Ban circumcision in San Fran???

what percent of cleft-palates lead to other health issues?

are cleft-palates removed before..or AFTER a health issue is created?

how about we put the surgery on hold...until a health issue develops?

I am not sure but they can lead to difficulty feeding and speech impediments for starts. It depends on how severe it is.
 
Are you really asking me for evidence that I get pleasure from my foreskin?
Nope.
What evidence would you accept for such a claim?
Well, your answer of "pleasure" implies that my lack of a foreskin means that I don't gain as much pleasure. What evidence do you have of that?
All the ways I can think of are absolutely not suitable for this forum!
Then why did you bring it up?
 
Thunder, which of these do you think is a more important:
1) An adult's right to make choices that affect his own body
2) An adult's right to make choices that affect another adult's body
 
Thunder, which of these do you think is a more important:
1) An adult's right to make choices that affect his own body
2) An adult's right to make choices that affect another adult's body

I can try to clarify if you point out any element that is confusing.
 
and what was the basis for THIS claim? you provided none.

You are correct. I did not offer a specific basis for that claim. It was a reprise, coming after a series of dishonest posts on your part.
Now, we really have left the track. Let's get back on it.
Can you answer me this:
why is it a good idea to circumcise a baby where there is no medical reason, instead of leaving him as born until he is able to give informed consent, given that no baby ever was injured or died from not having an unnecessary circumcision, while a small number of babies are injured and die from having unnecessary circumcisions.

This is one of the one or two questions you overlooked.
 
I have asked for evidence many times, and NO ONE has provided any evidence that female circumcision reduces STD infection & transmission rates. All that's been said is that female circumcision leads to painful sex, therefore there will be less STD infection & transmission due to the presumed decrease in sexual activity.

Just on HIV:

This study looking at FGM rates and HIV and found that FGM reduced the risk of contracting HIV, but the author still believes that the practise is wrong.

This study looking at women in Tanzania found that even after accounting for a whole host of factors still found a correlation between a reduction in HIV rates and circumcised women.

Oh and on the decreased sexual activity thing? This study (it's a link to the abstract since I don't know whether you have access to the whole article) found that women who had undergone FGM were more likely to have fewer sexual partners compared to women who hadn't undergone it. The first article I linked to suggests that this might be a factor in why there was a correlation between a lower rate of HIV among women who had undergone FGM.

Uncircumcised Male 1 has sex 100 times a year. His STD infection and transmission rate is X. Male 1 is circumcised, and the next year he has sex 100 times. The evidence suggests that his chances of getting an STD infection and transmitting such infection, is decreased significantly.

Uncircumcised Female 2 has sex 100 times a year. Her STD infection and transmission rate is Y. Female 2 is circumcised, and the next year she has sex 100 times. As of yet, no evidence has been provided that her chances of getting an STD infection and transmitting such infection, is decreased in any way.

Does ANYONE have any evidence that if Female 2 has sex 100 times in a year after being circumcised, her chances of STD infection & transmission are reduced from before she was circumcised and had sex 100 times in a year?

Your hypothetical examples are rather pointless because there are too vague. Since there are many factors that can affect the chance of STD infection you would have to be more precise.
 
Cleft-pallet surgery: meant to remove a socially-unacceptable physical feature.

...snip...

No it isn't and the hint is in the name "cleft palate", not cleft lip; the cleft lip is often the least of the problems associated with the birth defect; a person with a cleft palate may never be able to eat or drink properly or in some cases even breathe properly - never mind how it can effect speech, dentition and so on. The idea of regarding the repair of a cleft palate as a cosmetic procedure is laughable.

From pubmed:

...snip...

Other symptoms include:

Misaligned teeth

Change in nose shape (amount of distortion varies)

Problems that may be present because of a cleft lip or palate are:

Failure to gain weight

Feeding problems

Flow of milk through nasal passages during feeding

Misaligned teeth

Poor growth

Recurrent ear infections

Speech difficulties

...snip...
 
Nope.

Well, your answer of "pleasure" implies that my lack of a foreskin means that I don't gain as much pleasure. What evidence do you have of that?

No it doesn't - the question was what is the use of a foreskin, and one of the functions is pleasure.

Then why did you bring it up?

You were asking for evidence so asking you what kind of evidence will satisfy you that a foreskin gives pleasure is necessary to provide an appropriate answer.
 
i've got to agree wholeheartedly with thunder on this one.

its a parents right, sorry kids.

firstly of all, none of you provide any basis for what you say. you cant just say its wrong you no. you have to actually say the WHY.

let me wrap my head around the logic of the opposition here. so your telling me that a baby, who's all like "gah gah gah" 'n stuff, can't even remember nothing, he has a greater right then a GROWN UP adult, who chooses whats best for the baby? as if the baby knows anything.

a parent reserves a right to chop off part of their kids anatomy! that's why they had the kid in the first place! i say if i'm going to clean someone every day and look after them ever second for years and years and then give them a house, i should be able to chop them whenever i want! and if the baby didn't have trust for the parent he wouldn't have left the womb.

and if the parents want to "brand" the child, they can do that too! so long as he doesnt remember anything and he's just left with the scar. if the baby ever gets lost, they will know which one is theres, now tell me what!

and the jews had the holocaust so thats got to count for something.

u also say something about pleasure? okay, lets talk about pleasure, which is more pleasurable:1, circumsicion, or, 2, Aids. answer me please!

no seriously, i don't know, please answer.
 
I'm glad. I thought I might have been a little heavy handed with the commas. :D
 
again, this suggests that you believe parents should NOT have the right to pierce their child's ears, give them braces for aesthetic purposes, or withold desert, until the child reaches legally adult age.

you're basically saying that parents should no longer have the right to raise their children. The Kommisars should do it for them.
This suggests that you believe parents have the right to castrate the child. It's just their way of raising the kid! :eek:
I have been consistently arguing that the studies and reports show a reduction in STD infection & transmission rates for circumcised men as compared to uncircumcised men, due to the loss of highly infectable skin/organs.
The objects of studies were probably from the places with no water.

Seriously, nowdays to claim that circumcision reduces infections of all kinds is a lame argument, to say the least. Use the contraception and wash your body well in a bath daily, better twice a day.
 
i've got to agree wholeheartedly with thunder on this one.

its a parents right, sorry kids.

firstly of all, none of you provide any basis for what you say. you cant just say its wrong you no. you have to actually say the WHY.

let me wrap my head around the logic of the opposition here. so your telling me that a baby, who's all like "gah gah gah" 'n stuff, can't even remember nothing, he has a greater right then a GROWN UP adult, who chooses whats best for the baby? as if the baby knows anything.

a parent reserves a right to chop off part of their kids anatomy! that's why they had the kid in the first place! i say if i'm going to clean someone every day and look after them ever second for years and years and then give them a house, i should be able to chop them whenever i want! and if the baby didn't have trust for the parent he wouldn't have left the womb.

and if the parents want to "brand" the child, they can do that too! so long as he doesnt remember anything and he's just left with the scar. if the baby ever gets lost, they will know which one is theres, now tell me what!

and the jews had the holocaust so thats got to count for something.

u also say something about pleasure? okay, lets talk about pleasure, which is more pleasurable:1, circumsicion, or, 2, Aids. answer me please!

no seriously, i don't know, please answer.
If I didn't think it might get you a slap on the wrist I'd nominate this.

:D
 
So if unnecessary, non-reversible, cosmetic surgery on infants is ok, does that mean we're going to enter a phase where parents start getting plastic surgery on their newborns?

Does your baby look too frumpy? Our brand new baby face lifts will cheer them, you, and everyone around them right up! Too much "baby fat"? Infant Liposuction is right up your alley!

Why stop there? What if a father wants to get breast implants for his daughter?

After all, a large part of our society certainly does value women with large breasts. And I seem to recall there are studies showing that breast implants significantly reduce the chances of a woman developing breast cancer. And a flat chested girl might be kinda freaked out at seeing her well endowed mother and want to be like her, surely. Hell, they're even something she could have removed in later life if she wanted, so it's more defendable than circumcision if anything.

So presumably the circumcision advocates would be in favour of this. Or at the very least, they would be able to give a reason why they were not.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom