Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

I suppose the question is why do you think there's a reason why the universe exists, why do you think it's necessary to be good (beyond the biological imperatives that being a member of a social species such as homo sapiens necessitates), etc?
"Necessary" not in a "logically necessary" manner, just as something important to me.

Beyond that, doesn't the existence of God just change the question from why the universe exists to why God exists?
If you believe that the universe may not need a reason for its existence, then fair enough. To me, an "eternal God" is a place holder for why we exist. Could the universe be eternal, thus simply exists? Could be. I'm not trying to convince anyone here, or ask them to accept my reasons.
 
If you believe that the universe may not need a reason for its existence, then fair enough. To me, an "eternal God" is a place holder for why we exist. Could the universe be eternal, thus simply exists? Could be. I'm not trying to convince anyone here, or ask them to accept my reasons.
Eternal god or eternal universe? At least we know the universe actually exists. What's wrong with "We don't know"? Not mysteriously exciting or emotionally comforting I guess.
 
Last edited:
My initial thoughts as well.

From his post I wouldn’t say GDon is a “reasoned theist”. Certainly not intellectually/rationally reasoned. Emotionally reasoned perhaps, if that’s not a contradiction. To be fair I can’t find anywhere in his previous posts in this thread where GDon has claimed to be a “reasoned theist”. Perhaps it was in one of his three “deleted” posts?

He does seem to claim to be a rationally reasoned theist in his last post however . . .

I can see no evidence that he is, and much evidence that he isn't . . .


Back in post #13 GDon wrote:

I was an atheist until I was about 30 years old, then a theist afterwards. I started posting on atheist/theist discussion boards around 2000, and to me, a lot of Australians who have converted to atheism from theism suddenly start to believe that Christians MUST believe in the Bible, despite their own former position of not really caring what was in the Bible when they called themselves Christians.

I challenged him about this, suggesting perhaps that he thought he had reasoned himself into theism.
 
Back in post #13 GDon wrote:

I challenged him about this, suggesting perhaps that he thought he had reasoned himself into theism.
Thanks for explaining. Seems from post #337 that’s indeed what he thinks. I would only accept he has been emotionally reasoned, not intellectually/rationally reasoned.
 
Last edited:
Below I've given my reasons for moving from atheist to theist.

............


Thanks for your story GDon. I get the impression you "felt" your way into theism rather than "reasoned" however. (Perhaps I am guilty of suggesting the reasoned thing.) That to one side you are certainly not the kind of theist that I see as a threat .... I think .... because you don't draw on sacred texts, to guide you in your life or guide you into telling others how to live theirs. Do you get any inspiration from religious material?

Interesting that your father took you to see Erich Von Daniken. Did he go for that stuff? Was he a believer in any other kind of woo?
 
Interesting that your father took you to see Erich Von Daniken. Did he go for that stuff? Was he a believer in any other kind of woo?
Erich Von Daniken is woo?!?!?! . . . Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo

Oh well, at least "advanced aliensdidit" is infinitely more credible and possible than "magical, invisible goddidit".
 
Last edited:
Eternal god or eternal universe?

Which is the best candidate for the property "eternal" or "uncaused cause", a god or a physical universe?

At least we know the universe actually exists.

We know what our senses tell us. That information is compatible with atheism, theism, idealism, dualism, simulation theory, etc.

In short, we don't know a physical universe exists. It's an assumption people make.

What's wrong with "We don't know"? Not mysteriously exciting or emotionally comforting I guess.

That is probably the best position, but for every hardcore theist I've ever met, convinced the god they believe in exists, there's a similar hardcore atheist just as convinced no gods exist.
 
Thanks for your story GDon. I get the impression you "felt" your way into theism rather than "reasoned" however.
I prefer "leap of faith" as per my earlier post, but fair comment.

Do you get any inspiration from religious material?
Like all of us, I get inspiration from a lot of sources.

Interesting that your father took you to see Erich Von Daniken. Did he go for that stuff? Was he a believer in any other kind of woo?
If he was, he didn't really let on. I knew he loved conspiracy theories, though he didn't believe in anything in particular as far as I know. My father passed away almost a year ago today. Since he was suffering from dementia, and it was a peaceful passing, there was more relief than sadness when this happened.

What was sad, from my perspective, is what I found when we cleared out his house a few years ago, preparing him for an Aged Care centre. On his bookshelf were books on a variety of topics that interest me, including on UFOs, philosophy, Buddhism, Taosim, even one on the Jesus Myth theory from the 1950s. Unfortunately by that time he wasn't lucid enough to speak on those topics, so I never was able to discuss them with him.

I was fairly close to my Dad, but simply never knew of his interest in those things. Guys, whether you are atheists or theists, speak to your Dads if you haven't had a chance to! Ask him what's on his bookshelf. You may be surprised. Don't wait too long.
 
Which is the best candidate for the property "eternal" or "uncaused cause", a god or a physical universe?
"Eternal" and "uncaused cause" are not the same thing (not even close or even related).

"Eternal" in the context of this discussion means "eternal existence" (nothing to do with "cause"). Obviously the universe actually exists by any credible measure of anything that exists. There isn't a speck of credible evidence any god actually exists however, so the universe by far the best candidate.
 
Last edited:
We know what our senses tell us. That information is compatible with atheism, theism, idealism, dualism, simulation theory, etc.

In short, we don't know a physical universe exists. It's an assumption people make.
And where do you think our senses get the information from with which to "tell us"? Have you ever thought that perhaps it's almost like there's a physical universe that actually exists, that our senses actually interact with, and then send information about to our brain? And perhaps that information is therefore purely related to an actual physical reality? If reality is purely a product of consciousness why do we even need sensory functions at all? At least you've admitted we have them.

Atheism, theism, idealism, dualism, simulation theory, and the like are purely abstract concepts people make up and often believe are more.

In even shorter, you're talking rubbish! (at least you're consistent)
 
Last edited:
I prefer "leap of faith" as per my earlier post, but fair comment.


Like all of us, I get inspiration from a lot of sources.

I have to admit there has been a good deal of art and music inspired by religion but I can't say I have been directly inspired by any theistic source.

I wonder how strong your conviction is about the existence of a supernatural entity. Richard Dawkins said on a scale of 1 to 7 (1 being 100% sure there was a god and 7 being 100% sure there was not) he would place himself at 6. I would also and wonder where you are on the scale. Also interested to know if you have other friends with a similar persuasion.

If he was, he didn't really let on. I knew he loved conspiracy theories, though he didn't believe in anything in particular as far as I know. My father passed away almost a year ago today. Since he was suffering from dementia, and it was a peaceful passing, there was more relief than sadness when this happened.

What was sad, from my perspective, is what I found when we cleared out his house a few years ago, preparing him for an Aged Care centre. On his bookshelf were books on a variety of topics that interest me, including on UFOs, philosophy, Buddhism, Taosim, even one on the Jesus Myth theory from the 1950s. Unfortunately by that time he wasn't lucid enough to speak on those topics, so I never was able to discuss them with him.

I was fairly close to my Dad, but simply never knew of his interest in those things. Guys, whether you are atheists or theists, speak to your Dads if you haven't had a chance to! Ask him what's on his bookshelf. You may be surprised. Don't wait too long.

Sad to here of your lack of communication with your dad about this stuff. My dad was a bit wishy washy about religion. He was a Mason and they were on about "The Universal Architect" and such but he was not a church goer. We were quite close however, much closer than my brother and he, whose religious zeal drove a wedge between him and both parents.
 
A common belief of some atheists is you cannot reason someone out of something, (religious belief) they were not reasoned into.
It's possible with time and patience, but often you need to adapt the message for the hearer. Make it personal and something they can relate to. Documentaries like the one you posted will work for people who are already well on their way of leaving, but for stubborn adherents, you need to deal with them as individuals, not with a general broadcast.

The following video is a very thorough debunking of the authenticity of "The Book of Abraham" written by Joseph Smith, who supposedly translated some ancient Egyptian scrolls to write the book. The video suggests Mormonism is collapsing as a result of these findings and showed interviews with some ex-Mormons at the end.
All "prophecies" will prove untenable in the end. The ancient humans really should have found a better way to transmit warnings (which were sometimes based in observation or calculation i.e. Thales of Miletus' prediction of eclipses, not always guesswork. The Abrahamic sects have thrown a wrench into the matter), such as plainly stating what could happen. Fatalism is a disease which has infected various religions, particularly Christianity and Hinduism.
 
Last edited:
"Necessary" not in a "logically necessary" manner, just as something important to me.

That's fair enough, but it's not a reasoned position. It is, in so many words, something you're choosing to believe because you'd prefer reality to be that way.

If you believe that the universe may not need a reason for its existence, then fair enough. To me, an "eternal God" is a place holder for why we exist. Could the universe be eternal, thus simply exists? Could be. I'm not trying to convince anyone here, or ask them to accept my reasons.

I'm not expecting you to try to convince anybody. I'm interested in what your reasons are, and how you've thought about this.

To re-phrase my point, can you not see that positing God as a reason for the universe to exist just moves the question back one step? The question is still "why is there something, rather than nothing?", you're just substituting a different word for the word "something" in that sentence.

Do you have an answer for why you think God exists? If you don't, then why is that more satisfying than not having an answer for why the universe exists? Does it, again, come down to what you'd like to be true?
 
That's fair enough, but it's not a reasoned position. It is, in so many words, something you're choosing to believe because you'd prefer reality to be that way.
I agree.

To re-phrase my point, can you not see that positing God as a reason for the universe to exist just moves the question back one step? The question is still "why is there something, rather than nothing?", you're just substituting a different word for the word "something" in that sentence.
Again, I agree.

Do you have an answer for why you think God exists? If you don't, then why is that more satisfying than not having an answer for why the universe exists? Does it, again, come down to what you'd like to be true?
Yes.
 
The topic of this thread is whether it is possible to reason someone out of religion.

Re the original question - I think we need to establish (if) we are in fact referencing two ideas here, 1) our raw experience of reality, and 2) our interpretation of our experiences.
The question then is, can we be reasoned out of our interpretation of our experiences, where religion and scientific realism are two possible interpretations.
Since there are multiple cases of people swapping interpretations, the answer seems to be Yes - even on a daily or moment to moment basis.
A back-door assumption in this thread is that religion is an add on, meaning if one gets reasoned out of religion, then one automatically falls back to scientific realism (or some variant). But scientific realism is just another interpretation.
 
Re the original question - I think we need to establish (if) we are in fact referencing two ideas here, 1) our raw experience of reality, and 2) our interpretation of our experiences.
The question then is, can we be reasoned out of our interpretation of our experiences, where religion and scientific realism are two possible interpretations.
Since there are multiple cases of people swapping interpretations, the answer seems to be Yes - even on a daily or moment to moment basis.
A back-door assumption in this thread is that religion is an add on, meaning if one gets reasoned out of religion, then one automatically falls back to scientific realism (or some variant). But scientific realism is just another interpretation.
Wrong.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom