Ban circumcision in San Fran???

what I meant to say is: parents do all sorts of things to their children that you might consider offensive, obnoxious, evil, idiotic, and even abusive.

You are viewing this in an entirely black and white way. Life is full of nuance. The trick to this discussion is finding a reasonable way to determine which acts should be legal and which shouldn't. I think legality of a parent's act should be based on a number of factors. Just some factors that pop into my head:

1) How does the act help the child?
2) How does the act harm the child?
3) Is the act risky?
4) Is the act easily reversible?
5) Would a reasonable adult choose to perform this act on themselves?
6) How important is it that we perform the act while the child is still young rather than letting them grow up first? (ie vaccines should be administered at a early age)
7) Is the benefit derived from the act practical and objective or arbitrary and subjective?

Balancing these factors, I think that circumcision is a pointless, risky, irreversible act that most adults would not choose for themselves if they had the option. As such, it shouldn't be allowed.
 
Hmmm, one of the following is not the same as the others...

spanking is not illegal.

withholding desert is not illegal.

ear piercings are not illegal.

braces for purely aesthestic reasons is not illegal.

putting your child on a diet cause you believe he/she is fat, is not illegal.

giving a 13 year old child wine as part of his first Communion, is not illegal.

and circumcising a new-born baby boy, is not illegal.

Which could it be?

Lets take a look at this:

but the fact is, our society respects the rights of parents to raise their children as they see fit, as long as they are not causing any substantial emotional or physical harm.

Here, I will focus on the key part:

physical harm.

I await your epiphany.
 
The levels that reduce the woman's sexual pleasure. Less pleasure --> less sex --> reduced risk of STDs and unplanned pregnancies.

oh, so you have no actual evidence that suggests that female circumcision reduces the chances of STD infection and/or transmission?

I thought not. thanks for playing.
 
4) Is the act easily reversible?
This is important! If parents give their kid a dumb haircut or make him eat all my vegetables, he can reverse those things when he hits 18. By circumcising a child, you are robbing an adult of his ability to make choices about his own body. I thought circumcision supporters wanted adults to be able to make choices? Guess not.
 
oh, so you have no actual evidence that suggests that female circumcision reduces the chances of STD infection and/or transmission?

I thought not. thanks for playing.
If you're not going to address the facts in my post, then don't quote me.
 
They're not?

I'm no expert, but even I can see that a circumcised penis is scarred and unnatural. A normal one is laughable, but I'd go for the latter any time.

Rolfe.

ETA: I did not at any point mean to imply that a circumcised penis was not also laughable, just in case anyone got the wrong idea.

It is strange isn't it that as a society we don't like scars, that we go to great lengths to minimise scarring whenever we can but some folk are willing to permanently scar a baby's genitals for no medical reason, as long as that baby is male of course.
 
Last edited:
So if unnecessary, non-reversible, cosmetic surgery on infants is ok, does that mean we're going to enter a phase where parents start getting plastic surgery on their newborns?

Does your baby look too frumpy? Our brand new baby face lifts will cheer them, you, and everyone around them right up! Too much "baby fat"? Infant Liposuction is right up your alley!
 
oh, so you have no actual evidence that suggests that female circumcision reduces the chances of STD infection and/or transmission?

I thought not. thanks for playing.

You could try actually responding to the argument. Taarkin is illustrating logical necessity. I'll elaborate.

P1. If one is the recipient of female circumcision, then one will find sex less desirable (than the norm).
P2. If one finds sex less desirable, then one is less likely to have sex.
C1. If one is the recipient of female circumcision, then one is less likely to have sex. (hypothetical syllogism, from P1 and P2)
P3. If one is less likely to have sex, then one is less likely to contract an STD.
C2. If one is the recipient of female circumcision, then one is less likely to contract an STD. (hypothetical syllogism, from C1 and P3)

Could you please show me which of the premises you disagree with?
 
You could try actually responding to the argument. Taarkin is illustrating logical necessity. I'll elaborate.

I have provided evidence that the procedure itself, without any alteration of activity of the male-circumcised party, reduces the chances of STD infection & transmission.

What evidence do you have that any of the many level of female circumcision reduces the chances of STD infection and transmission, simply due to the physical alteration?
 
Do you really need a study that shows people do things less when it is less enjoyable than they do when they are more enjoyable. I'm pretty sure you can suss that one out yourself.
 
Do you really need a study that shows people do things less...

Ok, this is the 5th time this has been mentioned.

Whether or not female circumcision leads to LESS sex, is NOT the issue.

I have provided evidence that male cirumcision lowers the risk of infection & transmission of STDs. Not because circumcised men have less sex, but because the circumcision removes foreskin which his highly infectable and great at transmitting same infection.

Now, what evidence do you possess that female circumcision reduces the risk of infection and transmission by STDs, not due to a possible reduction in sexual activity, but due to the removal of highly infectable skin/organs and organs/skin that is great at transmitting infection?
 
Last edited:
What evidence do you have that any of the many level of female circumcision reduces the chances of STD infection and transmission, simply due to the physical alteration?

The very post you quoted illustrates the evidence. Are you trying to say that logical inference is not evidence?

Please respond to the argument. I will remind you again that the conclusion of the argument is that if one is the recipient of female circumcision, then one is less likely to contract an STD. Do you agree with the conclusion? If not, why not?

I have no need for red herrings. Respond to the argument.
 
The very post you quoted illustrates the evidence. Are you trying to say that logical inference is not evidence?

suggesting that female circumcision leads to less STD infection and transmission because it causes sex to be painful, does NOT mean that the physical outcome of female circumcision is less susceptable to STD infection and transmission.

On the contrary, these is a good deal of evidence that the purely anatomical results of male circumcision DOES reduce the chances of STD infection & transmission.

I have asked for evidence many times, and NO ONE has provided any evidence that female circumcision reduces STD infection & transmission rates. All that's been said is that female circumcision leads to painful sex, therefore there will be less STD infection & transmission due to the presumed decrease in sexual activity.

So I guess this means there is NO evidence that female circumcision makes the body less vulnerable to STD infection & transmission. I'm glad we finally cleared that up.
 
I will remind you again that the conclusion of the argument is that if one is the recipient of female circumcision, then one is less likely to contract an STD.

Uncircumcised Male 1 has sex 100 times a year. His STD infection and transmission rate is X. Male 1 is circumcised, and the next year he has sex 100 times. The evidence suggests that his chances of getting an STD infection and transmitting such infection, is decreased significantly.

Uncircumcised Female 2 has sex 100 times a year. Her STD infection and transmission rate is Y. Female 2 is circumcised, and the next year she has sex 100 times. As of yet, no evidence has been provided that her chances of getting an STD infection and transmitting such infection, is decreased in any way.

Does ANYONE have any evidence that if Female 2 has sex 100 times in a year after being circumcised, her chances of STD infection & transmission are reduced from before she was circumcised and had sex 100 times in a year?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom