Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Don't get me wrong, I've read the stories and the study too. It's just a bit difficult for me to believe. For example, I've communicated with the my local Medicaid benefit administrators on the issue of reimbursement and found that while the rates had been declining, as of 2008 we were still at 55%. And they're not willing to end reimbursement, at least for now. I would expect a bit higher in the general population. Now I am in a different state but only a bit further south. If it is in fact the case, it would make me really happy but again based on other information and intuition I don't think we are quite there yet though we're moving in the right direction.

The data you are looking at is presumably in a state where Medicaid covers circumcision.

1. Not all state Medicaid programs cover circumcision.
2. I don't have a set of data, but I would imagine that the number of newborns born that do not qualify for Medicaid is quite a bit larger than those who do.
 
The data you are looking at is presumably in a state where Medicaid covers circumcision.

I know, I am requesting and examining the data because I am trying to get the state to stop paying for it. ;)

1. Not all state Medicaid programs cover circumcision.
2. I don't have a set of data, but I would imagine that the number of newborns born that do not qualify for Medicaid is quite a bit larger than those who do.

1. You're correct, 17 states currently don't pay for it, I can list them if someone wants, but it's also easy enough to find. I've recently been informed that an 18th state (Colorado) will stop funding circumcision starting July 1st.

2. You're probably right, it might depend on the state though. In any case, I suspect that the rate of circumcision is lower among the pool of medicaid births than those whose births are paid for through other means.

What I am saying is that the study was performed in PA, a state where Medicaid continues to pay for circumcision, and as far as I knew a high risk state for boys to be born in to begin with.

Let me put it this way, I read that study with cautious optimism.
 
one of the main justifications being made for surgery on babies with a cleft-pallate/lip & on baby-girls with an enlarged clitoris, was the social isolation & stigma the child might feel..due to their condition.

if that is considered a legitimate reason for surgery for these conditions, then circumcision for purely cultural/religious reasons is also legitimate.

Only if you went to a school in which you wore your penis outside of your uniform.

As far as cleft lips and palates go it is obviously important for children to get surgery particularly given the fact that early surgery can remove a lot of scarring and can assist the child in developing normally. Even cosmetic surgery on a child's cleft lip will be far more useful than circumcision.

You know this of course but are choosing to play silly buggers.
 
No it doesn't - the question was what is the use of a foreskin, and one of the functions is pleasure.
Yes it does- if one of the uses of a foreskin is pleasure, then the absence of it would remove said pleasure no?


¡You were asking for evidence so asking you what kind of evidence will satisfy you that a foreskin gives pleasure is necessary to provide an appropriate answer.
No, its a way for you to dance around the fact that you made a bare assertion offering no evidence....

But, lest the dance continue, you could post one of the studies that shows how much pleasure men with foreskin get. That's not against the rules of the forum is it?
 
I know, I am requesting and examining the data because I am trying to get the state to stop paying for it. ;)

Fair enough. :)

1. You're correct, 17 states currently don't pay for it, I can list them if someone wants, but it's also easy enough to find. I've recently been informed that an 18th state (Colorado) will stop funding circumcision starting July 1st.

Sounds about right. No need to find the list, unless you want to.

2. You're probably right, it might depend on the state though. In any case, I suspect that the rate of circumcision is lower among the pool of medicaid births than those whose births are paid for through other means.

That's interesting. I really have no idea, but I might expect the opposite to be the case. IOW, with higher income and education, I might anticipate that couples are spending more time thinking about it, researching it, and declining the procedure. But I'm over 50 now, and most of my peers are preparing for grandchildren, and the subject doesn't come up. :D

What I am saying is that the study was performed in PA, a state where Medicaid continues to pay for circumcision, and as far as I knew a high risk state for boys to be born in to begin with.

Let me put it this way, I read that study with cautious optimism.

Born and raised in da 'Burgh. Go Stillers. ;)
 
Yes it does- if one of the uses of a foreskin is pleasure, then the absence of it would remove said pleasure no?



No, its a way for you to dance around the fact that you made a bare assertion offering no evidence....

But, lest the dance continue, you could post one of the studies that shows how much pleasure men with foreskin get. That's not against the rules of the forum is it?

Not necessarily the case. I can say that I get great pleasure from my children, without implying that people without children have less pleasure.
 
That's interesting. I really have no idea, but I might expect the opposite to be the case. IOW, with higher income and education, I might anticipate that couples are spending more time thinking about it, researching it, and declining the procedure. But I'm over 50 now, and most of my peers are preparing for grandchildren, and the subject doesn't come up. :D

This study (looking at data from the 1960s) shows a strong (positive) correlation between family income and rate of circumcision in the white population.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1646345/pdf/amjph00284-0068.pdf
 
Yes it does- if one of the uses of a foreskin is pleasure, then the absence of it would remove said pleasure no?

It would remove that pleasure yes - and?


No, its a way for you to dance around the fact that you made a bare assertion offering no evidence....

But, lest the dance continue, you could post one of the studies that shows how much pleasure men with foreskin get. That's not against the rules of the forum is it?

Since that was not part of my claim of course I'm not going to look to argue against your strawman.

As I said if you not believe that I get pleasure from my foreskin what evidence will it take to convince you that I do?
 
I read that anti-circumcision site with mounting horror. I am in no doubt at all that such a procedure would be banned if it were being done to animals, under animal welfare legislation.

Interestingly, one of the surgeons was reported as telling the parents that the procedure was little more than taking the tail off a lamb. I can assure him that it is a great deal more than taking the tail off a lamb. However, in that context, docking of lambs is one of the procedures that has come under increasing scrutiny in recent years, with producers being urged only to undertake it if there is a genuine welfare benefit - that is, if leaving the tail on has been shown to increase the incidence of fly-strike in the farm in question. I am seeing more and more lambs with natural tails.

Animal mutilations are an interesting parallel in general, in that there is an increasing trend in society to criticise and phase out mutilations which show no net welfare benefit. This castration of pigs doesn't happen in Britain any more, and more and more lambs and calves are being reared to slaughter weight without beiong castrated. I wonder, sometimes, if even ear tagging (which is little more than having your ears pierced) might go the same way in the future.

However, I have noted that in the USA animal mutilation is far more widely accepted than in Britain. Docking and even ear cropping of puppies is still normal. Surgical intervention to change the gait of horses seems to be quite widespread, and don't let's get started on declawing of cats. All of these bar tail docking of puppies have been illegal in Britain since I can't remember when. Tail docking is in its death throes.

Whether this has any bearing on the fact that baby mutilation seems a lot more popular in the USA, and to be viewed with a lot more equanimity, I don't know.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
According to this, Maimonides does think circumcision is about causing pain and reducing the amount of sexual pleasure and sexual frequency:

Similarly with regard to circumcision, one of the reasons for it is, in my opinion, the wish to bring about a decrease in sexual intercourse and a weakening of the organ in question, so that this activity be diminished and the organ be in as quiet a state as possible. It has been thought that circumcision perfects what is defective congenitally. This gave the possibility to everyone to raise an objection and to say: How can natural things be defective so that they need to be perfected from outside, all the more because we know how useful the foreskin is for that member? In fact this commandment has not been prescribed with a view to perfecting what is defective congenitally, but to perfecting what is defective morally. The bodily pain caused to that member is the real purpose of circumcision. None of the activities necessary for the preservation of the individual is harmed thereby, nor is procreation rendered impossible, but violent concupiscence and lust that goes beyond what is needed are diminished. The fact that circumcision weakens the faculty of sexual excitement and sometimes perhaps diminishes the pleasure is indubitable. For if at birth this member has been made to bleed and has had its covering taken away from it, it must indubitably be weakened. The Sages, may their memory be blessed, have explicitly stated: It is hard for a woman with whom an uncircumcised man has had sexual intercourse to separate from him. In my opinion this is the strongest of the reasons for circumcision.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

http://www.cirp.org/library/cultural/maimonides/
 
Sorry I'm late to this party. I've been busy bludgeoning Christians and AAers with their own Bibles.

#6. This clearly violates the separation of Church and State. Such a law would be no different than banning ritualized ear-piercing, branding, etc etc.

Chopping bits of a non-consenting person's anatomy is very different from a person of age choosing to alter their own bodies

It would be one thing, if the folks in SF demanded that all baby boys receive some form of pain killer before the procedure was done, in order to dull the pain. But this is not their concern. Their concern is clearly not the pain the baby suffers, but the ritual itself..and probably even its religious nature.

Evidence?

You appear to be implying that people who want to ban chopping bits off a non-consenting person's anatomy is an Anti-Semite.

Seeking to have the govt. ban a private religious act, because of its religious nature, is a violation of the 1st Amendment.

Chopping bits off a non-consenting person's anatomy is usually considered a Crime. Why should Judaism be given a pass on this one?

Banning criminal behaviour is not a violation of the First Amendment.

Many Religious Practices are banned in the US because they are considered to be Criminal Acts.

GB
 
Yes, and he also thinks that that is the point and presumably endorses it too.

Or "thought" and "endorsed".

Reading the article on that link, he more than "presumably" endorses it. Just because he endorses it doesn't necessarily mean, that he's wrong regarding the reasoning for doing it. It just means he's a Sadist.

GB
 
It would be one thing, if the folks in SF demanded that all baby boys receive some form of pain killer before the procedure was done, in order to dull the pain. But this is not their concern. Their concern is clearly not the pain the baby suffers, but the ritual itself..and probably even its religious nature.
What was your first clue?

Yes, we're agaisnt drastic body modifications of people much too young to voice consent. What would be the harm in letting them wait until they were 18? Oh, wait, then they'd just say no.

Let's say there was a sect in your area that wanted to start tattooing their sect's symbol on the underside of the feet of their newborn, with painkiller so that the little creature wouldn't feel a thing. Would you support or oppose this idea?

Animal mutilations are an interesting parallel in general, in that there is an increasing trend in society to criticise and phase out mutilations which show no net welfare benefit. This castration of pigs doesn't happen in Britain any more, and more and more lambs and calves are being reared to slaughter weight without beiong castrated. I wonder, sometimes, if even ear tagging (which is little more than having your ears pierced) might go the same way in the future.
Now that you mention it, Norwegian law forbids operating the tails off of rottweilers. The same laws permit chopping the foreskin off of newborn humans. I wonder what rottweilers have that humans don't.

Oh, wait, I do know -- rottweilers don't form crazed religious sects that uphold bizarre rituals for reasons of "tribal culture" and "tradition".
 
Last edited:
Let's say there was a sect in your area that wanted to start tattooing their sect's symbol on the underside of the feet of their newborn, with painkiller so that the little creature wouldn't feel a thing. Would you support or oppose this idea?
Amusingly enough, that procedure is reversible, so it's still not as bad as circumcision.
 
Now that Thunder has bowed out to lick his wounds, I'd be interested to know if anyone is still supporting the circumcision of male infants. In particular, I'd be interested to know if anyone is supporting the procedure when it is not required by a particular religion.

And if so, why?

Rolfe.
 
I am going through the other threads Darth posted, but I'm unclear as to why this is done without anesthesia?

Now I realize this is from an anti-circumcision site, but this is pretty horrifying:
http://www.circumstitions.com/Pain.html

So in newborns, the foreskin is actually attached somehow and has to be "ripped" down off the penis before it's removed? Jebus -- I'm sold. No cutting. If he wants one later, he can have it done himself.

:thumbsup:

This is good news. I mean, there are better reasons than that to go against the decision, but as long as it doesn't happen, that's fine.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom