Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Oh, man! Arthwollipot recommended that Thor 2 stops using ad homs when talking about believers:

You said that they needed counselling - that is questioning their mental health. You called people "precious" - not beliefs, people. You do this sort of thing all the time.

Even if that is not intended as an attack, it will be interpreted as one. If you really want to avoid attacking people and focus on their beliefs, you need to moderate your language a lot more.

I interrupted, and I apologise. I do hope you think about what I've said though. Please return to the conversation at hand, because it is an interesting one.


Thor 2 pretends that his ad-hom attacks aren’t ad homs:

Believers in woo shouldn't take it as a personal insult if I attack the woo. If they do it's their problem not mine. Not all people who need counselling are mentally ill either so that's a rather blunt barb.


And ynot backs him up with one of his many fabrications:

There’s a type of touchy-feely “Let’s be nice” atheist that’s predominately interested in being “nice” to theists. Seems they don’t like “nasty atheists” as they make them them look bad by association. They interpret attacks on theism as being attacks on theists every bit as much as many/most theists do. For some reason they seem happy for “nasty theists” to attack and threaten atheists however. Touchy-feely logic I guess. :rolleyes:


So we go from arthwollipot recommending that atheists criticize the belief rather than the believer to the claim that all he wants to do is ”be nice” to theists. So now Thor 2 repeats ynot’s strawman as if that was what arthwollipot actually said: It’s all about ”being nice” to theists:

Aw ...... can't I. You get to decide if guys like ynot and I are not being nice enough to theists however.


Their strategy appears to be much like the one employed by Trump: Make up strawmen and repeat them long enough for people to believe that that’s what your critics actually said.
And avoid answering questions at all costs! In particular when somebody shows what you're doing! Whining about being unfairly attacked is also one of Trump's favorite strategies.

Won't you please show us where somebody has said or implied that it's OK "to attack and threaten atheists"?! And if "nasty atheists" and "nasty theists" are actual quotations (from other people than you, that is!), won't you please supply us with link(s) to the post(s)?
 
Given the latest on this thread, perhaps a more useful question might be "Can a person be insulted to leave a religion/atheism?"

Some people are more comfortable with insulting a position rather than using reason to critique it. That may tell you something about their ability to do either.

It's not just religion either. Politics, sex, sports, it's part of tribalism. There is a certain satisfaction and validation received when insulting 'the other' when you are part of the in-group on a board.

Guys, what do you want to be known as? If you don't care if you are not known as a reasoner, then question answered! (Written by someone who doesn't mind throwing or receiving the odd zinger at times, but tries to never mistake insults for reason.)
 
Last edited:
People don't generally try to use degradation as a tool to help the person with whom they're communicating. They do it for fun, to promote their own social status, and for reasons like that. Most people are not terribly self-aware of their own motivations, though, myself included.
 
Given the latest on this thread, perhaps a more useful question might be "Can a person be insulted to leave a religion/atheism?"

Some people are more comfortable with insulting a position rather than using reason to critique it. That may tell you something about their ability to do either.

It's not just religion either. Politics, sex, sports, it's part of tribalism. There is a certain satisfaction and validation received when insulting 'the other' when you are part of the in-group on a board.

Guys, what do you want to be known as? If you don't care if you are not known as a reasoner, then question answered! (Written by someone who doesn't mind throwing or receiving the odd zinger at times, but tries to never mistake insults for reason.)


Disappointing post from you GDon. I had hoped to hear about how/if you managed to reason your way into faith. Reason, and its effectiveness in determining faith outcome, is what this thread is about.
 
Given the latest on this thread, perhaps a more useful question might be "Can a person be insulted to leave a religion/atheism?"


Probably. People can be insulted to do all kinds of things! :)



In general, however, I don't think that it's a very efficient way of convincing anybody of anything. And in the case of religion, a belief, the kind of force that an insult wields is negligible: Believers may decide that you're a despicable human being and ignore you. But if, for some reason (could be peer pressure, for instance), the believers want to maintain contact with you, they can just pretend that they don't believe. Not just religious faiths, but also political or sexual persuasions can be denied. (That's why religious persecution is probably one of the least efficient ways of putting an end to religion. All you need to do to escape prosecution is to pretend: You still believe in whatever you believe in, you just don't say it out loud.)

Some people are more comfortable with insulting a position rather than using reason to critique it. That may tell you something about their ability to do either.


It may or it may not, but you're right that sometimes people will resort to insults when they run out of arguments - if they had any, in the first place.

It's not just religion either. Politics, sex, sports, it's part of tribalism. There is a certain satisfaction and validation received when insulting 'the other' when you are part of the in-group on a board.


You are right, but I don't think that it would have to be the in-group. Peer pressure may be just as compelling in a persecuted minority group. It works in any group you want to belong to or depend on belonging to.

Guys, what do you want to be known as? If you don't care if you are not known as a reasoner, then question answered! (Written by someone who doesn't mind throwing or receiving the odd zinger at times, but tries to never mistake insults for reason.)


There's one thing that gets me riled up every time: elitism! Elitist behavior, elitist arguments, and (pseudo) elitist organizations. And it surprises me every time how unintelligent elitist thinking makes people. Since I started writing about IQ theory, more than 15 years ago ...
IQ: The democratically purified racism (Skeptic Report)
How intelligent is the average IQ test designer? (Skeptic Report)
... I've been attacked by Mensans a couple of times, sometimes openly and sometimes I was made aware of discussions taking place among Mensans. It never ceases to amaze me how dumb those guys are. And the beauty of it is that their combination of arrogance and stupidity makes them extremely vulnerable to criticism. They tend to argue in the following way: 'I haven't really spent any time studying/analyzing this, but ...' because they actually think that they are much more clever than 98 % of humanity and thus don't need to know anything. I've had discussions with Danish Mensans who contradicted what I said about the purpose of their cult because they didn't know what the statement of purpose of Dansk Mensa actually said. I've seen them claim that intelligence is fate - you have the IQ that you're born with, it's all in your genes, and studying can't improve it - while at the same time engaging in discussions about what you can do to improve your IQ if you lacked a few points in order to pass their test.
But even in the case of those guys, I try to avoid ad homs and other insults. An actual argument that shows how dumb they are is much more humiliating! :)


People don't generally try to use degradation as a tool to help the person with whom they're communicating. They do it for fun, to promote their own social status, and for reasons like that. Most people are not terribly self-aware of their own motivations, though, myself included.


Among "reasons like that", I think that their own need is what's most important: the need to feel superior! This is the reason why I've been trying to make it obvious to them how pathetic it is to pride oneself of knowing that there is no god, no beyond and no afterlife as if that were a gargantuan intellectual accomplishment.
I think that most of us know that it isn't. It's a starting point, that's all. Marx, for instance, criticized religion when he was 25. And then he spent the rest of his life criticizing capitalism ...
 
Last edited:
Disappointing post from you GDon. I had hoped to hear about how/if you managed to reason your way into faith. Reason, and its effectiveness in determining faith outcome, is what this thread is about.


Disappointing post from you, Thor 2. Everything in this world isn't what you hoped for! Neither is everything in this thread. Get used to it!
 
People don't generally try to use degradation as a tool to help the person with whom they're communicating. They do it for fun, to promote their own social status, and for reasons like that. Most people are not terribly self-aware of their own motivations, though, myself included.


We are between a rock and a hard place on this issue. Using reason we atheists find many religious beliefs to be quite absurd - we must be allowed to say this. If making this point insults those who hold these beliefs then so be it - it can't be avoided. Any offence we are guilty of pales into insignificance compared to the offence that religion has, and still does, impose on the non believer. I think we all know what they are.

Given the above I do not try and denigrate the religious personally although I do reserve the right to illustrate how ridiculous some of they beliefs are. Can we get back on the topic of this thread?
 
As an Australian myself, I'd say that is also true of most people who would call themselves "believers": they are also indifferent to religion. If they believe in God, they try not to let it interrupt their day.


I think that you're right about this: Only fundamentalists (believers or atheists) imagine that if you're a believer, you are believing 24/7. Most of the time, almost everybody is preoccupied with their everyday lives, not with religion. Most devout Christians are probably believing for an hour or two on Sundays.

In fact, I'd say that for all of human history, 90% or more of people have not really given a thought about religion. I know that there is this idea that everyone in the past were fundamentalists, and that gradually the Enlightenment has eroded fundamentalism so that people have become more liberal, but I'd suggest that most people have always been liberal about their beliefs, and the Enlightenment has been making more people fundamentalist.


I think that you are right about this as well: For the first couple of thousand years, people were trying to make sense of the world and came up with all kinds of weird explanations, but a delusion is not the same as a religion. And back then, even more so than now, people were busy getting food on the table - if they had advanced to the stage where they had tables ...
(I love this novel by one of my favourite authors, Daniel Chavarria, about the liberal religious views of the ancients: The Eye of Cybele)


There have been times in the past where the right kind of religious beliefs have been important, but those were times when heresy was as much or more to do with politics as with religion.

Yeah, but... How many Australians have you met personally who really care about what is in the Bible? How many people that call themselves Christians that you know personally care whether the Bible is correct, or accurate, or consistent? Very few is my guess. Most would look to the Bible for inspiration rather than history, like they would towards Oprah.


Bible thumping seems to be a fundamentalist thing, not something that most or even many Christians do.

I was an atheist until I was about 30 years old, then a theist afterwards. I started posting on atheist/theist discussion boards around 2000, and to me, a lot of Australians who have converted to atheism from theism suddenly start to believe that Christians MUST believe in the Bible, despite their own former position of not really caring what was in the Bible when they called themselves Christians.


As I've pointed out on this board a couple of times: In Denmark we have preachers who aren't theists.
And it seems to be spreading to the rest of the world and, what may be more surprising, also accepted by whole congregations:
One Sunday in 2001, she stood up in front of her congregation, as usual. But instead of a normal sermon, she declared that she no longer believed in God. "Something came over me, and I took God apart," she recalled. "I said I didn't believe in an interventionist God, not a God that was a Being, I didn't believe in Supernatural powers, or Heaven or Hell...My understanding of God is more about relationships with oneself, the others, and the planet."

Much to her surprise, neither the congregation nor the church board were bothered by this. Many even confessed that they, too, had their doubts. And so they carried on, without God.
This Christian minister doesn't believe in God - and she's not the only one (Vice News, Aug. 11, 2015)


I can't speak for Americans and Brits, but for Australians there is a strange 'conversion' affect that goes on on atheist boards, whereby their beliefs about what constitutes 'true' Christianity becomes defined around the literal truth of the Bible, despite them themselves formerly calling themselves Christians and not caring how 'true' the Bible was in a historical or even factual sense.


Some atheists are zealous believers. They just aren't theists! :)
 
We are between a rock and a hard place on this issue. Using reason we atheists find many religious beliefs to be quite absurd - we must be allowed to say this. If making this point insults those who hold these beliefs then so be it - it can't be avoided. Any offence we are guilty of pales into insignificance compared to the offence that religion has, and still does, impose on the non believer. I think we all know what they are.

Given the above I do not try and denigrate the religious personally although I do reserve the right to illustrate how ridiculous some of they beliefs are. Can we get back on the topic of this thread?


"We atheists"??! Really?!
Well, I atheist find many atheist beliefs absurd. And the holier-than-thou attitude apparently doesn't require that one is a theist ...
 
I should probably elaborate a little:

We are between a rock and a hard place on this issue. Using reason we atheists find many religious beliefs to be quite absurd - we must be allowed to say this.


Nobody's tried to infringe on your first amendment rights - or whatever they're called in your part of the world.

If making this point insults those who hold these beliefs


It doesn't! Not as such.

then so be it - it can't be avoided.


Yes, it can! You enjoy pretending that any criticism of religion = insults. Religious fundamentalists may find any criticism of religion to be insulting. That's their mistake. However, you make it yours when you pretend that your insults are mere criticism.

Any offence we are guilty of


I just thought you weren't guilty of any offences?!

pales into insignificance compared to the offence that religion has, and still does, impose on the non believer. I think we all know what they are.


You are particularly fond of this tu quoque, aren't you?! Atheist martyrs of the world, unite!

Given the above I do not try and denigrate the religious personally although I do reserve the right to illustrate how ridiculous some of they beliefs are. Can we get back on the topic of this thread?


So let's sum it up: 'We just can't help insulting believers. If we gave up on insulting the nutters, it would be a violation of our first-amendment rights. And anyway, the believers are to blame for our insults because believers are much worse than us. We are the real victims! We are the good guys so we have the right to tell believers that they are intellectually inferior to us.'
 
Any offence we are guilty of pales into insignificance compared to the offence that religion has, and still does, impose on the non believer.

There's a word for that line of thinking.

Even if you believe you're personally having your rights infringed upon by theists, it's crucial to not make them feel insulted if you wish to talk them out of it. It's a core principle of effective communication that you not put someone on the defensive too much if you want them to hear what you're saying.
 
But you're at cross purposes here, kellyb. The only thing Thor 2 wants them to hear is the insult.
 
Given the latest on this thread, perhaps a more useful question might be "Can a person be insulted to leave a religion/atheism?"
Obviously, some can, and have. Does that mean that it's a good idea? No, I don't think it does. I think that insulting someone more often just gives them an excuse to dismiss everything else you say.
 
Aw ...... can't I. You get to decide if guys like ynot and I are not being nice enough to theists however.

Since neither of you have enough candlepower to hold your own against someone with just a passing grasp of the facts, you should avoid condescension.
 
Given the latest on this thread, perhaps a more useful question might be "Can a person be insulted to leave a religion/atheism?"


Sorry about the resurrection, GDon, but I would prefer something along these lines:

A common belief of some atheists is that they are immensely intellectually superior to believers, an idea that they pride themselves of having reasoned their way into. But would it be possible for them to reason their way out of this belief, maybe with a little help from their friends? Or are they so stuck in this belief that any attempt at arguing against it will be interpreted as persecution and vile human rights abuse?

:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom