Ban circumcision in San Fran???

So my post doesn't count then? Or isn't HIV/AIDS an STD?

yes, I now see that evidence has been posted as to the possible STD-reducing qualities of female circumcision.

however, male circumcision, at least for Muslims & Jews, is not motivated by a desire to make sex less pleasurable for men...or to reduce masterbation.

while female circumcision, for many cultures, appears to have just such a goal.
 
Last edited:
yes, I now see that evidence has been posted as to the possible STD-reducing qualities of female circumcision.

however, male circumcision, at least for Muslims & Jews, is not motivated by a desire to make sex less pleasurable for men...or to reduce masterbation.

while female circumcision, for many cultures, appears to have just such a goal.

Who really cares why it started, the important thing is we no have a thin veneer on which to promote and expand the practice.
 
however, male circumcision, at least for Muslims & Jews, is not motivated by a desire to make sex less pleasurable for men...or to reduce masterbation.
Male circumcision started as a form of human sacrifice to seal a covenant with the genocidal blood god of a bronze age cult. So yeah it's totally not as bad as reducing sexual pleasure!
 
Last edited:
Somehow, I don't think Thunder is prevailing in this argument.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Somehow, I don't think Thunder is prevailing in this argument.

you're right. how can I be winning when everyone else is talking about evil, barbarism, sexual abuse, dishonesty, human sacrifice, 9-11 Truth, hating children, and Conspiracy Theorists?

;)
 
I know it's the Fail and it's not a father but...
Meh, that's just a voucher for the kid when she's old enough to get it if she wants it. If parents wanted to do that for circumcision I'd be all in favour - it's exactly what I've argued for myself! To be like the current situation the mother would actually be getting the implants put into the kid right now. Or rather, some years ago.

So my post doesn't count then? Or isn't HIV/AIDS an STD?
Hey, no argument against circumcision counts, no matter the merit of them. You should know that by now.
 
yes, I now see that evidence has been posted as to the possible STD-reducing qualities of female circumcision.

however, male circumcision, at least for Muslims & Jews, is not motivated by a desire to make sex less pleasurable for men...or to reduce masterbation.

while female circumcision, for many cultures, appears to have just such a goal.

What percentage of non-Muslim, non-Jewish male babies are circumcised in the USA?
 
Apologies for not reading all 40+ pages of this thread, but am I correct in saying the arguments FOR circumcision are as follows:

1. It's cleaner -- Promotes/allows for better hygiene.
2. It can help prevent STDs, UTIs and penile cancer.
3. It makes boys feel more like a member of the group and less like an outsider.

Does that pretty much cover it? I'm not addressing the religious reasons or the idea of parent's rights. I'm just looking at it from the point of view of a soon-to-be mom who has to decide if she wants her son circumcised.

From that viewpoint, may I ask the following of the 3 arguments:

1. Regarding argument one, is there anyone here who can attest that it is a real pain to keep an uncircumcised baby clean? Is there any uncut man here who can attest that it's problematic or difficult to keep self clean?

2. Is there any evidence that circumcision IN THE USA has reduced rates of STDs? Don't we pretty much encourage cut and uncut men to wear condoms? I'm not sure the data is entirely clear with regard to UTIs and cancer.

3. This is the toughest argument to evaluate for me (being a woman.) Is there anyone here who is uncut who was made fun of or made to feel other than normal as a child? Was anyone singled out in the locker room for having a foreskin? Or were any of you on the other side of the room, making fun of the uncut kid? I hear a lot of people saying uncut kids get made fun of and made to feel "not normal" -- but can anyone state from personal experience that they either felt this way, or made another child feel this way?


I am opposed to the idea, but number 3 is my hubby's sole reason for advocating circumcision, but I wonder if this idea that the kid will be made fun of is sort of a legend -- I know when I was a kid, we didn't have to look that closely at another kid to find something to bully or torment them about. If I had some sort of (even anecdotal) evidence that kids were really suffering from psychological damage by being uncut, I would reconsider arguing with him about this.
 
Apologies for not reading all 40+ pages of this thread, but am I correct in saying the arguments FOR circumcision are as follows:

1. It's cleaner -- Promotes/allows for better hygiene.
2. It can help prevent STDs, UTIs and penile cancer.
3. It makes boys feel more like a member of the group and less like an outsider.

and it usually does not cause any serious physical or emotional harm.

I see circumcision as no different than removing part of an ear lobe.

if some culture had earlobe-removal as part of their right of passage, I might find it odd....but I'd see no reason to make it illegal.
 
I am opposed to the idea, but number 3 is my hubby's sole reason for advocating circumcision, but I wonder if this idea that the kid will be made fun of is sort of a legend -- I know when I was a kid, we didn't have to look that closely at another kid to find something to bully or torment them about. If I had some sort of (even anecdotal) evidence that kids were really suffering from psychological damage by being uncut, I would reconsider arguing with him about this.

I have two friends who are uncut. I can't say we didn't make fun of them for it (I'm sure we did), but it was never a taboo thing that we fixated on. It was just their 'thing' (:D).

This seems like a bit of scare mongering. If your child goes to a school where he can't fit in because of his penis, chances are you're in a Catholic school and want to gtfo.
 
Apologies for not reading all 40+ pages of this thread, but am I correct in saying the arguments FOR circumcision are as follows:

1. It's cleaner -- Promotes/allows for better hygiene.
2. It can help prevent STDs, UTIs and penile cancer.
3. It makes boys feel more like a member of the group and less like an outsider.

Does that pretty much cover it? I'm not addressing the religious reasons or the idea of parent's rights. I'm just looking at it from the point of view of a soon-to-be mom who has to decide if she wants her son circumcised.

From that viewpoint, may I ask the following of the 3 arguments:

1. Regarding argument one, is there anyone here who can attest that it is a real pain to keep an uncircumcised baby clean? Is there any uncut man here who can attest that it's problematic or difficult to keep self clean?

2. Is there any evidence that circumcision IN THE USA has reduced rates of STDs? Don't we pretty much encourage cut and uncut men to wear condoms? I'm not sure the data is entirely clear with regard to UTIs and cancer.

3. This is the toughest argument to evaluate for me (being a woman.) Is there anyone here who is uncut who was made fun of or made to feel other than normal as a child? Was anyone singled out in the locker room for having a foreskin? Or were any of you on the other side of the room, making fun of the uncut kid? I hear a lot of people saying uncut kids get made fun of and made to feel "not normal" -- but can anyone state from personal experience that they either felt this way, or made another child feel this way?


I am opposed to the idea, but number 3 is my hubby's sole reason for advocating circumcision, but I wonder if this idea that the kid will be made fun of is sort of a legend -- I know when I was a kid, we didn't have to look that closely at another kid to find something to bully or torment them about. If I had some sort of (even anecdotal) evidence that kids were really suffering from psychological damage by being uncut, I would reconsider arguing with him about this.

That seems like a really dumb and inadequate reason to whimsically take away part of someone else's anatomy without them having any say in it whatsoever.

Doesn't being part of an exclusive "club" that requires you to have part of you get chopped off seem like a club you really want your son to pander to anyway? Besides, who's really going to find out, and if they are, what will happen? He's going to be shunned? It's not a prerequisite of any sort of normal group of boys or men, no one without some sort of serious cultural or personal bias would suddenly think any less of you than they would if you had different coloured hair. That goes for either way, so why not just leave everything how it is and avoid all of the ethical sins altogether? Are you going to go dye your kid's hair so he could fit in better? No, because it's fine how it is and it's his har, not yours. All that aside, I'm not sure what your sociological or geographical circumstances are, but circumcised men are the significant minority anyway. If anyone was to be teased in a normal setting about this issue, it would be the circumcised guy.

Just leave your son's body alone. And defend your son against silliness like that, come on.
 
1. Regarding argument one, is there anyone here who can attest that it is a real pain to keep an uncircumcised baby clean? Is there any uncut man here who can attest that it's problematic or difficult to keep self clean?
As a mother of three sons (and one daughter), I had no trouble keeping the boys' penises clean, nor in teaching them to wash thoroughly as soon as they were old enough.
I have not researched this.
3. This is the toughest argument to evaluate for me (being a woman.) Is there anyone here who is uncut who was made fun of or made to feel other than normal as a child? Was anyone singled out in the locker room for having a foreskin? Or were any of you on the other side of the room, making fun of the uncut kid? I hear a lot of people saying uncut kids get made fun of and made to feel "not normal" -- but can anyone state from personal experience that they either felt this way, or made another child feel this way?
Kids will sometimes tease other kids for anything and nothing. I have to say that this as an argument pro-circumcision makes me feel very uncomfortable, the idea that a parent should permanently change a child's appearance with no medical reason, to prevent some hypothetical teasing. That said, the chance of teasing - if such things do arise in locker rooms in the USA (it was not my sons' experiences in the UK), would depend on the number of boys who are circumcised vs the number who are not. This page suggests that in 2009 32.5% of infant boys in the US were circumcised - so the majority of boys born after 2009 will be intact. It would therefore be more likely to be the circumcised boys who end up being teased for being different.
 
one of the main justifications being made for surgery on babies with a cleft-pallate/lip & on baby-girls with an enlarged clitoris, was the social isolation & stigma the child might feel..due to their condition.

if that is considered a legitimate reason for surgery for these conditions, then circumcision for purely cultural/religious reasons is also legitimate.
 
Last edited:
one of the main justifications being made for surgery on babies with a cleft-pallate/lip & on baby-girls with an enlarged clitoris, was the social isolation & stigma the child might feel..due to their condition.

if that is considered a legitimate reason for surgery for these conditions, then circumcision for purely cultural/religious reasons is also legitimate.
It may well once have been a justification. I don't believe it is a justification now, particularly as fewer and fewer babies are circumcised and society is more used to the normal and natural variation of the human form.

Cleft lip and palate surgery isn't done purely for cosmetic reasons, babies with cl&p have problems with feeding, breathing and learning to speak; it is also not an alteration of the normal, it is a repair of a birth defect.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom