Antiquehunter
Degenerate Gambler
- Joined
- Aug 7, 2005
- Messages
- 5,088
A query (and my apologies if this has been addressed, I don't want to have to search 46 pages for an answer)...
So the OP implies that San Francisco - a City, in a large State, is going to impose a ban on something. Fine.
If someone is passionate about getting their son circumcised (religious beliefs or otherwise) how are they going to prevent this person from taking their child out of the city for the procedure?
It doesn't strike me as a particularly enforceable piece of legislation (if indeed that is what it is.)
I don't have any kids, am not going to have any kids, and am not particularly passionate one way or another. Preponderance of evidence appears to be that there is little to no medical reason or benefit for the procedure. It would seem its a religious issue at that point (except in cases where there are adhesions or a medical need for the procedure) - and if it becomes a religious issue, well... danger Will Robinson...
-AH
So the OP implies that San Francisco - a City, in a large State, is going to impose a ban on something. Fine.
If someone is passionate about getting their son circumcised (religious beliefs or otherwise) how are they going to prevent this person from taking their child out of the city for the procedure?
It doesn't strike me as a particularly enforceable piece of legislation (if indeed that is what it is.)
I don't have any kids, am not going to have any kids, and am not particularly passionate one way or another. Preponderance of evidence appears to be that there is little to no medical reason or benefit for the procedure. It would seem its a religious issue at that point (except in cases where there are adhesions or a medical need for the procedure) - and if it becomes a religious issue, well... danger Will Robinson...
-AH