Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Yes, I fully agree.

Condoms, like circumcision, reduces the chances of STD infection & transmission. Neither is a perfect solution.

Circumcision isn't a "solution" at all! It's basically a happy coincidence that the mutilation that societies have done to their children for thousands of years happens to reduce the need for extra hygiene and care in that sensitive area. That's still no reason to continue doing it and you arguing it is makes it sound like you really, really have nothing better.

Thunder, man, you're really bad at this. You've been going in circles the entire time and constantly crying religious persecution when we all know very well that's not what it's about.
 
And still, let's say it offered pretty good protection, men who aren't circumcised can CHOOSE to get it when they become sexually active.

again, this logic suggests that a child with a cleft-pallet or an enlarge clitoris, should not be operated on until they are of the legal age to consent to such medical procedures.
 
Originally Posted by Thunder
contracting STDs. foreskins are marvelous for that.

http://health.usnews.com/health-news...s-against-stds

In a study of more than 5,000 uncircumcised adult Ugandan males, researchers found that after circumcision, the rates of infection with the virus that causes herpes went down by 28 percent, and the transmission of human papillomavirus (HPV) -- the virus that can cause cervical cancer and genital warts -- was reduced by 35 percent

In a previous study, the same researchers found that circumcision reduced infection with the HIV virus by 60 percent. Two other research groups -- one working in Kenya and the other in South Africa -- have also had similar findings.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/35407224...s-risk-africa/

Kim Dickson, an AIDS expert at the World Health Organization, said mass circumcision could prevent about 4 million adult HIV infections between 2009 and 2025.

http://bodywart.com/hpv-news/hpv-str...-the-foreskin/

An Australian cohort study reveals that in close to one third of the cases, the participants’ foreskin contained HPV strains, which cause 70 percent of the cervical cancer cases. The results of the study were announced at the meeting of the American Urological Association last Tuesday. The research is in its preliminary stage and has not been published in a peer-reviewed journal yet.

This research gives new evidence that circumcision is beneficial. It has already been established that circumcision helps reduce the risk of developing penile cancer, which is not a common condition. In a previous research study, the team has established that circumcision reduces the risk of infection with HPV.

http://www.thebody.com/content/art23101.html

According to a study in this week's New England Journal of Medicine (No. 346; Vol. 15), women whose sex partners are circumcised may be less likely to get cervical cancer. The study found that men with intact foreskins were three times more likely than circumcised men to be infected with human papillomavirus. That, in turn, may increase the risk of passing the virus on to their sex partners.

The theory is that the foreskin's inner lining is especially vulnerable to the virus. This also raises questions about whether circumcision can reduce the spread of HIV. Studies dating back to at least 1988 have suggested that circumcision offers some protection against AIDS, but the research does not prove it, and more definitive studies are underway.
 
again, this logic suggests that a child with a cleft-pallet or an enlarge clitoris, should not be operated on until they are of the legal age to consent to such medical procedures.

Palate. Pallet is something you can find in a warehouse.

Cleft lip / cleft palate can have effects on a persons social life and acceptance in a society - an enlarged clitoris may cause a little girl to become uncomfortable (or the opposite). These things impact their day to day life. Surgery, while not life threatening, is done for the betterment of the individual.

Implying that circumcision is akin to the two examples you listed is laughable. The STD argument is silly, since newborns are not sexually active. Even when they are of an age that they may become sexually active, better parenting (and proper hygiene / sexual education) will prevent STDs more assuredly than your barbaric practice.
 
again, this logic suggests that a child with a cleft-pallet or an enlarge clitoris, should not be operated on until they are of the legal age to consent to such medical procedures.

Bull. My cousin's daughter was born with a cleft palate and, besides being a disturbing thing to look at, would have had a significant impact on the child's life. I have no opinion on an enlarged clitoris.

Circumcision is a completely unnecessary, irreversible, cosmetic surgery.
 
Bull. My cousin's daughter was born with a cleft palate and, besides being a disturbing thing to look at,

I consider foreskin to be a disturbing thing to look at. By your logic, I therefore have the right to remove it from my infant son.

I have no opinion on an enlarged clitoris.

translation: I support this surgery on baby girls, but refuse to admit this as it would annihilate much of my argument.

Circumcision is a completely unnecessary, irreversible, cosmetic surgery.

in many cases, surgery on a cleft-palate is also for purely cosmetic reasons.

I guess we are now in agreement, even though you won't admit to it.

at least...not today.

;)
 
Cleft lip / cleft palate
penile foreskin can have effects on a persons social life and acceptance in a society - a enlarged clitoris penis with foreskin may cause a little girl boy to become uncomfortable. These things impact their day to day life. Surgery, while not life threatening, is done for the betterment of the individual.

ftfy for proper pespective.

no need to thank me :)


thanks guys, for helping me win this argument.
 
Last edited:
ftfy for proper pespective.

No, that is not a 'proper' perspective.

The idea that a physical deformity will have an adverse effect on an individual's social life (as in, how the world interacts with him) is not at all comparable to circumcision, or having foreskin.

If the foreskin were to physically make the child uncomfortable and cause problems, I would argue that it should be removed. If it doesn't, there is no reason to. Much like the cleft palate, if it is a physical deformity (IE not normal and potentially socially damaging/harmful to the individual) it should be corrected with surgery if possible.
 
Last edited:
Condoms, like circumcision, reduces the chances of STD infection & transmission.

The evidence is by no means clear that this is even true. Does it not worry you in the slightest that you're ignoring any studies - like, for example, the ones in post #1647 from Darat - that contradict your chosen conclusion, and only paying any attention to the ones that confirm it? That you've decided to act exactly like the 9/11 truthers you seem to despise so much?

Dave
 
No, that is not a 'proper' perspective.

The idea that a physical deformity will have an adverse effect on an individual's social life (as in, how the world interacts with him)

living amoung only Jews or Muslims, a boy with an uncircumcised penis will appear "deformed" and "unusual". This may have a large effect on his social life and emotional state.

1/4 of the planet Earth...is Jewish or Muslim. That's quite a large society to NOT fit in with.
 
The evidence is by no means clear that this is even true.

I have provided evidence that suggests this is indeed true. I am quite confident a lot more exists.

Does it not worry you in the slightest that you're ignoring any studies - like, for example, the ones in post #1647 from Darat - that contradict your chosen conclusion,

I shall look at Darat's links tonight.

That you've decided to act exactly like the 9/11 truthers you seem to despise so much?

oh, that's clever. now you're suggesting my reasoning is NO better than that of a 9-11 Truther, who believes in insane ideas, nutcase logic, pseudo-science, and demagoguery.

nice job there. I guess you just got bored of sticking to the subject matter? what's coming up next...accusing me of thinking like a Holocaust Denier?
 
living amoung only Jews or Muslims, a boy with an uncircumcised penis will appear "deformed" and "unusual". This may have a large effect on his social life and emotional state.

1/4 of the planet Earth...is Jewish or Muslim. That's quite a large society to NOT fit in with.

So would the females in Africa have trouble fitting in amongst the families that would sew her vagina shut or saw off her clitoris, if she chose to not go through with it. Are you advocating that a female girl go through with this mutilation in order to 'fit in'?

I of course was not trying to make that sort of social argument. I was suggesting those individual with physical deformities would have trouble being accepted by a society and should perhaps consider (by their parents even) to have surgery in order that this deformity be corrected so that they may develop as you or I would in our world.

And I could care less what Jews or Muslims think about their children. If they wish to take a knife to a newborn infant because of a covenant they made with god, I have a problem with it.

That you seem to be ignorant of the barbarism practiced by your scared cows does not make an argument.
 
oh, that's clever. now you're suggesting my reasoning is NO better than that of a 9-11 Truther, who believes in insane ideas, nutcase logic, pseudo-science, and demagoguery.

Yes, that's exactly what I'm suggesting. You've started from the conclusion that circumcision is acceptable, and worked backwards to the evidence that you want to believe.

what's coming up next...accusing me of thinking like a Holocaust Denier?

Unlikely. "Thinking like a Holocaust denier" is an oxymoron.

Dave
 
I was suggesting those individual with physical deformities would have trouble being accepted by a society and should perhaps consider (by their parents even) to have surgery in order that this deformity be corrected so that they may develop as you or I would in our world.

Jews and Muslims might consider an uncircumcised penis to be "deformed"..in need of "correction". Such procedure might be considered important to help the child feel "accepted".

That you seem to be ignorant of the barbarism practiced by your scared cows does not make an argument.

oh look, more hyperbole. next you'll call all Jewish parents "child abusers" and "evil".
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom