Ban circumcision in San Fran???

So I guess this means there is NO evidence that female circumcision makes the body less vulnerable to STD infection & transmission. I'm glad we finally cleared that up.

Closing your eyes does not make the evidence disappear.

Which of my premises do you disagree with? Is my logic in error?

EDIT:
So you're saying that the following premise is unjustified?

If one finds sex less desirable, then one is less likely to have sex.
 
Last edited:
Whether or not female circumcision leads to LESS sex, is NOT the issue.
Sex is part of the issue of STDs! It's right there in the name.

Now, what evidence do you possess that female circumcision reduces the risk of infection and transmission by STDs, not due to a possible reduction in sexual activity, but due to the removal of highly infectable skin/organs and organs/skin that is great at transmitting infection?
I never said that. Please stop strawmanning, it makes you look dishonest.
 
Uncircumcised Male 1 has sex 100 times a year. His STD infection and transmission rate is X. Male 1 is circumcised, and the next year he has sex 100 times. The evidence suggests that his chances of getting an STD infection and transmitting such infection, is decreased significantly.

Uncircumcised Female 2 has sex 100 times a year. Her STD infection and transmission rate is Y. Female 2 is circumcised, and the next year she has sex 100 times. As of yet, no evidence has been provided that her chances of getting an STD infection and transmitting such infection, is decreased in any way.

Does ANYONE have any evidence that if Female 2 has sex 100 times in a year after being circumcised, her chances of STD infection & transmission are reduced from before she was circumcised and had sex 100 times in a year?

come on guys, you can answer this.

I know you can do it.
 
Unlike the religion, the circumcision is done forever to the child. He won't be able to change it. Therefore, it counts as a bodily harm that must be banned. If a man chooses to be cirsumcised, he is free to do that when he reaches the legally adult age.
 
So you're saying that the following premise is unjustified?

If one finds sex less desirable, then one is less likely to have sex.
 
Unlike the religion, the circumcision is done forever to the child. He won't be able to change it. Therefore, it counts as a bodily harm that must be banned. If a man chooses to be cirsumcised, he is free to do that when he reaches the legally adult age.

again, this suggests that you believe parents should NOT have the right to pierce their child's ears, give them braces for aesthetic purposes, or withold desert, until the child reaches legally adult age.

you're basically saying that parents should no longer have the right to raise their children. The Kommisars should do it for them.
 
Last edited:
So you're saying that the following premise is unjustified?

If one finds sex less desirable, then one is less likely to have sex.

what evidence do you have that the STD infection & transmission rates for a circumcised woman, who has sex 100 times a year, are less than those of an uncircumcised woman, who has sex 100 times a year?

got no answer? thought not.

your refusal to answer my very clear question, is VERY telling.
 
what evidence do you have that the STD infection & transmission rates for a circumcised woman, who has sex 100 times a year, are less than those of an uncircumcised woman, who has sex 100 times a year?

got no answer? thought not.

your refusal to answer my very clear question, is VERY telling.
Your dedication to assailing that strawman instead of addressing what people actually say is very telling.
 
Thunder, I think this conversation would be a lot more productive if you went into your control panel and took the truth off of ignore.

I agree that people who have sex in equal proportions will, all other things being equal, be equally likely to contract an STD. But that has nothing to do with my argument. My argument proposes that if they had unequal levels of sexual contact, then those who have sex less often are less likely to be infected. Now, does circumcision in females make sex less likely? Yes, it does.

This shouldn't be hard for you to figure out. This was all in the argument, the very one which I have repeatedly asked you to respond to, and you have repeatedly ignored.
 
Your dedication to assailing that strawman instead of addressing what people actually say is very telling.

I have been consistently arguing that the studies and reports show a reduction in STD infection & transmission rates for circumcised men as compared to uncircumcised men, due to the loss of highly infectable skin/organs.

Whether or not circumcision MAY reduce sexual activity, is really not my concern.

Now, are you going to answer my question or not?

Does female circumcision reduce the rates of STD infection & transmission, if the level of sexual activity remains unchanged?
 
Chopping of additional parts of the penis would probably help in preventing STD's even moreso.
 
Whether or not circumcision MAY reduce sexual activity, is really not my concern.
If you care about STDs, which you allegedly do, then you SHOULD care about the amount of sexual activity!

Now, are you going to answer my question or not?

Does female circumcision reduce the rates of STD infection & transmission, if the level of sexual activity remains unchanged?
I never suggested that it would, I don't know why you keep bringing it up in lieu of addressing actual things that actual people actually said.

"Does becoming a vegetarian reduce the amount of meat you eat if you continue to eat the same amount of meat?"
 
Last edited:
Chopping of additional parts of the penis would probably help in preventing STD's even moreso.

yes, removing the entire penis will likely lead to an STD infection & transmission rate of ZERO.

thank you.

;)
 
I never suggested that it would,

thank you.

now, as to your point, I understand that making sex painful is likely to reduce the frequency of sex.

and the less you have sex, the less likely you are to get infected & spread such infection.

but if a woman IS circumcised, but she does NOT reduce her sexual activity, there is no evidence as of yet that she is any less likely to get infected by STDs and transmit STDs.

we can assume all we like that painful sex means less frequent sex, but that's just an unproven assumption.

but the FACT is....if an uncircumcised woman who has sex 100 times a year, has an STD infection & transmission rate of 10%....is circumcised and now only has sex 30 times a year, her STD infection & transmission rates for each individual act of sex, STAYS THE SAME.....

....unless you have evidence to the contrary.

rates of infection & transmission are the same whether you have sex 1,000 times a year..or 100 times a year.
 
Last edited:
ok, the fact is that there is no evidence that female circumcision alters the body in a way that reduces the chances of STD infection & transmission.

now that we have established this, I shall move on to other things.

later gators.
 
ok, the fact is that there is no evidence that female circumcision alters the body in a way that reduces the chances of STD infection & transmission.
Are you just going to ignore the fact that the premise necessary for this conclusion (women who don't like sex will have exactly as much sex as women who do like sex) is a really dumb premise that you shouldn't hold unless you want to reach a dumb conclusion?
now that we have established this, I shall move on to other things.

later gators.
Maybe you can address the fact that you claim to be in favor of allowing circumcision because adults should be allowed to make choices about bodies, but ignore the fact that circumcising a child robs an adult of his ability to make choices about his body.
 
Last edited:
yes, removing the entire penis will likely lead to an STD infection & transmission rate of ZERO.

thank you.

;)
But if he continues to have exactly as much sex with his nonexistent penis, he will still have the same chance of getting STDs!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom