Ban circumcision in San Fran???

one of the main justifications being made for surgery on babies with a cleft-pallate/lip & on baby-girls with an enlarged clitoris, was the social isolation & stigma the child might feel..due to their condition.
if that is considered a legitimate reason for surgery for these conditions, then circumcision for purely cultural/religious reasons is also legitimate.

No it wasn't - as I showed you cleft palates are repaired primarily for medical reasons since such a defect impacts on a baby's ability to thrive.
 
Regarding the hygiene question, I know for a fact it takes no longer to clean a penis that has a foreskin and one that doesn't. Of course if someone's personal hygiene is poor then there may be complications that arise from that.
 
Regarding the hygiene question, I know for a fact it takes no longer to clean a penis that has a foreskin and one that doesn't. Of course if someone's personal hygiene is poor then there may be complications that arise from that.

hygiene was never one of my arguments.
 
I am going through the other threads Darth posted, but I'm unclear as to why this is done without anesthesia?

Now I realize this is from an anti-circumcision site, but this is pretty horrifying:
http://www.circumstitions.com/Pain.html

So in newborns, the foreskin is actually attached somehow and has to be "ripped" down off the penis before it's removed? Jebus -- I'm sold. No cutting. If he wants one later, he can have it done himself.
 
anyway, I would like to see a Federal law requiring anesthesia for circumcisions. remove the foreskin all you like, but give the poor kid a seditive to reduce the pain.

the point of circumcision is NOT to cause a baby pain, therefore the removal of such pain should not be an issue.
 
So that means the post in which you quoted my comment was a non sequitur.

no, I figured that since I'm the only one arguing for legalized circumcision, that you were refering to an assumed post or belief of mine.

it was nothing malicious.
 
One can only hope that increased education and debate will, somehow, gradually change the culture and minimise the circumcision supporters to the point where the practice can be stopped. In the meantime... well it's just tough on the kids, I guess, but such is life.

Apparently the rate of circumcision is dropping rapidly in the USA.


Somehow, I don't think Thunder is prevailing in this argument.

This is true of a great many threads.


What percentage of non-Muslim, non-Jewish male babies are circumcised in the USA?

Per the stats that were already posted by Agatha, above, the overall rate seems to have dropped to 32.5% in 2009.


1. Regarding argument one, is there anyone here who can attest that it is a real pain to keep an uncircumcised baby clean? Is there any uncut man here who can attest that it's problematic or difficult to keep self clean?

I don't know from first-hand experience, alas, but I don't think it's a matter of circumcision making it that much easier to keep clean, but, rather, that the consequences of poor hygiene are greater for the uncircumcised.

2. Is there any evidence that circumcision IN THE USA has reduced rates of STDs?

Not that I've seen.

Don't we pretty much encourage cut and uncut men to wear condoms?

Well, we should, anyway.



3. This is the toughest argument to evaluate for me (being a woman.) Is there anyone here who is uncut who was made fun of or made to feel other than normal as a child? Was anyone singled out in the locker room for having a foreskin? Or were any of you on the other side of the room, making fun of the uncut kid? I hear a lot of people saying uncut kids get made fun of and made to feel "not normal" -- but can anyone state from personal experience that they either felt this way, or made another child feel this way?

As pointed out, it would seem that majority of boys born in the US since at least 2009 are likely to be uncircumcised. So, if that argument were actually rational, it would now support the other side of the debate.
 
...snip...

Per the stats that were already posted by Agatha, above, the overall rate seems to have dropped to 32.5% in 2009.

...snip...

That's why I was wondering about the percentage carried out for religious reasons, to me it seems that circumcised penises are soon going to be the unusual penises in "the locker room".
 
That's why I was wondering about the percentage carried out for religious reasons, to me it seems that circumcised penises are soon going to be the unusual penises in "the locker room".

Well, those numbers don't include circumcisions carried out by non-medical personnel (such as moyels), so a large chunk of the "for religious reasons" crowd aren't included. On the other hand Jews and Muslims make up a very small percentage of the population, so they might not have much of an effect on the numbers, anyway.
 
such as?

and do me a favor and don't post obvious strawmen arguments.
When it was pointed out that female circumcision would reduce the risk of STDs and unwanted pregnancies by reducing the amount of sex that they have, and instead of addressing that argument you addressed a different argument that no one made and pretended that by doing so you were actually addressing the original argument.
 
What do your figures refer to?

The figure you're asking for is difficult to get a firm value on. It is generally believed that on average (across the whole country) it's in the 60 percent range. Though it's a bit misleading because the local figures vary widely by region. More progressive areas (such as the West coast) have much lower rates (<30%) while less progressive ones (such as the mid west) have much higher numbers (>85%). States where Medicaid no longer pays for the the procedure have lower rates than those that do. Currently, the procedure is not publicly funded in 17 states, as of July 1st that will be 18 with the addition of Colorado.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom