Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Ja, because vee and ze Kommisars know vat iz best..fur ze children.

;)

You said parents should be able to raise their children as they see fit. It was pointed out that they in fact should not.
Why is that difficult for you to acknowledge?
 
You said parents should be able to raise their children as they see fit.

yes, it is my view that parents should be allowed to raise their children as they see fit, as long they do the children no serious physical or emotional harm. this is my view..and I am entitled to it.

It was pointed out that they in fact should not.
Why is that difficult for you to acknowledge?

why is it difficult for me to acknowledge someone else's view? I certainly do acknowledge it.

but I also disagree with it.

I do still have the right to disagree with people..right? This is still a free country...right?
 
.

you're basically saying that parents should no longer have the right to raise their children. The Kommisars should do it for them.

You are still repeating this?
No, parents should not have the right to raise their children in any way they see fit.
Your strawmen are enough to feed my horses for the winter (although they prefer hay) Please arrange shipment immediately.
 
I have been consistently arguing that the studies and reports show a reduction in STD infection & transmission rates for circumcised men as compared to uncircumcised men, due to the loss of highly infectable skin/organs.

Have you resiled from the justification that circumcision will allow boys to fit in at school and camp?
That it only makes babies cry for 10 seconds but anaesthetics should be compulsory? (Whatever happened to allowing parents to raise their children as they see fit?)
That it's been done for a few thousand years and therefore is a good thing?

Let's run with the STD argument. Is circumcision a better protection than condoms? Monogamy? Abstinence?
If so, why must it be done to babies who cannot give informed consent? They might want to make a different choice when the time comes.
 
That it's been done for a few thousand years and therefore is a good thing?.

strawman.

Let's run with the STD argument. Is circumcision a better protection than condoms? Monogamy? Abstinence?

many cultures and religions are very against condoms. and are surely against abstinence before marriage.

that said, the least we can do is make their bodies less sensitive to STD infection and transmission.
 
Wikipedia:

...snip...

In addition to the studies which provided information about female-to-male transmission, some studies have addressed other transmission routes. A randomised controlled trial in Uganda found that male circumcision did not reduce male to female transmission of HIV. The authors could not rule out the possibility of higher risk of transmission from men who did not wait for the wound to fully heal before engaging in intercourse.[179] A meta-analysis of data from fifteen observational studies of men who have sex with men found "insufficient evidence that male circumcision protects against HIV infection or other STIs."[180]

...snip...

Two studies have shown that circumcised men report, or were found to have, a higher prevalence of genital warts than uncircumcised men;

...snip...

Studies evaluating the effect of circumcision on the incidence of other sexually transmitted infections have reached conflicting conclusions

...snip...

The evidence is not as clear cut as Thunder would like to believe, plus of course the procedure in the USA is not undertaken to reduce the likelihood of contracting or passing on a STI, so whether it does reduce such risks is in fact a red herring in regards to circumcision in the USA.
 
yes, it is my view that parents should be allowed to raise their children as they see fit, as long they do the children no serious physical or emotional harm. this is my view..and I am entitled to it.



why is it difficult for me to acknowledge someone else's view? I certainly do acknowledge it.

but I also disagree with it.

I do still have the right to disagree with people..right? This is still a free country...right?

The highlighted part was not in the post I was responding to.

You simply said parents should be able to raise their children as they see fit, then threw in your silly communist reference.

The whole point has been about the highlighted bit.
Circumcision without medical reason can cause serious harm or death.
Has a baby ever been harmed, or died, from not having a cicumcision without medical reason?
Has a baby ever been harmed, or died, from having a circumcision without medical reason?
Why do you prefer to circumcise babies when there is no medical reason, rather than let the choice be made by the subject (see, I didn't say victim) when he is able to give informed consent?
 
strawman.



many cultures and religions are very against condoms. and are surely against abstinence before marriage.

that said, the least we can do is make their bodies less sensitive to STD infection and transmission.

You are really impressively dishonest in what you choose to quote.
How about you look again and answer honestly?
 
Why do you prefer to circumcise babies when there is no medical reason, rather than let the choice be made by the subject (see, I didn't say victim) when he is able to give informed consent?

so by this logic, you are also against parents having surgery performed on baby girls to reduce the size of an abnormally large clitoris?

what about performing surgery on a cleft-pallet? should that wait till the kid is of legal age?
 
Last edited:
I have provided evidence that the procedure itself, without any alteration of activity of the male-circumcised party, reduces the chances of STD infection & transmission.

It's amusing because that is a really, really lousy argument in favor of it. It's not protection against STDs, like condoms do (for the most part), it just reduces the chances of it some. I'm not going to go "hey, I know that chick has HIV, but I'm cut so it's all good". That would be stupid.

Heck, at most you're supporting unprotected sex with women who have VD by using that argument.

And still, let's say it offered pretty good protection, men who aren't circumcised can CHOOSE to get it when they become sexually active.
 
so by this logic, you are also against parents having surgery performed on baby girls to reduce the size of abnormally large clitoris?

what about performing surgery on a cleft-pallet? should that wait till the kid is of legal age?

Is your can of herrings empty yet?
And your supply of dishonesty?
Have you shipped my horses' hay yet?
Please respond to what I actually posted, not your version of it.


ETA: my post involved no logic. It was a question.
 
Repeated for Thunder since he is still here, but being very selective about what he responds to:
Have you resiled from the justification that circumcision will allow boys to fit in at school and camp?
That it only makes babies cry for 10 seconds but anaesthetics should be compulsory? (Whatever happened to allowing parents to raise their children as they see fit?)
That it's been done for a few thousand years and therefore is a good thing?

Let's run with the STD argument. Is circumcision a better protection than condoms? Monogamy? Abstinence?
If so, why must it be done to babies who cannot give informed consent? They might want to make a different choice when the time comes.
 
It's amusing because that is a really, really lousy argument in favor of it. It's not protection against STDs, like condoms do (for the most part), it just reduces the chances of it some.

Yes, I fully agree.

Condoms, like circumcision, reduces the chances of STD infection & transmission. Neither is a perfect solution.
 
Repeated for Thunder.

The highlighted part was not in the post I was responding to.

You simply said parents should be able to raise their children as they see fit, then threw in your silly communist reference.

The whole point has been about the highlighted bit.
Circumcision without medical reason can cause serious harm or death.
Has a baby ever been harmed, or died, from not having a cicumcision without medical reason?
Has a baby ever been harmed, or died, from having a circumcision without medical reason?
Why do you prefer to circumcise babies when there is no medical reason, rather than let the choice be made by the subject (see, I didn't say victim) when he is able to give informed consent?
 
It's amusing because that is a really, really lousy argument in favor of it. It's not protection against STDs, like condoms do (for the most part), it just reduces the chances of it some. I'm not going to go "hey, I know that chick has HIV, but I'm cut so it's all good". That would be stupid.

Heck, at most you're supporting unprotected sex with women who have VD by using that argument.

And still, let's say it offered pretty good protection, men who aren't circumcised can CHOOSE to get it when they become sexually active.

May as well leave HIV out of it. Being cut does not, in anyway, protect against HIV.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom