Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

To re-phrase my point, can you not see that positing God as a reason for the universe to exist just moves the question back one step? The question is still "why is there something, rather than nothing?", you're just substituting a different word for the word "something" in that sentence.

Do you have an answer for why you think God exists? If you don't, then why is that more satisfying than not having an answer for why the universe exists? Does it, again, come down to what you'd like to be true?


This point has been made so many times by so many it's almost becoming trite to say it. That to one side it is still a very valid point although it fails to strike home with the religious.

Generally I find they parry the thrust with stuff like "God has always been." and the ultimate backstop "We can't understand this stuff with our limited comprehension."
 
Re the original question - I think we need to establish (if) we are in fact referencing two ideas here, 1) our raw experience of reality, and 2) our interpretation of our experiences.
The question then is, can we be reasoned out of our interpretation of our experiences, where religion and scientific realism are two possible interpretations.
Since there are multiple cases of people swapping interpretations, the answer seems to be Yes - even on a daily or moment to moment basis.
A back-door assumption in this thread is that religion is an add on, meaning if one gets reasoned out of religion, then one automatically falls back to scientific realism (or some variant). But scientific realism is just another interpretation.



I sense you are right that it is wrong, but damned if I can make enough sense of it to figure out what is wrong.:confused::boggled:
 
I sense you are right that it is wrong, but damned if I can make enough sense of it to figure out what is wrong.:confused::boggled:
Some posts are so far out of the ballpark it’s hard enough just to find the ball, let alone return it.

ETA - But I will try anyway . . .
Re the original question - I think we need to establish (if) we are in fact referencing two ideas here, 1) our raw experience of reality, and 2) our interpretation of our experiences.
We are not “in fact referencing two ideas here”.

The question then is, can we be reasoned out of our interpretation of our experiences, where religion and scientific realism are two possible interpretations.
This is not the question being asked by this thread

Since there are multiple cases of people swapping interpretations, the answer seems to be Yes - even on a daily or moment to moment basis.
Irrelevant.

A back-door assumption in this thread is that religion is an add on, meaning if one gets reasoned out of religion, then one automatically falls back to scientific realism (or some variant).
That’s not a "back-door assumption".

But scientific realism is just another interpretation.
No it isn’t.
 
Last edited:
This point has been made so many times by so many it's almost becoming trite to say it. That to one side it is still a very valid point although it fails to strike home with the religious.

Generally I find they parry the thrust with stuff like "God has always been." and the ultimate backstop "We can't understand this stuff with our limited comprehension."

There's never anything new in these discussions. All the points have been made before, many times, by many people.

I was interested, specifically, in GDon's answer.
 
There's never anything new in these discussions. All the points have been made before, many times, by many people.

I was interested, specifically, in GDon's answer.


Well as I said it is a valid point and yes it would be interesting to hear GDon's take on it. As distinct from the average indoctrinated theist, he seems to have thought or felt his way into where he is today.
 
Well as I said it is a valid point and yes it would be interesting to hear GDon's take on it. As distinct from the average indoctrinated theist, he seems to have thought or felt his way into where he is today.

I did briefly as a teenager - the vicar said that the early Christians died for their beliefs and they'd have known if it was a lie. I was never particularly comfortable with the idea of miracles, but thought it a good argument at the time. Since then I have realised how people can convince themselves of many things - to say nothing about the possibility that the most effective disciples would have been self-selecting for cult-like behaviour.
 
Well as I said it is a valid point and yes it would be interesting to hear GDon's take on it.

We have his take on it - that he's happy to believe whatever makes him happy. It's an attitude I've seen a couple of times before, and it's impossible to argue against, even if I were inclined to try.

If someone values their own happiness more than whether what they believe is empirically true, then that's how they feel, and they're entitled to feel like that. There's no point trying to tell them that they ought to value empiricism more than they do what makes them happy.
 
We have his take on it - that he's happy to believe whatever makes him happy. It's an attitude I've seen a couple of times before, and it's impossible to argue against, even if I were inclined to try.

If someone values their own happiness more than whether what they believe is empirically true, then that's how they feel, and they're entitled to feel like that. There's no point trying to tell them that they ought to value empiricism more than they do what makes them happy.


If you already know all this stuff why did you say:

"I was interested, specifically, in GDon's answer."
 
We have his take on it - that he's happy to believe whatever makes him happy. It's an attitude I've seen a couple of times before, and it's impossible to argue against, even if I were inclined to try.
I wouldn't say I believe it because it makes me happy. I'm happy to believe it because "there is a God" makes sense within a metaphysical framework that best describes a number of things I came to believe were important. I'd prefer to describe it as a "leap of faith", which is required for taking any such metaphysical position.

If someone values their own happiness more than whether what they believe is empirically true, then that's how they feel, and they're entitled to feel like that.
That's an interesting statement. What is the "empirically true" evidence that I am ignoring? Off-hand, I can't think of anything. What have I missed?
 
Last edited:
I did briefly as a teenager - the vicar said that the early Christians died for their beliefs and they'd have known if it was a lie. I was never particularly comfortable with the idea of miracles, but thought it a good argument at the time. Since then I have realised how people can convince themselves of many things - to say nothing about the possibility that the most effective disciples would have been self-selecting for cult-like behaviour.


The number of Christians dying for their beliefs are thin on the ground these days, but the number of others dying for the beliefs of Christians not so. Witness the ones in Africa dying of Aids because they are denied the use of condoms, the mothers in El Salvador dying because abortion is denied when needed, the gay guys dying because their rights to be gay are denied.

Mind you the Islamic extremists are well above par, in the dying for their beliefs stakes today.

Interesting how these arguments, (Can they even be called that?), seem so compelling to the indoctrinated mind, but so silly when reason is brought to bear.
 
Well as I said it is a valid point and yes it would be interesting to hear GDon's take on it. As distinct from the average indoctrinated theist, he seems to have thought or felt his way into where he is today.
I'd say "emotionally thought", not "intellectually thought". Essentially no different from other theists. I'd be happy to hear details of any counter-argument.
 
That's an interesting statement. What is the "empirically true" evidence that I am ignoring? Off-hand, I can't think of anything. What have I missed?
There's no such thing as empirically true metaphysical evidence. To have a metaphysical belief therefore you have to "ignore" any empirically true evidence that contradicts it. Are you claiming that a metaphysical god belief doesn't contradict any empirically true evidence?
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't say I believe it because it makes me happy. I'm happy to believe it because "there is a God" makes sense within a metaphysical framework that best describes a number of things I came to believe were important. I'd prefer to describe it as a "leap of faith", which is required for taking any such metaphysical position.

What is the "empirically true" evidence that I am ignoring? Off-hand, I can't think of anything. What have I missed?


When your own description is as hazy as this, you really can't ask anybody for evidence. You present no other reason for believing than 'having come to believe that it's important' to you, i.e. that you want to believe. Your "metaphysical framework" is mere pretentiousness, which enables you to maintain the delusion that you are a skeptic believer who reasoned his way into believing in something that there's actually no rational reason to believe. Sure, you'd "prefer (!) to describe it as a "leap of faith"".
You confuse reason with rationalization.
 
Last edited:
We have his take on it - that he's happy to believe whatever makes him happy. It's an attitude I've seen a couple of times before, and it's impossible to argue against, even if I were inclined to try.


A couple of times?! It's the basic idea of religion!

I am happy, I am happy
Happy Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday
I am happy, I am happy
'Cause Jesus is my best friend


That's what we used to sing at Sunday School at the local Baptist church when I was a few years old. Except that we did it in Danish, of course. :)
 
Last edited:
There's no such thing as empirically true metaphysical evidence.
Exactly. It's a contradiction in terms.

To have a metaphysical belief therefore you have to "ignore" any empirically true evidence that contradicts it.
What am I ignoring, in your opinion?

Are you claiming that a metaphysical god belief doesn't contradict any empirically true evidence?
Your metaphysical beliefs in what the "real" god who doesn't exist might. But my metaphysical god belief doesn't, as far as I know. So I'd be interested if I've missed anything. There are some philosophical and metaphysical arguments ("suffering in this world contradicts an omni God") that need to be resolved, but no empirical ones that I know about.
 
When your own description is as hazy as this, you really can't ask anybody for evidence.
Let me be clear: I'm not asking anyone to accept my reasons. I was asked for my own reasons, and that's what I've given.

As for my "hazy description": yes, I know my description doesn't satisfy many atheists, whom want an empirically clear reason to believe in a metaphysical being (which is impossible, as ynot demonstrates above), but that is on them, not me. I call it the atheists' "'real god' that doesn't exist".

You present no other reason for believing than 'having come to believe that it's important' to you, i.e. that you want to believe. Your "metaphysical framework" is mere pretentiousness, which enables you to maintain the delusion that you are a skeptic believer who reasoned his way into believing in something that there's actually no rational reason to believe. Sure, you'd "prefer (!) to describe it as a "leap of faith"".
You confuse reason with rationalization.
Okay, thanks for your input.
 
Exactly. It's a contradiction in terms.
Do you also agree that there's no such thing as true (actual) metaphysical evidence?

What am I ignoring, in your opinion?
Empirically true evidence in favour of evidence devoid belief.

Your metaphysical beliefs in what the "real" god who doesn't exist might. But my metaphysical god belief doesn't, as far as I know. So I'd be interested if I've missed anything. There are some philosophical and metaphysical arguments ("suffering in this world contradicts an omni God") that need to be resolved, but no empirical ones that I know about.
I have neither metaphysical nor god beliefs. Are you claiming that your metaphysical god belief is compatible with empirically true evidence and there's no contradiction between the two?
 
Last edited:
Let me be clear: I'm not asking anyone to accept my reasons. I was asked for my own reasons, and that's what I've given.
I’m happy to accept your reasons as being merely your reasons, but nothing else.

So far your reasons seem to be “I believe in a god because I want to, and it suits me to do so”. Please let me know if there’s anything I’ve missed.
 
Last edited:
Let me be clear: I'm not asking anyone to accept my reasons. I was asked for my own reasons, and that's what I've given.

As for my "hazy description": yes, I know my description doesn't satisfy many atheists, whom want an empirically clear reason to believe in a metaphysical being (which is impossible, as ynot demonstrates above), but that is on them, not me. I call it the atheists' "'real god' that doesn't exist".

Okay, thanks for your input.


You're the one who claimed to have reasoned your way into religion, yet, when you present us with the alleged reasons, you simply say: 'reasons', i.e. "a number (!) of things (!) I came to believe were important." You say that you don't believe "because it makes me happy." Yet, "I'm happy to believe it because ..."

There's a reason (actually there are a number of things) why cosmologists are pretty convinced that the Big Bang was an actual thing (or an actual event), and what's more, they are actually able to name those things. Same thing with evolution and Darwin. He might have said, 'Evolution is an idea I've reasoned my way into.' But he'd continue, 'Now let me show you some fossils.'

See the difference?!
 
If you already know all this stuff why did you say:

"I was interested, specifically, in GDon's answer."

Because not everybody would have given the same answer. Once I'd heard GDon's answer I knew it was one I'd heard before from some people. Until I'd heard his answer I didn't know what his answer was going to be.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom