Ban circumcision in San Fran???

male circumcision is not done to reduce or remove sexual pleasure for men, let alone make sex painful...as it is one of the main motivators for female circumcision. at least for Muslims & Jews.

I think its an unfair and incorrect comparison.

So the reduction in STD infection and transmission rates is only a valid reason when applied to male circumcision, why am I not surprised?

...snip...

It always amazes me that those that argue for genital mutilation of either sex use the same arguments, yet usually in our society those arguments only have weight when applied to male genital mutilation.






the claim has been made many times, that foreskin-equipped sex has more sensitivity & pleasure than foreskin-lacking sex.

I am fascinated to find out how exactly they came up with such a conclusion.

:D

That may be the case but in this instance "pleasure" was the answer to this question:

Useful for what?

If you disagree with my answer can you tell me how to provide the evidence that would satisfy you however why you need evidence that skin has nerve endings is beyond me.
 
the claim has been made many times, that foreskin-equipped sex has more sensitivity & pleasure than foreskin-lacking sex.

I am fascinated to find out how exactly they came up with such a conclusion.

:D

I've only skimmed this thread, because your arguments are completely circular and fallacious, but a link to a study which demonstrated that circumcising reduces gland sensitivity was produced much earlier in the thread. Unsurprisingly, it didn't look like any of the pro-infant circumcision folk bothered with it. The basic idea, if I recall correctly, was that constant rubbing against underwear numbed the sensitive tip area, which the presence of foreskin would far reduce.

Full disclosure: I was circumcised as a child. Pretty much because that's just what they did/do in the US and, as an aside, all this talk about religious discrimination just sounds like whining. Personally I wish I'd been given the choice instead of it being made for me.
 
Last edited:
male circumcision is not done to reduce or remove sexual pleasure for men, let alone make sex painful...as it is one of the main motivators for female circumcision. at least for Muslims & Jews.

I think its an unfair and incorrect comparison.
If circumcised women find sex less enjoyable, then they will have less sex and therefore reduce the risk of STDs and unwanted pregnancy.
 
yes, I too would like to see this evidence for "increased sensitivity & pleasure".

I have never heard a circumcised person complain about the lack of sensitivity & pleasure from sex.

Hi there, I'm cut and I can barely feel anything with a normal condom on, and I can absolutely tell my sensitivity is considerably reduced from the no-condom state when wearing a feather-light one.

I somehow doubt I have a defective penis.
 
the claim has been made many times, that foreskin-equipped sex has more sensitivity & pleasure than foreskin-lacking sex.

I am fascinated to find out how exactly they came up with such a conclusion.

:D

There is only one way I can think of to study the level of pleasure: Find an uncircumsized man who has had sex numerous times. Circumsize him. Ask him to compare the sensation before and after.

What's that? You can't get volunteers? Maybe that should tell you something.

In any event, pleasure isn't the only concern. All surgery carries risk of permanent injury. For that reason, I would have refused circumcision as a child if I had had the capacity.
 
Last edited:
There is only one way I can think of to study the level of pleasure: Find an uncircumsized man who has had sex numerous times. Circumsize him. Ask him to compare the sensation before and after.

...snip...

A friend of mine was circumcised when he was in his early twenties and according to him it made sex much more pleasurable for him, but that is because he had a medical problem with his foreskin that meant sex was quite painful for him prior to his circumcision (he also had some other complications).
 
Hi there, I'm cut and I can barely feel anything with a normal condom on, and I can absolutely tell my sensitivity is considerably reduced from the no-condom state when wearing a feather-light one.

I somehow doubt I have a defective penis.

Lol.

Actually, now that you mention it, I don't bother with condoms anymore precisely because I cannot feel anything because I'm cut. If I were with a random woman, I'd be awfully tempted to not use one because of that fact. Wouldn't this increase my chances of getting an STD?
 
There is only one way I can think of to study the level of pleasure: Find an uncircumsized man who has had sex numerous times. Circumsize him. Ask him to compare the sensation before and after.

What's that? You can't get volunteers? Maybe that should tell you something.

yes, that tells us that it is IMPOSSIBLE to say that sex with foreskin is significantly more pleasureable than without foreskin. thank you for assissting me with my argument.
 
Actually, now that you mention it, I don't bother with condoms anymore precisely because I cannot feel anything because I'm cut.

prove it. I have sex with condoms all the time and I feel it. I lost my virginity while wearing a condom, and I clearly felt it.

are you also suggesting that sex for uncircumcised men with a condom is NO different than without a condom?
 
Oh shucks, well my grandma always said if you see something God didn't put there, then you can scream. :eye-poppi
 
I find it interesting that some people find a badly scarred and mutilated penis to be 'better looking' than a perfectly healthy looking one,
But the argument, for me, is no longer, why do we need to ban circumcision it is, why is it acceptable for children to be disfigured against their consent?
By definition a *perfect* baby boy has all its skin everywhere. Removing part of the skin *is* by virtue of point 1 making imperfect.

Does this include the tail bone, appendix, third-eye lids, our ear-muscles, are ability to make goose-bumps, etc etc? These are all part of the "perfect" human being?

and without these body parts, a child is now "imperfect" or "disfigured"? huh.
 
Last edited:
Does this include the tail bone, appendix, third-eye lids, our ear-muscles, are ability to make goose-bumps, etc etc? These are all part of the "perfect human being"?

and without these body parts, a child is now "imperfect"? huh.

You get back to us when we evolve a lack of foreskin, k?
 
You get back to us when we evolve a lack of foreskin, k?

I'd just like to know how it is that we are all born soooo "perfect", even though we have these utterly and completely useless skin (earlobe), organs (appendix) and bones (tailbone).

that's some perfection.


...not only that, but often these "perfect" useless additions to our bodies often cause us great harm and even sometimes kill us.
 
Last edited:
I'd just like to know how it is that we are all born soooo "perfect", even though we have these utterly and completely useless skin (earlobe), organs (appendix) and bones (tailbone).

that's some perfection.

It's called evolution. I'm sure there are some threads in the science section that can explain it. And I think you're confusing vestigial with useless - a lot of creationists do that. Either way, the foreskin isn't useless; it has a use in protecting the sensitive glands of the penis.

A new born is about as perfect a human as it's ever going to be - it is what it's genes made it. Once you start cutting it up it becomes less "perfect".

Why are you ashamed of your body?[/hyperbole]
 
It's called evolution. I'm sure there are some threads in the science section that can explain it. And I think you're confusing vestigial with useless -

really? what purpose does the tailbone, earlobe, and appendix serve? (other than getting infected and possibly killing you)

A new born is about as perfect a human as it's ever going to be..

Like I said, a perfect being is not born with useless organs, bones, and skin.

Clearly, human beings and probably most other mammals are born somewhat "imperfect".

The argument that a baby born with foreskin is perfect, and having his foreskin removed makes him imperfect, is silly. And ignores human anatomy & biology.
 
defeat acknowledged. surrender accepted.

Absolutely. I admit that your position is impossible to understand and I surrender in my attempt to understand it.

Regarding circumcision, however, I'm glad that we agree that you can't defend it coherently. I assume you now agree people should oppose it.
 
...not only that, but often these "perfect" useless additions to our bodies often cause us great harm and even sometimes kill us.

And so we cut off routinely a useless addition which does not ever cause great harm or kill us: in fact the cutting off is what sometimes causes great harm or even kills.
Your arguments are increasing desperate, and own-goals.
Tell me again why it is a good idea to circumcise a new born , without any medical reason, rather than allowing an adult to give informed consent.
 
Last edited:
And so we cut off routinely a useless addition which does not ever cause great harm or kill us: in fact the cutting off is what sometimes causes great harm or even kills.
Your arguments are increasing desperate, and own-goals.
Tell me again why it is a good idea to circumcise a new born , without any medical reason, rather than allowing an adult to give informed consent.

so it should be ILLEGAL to do ANYTHING to a child's body, unless it is a medical neccessity?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom