Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Progress!
yes, it is my view that parents should be allowed to raise their children as they see fit, as long they do the children no serious physical or emotional harm. this is my view..and I am entitled to it.
Now we agree that parents should not be allowed to raise children however they want. :)
lol!!!!!!!!!!!!!

:D:p
Now we agree that it is very silly to presume that people who undergo procedures designed to reduce the amount of sex they have would not actually reduce the amount of sex that they have. :)

And still, let's say it offered pretty good protection, men who aren't circumcised can CHOOSE to get it when they become sexually active.
Contrary to his rhetoric about free choice, Thunder actually does not believe that adults should be allowed to choose whether or not they should be circumcised.
 
Jews and Muslims might consider an uncircumcised penis to be "deformed".

Some groups may consider a vagina that still has its clitoris, or one that isn't sewn shut to be deformed. What do you think they should do?

oh look, more hyperbole. next you'll call all Jewish parents "child abusers" and "evil".

It's not at all an exaggeration. I think circumcision is barbaric.
 
Contrary to his rhetoric about free choice, Thunder actually does not believe that adults should be allowed to choose whether or not they should be circumcised.

8-day old babies are not adults.

I believe there are many medical and other procedures that children should NOT be allowed to decide for themselves to do.

if a 7 year old boy wants to put a 1-inch diameter hole in his ear lobe or lower-lip, I do not believe his choice should over-ride the decision of his parents.
 
we are all entitled to our own opinions. I see it as just some skin removed.
...said the shaman about FGM.
8-day old babies are not adults.
ADULTS are adults. When a child is circumcised, he is robbed of his choice when he becomes an adult. Why do you want to rob adults of their freedom to make choices about their own circumcision?
 
ADULTS are adults. When a child is circumcised, he is robbed of his choice when he becomes an adult. Why do you want to rob adults of their freedom to make choices about their own circumcision?

why do you want to ROB parents of their parental rights?

why do you want to give the government the final say on how YOUR children are raised?

why do you hate freedom?
 
Palate. Pallet is something you can find in a warehouse.

Cleft lip / cleft palate can have effects on a persons social life and acceptance in a society

I would also add that a cleft lip/palate is actually a birth defect while the foreskin is not. Being born without a foreskin, aposthia, is also a birth defect. So in a sense, circumcision is imposing a birth defect that didn't occur. It would be like splitting the lip of a child who was not born with a cleft lip. :eek:
 
I know very well what logic is and know very well when a statement is totally lacking in any.

Excellent. Let's try two things.
First, a statement. Explain whether or not it involves logic.
Circumcision should not be performed on babies.
Next a question. Explain whether or not it involves logic.
Why do you think it is acceptable to circumcise babies, when there is no medical reason, rather than wait until they are able to give informed consent?
 
1.8-day old babies are not adults.

2.I believe there are many medical and other procedures that children should NOT be allowed to decide for themselves to do.

3.if a 7 year old boy wants to put a 1-inch diameter hole in his ear lobe or lower-lip, I do not believe his choice should over-ride the decision of his parents.

1. Exactly what has been said again and again. Any medically unnecessary surgery should not be performed on babies. it should be performed on adults able to give informed consent.
2. I agree. Children unable to give informed consent should not make the decision to have any surgery.
3. I agree. He is not able to give informed consent. Equally, the parents should not be able to put holes in his ear lobes or lips.
 
Cleft-pallet surgery: meant to remove a socially-unacceptable physical feature.

circumcision: often done to help a child fit in with his community.

cleft-pallet surgery: always acceptable, regardless of the age of the child.

circumcision: only acceptable when the boy is 18??



enlarged clitorial surgery: meant to remove a possibly embarrasing and emotionally confusing physical feature.

circumcision: meant to comply with a 3,000-year old cultural practise

enlarged clitoral surgery: always acceptable, regardless of the age of the child.

circumcision: only acceptable when the boy is of legal age to consent??
 
Last edited:
Cleft-pallet surgery: meant to remove a socially-unacceptable physical feature.

Actually, cleft-palate can lead to other health problems in the immediate term for the infant, feeding problems for example. So it is by no means entirely for social reasons therapeutic need clearly exists.

circumcision: often done to help a child fit in with his community.

Nearly always done for this reason, rarely is it done for legitimate medical need.

cleft-pallet surgery: always acceptable, regardless of the age of the child.

circumcision: only acceptable when the boy is 18??
Because there is therapeutic need for the former, circumcision may be acceptable if there is a therapeutic need.
 
Actually, cleft-palate can lead to other health problems in the immediate term for the infant,

what percent of cleft-palates lead to other health issues?

are cleft-palates removed before..or AFTER a health issue is created?

how about we put the surgery on hold...until a health issue develops?
 
what percent of cleft-palates lead to other health issues?

are cleft-palates removed before..or AFTER a health issue is created?

how about we put the surgery on hold...until a health issue develops?

Cleft lips/palates aren't removed--they are repaired.

Psychosocial issues
Having a cleft palate/lip does not inevitably lead to a psychosocial problem. Most children who have their clefts repaired early enough are able to have a happy youth and a healthy social life. However, it is important to remember that adolescents with cleft palate/lip are at an elevated risk for developing psychosocial problems especially those relating to self concept, peer relationships, and appearance. It is important for parents to be aware of the psychosocial challenges their adolescents may face and to know where to find professional help if problems arise.
A cleft palate/lip may impact an individual’s self-esteem, social skills, and behavior. There is a large amount of research dedicated to the psychosocial development of individuals with cleft palate. Self-concept may be adversely affected by the presence of a cleft lip and or cleft palate. Research has shown that during the early preschool years (ages 3–5), children with cleft lip and or cleft palate tend to have a self-concept that is similar to their peers without a cleft. However, as they grow older and their social interactions with other children increase, children with clefts tend to report more dissatisfaction with peer relationships and higher levels of social anxiety. Experts conclude that this is probably due to the associated stigma of visible deformities and speech abnormalities, if present. Children who are judged as attractive tend to be perceived as more intelligent, exhibit more positive social behaviors, and are treated more positively than children with cleft lip and or cleft palate.[6] Children with clefts tend to report feelings of anger, sadness, fear, and alienation from their peers. Yet these children were similar to their peers in regard to "how well they liked themselves."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cleft_lip_and_palate
 
Cleft lips/palates aren't removed--they are repaired.

I ask again: what percent of cleft lips/palates lead to physical health problems?

psychological health issues is not the issue, as a man with an uncircumcised penis living in a Jewish or Muslim culture, may too suffer from emotional problems, and a woman with an enlarged clitoris may suffer from emotional issues.
 
Last edited:
I ask again: what percent of cleft lips/palates lead to physical health problems?

Since most deformities that can be repaired are done so as soon as possible, I doubt you can find the numbers you seek. But:

Does a cleft lip or cleft palate cause problems for a child?
Ear disease and dental problems occur frequently, as do problems with proper speech development. Children who suffer from a cleft lip and/or cleft palate may have difficulty eating. To address these issues, a child and family may work with a team of specialists — a pediatrician, a plastic surgeon, dental specialists, an otolaryngologist (ear, nose and throat specialist), a speech-language pathologist and audiologist, a geneticist and a psychologist/social worker.

http://www.operationsmile.org/about_us/who-we-are/cleft-lip-and-cleft-palate.html
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom