Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Still incorrect. Muslim countires limiting the rights of Christians is not an attack on the religious freedom of Muslims.

I 100% disagree. A nation that allows religious persection of one religion, can just as easily persecute every other religion.

A Muslim nation that allows persecution of Christians, could very easily persecute a Muslim-sect that is unpopular.
 
yes, and I am comparing circumcision to another procedure performed upon a child. we ain't talking about a fertilized egg here.

if we can compare it to ear-piercings, braces, clitoral-reduction, then we can compare it to all medical procedures performed upon a child's body.

just because you are highly bothered by the analogy, does not mean the analogy is inappropriate for the discussion.

I'm not highly bothered because it's not an analogy at all. Calling a fetus a child doesn't make it so.
 
how many of the folks here who are against circumcision, are also against clitoral reduction surgery?
 
Last edited:
Firstly, you have not evidenced this. I am against all surgery on a person too young to consent unless it is medically necessary - one data point against what you "think".

Secondly, you are moving the goalposts by first talking of "clitoral reduction" and then talking of "corrective surgery". Clitoral reduction on its own carries no connotation of corrective surgery, and corrective surgery is not analogous to male circumcision.

It would be better if you decided where the goalposts are, and left them in one place.
 
Secondly, you are moving the goalposts by first talking of "clitoral reduction" and then talking of "corrective surgery". Clitoral reduction on its own carries no connotation of corrective surgery, and corrective surgery is not analogous to male circumcision.

clitoral reduction surgery, clitoral corrective surgery, I didn't really see it as different things.

but if you insist, I shall stick with clitoral reduction surgery.

and yes, some of the folks here who are against infant male-circumcision support clitoral reduction surgery on baby girls.

let me find the posts..hold on.
 
ok, no one out right said they support clitoral-reduction surgery. but no one came out against it either.

so, those of you who are against male-baby circumcision, are you also against clitoral-reduction surgery?
 
clitoral reduction surgery, clitoral corrective surgery, I didn't really see it as different things.

but if you insist, I shall stick with clitoral reduction surgery.

and yes, some of the folks here who are against infant male-circumcision support clitoral reduction surgery on baby girls.

let me find the posts..hold on.
I'm just quoting you because you seem to have developed a habit of deleting posts in the last couple of hours.

People who are against medically unnecessary surgery on infants may be in favour of surgery where it is medically necessary. That isn't what you first contended, you do realise? What you originally said was
how many of the folks here who are against circumcision, are also against clitoral reduction surgery?
with no qualifier on whether the second was medically necessary. I made the mistake of thinking you were debating honestly, and answered honestly. You then moved the goalposts and changed the second part of your hypothetical to 'correcting an enlarged clitoris'.

This is not an honest way to discuss things.
 
I'm just quoting you because you seem to have developed a habit of deleting posts in the last couple of hours.

that was to prevent getting an infraction for a possible derail.

People who are against medically unnecessary surgery on infants may be in favour of surgery where it is medically necessary.

you are being very polite and courteous, and I appreciate that.

that said, I simply wish to know who here is against performing a clitoral reduction procedure upon an infant, before any known health problems have developed.

I think its a very fair question, since most folks here are against male circumcision on babies, without a medical reason.
 
ok, no one out right said they support clitoral-reduction surgery. but no one came out against it either.

so, those of you who are against male-baby circumcision, are you also against clitoral-reduction surgery?
So you were wrong.

And the answer to your question (again :rolleyes: ) is yes, I am against it unless it's deemed medically necessary. Not, therefore, if it's done for cultural, religious or social reasons. Frankly, unless we are considering a gross abnormality (in which case the child probably has more medical problems to be addressed), I cannot see any reason for such a thing to be done but I am not going to google this late at night; I don't want my dreams haunted by the appalling things some people will do to infants in the name of religion, culture or society.
 
I am against it unless it's deemed medically necessary. Not, therefore, if it's done for cultural, religious or social reasons. Frankly, unless we are considering a gross abnormality (in which case the child probably has more medical problems to be addressed), I cannot see any reason for such a thing to be done but I am not going to google this late at night; I don't want my dreams haunted by the appalling things some people will do to infants in the name of religion, culture or society.

ok, so unless a medical problem develops, the procedure should not be performed on a child.

it should not be performed simply due to a perceived possible future physical or psychological problem.

thank you, at least YOU are consistent.
 
Last edited:
I 100% disagree. A nation that allows religious persection of one religion, can just as easily persecute every other religion.

A Muslim nation that allows persecution of Christians, could very easily persecute a Muslim-sect that is unpopular.

You are still wrong. That is not persecution of all religions.
 
I am always polite and courteous.

I think you may have misunderstood your opponents' arguments if you really think that people will support unnecessary surgery on infant girls while at the same time arguing against infant male circumcision.

What people in this thread have argued for is not a ban on circumcision per se, but a ban on it being carried out on infants too young to consent. Adult males are free to have the operation if they wish, when they are old enough to make an informed choice about the risks of the surgery, and its permanent nature.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom