Apologies for not reading all 40+ pages of this thread, but am I correct in saying the arguments FOR circumcision are as follows:
1. It's cleaner -- Promotes/allows for better hygiene.
2. It can help prevent STDs, UTIs and penile cancer.
3. It makes boys feel more like a member of the group and less like an outsider.
Does that pretty much cover it? I'm not addressing the religious reasons or the idea of parent's rights. I'm just looking at it from the point of view of a soon-to-be mom who has to decide if she wants her son circumcised.
From that viewpoint, may I ask the following of the 3 arguments:
1. Regarding argument one, is there anyone here who can attest that it is a real pain to keep an uncircumcised baby clean? Is there any uncut man here who can attest that it's problematic or difficult to keep self clean?
2. Is there any evidence that circumcision IN THE USA has reduced rates of STDs? Don't we pretty much encourage cut and uncut men to wear condoms? I'm not sure the data is entirely clear with regard to UTIs and cancer.
3. This is the toughest argument to evaluate for me (being a woman.) Is there anyone here who is uncut who was made fun of or made to feel other than normal as a child? Was anyone singled out in the locker room for having a foreskin? Or were any of you on the other side of the room, making fun of the uncut kid? I hear a lot of people saying uncut kids get made fun of and made to feel "not normal" -- but can anyone state from personal experience that they either felt this way, or made another child feel this way?
I am opposed to the idea, but number 3 is my hubby's sole reason for advocating circumcision, but I wonder if this idea that the kid will be made fun of is sort of a legend -- I know when I was a kid, we didn't have to look that closely at another kid to find something to bully or torment them about. If I had some sort of (even anecdotal) evidence that kids were really suffering from psychological damage by being uncut, I would reconsider arguing with him about this.