God.

Unfortunately, Osama bin Laden also probably prayed and his God apparently told him to murder 3,000 people. So I don't make any broad claims about the efficacy of prayer. I very seldom tell people I'll pray for them, because I don't think God or whoever/whatever is holding a popularity contest to decide who to save. (I also might forget to pray for them, being self-absorbed as I am).

I could give other examples. When I was regularly doing morning prayer/meditation my life just seemed ... I don't even know how to say it. I just felt guided, in a positive way judging by how useful I was to other people (roughly, you know the spirit by the fruits). I still do it, but only sporadically. Lately I've been dealing with a lot of tough-acting teenagers who often are basically homeless or otherwise facing hair-raising personal lives. I pray for the strength to accept and support them. There's no drama to it; it just seems to tip me in the direction of empathy and patience, even if I do have to play the authority figure sometimes.

As far as I can tell there is no empirical finding I reject; no religion I believe in its entirety; no need to convert anyone. I'm just talking about me. Perhaps humans have evolved as creatures who deal with the awareness of death by seeking a connection with the eternal - whatever that is - through rituals of supplication. From my perspective I did not "choose" to believe anything. I call myself agnostic rather than a theist. I've heard people say their own survival proves there's a God, which I find ridiculous. (I don't, however, ridicule them).

I'd love to really grasp all the math and physics that apparently led to the sudden and spontaneous creation of the universe, but I don't doubt that it happened roughly the way cosmologists say it did. I don't think there's anything to reason me out of. No YEC or big boat or transubstantiation. No magic, no miracles, no dogma that I know of. Yet - the concept of redemption sticks with me, which would be another overlong post!

This is just an experience I've wanted to share on these boards for awhile, but not something I wanted to start a thread on.
 
The 'leap of faith' thing. You seem to be implying that (forgive me if I am wrong), though I know that the universe is one way, I want it to be another way which I prefer to be true. But my belief in a God is consistent with empirical truth as well as a metaphysical truth that I came to accept as a 'leap of faith'.

You say it is the same thing, and I don't disagree. But again, just to be clear: I'm not 'preferring it to be true', in the sense that 'I know it isn't true but I wish it was so I believe it.' I accept "there is a God" is true as an informal 'working hypothesis', in the absence of evidence to the contrary, and in its consistency with my metaphysical beliefs.
What are the characteristics of your God?
 
This is just an experience I've wanted to share on these boards for awhile, but not something I wanted to start a thread on.


Thinking seriously about a problem of any kind, may be a way of solving it, or it may be a way of coming to terms with it. Writing about it, discussing it with a friend, real or imaginary, likewise.
 
It appears to me that your belief in God (as well as GDon's) is the result of reasoning. Whether that reasoning is valid or not is not for me to say, but the point being that the belief is a result of tying the contents of thoughts ( aka ideas) in a religious based construct.
As compared to a belief in God stemming from raw experience, such as a shared experience of seeing and hearing a giant speaking floating head.
As such, your belief is subject to modification, either by yourself, or the ideas of others.
Which is not saying that every person who holds a belief, can have their belief modified by any argument; but in principle, beliefs are fluid.
So I don't get the thinking behind this thread.
Which is why I opened up the original question to 'If a person is reasoned out of a religious belief - where do they end up, what then is their belief system?'
The most common assumption in this thread is that then this person believes in or accepts scientific realism (or a variant). Is this the case?
 
It appears to me that your belief in God (as well as GDon's) is the result of reasoning. Whether that reasoning is valid or not is not for me to say, but the point being that the belief is a result of tying the contents of thoughts ( aka ideas) in a religious based construct.
As compared to a belief in God stemming from raw experience, such as a shared experience of seeing and hearing a giant speaking floating head.
As such, your belief is subject to modification, either by yourself, or the ideas of others.
Which is not saying that every person who holds a belief, can have their belief modified by any argument; but in principle, beliefs are fluid.
So I don't get the thinking behind this thread.
Which is why I opened up the original question to 'If a person is reasoned out of a religious belief - where do they end up, what then is their belief system?'
The most common assumption in this thread is that then this person believes in or accepts scientific realism (or a variant). Is this the case?

No!
Well, in a sense that no is to simple, because it has nothing per se to do with science. It has to do with, how the person is reasoned out of religion, if emotions are used, and what kind of morality/ethics the person reasoned out of religion ends up with.

You can claim science enables objective morality/ethics.
That you can't do morality/ethics using science.
Within the claim of objective morality/ethics, you find opposed different philosophical/political ideologies all being objective respectively and connected to science.

With regards
 
I'm trying to make sense of the original question: Can someone be reasoned out of religion (or any belief), that they weren't reasoned into.
The question assumes that reason (and emotion) can be distinguished, that person A beliefs were acquired via rationality, and person B was acquired via emotion (or something else).
I am not aware of any (ontological or moral) beliefs that were acquired via rationality alone.
 
I believe Dragon actually exists, and I’m happy to believe Dragon actually exists. My Dragon belief isn’t the same as other people’s dragon beliefs. My Dragon belief is consistent with empirical truth as well as a metaphysical truth. My Dragon belief is both rationally reasoned and a “leap of faith”. My Dragon belief is true because I know of no empirical evidence that proves it isn’t. If you believe you have such evidence please provide it.

Is it possible to reason me out of my Dragon belief?
 
Last edited:
I believe in your dragon, but I call it Bigfoot.
Sorry, but your dragon belief isn't the same as my Dragon belief.

Let me be clear: I'm not asking anyone to accept my Dragon belief or my reasons for believing it.

But if you have any ideas, I'd be interested to read them. What I won't respond to are (A) insults (unavoidable or not!), or (B) "maybe" arguments, e.g. "maybe Dragon is bad" or "maybe Bigfoot exists", or things like that.
 
Last edited:
True enough, but I see the way GDon got to his theism as being unusual and his responses to questions thought out, rather than glib answers fed to him by a religious hierarchy.
Actually, I'd say my path to theism is not unusual at all. If you read early writers like Plutarch and Origen, they trod similar paths. Buddhists and Taoists do also. A more recent example can be found in Terry Pratchett's Hogfather book, from here:
https://www.goodreads.com/work/quotes/583655-hogfather

Death is talking to Susan. Death's comments are in caps (caps in the original):

“All right," said Susan. "I'm not stupid. You're saying humans need... fantasies to make life bearable."

REALLY? AS IF IT WAS SOME KIND OF PINK PILL? NO. HUMANS NEED FANTASY TO BE HUMAN. TO BE THE PLACE WHERE THE FALLING ANGEL MEETS THE RISING APE.

"Tooth fairies? Hogfathers? Little—"

YES. AS PRACTICE. YOU HAVE TO START OUT LEARNING TO BELIEVE THE LITTLE LIES.

"So we can believe the big ones?"

YES. JUSTICE. MERCY. DUTY. THAT SORT OF THING.

"They're not the same at all!"

YOU THINK SO? THEN TAKE THE UNIVERSE AND GRIND IT DOWN TO THE FINEST POWDER AND SIEVE IT THROUGH THE FINEST SIEVE AND THEN SHOW ME ONE ATOM OF JUSTICE, ONE MOLECULE OF MERCY. AND YET—Death waved a hand. AND YET YOU ACT AS IF THERE IS SOME IDEAL ORDER IN THE WORLD, AS IF THERE IS SOME...SOME RIGHTNESS IN THE UNIVERSE BY WHICH IT MAY BE JUDGED.

"Yes, but people have got to believe that, or what's the point—"

MY POINT EXACTLY.”​

The idea "there is more to life" pops up everywhere. How do you argue with someone who doesn't believe that there is more to life than just living? I don't think you can, since it isn't an empirically true statement. You either believe it or you don't.
 
Others can’t ask “me” to provide empirical evidence to prove “my” metaphysical belief because there’s no such thing as empirical evidence for metaphysical beliefs.

“I” can ask others to provide empirical evidence to disprove “my” metaphysical belief however, because when they can’t (obviously), “I” can then claim “my” metaphysical belief is therefore consistent with empirical evidence.

Lack of proof for isn’t disproof against, but lack of disproof against is proof for. This is what "I" call “rational”.
 
Last edited:
The valid conclusion "there is no more to life" pops up everywhere. How do you argue with someone who believes that there is more to life than just living? I don't think you can, since it isn't an empirically true statement. That you believe it's true doesn't establish that it is empirically true. That there’s absolutely no empirical evidence that proves or even suggests it is true, makes it valid to conclude it's virtually certain it isn’t. But belief has the advantage of being emotionally comforting for those that desire/require crutch comforts.
 
Last edited:
Well, in a sense that no is to simple, because it has nothing per se to do with science. It has to do with, how the person is reasoned out of religion, if emotions are used, and what kind of morality/ethics the person reasoned out of religion ends up with.
I'd be interested in hearing the experiences of those who have been reasoned out of religion. If it is because of some tragedy in their lives, resulting in "no good God would allow that", then that is a philosophical/metaphysical argument. It's certainly not something that is empirically true, since it needs to make certain assumptions about God. It seems as valid as the reverse.

Perhaps some who were theists and became atheists can give their reasons?
 
NEWSFLASH! . . . Apparently The Bible is not empirically true, and it makes assumptions and philosophical/metaphysical arguments! You heard it here first. More at 6:00.
 
Last edited:
Actually, I'd say my path to theism is not unusual at all. If you read early writers like Plutarch and Origen, they trod similar paths. Buddhists and Taoists do also. A more recent example can be found in Terry Pratchett's Hogfather book, from here:
https://www.goodreads.com/work/quotes/583655-hogfather

..........

The idea "there is more to life" pops up everywhere. How do you argue with someone who doesn't believe that there is more to life than just living? I don't think you can, since it isn't an empirically true statement. You either believe it or you don't.

Ok then not exceptionally unusual but somewhat different to the average theist, who is indoctrinated with a particular dogma in childhood, and cannot bring any critical analysis to bear on that. We have, and have had, many on this forum. Those who quote Biblical and Koranic verse at us, and state with authority that this or that is the "one true church" without constructive argument to substantiate.

That "there's more to life than just living" sounds very much like a deepedees - a term made famous by Dan Dennett. A term that sounds profound but on closer examination is revealed to be quite meaningless.
 
Ok then not exceptionally unusual but somewhat different to the average theist, who is indoctrinated with a particular dogma in childhood, and cannot bring any critical analysis to bear on that.
But how do you know that? I think I've mentioned elsewhere that IMO probably 90% of theists throughout history haven't really cared about God or their Holy Books. It's not that they CAN'T bring any critical analysis to bear on that, but they can't be bothered. What does it get them? They're busy with their lives, working and raising children.

That's the average theist. The non-average theist -- the other 10% -- probably have looked into their beliefs critically to some degree. I suggest you are coming from a position of "if they TRULY brought critical analysis to bear, they wouldn't be theists."

I'd also suggest that the percentages are the same for atheists as well.

We have, and have had, many on this forum. Those who quote Biblical and Koranic verse at us, and state with authority that this or that is the "one true church" without constructive argument to substantiate.
I honestly haven't seen many on this "Religion and Philosophy" forum. Perhaps we disagree over what makes "many".

That "there's more to life than just living" sounds very much like a deepedees - a term made famous by Dan Dennett. A term that sounds profound but on closer examination is revealed to be quite meaningless.
Sounds like Ms Teschmacher talking to Lex Luthor here (20 sec video):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1O83e7nagEw

"There's more to life than just living" is meaningless, IYO? Let me rephrase that as a True/False question: "If atheism is true, then there's no more to life than just living." True or false? Or meaningless?
 
Fortunately, there isn't more to life than just living. You don't need more if you're doing it right. When you enjoy life, you don't ask for more: 'Is that all?!'
However, doing it right depends on your living conditions: A lot of people are forced to work so much that they don't have time to live, or they don't have the basic necessities for enjoying life.
That's what makes class struggle necessary.
Religion, the people's opium, enables them to carry on with their meaningless lives by giving them a delusory reason to accept unacceptable conditions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom