Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Oh noes! Almost all the men in Europe are honking pox-ridden pestilences!

Has anybody told the European women?

Rolfe.
 
They're not?

I'm no expert, but even I can see that a circumcised penis is scarred and unnatural. A normal one is laughable, but I'd go for the latter any time.

Rolfe.

ETA: I did not at any point mean to imply that a circumcised penis was not also laughable, just in case anyone got the wrong idea.
 
Last edited:
What's odd is that I don't really support a law against circumcision and in a way the last 40 pages have confirmed that it's not workable.

I base my opinions on things like reason, logic, evidence. But reading through this thread it's very clear that there simply are no reasonable logical evidence based arguments for circumcision. Not a one has been presented here. Rather, it's a half baked mixture of strawmen, emotive arguments, and just plain nonsensical ramblings.

But here's the thing. The fact that those in favour of circumcision are clearly deeply emotional rather than rational, means that many of them will simply never be convinced. It's like religion - you can't use logic to argue some people out of their position because it's not held for logical reasons. (Indeed for some it IS religion, obviously.) So all you can do is compel them... but there's just too many. Ultimately society runs on consent... things like police and courts and prisons can only be effective if they are dealing with a relatively small minority, you can't use them against a large fraction of the population. No matter what the moral issues, if a big enough fraction of society says "we're going to do it anyway!" then there's really nothing you can do about it. A lesson many countries are struggling with when it comes to drugs, actually.

One can only hope that increased education and debate will, somehow, gradually change the culture and minimise the circumcision supporters to the point where the practice can be stopped. In the meantime... well it's just tough on the kids, I guess, but such is life.
 
What's odd is that I don't really support a law against circumcision and in a way the last 40 pages have confirmed that it's not workable.

I base my opinions on things like reason, logic, evidence. But reading through this thread it's very clear that there simply are no reasonable logical evidence based arguments for circumcision. Not a one has been presented here. Rather, it's a half baked mixture of strawmen, emotive arguments, and just plain nonsensical ramblings.

But here's the thing. The fact that those in favour of circumcision are clearly deeply emotional rather than rational, means that many of them will simply never be convinced. It's like religion - you can't use logic to argue some people out of their position because it's not held for logical reasons. (Indeed for some it IS religion, obviously.) So all you can do is compel them... but there's just too many. Ultimately society runs on consent... things like police and courts and prisons can only be effective if they are dealing with a relatively small minority, you can't use them against a large fraction of the population. No matter what the moral issues, if a big enough fraction of society says "we're going to do it anyway!" then there's really nothing you can do about it. A lesson many countries are struggling with when it comes to drugs, actually.

One can only hope that increased education and debate will, somehow, gradually change the culture and minimise the circumcision supporters to the point where the practice can be stopped. In the meantime... well it's just tough on the kids, I guess, but such is life.

Well, telling someone that their parents were responsible for having their penis hacked up for no good reason (and that their plans to hack up their kids genitals are also unreasonable)... is going to generate some serious denial!
 
um...so because no man is willing to be circumcised simply to be a guinea pig for a test on sexual-pleasure, that means that circumcision is bad?

I hate needles. They scare me. They hurt. Does that mean needles for a blood-test are bad?


huh...interesting logic there. or something.

No, it means babies should not be circumcised when they are unable to give informed consent.
You persist in lying about what people say.
Is your position really so weak?
 
I'm saying this: I and ALL of my Jewish friends are circumcised. All of us have very pleasurable sex lives. None of us have ever complained about not feeling anything.

Yes, when using a condom, we feel less. When we don't use a condom, we feel more.

But doesn't that go for all men, circumcised or not?

Feels less =/= feels nothing. You're taking the claim that as two circumcised men, condoms render us with little to no sensation and telling us we mean that uncut men have no difference in sensation if they cap it or not.

You do understand that's what you're doing right?
 
They're not?

I'm no expert, but even I can see that a circumcised penis is scarred and unnatural.

I know of more than a few women who find a circumcised penis to be just fine.

...and sometimes, even more than fine. I think this whole concept that a circumcised penis is "flawed", "imperfect", "broken", "ruined", truly is in the eye of the beholder. I do not know of any, nor have I heard any women, refer to a circumcised penis in such a way.

and if THEY'RE satisfied...then I'M satisfied. :)
 
No, it means babies should not be circumcised when they are unable to give informed consent.

parents do ALL SORTS of things to their babies, without his/her consent.

babies are incapable of giving consent, my friend. that doesn't mean we don't raise them and do things to them that we as parents, see fit.
 
Feels less =/= feels nothing. You're taking the claim that as two circumcised men, condoms render us with little to no sensation..

I will say this: if wearing a condom renders you with little to ZERO sensation, then I am very sorry. :(

But I have to tell you that based on EXPERIENCE, it has nothing to do with your circumcision.
 
Santa Monica circumcision ban backer drops ballot effort

Circumcision for boys is a religious rite in Judaism and Islam, a matter of men's health to some, a cultural custom to others. But to "intactivists" it's a form of genital mutilation that should be banned. No exceptions.

The latter was the original argument behind Jena Troutman's push for a ballot measure banning circumcision in Santa Monica, but now that it's been linked to some anti-Semitic commentary in a similar effort in San Francisco, Troutman says she's dropping the proposal.
(...)

"It shouldn't have been about religion in the first place," Troutman told the Jewish Journal. "Ninety-five percent of people aren't doing it for religious reasons, and with everyone from the New York Times to Glenn Beck focusing on the religious issue, it's closing Americans down to the conversation...."

http://content.usatoday.com/communi...11/06/circumcision-ban-jewish-muslim-islam-/1
 
Well, telling someone that their parents were responsible for having their penis hacked up for no good reason (and that their plans to hack up their kids genitals are also unreasonable)... is going to generate some serious denial!


Especially if that someone over-identifies with the religion/culture which delivered no good reason.
 
Santa Monica circumcision ban backer drops ballot effort

good to hear it. hopefully in a few years they will add a law to the ballot requiring anesthesia.
 
parents do ALL SORTS of things to their babies, without his/her consent.

babies are incapable of giving consent, my friend. that doesn't mean we don't raise them and do things to them that we as parents, see fit.

Of course parents do all sorts of things to their children. Some parents even circumcise them where there is no medical reason. Some even kill their children.
Obviously, parents should not be able to raise their children as they see fit.
That is the whole point.
 
Santa Monica circumcision ban backer drops ballot effort

good to hear it. hopefully in a few years they will add a law to the ballot requiring anesthesia.

Why would you want anesthesia, when earlier, in saying the baby stops crying in 10 seconds, you dismissed the pain as inconsequential.
You really ought to get your story straight.
Tell me again why a baby should be circumcised, for no medical reason. Why is it unreasonable to wait until he can give informed consent. He can use anesthesia then.
 
Of course parents do all sorts of things to their children.

what I meant to say is: parents do all sorts of things to their children that you might consider offensive, obnoxious, evil, idiotic, and even abusive.

but the fact is, our society respects the rights of parents to raise their children as they see fit, as long as they are not causing any substantial emotional or physical harm.

spanking is not illegal.

withholding desert is not illegal.

ear piercings are not illegal.

braces for purely aesthestic reasons is not illegal.

putting your child on a diet cause you believe he/she is fat, is not illegal.

giving a 13 year old child wine as part of his first Communion, is not illegal.

and circumcising a new-born baby boy, is not illegal.

at least not yet.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom