If he was, he didn't really let on. I knew he loved conspiracy theories, though he didn't believe in anything in particular as far as I know. My father passed away almost a year ago today. Since he was suffering from dementia, and it was a peaceful passing, there was more relief than sadness when this happened.
What was sad, from my perspective, is what I found when we cleared out his house a few years ago, preparing him for an Aged Care centre. On his bookshelf were books on a variety of topics that interest me, including on UFOs, philosophy, Buddhism, Taosim, even one on the Jesus Myth theory from the 1950s. Unfortunately by that time he wasn't lucid enough to speak on those topics, so I never was able to discuss them with him.
I was fairly close to my Dad, but simply never knew of his interest in those things. Guys, whether you are atheists or theists, speak to your Dads if you haven't had a chance to! Ask him what's on his bookshelf. You may be surprised. Don't wait too long.