Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Since neither of you have enough candlepower to hold your own against someone with just a passing grasp of the facts, you should avoid condescension.


I'm not sure if you mean it literally, but I think it should be boiled down to just: "avoid condescension."
 
Among "reasons like that", I think that their own need is what's most important: the need to feel superior! This is the reason why I've been trying to make it obvious to them how pathetic it is to pride oneself of knowing that there is no god, no beyond and no afterlife as if that were a gargantuan intellectual accomplishment.

I hope that one day people like that will come to understand how weak it makes them seem.

To me it seems equivalent of Donald Trump banging on and on about how his inauguration crowd was bigger than Obama's. Firstly, you don't need to say that it's the biggest if it actually is - people can see that for themselves. Secondly, it's giving all the power to the other guy - you're just demonstrating how much of a hold they have over you. Finally, it's showing everybody how small you are if that's how you feel you have to present yourself to the world.

It's acting like you think you're a big, tough guy, when actually you're just laying out all your petty insecurities for everybody to see.

I think discourse is so much better for everybody concerned, from all participants to all onlookers, when all parties are secure enough within themselves to avoid all the silly posturing.
 
"We atheists"??! Really?!
Well, I atheist find many atheist beliefs absurd. And the holier-than-thou attitude apparently doesn't require that one is a theist ...


Atheists beliefs? Are you, and can you, be taken seriously?

What does the word atheist imply in Denmark? For us in the English speaking World it just means a lack of belief in gods. That's it! There are no beliefs in anything else needed.
 
Atheists beliefs? Are you, and can you, be taken seriously?

What does the word atheist imply in Denmark? For us in the English speaking World it just means a lack of belief in gods. That's it! There are no beliefs in anything else needed.
Oh come on. Even you know that in practical use the word "atheist" carries a whole bunch of baggage other than it's purely literal dictionary definition. Which, by the way, includes active belief that no gods exist.

dictionary.com said:
noun
1.
the doctrine or belief that there is no God.
2.
disbelief in the existence of a supreme being or beings.
 
Disappointing post from you, Thor 2. Everything in this world isn't what you hoped for! Neither is everything in this thread. Get used to it!


I was disappointed that GDon did not follow the discussion about reasoning and religion. (The subject matter of this thread). So you are disappointed in me for for being disappointed about this?

Leave the schoolyard type taunts out of it please.
 
Oh come on. Even you know that in practical use the word "atheist" carries a whole bunch of baggage other than it's purely literal dictionary definition. Which, by the way, includes active belief that no gods exist.


My dictionary says:

"a person who disbelieves or lacks belief in the existence of God or gods."

A much better definition.

Can you give me an "atheist belief" apart from your dodgy dictionary extract?
 
I should probably elaborate a little:

You shouldn't have bothered methinks given the stuff below.




Nobody's tried to infringe on your first amendment rights - or whatever they're called in your part of the world.




It doesn't! Not as such.




Yes, it can! You enjoy pretending that any criticism of religion = insults. Religious fundamentalists may find any criticism of religion to be insulting. That's their mistake. However, you make it yours when you pretend that your insults are mere criticism.




I just thought you weren't guilty of any offences?!




You are particularly fond of this tu quoque, aren't you?! Atheist martyrs of the world, unite!

My part of the World is Australia. It's right there under my name and we don't have a first amendment. :footinmou

You're strategy of breaking sentences in parts and replying to those parts does little to enhance you're argument. Forgive my ignorance but what is tu quoque?

So let's sum it up: 'We just can't help insulting believers. If we gave up on insulting the nutters, it would be a violation of our first-amendment rights. And anyway, the believers are to blame for our insults because believers are much worse than us. We are the real victims! We are the good guys so we have the right to tell believers that they are intellectually inferior to us.'

More nonsense with another reference to the first amendment.:confused:
 
Ah, Webster's Dictionary is dodgy now. I don't have time to find alternatives for you right now, not that you'd consider any of them any less dodgy if they told you something you didn't agree with. I have time when I get home from work.
 
Ah, Webster's Dictionary is dodgy now. I don't have time to find alternatives for you right now, not that you'd consider any of them any less dodgy if they told you something you didn't agree with. I have time when I get home from work.


Take you're time I have patience.

Language is fluid and forever changing. The majority of atheists I speak to, and I think the majority who post here, just proclaim a lack of belief in gods, not a positive belief in there being no god. Even Richard Dawkins falls into this category.
 
Ah, Webster's Dictionary is dodgy now. I don't have time to find alternatives for you right now, not that you'd consider any of them any less dodgy if they told you something you didn't agree with. I have time when I get home from work.


Don't bother, arthwollipot! Thor 2 is incorrigible. When he's lost his last limb, there's really no point in fightning him anymore.

 
There's a word for that line of thinking.

Even if you believe you're personally having your rights infringed upon by theists, it's crucial to not make them feel insulted if you wish to talk them out of it. It's a core principle of effective communication that you not put someone on the defensive too much if you want them to hear what you're saying.


I detect measured tone in your writing kellyb so perhaps you may be prepared to listen to what I say. Dann has now resorted to personal insults so it would seem his arguments, such as they were, have failed.

My brother found Jesus when he was 18 years old when I read Bertrand Russell and found release at the age of 16. Can you imagine the discussions we had?

My brother married in the church, (to someone he met in the church), and they raised 4 children. The children went to religious schools, camps, and so on so became Christians also. Quite a fundy lot actually - not believing in evolution and such.

In spite of our diametrically opposed positions my brother and I never fell out. In later years he stopped trying to convert me so I left him to his beliefs as he left me alone with my lack of belief.

My brother died when quite young unfortunately, (God needed him to do things for him in heaven I was told), but his son, my nephew, has taken things to a new level. He's a praise Jesus faith healer, actively driving demons out of folk to cure them of all kinds of maladies, including homosexuality. He took it upon himself to convert me to his faith. It didn't work.:D

The emails between my nephew and I would fill a book and I can tell you I didn't pull any punches with my arguments. I never told him he was stupid but I certainly let him know what I thought of his beliefs. His arguments were all about experiences and just I believe because I believe because ........

He has stopped trying to convert me now and we remain friends.:)
 
Take you're time I have patience.

Language is fluid and forever changing. The majority of atheists I speak to, and I think the majority who post here, just proclaim a lack of belief in gods, not a positive belief in there being no god. Even Richard Dawkins falls into this category.
Yes, they do indeed. As a method of making an argument, generally. That doesn't mean that a majority of English speakers use the word in that way. You're free to use whatever definitions you choose, but if you use one that most others don't use, you can't be surprised that people will misunderstand you.

If you go up to randoms in the street and ask them what "atheism" means, I guarantee that most of them will give you a definition that carries baggage other than the naive lack-of-belief definition.

Note: I haven't tried this experiment. If you do, and you get a result other than that, I will surprisedly withdraw my argument.
 
Yes, they do indeed. As a method of making an argument, generally. That doesn't mean that a majority of English speakers use the word in that way. You're free to use whatever definitions you choose, but if you use one that most others don't use, you can't be surprised that people will misunderstand you.

If you go up to randoms in the street and ask them what "atheism" means, I guarantee that most of them will give you a definition that carries baggage other than the naive lack-of-belief definition.

Note: I haven't tried this experiment. If you do, and you get a result other than that, I will surprisedly withdraw my argument.


No, no, no, ...... you can't just make a word mean whatever you want. It may change in meaning over time but its difficult to see that happening with the word atheist.

From my dictionary:

theism
noun [ mass noun ]

belief in the existence of a god or gods, specifically of a creator who intervenes in the universe. there are many different forms of theism.

Now when you put an "a" in front of theism and get "atheism" thats all it means. Just not a theist.

Just to add to my post above in response to kellyb, where I was illustrating how one can have discussions with theists, being very blunt about what you think of their beliefs but still remain friends, I draw the attention of readers to the documentary "Religulous" by Bill Mayer.

Bill interviewed one Pastor John Westcott and was not shy in pointing out the weak points in the pastors beliefs. At the end of the interview the good pastor insisted on giving Bill a hug when he went on his way.:)
 
Thor 2:
Atheism is, in the broadest sense, the absence of belief in the existence of deities. Less broadly, atheism is the rejection of belief that any deities exist. In an even narrower sense, atheism is specifically the position that there are no deities.Atheism is contrasted with theism, which, in its most general form, is the belief that at least one deity exists.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atheism

Now here is what happens in practice and it also happens here on this forum. Ask a sufficient amount of atheist about beliefs in deities and some will claim, that beliefs in deities are wrong in the non-moral sense. If you ask further these atheists will start using reason, logic and evidence to explain how religion is wrong and how beliefs in deities are wrong. In short they will claim that since there is no evidence for deities, deities don't exist.
They may claim that atheism is the lack of beliefs in deities, but if you engage them in debate they will claim that deities don't exist.

With regard
 
Thor 2:


Now here is what happens in practice and it also happens here on this forum. Ask a sufficient amount of atheist about beliefs in deities and some will claim, that beliefs in deities are wrong in the non-moral sense. If you ask further these atheists will start using reason, logic and evidence to explain how religion is wrong and how beliefs in deities are wrong. In short they will claim that since there is no evidence for deities, deities don't exist.
They may claim that atheism is the lack of beliefs in deities, but if you engage them in debate they will claim that deities don't exist.

With regard


Hello Tommy :)

Just like you to explode on the scene with a load of waffle to cloud the issue.:gasp:
 
Hello Tommy :)

Just like you to explode on the scene with a load of waffle to cloud the issue.:gasp:

You really like to debate using just feelings/emotions. No reasoning, logic and evidence. Just your personal subjective, biased interpretations. How about for once reflecting over your own words.
Look at them:
Just like you to explode on the scene with a load of waffle to cloud the issue.:gasp:

No reasoning, logic or evidence.

With regard
 
Incredible!
The same guy who blames you, "Just like you to explode on the scene with a load of waffle to cloud the issue," only yesterday complained that "Dann has now resorted to personal insults ...".
Like said, incorrigible!
 
Incredible!
The same guy who blames you, "Just like you to explode on the scene with a load of waffle to cloud the issue," only yesterday complained that "Dann has now resorted to personal insults ...".
Like said, incorrigible!

Feelings/emotions, opinions, subjective justification/evaluation/measure and what not. Well, in the recorded history of mankind here is an old one:
"Man is the measure of all things: of the things that are, that they are, of the things that are not, that they are not." - Protagoras.

#Some humans use subjectivity to claim the super-natural.
#Others use subjectivity to deny it in other versions than their own.
Both kinds of humans are different in how they use their individual subjectivity, but they share the same characteristic. They don't reflect and understand that they themselves are subjective and that other humans are subjectively different in how they think, believe, feel and so on.

I suspect it has to do with this:
Neurotypical: "neurotypical individuals often assume that their experience of the world is either the only one or the only correct one". From google.

In everyday words it goes like this: I can't believe that other humans experience the world differently, because it doesn't make sense to me, therefore it doesn't make sense to other humans.

As long as these humans think like that, you can't convince them otherwise, because it works for them. If you point out you have a different experience, it is not real because it doesn't make sense or it is incorrect, because their experience is the correct one.

With regard
 
From my dictionary:



Now when you put an "a" in front of theism and get "atheism" thats all it means. Just not a theist.
Oh, right. When you don't like a dictionary definition, you can ignore it and simply define the word as the negation of another word. Despite the fact that the word in question actually has its own entry. Because that's how dictionaries work.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom