Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

The patients could spot that the normal guys were normal, but the staff couldn't?!
Did they let them all out, or are some of them still there? :)
 
The patients could spot that the normal guys were normal, but the staff couldn't?!
Did they let them all out, or are some of them still there? :)

It was a professor in psychology, who got some of his students to volunteer. So yes, they are out.
If I recall right it was a study about confirmation bias. :) It has been years since I read about it.

With regard
 
Probably both, I guess, but I don't think that the phrase confirmation bias had been coined back in '73.
 
From what I understand, it (well, the aftermath) was key in the cultural shift within psychiatry away from psychoanalysis towards more strict psychopharmacology. "Paradigm disrupting", if you will.
 
“Well they had a good innings” makes death more acceptable to most (even nasty atheists) as dying of old age is the expected way of nature. But for “not good innings” deaths (babies, toddlers, teenagers, and anyone not “old”.), religions offer a comforting, denial of reality belief package that many find too attractive to refuse. “Your loved one isn’t really dead, they’ve merely passed-over to a better place with all your other deceased loved ones, and they’re all waiting for you to join them there when you pass-over”.

Atheists aren’t prepared to prostitute reality for this comforting belief package and must accept death for what the current evidence says it is. It can be tough being and atheist, but it's self-honest.

They sound like outstanding and extremely brave individuals, those atheists of yours! Or maybe they just sound smug. Could it be that they just never had something like that happen to them? Have you considered that you might find yourself in a situation one day where 'prostituting reality' would be the only way for you to cope? Where your loss is so great that you need 'this comforting belief package' (and it doesn't have to be a package; you can make one up like the child in Beslan)? Where's your compassion when you use descriptions like these?
We have a couple of Christians in our group, and they are excellent skeptics. They're the first to criticize weeping Madonnas and Creationism, and they would never consider criticizing other kinds of superstition for being unholy or unchristian.
On the other hand, we have a Danish atheist society that invited this guy to give a speech because, at one point, he also published a paper against astrology.
I sure as hell prefer our Christians to any racist atheist!


What is there in ynot's post to prompt this ridicules outburst? :confused:

Sarcastic reference to brave atheists at the beginning, and you round it of with a jab about racist atheists. Are you reading stuff from between the lines of ynot's post perhaps?:rolleyes:
 
If some folk are that precious, they cannot stand to see the nonsense they believe questioned, they are the ones in need of counselling.
You're calling people "precious", saying that they believe nonsense, and questioning their mental health. Can't you see how that can be interpreted as attacking people rather than their belief?
 
So it's Tommy the shrink now is it?:rolleyes:

This may have escaped your attention but I am all about attacking ideas not people. If some folk are that precious, they cannot stand to see the nonsense they believe questioned, they are the ones in need of counselling.

Now here is what I don't get, you are reflected about how reality works and that includes that you know that humans who hold incorrect beliefs, must actually be aware with doubt that they hold incorrect beliefs and thus they don't really believe in their incorrect beliefs.
.......

More convoluted crap.

.......

You are saying something about humans as they are and not just the ideas/beliefs that they hold.
So I would like evidence.

With regard


Your highlighted sentence is a real doozy. "..... they don't really believe in their incorrect beliefs." :boggled:

What you haven't done is addressed the content of my post that you responded to.
 
What is there in ynot's post to prompt this ridicules outburst? :confused:

Sarcastic reference to brave atheists at the beginning, and you round it of with a jab about racist atheists. Are you reading stuff from between the lines of ynot's post perhaps?:rolleyes:
The angry mob is so fired-up with prejudicial and willful misreading, misinterpreting and misquoting of my words I’m not even going to bother to respond as their counter responses would be just more of the same. Hard to have a meaningful and fair debate with an angry mob waving burning torches and pitchforks.
 
Last edited:
I did not question their mental health and no I am just questioning beliefs not "attacking people."
You said that they needed counselling - that is questioning their mental health. You called people "precious" - not beliefs, people. You do this sort of thing all the time.

Even if that is not intended as an attack, it will be interpreted as one. If you really want to avoid attacking people and focus on their beliefs, you need to moderate your language a lot more.

I interrupted, and I apologise. I do hope you think about what I've said though. Please return to the conversation at hand, because it is an interesting one.
 
I think there's a countervailing dynamic also, though. Someone who is focused on survival in probably going to take a pragmatic approach to those immediate concerns, and be casually agnostic about the rest of reality. It takes a pampered mind to really indulge in woo.

No, it doesn't. The opposite is true, actually. Religion is a crutch for the desperate, and rationality is a luxury affordable only to those who are safe.

I agree, at least when it comes to the religious flavours of woo. I’m not looking forward to the day western societies become less pampered and safe as religions will surely raise their ugly heads again and many will be attracted to the “safety” and “protection” they “offer”. Death of loved ones is a great recruiter for religions. Suffering grief is hardly being pampered.


The old saw about there being no atheists in foxholes is not completely true, but it certainly has elements of truth.

However there are types of Woo that attract the pampered worried well.

Californian New Age is one obvious thing that springs to mind - but that is quite different to say Christianity after a few decades of the Black Death.


The first is that everything is generally nice and fluffy and if you keep a sufficiently open mind (so open that your brain falls out) you can have some good happen to you that is often rather nebulous and ill defined.
The latter is blaming the troubles on sin and saying that only those with a rigid adherence to the edicts of the Church will be spared, and that the solution is a more closed mind.
 
You said that they needed counselling - that is questioning their mental health. You called people "precious" - not beliefs, people. You do this sort of thing all the time.

Even if that is not intended as an attack, it will be interpreted as one. If you really want to avoid attacking people and focus on their beliefs, you need to moderate your language a lot more.

I interrupted, and I apologise. I do hope you think about what I've said though. Please return to the conversation at hand, because it is an interesting one.


Tis a long bow you draw here arth.

Believers in woo shouldn't take it as a personal insult if I attack the woo. If they do it's their problem not mine. Not all people who need counselling are mentally ill either so that's a rather blunt barb.
 
Tis a long bow you draw here arth.

Believers in woo shouldn't take it as a personal insult if I attack the woo. If they do it's their problem not mine. Not all people who need counselling are mentally ill either so that's a rather blunt barb.
There’s a type of touchy-feely “Let’s be nice” atheist that’s predominately interested in being “nice” to theists. Seems they don’t like “nasty atheists” as they make them them look bad by association. They interpret attacks on theism as being attacks on theists every bit as much as many/most theists do. For some reason they seem happy for “nasty theists” to attack and threaten atheists however. Touchy-feely logic I guess. :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
There’s a type of weak “Let’s be nice” atheist that’s predominately interested in being “nice” to theists. Seems they don’t like “nasty atheists” as they make them them look bad by association.

Do you pride yourself on being a nasty sort of atheist as opposed to a "weak", nice one?

Do you think it's possible to be nice without being weak?
 
Do you pride yourself on being a nasty sort of atheist as opposed to a "weak", nice one?

Do you think it's possible to be nice without being weak?
Before you posted I changed "weak" to "touchy-feely" (but "weak" will do).

I don't accept that I am a nasty atheist, that's a label others pin on me and other atheists that don't conform to their particular touchy-feely level of "nice".
 
Before you posted I changed "weak" to "touchy-feely" (but "weak" will do).

I don't accept that I am a nasty atheist, that's a label others pin on me and other atheists that don't conform to their particular touchy-feely level of "nice".

Do you understand that nobody in this thread pinned that on you?
 
Just have to respond to this “pitchfork in the foot” post . . .
Is it really that much of an intellectual accomplishment to realize that there is no God? Or god?
It's pretty obvious that there isn't, and analytically it isn't harder to figure out that there is no god than to figure out that there is no Santa or Easter Bunny.
Dann is saying it doesn’t take much intellect to realise and conclude there is no God or god.

But unlike those two fairytale creatures, the God delusion gives comfort to grown ups, which is the main difference.
Dann is saying theists are less intellectual and more emotional than atheists regarding god beliefs to gain emotional comfort.

But when atheists say essentially the same thing dann says . . .
Somehow this kind of vanity seems to be a significant part of the "comforting belief package" of many atheists: that they are intellectually superior to believers!
Your own words agree that atheists are intellectually superior to theists/believers when it comes to God/god beliefs. I guess that makes you as "vain" and "smug" as those you criticise.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom