Ban circumcision in San Fran???

(from what I read, the number of deaths of babies in the USA due to circumcision is around .01%. That's one-hundreth of a percent.)

And each one of them completely unnecessary and avoidable. Not to mention the infections and accidental severe mutilation. Again, completely unnecessary and avoidable.
 
And each one of them completely unnecessary and avoidable. Not to mention the infections and accidental severe mutilation. Again, completely unnecessary and avoidable.

but there is a great deal of evidence suggesting they are indeed beneficial.

I'm personally willing to accept the risks, in order to receive the benefits.

I am glad my parents had me circumcised.
 
but there is a great deal of evidence suggesting they are indeed beneficial.

I'm personally willing to accept the risks, in order to receive the benefits.

I am glad my parents had me circumcised.

Where is the evidence that a baby will die or get an infection from not being circumcised?
Could you not have made the decision yourself when you were old enough to know it would make you glad?
 
Last edited:
I was simply taking your argument and logic to its extreme and quite ridiculous conclusion.

Something doesn't become a logical conclusion just because you say so. It helps to actually illustrate the logic. Please do so next time.

And on that subject, you might want to read up on the accident fallacyWP.
 
STD's a big health issue for newborns, are they?
So STD infection is a reason for circumcision... but asking if the people who are circumcised tend to suffer from STDs is suddenly a strawman? How does that work, exactly?

yes, reducing the chances of STD infection and transmission is one reason for circumcision.

now, are you ACTUALLY asking me if newborns are sexually active, and if circumcision has been reducing the rate of STD infection & transmission, in baby boys?

:p

I hoped it was a strawman, but now I see it might actually be an insane & absolutely ridiculous question from you.

:D
 
Last edited:
yes, reducing the chances of STD infection and transmission is one reason for circumcision.

now, are you ACTUALLY asking me if newborns are sexually active, and if circumcision has been reducing the rate of STD infection & transmission, in baby boys?

:p
Yes, I actually am. Because, and this seems to have escaped you, if the answer is "no", then that is a completely bogus reason to circumcise newborns.

If STDs are a reason to circumcise, then the reasonable course of action is to talk about this when kids reach the age where they are going to become sexually active, offer them the option, and if they want to indulge in this form of safer sex then they're perfectly free to.

I hoped it was a strawman, but now I see it might actually be an insane & absolutely ridiculous question from you.
Frankly, after reading the last few pages, I don't put a whole lot of stock in your opinion of what makes for a ridiculous question.
 
Then I...am speechless.



oh..and what age is that?

16?

14?

12?

8?

You want 8-year olds deciding to or not to have surgery performed upon them?

huh. :boggled:


Are 8-year olds sexually active? In what country do you live if they are?

By the way, this:

reducing the chances of STD infection and transmission is one reason for circumcision

is a lie isn't it?

The reasons for circumcision are basically moral/puritanical/religious reasons. In particular, as has been pointed out,

Circumcision arrived in America not primarily with Jewish immigrants but as a Victorian British fad, in which the original stated objective was to discourage masturbation and nocturnal emissions.

It may be one of your many, many attempts at a reason for circumcision (although by now you have given about a thousand terrible and easily debunked desparate apologias) but it generally isn't the stated reason for those who support circumcision. Parents and doctors generally do not say, "Quick let's get our baby boy circumcised to reduce his chances of contracting HIV and other STDs!" and no this isn't a "strawman" this is exactly the argument you are making.

Circumcision needn't arise though as most men would be better off using protection than getting circumcised. In fact, if you are preaching circumcision as a sufficient or a practical way of avoiding STDs or HIV then you are preaching utterly irresponsible and dangerous fanatical nonsense.
 
good to know you want the govt. telling parents how to raise their children.

In many cases they already do. The gubmint gets to tell you whether you can let your baby drink alcohol or smoke and the gubmint tells you whether you can get your female baby circumcised. This is the problem with your argument. It fails because even you accept that the gubmint gets to tell parents how to raise their children. You are even a big supporter of the gubmint telling people how to raise their children so you fail. Again.
 
In what world does cutting off a foreskin not meet #1?
This right after you have accused someone else of arguing in bad faith.
It would be honest to say, yes it is mutilation, but minor enough that it is acceptable.
Would you describe amputating an earlobe as a mutilation?

Why does it even matter? We've already got a word that tells us exactly what we're talking about: circumcision. To use another word (or phrase) in it's place can only be for rhetorical purposes. Personally I'd rather just discuss the issue rationally. As long as we all know what we're talking about when we refer to circumcision, what possible reason is there to even debate whether some other word may or may not apply?

Edit: woops, didn't realise I was somewhere far behind on this thread.
 
Last edited:
If STDs are a reason to circumcise, then the reasonable course of action is to talk about this when kids reach the age where they are going to become sexually active, offer them the option, and if they want to indulge in this form of safer sex then they're perfectly free to.

Not necessarily. If the procedure is considerably safer when practiced on newborns than adolescents or teenagers, then it makes sense to do it earlier rather than later.

There's also the issue that people don't always know in advance that they're going to be sexually active.
 
Are 8-year olds sexually active? In what country do you live if they are?

the United States of America.

http://www.sciencecodex.com/children_from_lowincome_families_sexually_active_by_12_years_old

AMES, Iowa -- As a new mother herself, Brenda Lohman admits to being shocked by the results of a new study she co-authored. It found that among nearly 1,000 low-income families in three major cities, one in four children between the ages of 11 and 16 reported having sex, with their first sexual intercourse experience occurring at the average age of 12.

"So if 12 years was the average age here, that meant that some kids were starting at 10 or younger," said Lohman, an Iowa State University associate professor of human development and family studies (HDFS). "A handful of kids reported having sex as early as 8 or 9. We know from our follow-up interviews that one boy who reported having sexual intercourse for the first time at age nine had fathered four children by the time he was 18."



...you REALLY think I would make something like that up??
 
the United States of America.

http://www.sciencecodex.com/children_from_lowincome_families_sexually_active_by_12_years_old

AMES, Iowa -- As a new mother herself, Brenda Lohman admits to being shocked by the results of a new study she co-authored. It found that among nearly 1,000 low-income families in three major cities, one in four children between the ages of 11 and 16 reported having sex, with their first sexual intercourse experience occurring at the average age of 12.

"So if 12 years was the average age here, that meant that some kids were starting at 10 or younger," said Lohman, an Iowa State University associate professor of human development and family studies (HDFS). "A handful of kids reported having sex as early as 8 or 9. We know from our follow-up interviews that one boy who reported having sexual intercourse for the first time at age nine had fathered four children by the time he was 18."



...you REALLY think I would make something like that up??


So your argument is that baby boys should be circumcised to reduce their risk of contracting STDs when they start having sex at the age of 8, 9, 10 or slightly older??????
 
So your argument is that baby boys should be circumcised to reduce their risk of contracting STDs when they start having sex at the age of 8, 9, 10 or slightly older??????

8, 9, and 10 year olds are too immature & intellectually undeveloped to make such decisions for themselves.

that's why such decisions should be left to their parents.
 
Then I...am speechless.
No comment.

oh..and what age is that?

16?

14?

12?

8?

You want 8-year olds deciding to or not to have surgery performed upon them?

huh. :boggled:
So you're okay on the fact that babies don't have sex... but you think it's a big problem for 8 year olds?

Where I live the age of consent is 16. That seems pretty reasonable enough to me... I've known several thousand 16 year olds, and I'd say they're more than capable of deciding whether they want bits cut off themselves or not.

In fact I'd probably be quite okay with 15, or even 14. Again, I've known a great many kids this age (I'm a teacher by trade) and in general they seem pretty capable of making those sorts of decisions.

Or here's a radical thought. How about we graph STD rate against age and see if there's a particular number that jumps out as being a good age to start?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom