Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Hi GDon

I don't know the exact nature of your beliefs, but I will go through one possible version of beliefs in God, which is not contradictory to epistemological evidence.
Now the joke in that is that some of my fellow atheists can't if their life depended on it separate metaphysics and epistemology.

Metaphysics and transcendent beliefs: The cornerstone in understanding that is to get behind the words in this version of objective: "having reality independent of the mind".
How does that work in practice? Well, I believe that I am not the first unmoved mover of reality, rather I am in causal terms the effect of being caused by something else; the rest of reality. The content of in my mind, my experiences, are not caused by me, they are caused by the part of reality, which is objective.
So in the formal sense: Objective reality causes subjective reality, my experiences; i.e. OR -> SR. So how do I know that there is computer screen in front of me independent of my mind? I don't, because it is a metaphysical/transcendent belief to claim that my experience of the computer means that the computer screen is there as the computer screen independent of my experience of it. I don't know that because I have no objective point of view. I only have my experiences.

So I don't know what OR is, other than it is there. So I believe the following: OR is as it appears to me and there is no supernatural OR. But from that doesn't follow what OR is! It only means that I believe in natural reality.
So then what about supernatural beliefs: You can believe in a Creator God, which has given you a soul and that you will go to Heaven. What you can't do, is to claim that you have for reality as it appears to both of us Objective Authority.
How is that? Because is unknown, what good/right and bad/wrong is for OR. So in practice it works this way; i.e. for a strong believer in Hell, she/he can claim that there are humans, who go to Hell and a strong believer in the Natural Reality can claim, that we all die when we die. But both are metaphysical/transcendent beliefs and there can be given no evidence for either.
In practice in means that we, you and I, can share the same ethical beliefs, though you are a theist and I am an atheist.
If you believe in a humanistic sense in humans, accept a secular society and democracy, don't judge humans in an OR sense and believe in universal human rights, we are the same. For everyday politics within this frame we might disagree, but we would hold the same core beliefs/opinions with it comes to morality/ethics.

With regards
 
I wouldn't say I believe it because it makes me happy. I'm happy to believe it because "there is a God" makes sense within a metaphysical framework that best describes a number of things I came to believe were important. I'd prefer to describe it as a "leap of faith", which is required for taking any such metaphysical position.

This seems like a tomayto/tomahto thing to me, although I'm happy to be corrected. You explicitly agreed that you choose to believe what you believe because you'd prefer reality to be that way.

That's an interesting statement. What is the "empirically true" evidence that I am ignoring? Off-hand, I can't think of anything. What have I missed?

I didn't say you'd missed any evidence. I said that you were less concerned with whether the existence of God was empirically true than you were with whether you'd like God to exist. That's what you're saying when you say that you're choosing to hold the beliefs you do because you'd prefer reality to be the way it is if your beliefs are true, rather than because empirical evidence has led you to those conclusions.

To discuss the specifics of empirical evidence and the existence or non-existence of God I'd need to know a lot more about the specifics of your beliefs, and that seems like a long and involved conversation that should probably happen in another thread.
 
A couple of times?! It's the basic idea of religion!

I think that most religious people care whether or not God actually exists. I think it's rarer for people to choose to believe because they'd like it to be true than it is for people to believe because they actually think it's true - or, at the very least, for this to be a conscious thought process that they are cognisant of.
 
In practice in means that we, you and I, can share the same ethical beliefs, though you are a theist and I am an atheist.
If you believe in a humanistic sense in humans, accept a secular society and democracy, don't judge humans in an OR sense and believe in universal human rights, we are the same. For everyday politics within this frame we might disagree, but we would hold the same core beliefs/opinions with it comes to morality/ethics.
Well said! :thumbsup:
 
I didn't say you'd missed any evidence. I said that you were less concerned with whether the existence of God was empirically true than you were with whether you'd like God to exist.
I've very concerned whether God is empirically true or not. Much more so than whether I'd like God to exist. If I've given a different opinion, then my apologies.

That's what you're saying when you say that you're choosing to hold the beliefs you do because you'd prefer reality to be the way it is if your beliefs are true, rather than because empirical evidence has led you to those conclusions.
I'd say that reality is foremost consistent with my beliefs, at least from an empirical perspective. The rest is a leap of faith, which as you say is 'tomato/tomayto'. If I'm not missing any contrary empirical evidence, then I'm guessing that means I've already evaluated all the empirical evidence available for the existence of God. Is there any empirical evidence that I'm missing, in your opinion?
 
Last edited:
Do you also agree that there's no such thing as true (actual) metaphysical evidence?
No, I disagree. If you die and go to heaven and meet God, would that constitute true (actual) metaphysical evidence to you?

GDon said:
What am I ignoring, in your opinion?
Empirically true evidence in favour of evidence devoid belief.
Okay. What empirically true evidence in favour of evidence devoid belief am I ignoring, in your opinion?

I have neither metaphysical nor god beliefs. Are you claiming that your metaphysical god belief is compatible with empirically true evidence and there's no contradiction between the two?
Yes. What's the empirically true evidence that contradicts my metaphysical god belief?
 
Well said! :thumbsup:

Now religion as an atheist regarding faith in faith, leap of faith, fidelity, doing the work and so on.

First faith in faith and leap of faith: I could be a Boltzmann brain or live in a reality, where I go to Hell. But I have made a leap of faith, I believe in a natural reality and my faith in faith works for me, because it grounds me. I am at peace in my faith and belief in a natural reality. I show fidelity to that reality that I believe in by believing everyday in accordance with my belief/faith in a natural reality and living according to that belief.

Doing the work; i.e. in regards to good and evil, evil is a word for certain human beliefs/emotions/feelings and it connects to other bad/negative beliefs/emotions/feelings. I work every day to replace those with empathy, compassion, love and so on. I am not saved just because I believe in empathy, compassion, love and so on. I have to work for that every day.

With regard
 
I've very concerned whether God is empirically true or not. Much more so than whether I'd like God to exist. If I've given a different opinion, then my apologies.

So when you agreed that you believed because it's what you'd prefer to be true, what did you mean?

If I'm not missing any contrary empirical evidence, then I'm guessing that means I've already evaluated all the empirical evidence available for the existence of God. Is there any empirical evidence that I'm missing, in your opinion?

Your first sentence is not what I said, and you snipped out of my post the answer to the question in your second sentence.
 
No, I disagree. If you die and go to heaven and meet God, would that constitute true (actual) metaphysical evidence to you?
"There's" ("there IS") is current tense. Your "If" is a purely speculative future tense fantasy for which no current empirically evidence exists that it will ever be true, could ever be true, or even should ever be true. No more credible than believing flying, fire-breathing dragons will one day be found to exist.

Okay. What empirically true evidence in favour of evidence devoid belief am I ignoring, in your opinion?
All of it. What empirically true evidence doesn’t contradict your metaphysical god belief?

Then you ignore/deny your own cognitive dissonance. Or you have some form of cognitive dissonance handicap.

What's the empirically true evidence that contradicts my metaphysical god belief?
All of it. What empirically true evidence tdoesn’t contradict your metaphysical god belief?

Try answering a question with an answer rather than a question. It’s a more honest and fair way of debating.
 
Last edited:
So when you agreed that you believed because it's what you'd prefer to be true, what did you mean?
The 'leap of faith' thing. You seem to be implying that (forgive me if I am wrong), though I know that the universe is one way, I want it to be another way which I prefer to be true. But my belief in a God is consistent with empirical truth as well as a metaphysical truth that I came to accept as a 'leap of faith'.

You say it is the same thing, and I don't disagree. But again, just to be clear: I'm not 'preferring it to be true', in the sense that 'I know it isn't true but I wish it was so I believe it.' I accept "there is a God" is true as an informal 'working hypothesis', in the absence of evidence to the contrary, and in its consistency with my metaphysical beliefs.
 
Last edited:
What empirically true evidence doesn’t contradict your metaphysical god belief?
I'm not aware of any empirically true evidence that contradicts my metaphysical god belief. If you know any, I'd appreciate you letting me know.
 
But my belief in a God is consistent with empirical truth as well as a metaphysical truth that I came to accept as a 'leap of faith'.
Give an example of a single empirical evidence truth that's consistent with your "leap of faith" God belief.

Your claim, your onus to provide the proof. No one has the onus to disprove it.
 
Last edited:
Give an example of a single empirical evidence truth that's consistent with your "leap of faith" God belief.

That evidence used within empiricism rests on an axiom for which no truth is possible. It is possible to believe in at least one version of a god, which is compatible with empiricism.

Now I have done this for years, i.e. these debates about metaphysics/transcendent beliefs versus the axiom of empiricism and the challenge you face is this:
You believe that your experience of reading this, if you have eye sight, is that outside your experience of a computer screen, that there is an actual computer screen, which matches your experience, but is independent of your experience.
That is not possible to give evidence for that using reason and logic and to claim it as true rest on a dogmatic claim, circular reasoning or magical thinking.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=107037

One assumption: That the universe matches a set of rules.

However you phrase that, as an assumption, an axiom or what ever, you can't show truth for that using reason, logic and evidence. Rather reason, logic and evidence rest on that assumption/axiom.

With regards
 
Give an example of a single empirical evidence truth that's consistent with your "leap of faith" God belief.

Your claim, your onus to provide the proof. No one has the onus to disprove it.
I agree. But as I said from the start, I was asked my reasons by Thor 2, and so I provided them. I'm not asking anyone to accept my "leap of faith", nor should you.

We seem to be arguing on something we agree about. Earlier you wrote:

"There's no such thing as empirically true metaphysical evidence."

I responded:

"Exactly. It's a contradiction in terms."

And now you are asking me for empirical evidence for a "leap of faith". Again, it is a contradiction in terms. I'm not claiming any empirical evidence for a "leap of faith". That comes from my metaphysical beliefs. So I don't know why you ask for empirical evidence for metaphysical beliefs when we both agree it doesn't exist. As for empirical evidence being consistent with the existence of God: there is nothing inconsistent with a creator God, so everything is consistent. You need to start making metaphysical statements to show inconsistency. Perhaps you are confusing 'consistency' with 'proof'?

Unless you can keep this clear, then I might make this my last response to you on this matter. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
You seem to be implying that (forgive me if I am wrong), though I know that the universe is one way, I want it to be another way which I prefer to be true.

No, that's not what I'm saying. I don't think we're disagreeing on anything other than turns of phrase.
 
I agree. But as I said from the start, I was asked my reasons by Thor 2, and so I provided them. I'm not asking anyone to accept my "leap of faith", nor should you.

We seem to be arguing on something we agree about. Earlier you wrote:

"There's no such thing as empirically true metaphysical evidence."

I responded:

"Exactly. It's a contradiction in terms."

And now you are asking me for empirical evidence for a "leap of faith". Again, it is a contradiction in terms. I'm not claiming any empirical evidence for a "leap of faith". That comes from my metaphysical beliefs. So I don't know why you ask for empirical evidence for metaphysical beliefs when we both agree it doesn't exist. As for empirical evidence being consistent with the existence of God: there is nothing inconsistent with a creator God, so everything is consistent. You need to start making metaphysical statements to show inconsistency.

Unless you can keep this clear, then I might make this my last response to you on this matter. Thanks.
I'm not arguing about something we have previously agreed on (There's no such thing as empirically true metaphysical evidence).

It's exactly that fact that makes your "my belief in a God is consistent with empirical truth" a complete nonsense. Empirical knowledge is inconsistent with metaphysical belief because the former is based on empirical evidence and the latter isn't. Knowledge is revealed by scientific investigation and analysis of empirical evidence, metaphysical belief is arbitrarily created purely from fantasy imagination. You're essentially claiming that fantasy is consistent with reality in a pathetic attempt to make your religious beliefs consistent with science.

This is definitely my last direct response to you on this matter. Thanks.
 
Last edited:
You believe that your experience of reading this, if you have eye sight, is that outside your experience of a computer screen, that there is an actual computer screen, which matches your experience, but is independent of your experience.
That is not possible to give evidence for that using reason and logic and to claim it as true rest on a dogmatic claim, circular reasoning or magical thinking.

Proof is not, ultimately, possible. Evidence, on the other hand, is. The first bit of evidence would be whether other people also seem to have experience of said computer screen. If I set my computer to hibernate, walk out of the room, and ask another person to boot the computer up and read out to me what's written on the screen, is what they are saying consistent with my memory? If so, then that's one datapoint that supports the case that the computer screen exists independent of my experience of it. If it's not, then that's either a datapoint against it, or an indicator of something else going on (that the person is lying about what they can read, that the text has changed through some natural process like a post being edited by a mod, etc.).

Yes, I'm aware how recursive this argument can get, and I think it's a debate for a different thread than this one, but I felt the need to comment on how your specific assertion was incorrect.
 
Proof is not, ultimately, possible. Evidence, on the other hand, is. The first bit of evidence would be whether other people also seem to have experience of said computer screen. If I set my computer to hibernate, walk out of the room, and ask another person to boot the computer up and read out to me what's written on the screen, is what they are saying consistent with my memory? If so, then that's one datapoint that supports the case that the computer screen exists independent of my experience of it. If it's not, then that's either a datapoint against it, or an indicator of something else going on (that the person is lying about what they can read, that the text has changed through some natural process like a post being edited by a mod, etc.).

Yes, I'm aware how recursive this argument can get, and I think it's a debate for a different thread than this one, but I felt the need to comment on how your specific assertion was incorrect.

If you feel for it, make another thread. :)

With regard
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom