Ban circumcision in San Fran???

When it was pointed out that female circumcision would reduce the risk of STDs and unwanted pregnancies by reducing the amount of sex that they have, and instead of addressing that argument you addressed a different argument that no one made and pretended that by doing so you were actually addressing the original argument.

Thanks for that. There have been more than one other examples, but I have given up explaining.
 
Per the stats that were already posted by Agatha, above, the overall rate seems to have dropped to 32.5% in 2009.

I am a bit skeptical about this number, I really wish it was that low, it would demonstrate great progress but it's difficult to believe.
 
When it was pointed out that female circumcision would reduce the risk of STDs and unwanted pregnancies by reducing the amount of sex that they have,

where are these studies that show that female circumcision reduces sexual activity?

there are none. its just mere speculation.

just like how folks keep suggesting that male-circumcision makes sex less-pleasurable, and yet no one has any evidence that male-circumcision reduces sexual activity.

show me studies on hundreds of random women, showing that post-circumcision sex-rates are less than pre-circumcision sex-rates, and I will believe. but until then, its just biased speculation to confirm pre-conceived notions...similar to what a Truther or CTist would do.

oh...did I say that? :)
 
Last edited:
The last time I addressed that, you reflexively handwaved it away as irrelevant(without explaining why) and instead attacked an argument that nobody made.
 
Why is it a good idea to circumcise a baby where there is no medical reason, instead of leaving him as born until he is able to give informed consent, given that no baby ever was injured or died from not having an unnecessary circumcision, while a small number of babies are injured and die from having unnecessary circumcisions.
 
where are these studies that show that female circumcision reduces sexual activity?

Is someone actually arguing that?

(My experience is with North Africans, not Sub-Saharan Africans, so the mileage may vary.)

Female circumcision is illegal in many of these countries, but it is still secretly practiced. The rationale is most often "tradition," but when pressed, mothers will tell you that uncircumcised girls will be thought to be loose-moraled. There is the IMPRESSION in many of these women that they are doing their daughters a favor.

Also, in these countries (as opposed to in West and South Africa) it is usually done right before the onset of puberty, and not in infancy. Either way, it is performed before the girls would ever be sexually active, so there's no way to say if it reduces sexual activity. (There is the general perception in the community that circumcised girls won't have sex before marriage or commit adultery, but that's not something they admit to, in any case.)

The IMPRESSION or general attitude is that an intact girl will crave sex outside of marriage, will cheat on her husband, will encourage her husband to be sterile by having too much sex, will cause impotency in her husband for the same reason ... etc. Superstition mostly. Some women will tell you that if a man even touches the clitoris he will become impotent. I've heard weirder, but that one was pretty common.

Women who HAVE been circumcised don't know what sexual pleasure is like prior to the circumcision, so you won't find that many who say it "decreases" their sensitivity -- since they don't know where that threshold for pleasure is to begin with.

Oddly enough in the baladi areas of Egypt, the men are often very opposed to the procedure, but it's the mothers and grandmothers who maintain this "tradition" -- and they are the ones who usually do the cutting. Again, it's rationalized that "Men will know she is a good girl" if she's cut, despite what the men themselves say.

I have asked whether or not they enjoy sex, and everyone who responded said they did -- but I don't know if that's what they think I expect to hear or if it's true. Also, I wonder to myself if they wouldn't enjoy it MORE if they had a clitoris, but it's not something you argue with a woman about if you want to stay friends or benefit from her hospitality.
 
Is someone actually arguing that?

yes ma'am.

When it was pointed out that female circumcision would reduce the risk of STDs and unwanted pregnancies by reducing the amount of sex that they have,

Now we agree that it is very silly to presume that people who undergo procedures designed to reduce the amount of sex they have would not actually reduce the amount of sex that they have.

The levels that reduce the woman's sexual pleasure. Less pleasure --> less sex --> reduced risk of STDs and unplanned pregnancies.

Do you really need a study that shows people do things less when it is less enjoyable than they do when they are more enjoyable. I'm pretty sure you can suss that one out yourself.

Sex is part of the issue of STDs! It's right there in the name.

If you care about STDs, which you allegedly do, then you SHOULD care about the amount of sexual activity!

Originally Posted by Thunder
and reducing the infection & spread of sexually-transmitted diseases.


Yes, female circumcision does those things and is therefore good.
(because female-circumcision supposedly reduces female sex-rates)
 
Last edited:
Pretty sure I rephrased that later to "would otherwise have", in deference to those who couldn't grasp the obvious intent of the statement.
 
Last edited:
An interesting video regarding female circumcision in Egypt:

http://www.youtube.com/v/qsqEyGdLh8I

Don't worry, it's just interviews. Clearly though, the women do it for: religion, tradition, and health. I don't see any indication that they believe they are doing anything that is not in the child's best interest. It really is much like male circumcision.

ETA: It's chilling, I've seen, read, heard, and watch interviews regarding male circumcision in the US where the responses were exactly the same.
 
Last edited:
Pretty sure I rephrased that later to "would otherwise have", in deference to those who couldn't grasp the obvious intent of the statement.

you stated, time & time again, that female-circumcision reduces SDT/HIV infection & transmission rates, due to the lower chances of sexual activity.

you also stated, that no report or evidence is needed to prove this, as it can simply be deduced.
 
The logic used IS a type of evidence. If you want to argue against the premises with something other than feigned incredulity you'll have to address them instead of handwaving into oblivion.
 
you stated, time & time again, that female-circumcision reduces SDT/HIV infection & transmission rates, due to the lower chances of sexual activity.

you also stated, that no report or evidence is needed to prove this, as it can simply be deduced.

Wildy's post, which you ignored. Conveniently.
 
Do you disagree with the premise that people will do things less if they are less enjoyable? If so, why?

Before mashing the "submit" button, check to see if your post actually addresses this, thanks in advance.
 
Last edited:
A few posts moved to AAH.

Legend, Thunder - stop the bickering.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Gaspode
 
A few posts moved to AAH.

Legend, Thunder - stop the bickering.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Gaspode

naa, I'm done here. For real this time. My opponents in this debate simply refuse to remain civil.
 
Thunder, which of these do you think is more important:
1) An adult's right to make choices that affect his own body
2) An adult's right to make choices that affect another adult's body
 
I am a bit skeptical about this number, I really wish it was that low, it would demonstrate great progress but it's difficult to believe.



Study: Circumcision Rates Falling Fast In U.S.

August 22, 2010
New research about a steep drop in circumcisions made headlines this past week. According to one federal researcher, circumcision rates in U.S. hospitals slid from 56 percent in 2006 to fewer than a third of boys born last year.

Doctors caution that those numbers aren't definitive — for instance, they don't include circumcisions not covered by insurance policies or circumcisions performed in religious settings.

But Dr. Douglas Diekema, a pediatrics bioethicist at the University of Washington, tells NPR's Audie Cornish there's no doubt about the overall trend.

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=129362160
 

Don't get me wrong, I've read the stories and the study too. It's just a bit difficult for me to believe. For example, I've communicated with the my local Medicaid benefit administrators on the issue of reimbursement and found that while the rates had been declining, as of 2008 we were still at 55%. And they're not willing to end reimbursement, at least for now. I would expect a bit higher in the general population. Now I am in a different state but only a bit further south. If it is in fact the case, it would make me really happy but again based on other information and intuition I don't think we are quite there yet though we're moving in the right direction.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom