Tommy Jeppesen
Illuminator
- Joined
- Nov 14, 2008
- Messages
- 3,578
Hi GDon
I don't know the exact nature of your beliefs, but I will go through one possible version of beliefs in God, which is not contradictory to epistemological evidence.
Now the joke in that is that some of my fellow atheists can't if their life depended on it separate metaphysics and epistemology.
Metaphysics and transcendent beliefs: The cornerstone in understanding that is to get behind the words in this version of objective: "having reality independent of the mind".
How does that work in practice? Well, I believe that I am not the first unmoved mover of reality, rather I am in causal terms the effect of being caused by something else; the rest of reality. The content of in my mind, my experiences, are not caused by me, they are caused by the part of reality, which is objective.
So in the formal sense: Objective reality causes subjective reality, my experiences; i.e. OR -> SR. So how do I know that there is computer screen in front of me independent of my mind? I don't, because it is a metaphysical/transcendent belief to claim that my experience of the computer means that the computer screen is there as the computer screen independent of my experience of it. I don't know that because I have no objective point of view. I only have my experiences.
So I don't know what OR is, other than it is there. So I believe the following: OR is as it appears to me and there is no supernatural OR. But from that doesn't follow what OR is! It only means that I believe in natural reality.
So then what about supernatural beliefs: You can believe in a Creator God, which has given you a soul and that you will go to Heaven. What you can't do, is to claim that you have for reality as it appears to both of us Objective Authority.
How is that? Because is unknown, what good/right and bad/wrong is for OR. So in practice it works this way; i.e. for a strong believer in Hell, she/he can claim that there are humans, who go to Hell and a strong believer in the Natural Reality can claim, that we all die when we die. But both are metaphysical/transcendent beliefs and there can be given no evidence for either.
In practice in means that we, you and I, can share the same ethical beliefs, though you are a theist and I am an atheist.
If you believe in a humanistic sense in humans, accept a secular society and democracy, don't judge humans in an OR sense and believe in universal human rights, we are the same. For everyday politics within this frame we might disagree, but we would hold the same core beliefs/opinions with it comes to morality/ethics.
With regards
I don't know the exact nature of your beliefs, but I will go through one possible version of beliefs in God, which is not contradictory to epistemological evidence.
Now the joke in that is that some of my fellow atheists can't if their life depended on it separate metaphysics and epistemology.
Metaphysics and transcendent beliefs: The cornerstone in understanding that is to get behind the words in this version of objective: "having reality independent of the mind".
How does that work in practice? Well, I believe that I am not the first unmoved mover of reality, rather I am in causal terms the effect of being caused by something else; the rest of reality. The content of in my mind, my experiences, are not caused by me, they are caused by the part of reality, which is objective.
So in the formal sense: Objective reality causes subjective reality, my experiences; i.e. OR -> SR. So how do I know that there is computer screen in front of me independent of my mind? I don't, because it is a metaphysical/transcendent belief to claim that my experience of the computer means that the computer screen is there as the computer screen independent of my experience of it. I don't know that because I have no objective point of view. I only have my experiences.
So I don't know what OR is, other than it is there. So I believe the following: OR is as it appears to me and there is no supernatural OR. But from that doesn't follow what OR is! It only means that I believe in natural reality.
So then what about supernatural beliefs: You can believe in a Creator God, which has given you a soul and that you will go to Heaven. What you can't do, is to claim that you have for reality as it appears to both of us Objective Authority.
How is that? Because is unknown, what good/right and bad/wrong is for OR. So in practice it works this way; i.e. for a strong believer in Hell, she/he can claim that there are humans, who go to Hell and a strong believer in the Natural Reality can claim, that we all die when we die. But both are metaphysical/transcendent beliefs and there can be given no evidence for either.
In practice in means that we, you and I, can share the same ethical beliefs, though you are a theist and I am an atheist.
If you believe in a humanistic sense in humans, accept a secular society and democracy, don't judge humans in an OR sense and believe in universal human rights, we are the same. For everyday politics within this frame we might disagree, but we would hold the same core beliefs/opinions with it comes to morality/ethics.
With regards