Dann is saying it doesn’t take much intellect to realise and conclude there is no God or god.
Dann is saying theists are less intellectual and more emotional than atheists regarding god beliefs to gain emotional comfort.
FTFYDo you really disagree?
Dann is saying people (adults) who don't have theirbasicemotional needs met are more emotional and less rational than those who do.
You agree with him there, too.
What is there in ynot's post to prompt this ridicules outburst?![]()
Sarcastic reference to brave atheists at the beginning,
and you round it of with a jab about racist atheists.
Are you reading stuff from between the lines of ynot's post perhaps?![]()
FTFY
"Less rational" = "less intellectual"
The angry mob is so fired-up with prejudicial and willful misreading, misinterpreting and misquoting of my words I’m not even going to bother to respond as their counter responses would be just more of the same. Hard to have a meaningful and fair debate with an angry mob waving burning torches and pitchforks.
Just have to respond to this “pitchfork in the foot” post . . .
Dann is saying it doesn’t take much intellect to realise and conclude there is no God or god.
Dann is saying theists are less intellectual and more emotional than atheists regarding god beliefs to gain emotional comfort.
But when atheists say essentially the same thing dann says . . .
Your own words agree that atheists are intellectually superior to theists/believers when it comes to God/god beliefs.
I guess that makes you as "vain" and "smug" as those you criticise.
The angry mob is so fired-up with prejudicial and willful misreading, misinterpreting and misquoting of my words I’m not even going to bother to respond as their counter responses would be just more of the same. Hard to have a meaningful and fair debate with an angry mob waving burning torches and pitchforks.
Seems you didn't bother to read (or at least comprehend) my entire post in which I made it blatantly clear that dann is saying essentially exactly the same thing as I said and some other atheists say. Yet (s)he criticises us for saying it with accusations of us being "vain, smug, superior", etc.
There’s a type of touchy-feely “Let’s be nice” atheist that’s predominately interested in being “nice” to theists. Seems they don’t like “nasty atheists” as they make them them look bad by association. They interpret attacks on theism as being attacks on theists every bit as much as many/most theists do. For some reason they seem happy for “nasty theists” to attack and threaten atheists however. Touchy-feely logic I guess.![]()
This sure does feel boring for a witch hunt.
Honestly, I wish being atheists did give us intellectual sparkle ponies upstairs. I don't think I gained any IQ points when I left religion, though.
I’m specifically talking about what influences some people to BECOME theists. I’m NOT talking about staying or giving up BEING a theist, and I have no idea why you seem to think I am. Please feel free to quote where I’ve said anything about anyone remaining or giving up being a theist.It requires a whole lot less intellectual effort to stay a theist than to give up the belief. Realizing that there is no God isn't intellectually difficult, which is why I, unlike ynot, am not particularly proud of my achievement in this field. It required neither intellectual effort nor bravery. Why would it be an act of courage to give up on the idea that there's an omnipotent and omniscient guy in the sky who'll punish me when I die when absolutely nothing seems to indicate that this guy actually exists? It's about as courageous as giving up on the idea that there's a monster under my bed who'll devour me when I go to sleep.
You said . . .I also don't know how ynot comes up with the idea that I've said that theists are "more emotional than atheists regarding god beliefs." Some atheists seem to be extremely emotional about this. However, it's true that the theists usually believe "to gain emotional comfort." They very often say so themselves, so it's no big secret.
YOU are clearly saying that believing in a god is more emotionally influenced (for emotional comfort) than intellectually. In fact YOU are saying even a small amount of intellectual “figuring out” easily concludes there is no god. Therefore YOU are saying to conclude there is a god one has to be more emotionally influenced than intellectually. So by YOUR words, theists are more emotional than atheists regarding god beliefs.and analytically it isn't harder to figure out that there is no god than to figure out that there is no Santa or Easter Bunny. But unlike those two fairytale creatures, the God delusion gives comfort to grown ups, which is the main difference.
Me too. So what? I'm specifically talking about what influences some people to become theists. I'm not talking about theists lives outside of their their god beliefs. Are you saying you know some people that have become theists as a result of them being exceedingly "bright"?Naw. I know some 100% rational people who are "dull" (for lack of a better word), and some highly, exceedingly "bright", intellectual theists.
Me too. So what? I'm specifically talking about what influences some people to become theists. I'm not talking about theists lives outside of their their god beliefs. Are you saying you know some people that have become theists as a result of them being exceedingly "bright"?
Yes, in the sense that reason is sterile and you have to combine it with emotions..
Okay, skepticism on skepticism. We can't really in principle know if I am God, therefore I am God.
In practice gravity and subjective morality/ethics are equally certain, absolute and what not, yet of course the induction problem means that tomorrow the universe will stop existing.
You want a better world, right?!!! Then start treating everybody different from you as wrong even in the non-moral sense and point out that only you and your "we" can decide right and wrong. And then you are no different that those you oppose.
Yes, religious humans can be dangerous, yet they are also humans and if you start treating them in effect in a derogatory way you increase the chance of you and others getting hurt. Treat them as humans, as you would like to be treated.
Do you like be called irrational or wrong? No, then don't use words, which can offend.
You believe differently that me. I accept that. I am just pointing out that all humans are humans and nobody has the upper hand on others with reason, logic and evidence when it comes to morality or what reality really is.
What religious humans do, is natural and they are humans.
We are equal as humans and different as individuals.
I’m specifically talking about what influences some people to BECOME theists. I’m NOT talking about staying or giving up BEING a theist, and I have no idea why you seem to think I am. Please feel free to quote where I’ve said anything about anyone remaining or giving up being a theist.
It requires a whole lot more intellectual effort to stay a theist than to give up the belief. Realizing that there is no God isn't intellectually difficult, which is why I, unlike ynot, am not particularly proud of my achievement in this field. It required neither intellectual effort nor bravery. Why would it be an act of courage to give up on the idea that there's an omnipotent and omniscient guy in the sky who'll punish me when I die when absolutely nothing seems to indicate that this guy actually exists? It's about as courageous as giving up on the idea that there's a monster under my bed who'll devour me when I go to sleep.
I’ve never ever been a theist so how can I possibly be “proud of my achievement in this field (of giving up a god belief)’ when there hasn’t ever been any such thing for me to achieve?
You said . . .
YOU are clearly saying that believing in a god is more emotionally influenced (for emotional comfort) than intellectually. In fact YOU are saying even a small amount of intellectual “figuring out” easily concludes there is no god. Therefore YOU are saying to conclude there is a god one has to be more emotionally influenced than intellectually. So by YOUR words, theists are more emotional than atheists regarding god beliefs.
I can see why you're confused about my "ridicules outbursts":
Believers "prostitute reality", unlike atheists, who "aren't prepared to prostitute reality" because they "accept death", follow "evidence" and are "tough" and "self-honest", which, of course, is not at all smug and self-congratulatory.
which I have now repeated in this post. I hope that you're happy!
Yes, I round it off with a jab at racist atheists, the organized atheists in my country, who were and still are so brave that I can no longer find a single reference online where they mention their invitation to racist Helmuth Nyborg to speak at one of their meetings. Ynot's excuse for inviting a racist to speak, "It could merely mean you're open to hearing about all opinions and beliefs," might have been correct if they had followed up on the meeting and distanced themselves from the ********, if they had been tough and self-honest enough to criticize him and openly admit that it was a mistake to provide him with a platform for his IQ racism (and sexism as well). But instead, they seem to prefer being in denial about the whole thing.
Oh, no. Bright people can be indoctrinated into theism in a way that sticks, but I've never encountered a really bright person who went from agnostic/atheist/apatheist to "actual theist" (I'm excluding "theisms" like pantheism) as an adult.
That appears to be the general trend. My confirmation bias might be skewing my perception of my anecdotal "data collection" there, tho, maybe.Oh yes I agree with this, although I wonder if the stickiness of religious upbringing is less effective when the bright person matures, as compared to the dullard.
From Daniel Dennett's work in helping non believing clergy to exit the profession, we can take it as a given that many clergy have lost their faith. In the Catholic Church the theme that a priest is having trouble with their faith is a recurring one in books and movies. You also here Catholic clergy talking about a love of the church. Is this an alternative to a belief in the religious dogma and are these the bright ones?
All that stuff in italics doesn't change the fact that you went somewhat overboard in your ridiculous outburst answering ynot.
This kind of silly taunt doesn't increase your kudos you know.
Did ynot make any mention of support for Helmuth Nyborg? If he did I missed it.
As I read Helmuth was accused of racism but later acquitted.
It would seem his work is to some extent aligned with that of Charles Murray, (co author of "The Bell Curve" I think), who was interviewed by Sam Harris.
Are you among the many who condemned Harris as a racist because of this?