Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Why are Jews so obsessed with foreskins, anyway?

yes, we think about them, talk about them, dream about them every day.

thanks for adding your at the very least insensitive, and at the very most...anti-Semitic remark to the already poisoned well of discourse.

first the Model comic and now this. boy, what a weekend.
 
Last edited:
Why are Jews so obsessed with foreskins, anyway?

At a guess, it's part of the reproductive control that many religions feature. If you circumcise and those around you don't, it makes it pretty easy to keep to an "us and them" mentality, especially when it comes to making babies.

But I'm just guessing. There are aspects of religious motivation that baffle me.
 
Hopefully this isn't off topic --

for those of you opposed to circumcision, what do you do when you find out that friends or family plan on circumcising their newborn if its a boy?

Do you try to talk them out of it, or do you keep your opinion to yourself? Just curious.
 
Hopefully this isn't off topic --

for those of you opposed to circumcision, what do you do when you find out that friends or family plan on circumcising their newborn if its a boy?

Do you try to talk them out of it, or do you keep your opinion to yourself? Just curious.
I would express my opposition. Why should I keep my opinion to myself , especially when they clearly don't?
 
It's been pointed out to me that my own 'penis issues' might bias me too heavily and I'll thus be bowing out of this thread. However, I do want to expand and clarify some points.

The line of reasoning that it would be psychologically damaging to a child to notice that his penis is different from his father's is laughably bad. It is just as much an argument against circumcision as it is for it, if true. Besides that, it isn't on the whole true. The human penis has a lot of natural variation to it, and a child might notice that his is different from his father's anyway. This could be damaging to the child, yes, but so can a lot of perfectly normal things and probably isn't especially a problem with being cut/uncut.

The same line of reasoning that circumcision is horrible mutilation means that for men who naturally don't have a lot of foreskin, they are being told they have a messed up penis, as if someone hacked a piece off with a knife. This, to me, is an unacceptable social stance. Some people have a penis longer, shorter, thicker, thinner, yawing, curving, straight, with a large head, with a small head, lots of foreskin, very little foreskin, of the same color as the rest of his skin, or differently shaded. The message as a society we should be sending is that, it's all alright. But that certainly isn't the message being sent. This happens with female genitals as well, and leads to all sorts of insecurities and problems. I see no reason to believe the same doesn't happen to many males, especially with the amount of, 'my penis is better than yours, you should see what my foreskin can do,' mixed into these discussions.

Standards and expectations for these things must be approached cautiously, least more damage than good be done. I'd like to type more, but it goes into TMI land on a bullet train.

So I will no long participate in the debate about banning circumcision and leave with basically the same view I had coming in. Phase it out socially, but governmental action is unneeded.
 
and would u consider them evil if they go through with it despite your opposition?

Of course I would consider that they have done a cruel thing to their child.
How could I not, when that is the reason for my opposition?
 
Useful for what?

Increasing sensitivity, for one thing. I believe it also offers some benefits with regards to sexually transmitted disease avoidance, although I may well be wrong there.

However, if it didn't do anything, I'd suggest that doesn't exactly give anyone the right to just cut it off.
 
Increasing sensitivity, for one thing. I believe it also offers some benefits with regards to sexually transmitted disease avoidance, although I may well be wrong there.

However, if it didn't do anything, I'd suggest that doesn't exactly give anyone the right to just cut it off.

actually, studies in africa showed that circumcised men were less likely to contract aids.
 
you want me to substantiate the hypothetical situation where a boy feels strange that his father has a circumcised penis while he does not?

No, Thunder, I specifically quoted the bit where you said:

having a penis that looks different from one's father, could indeed cause mental health issues.

...and I asked you to substantiate that claim. You then decided to try and weasel out of it by saying that you don't have to substantiate because it is hypothetical (read: made-up).

why don't you go ask your uncircumcised friends if their dads are also cut, and ask them how they felt about this when they were younger.

No need, Thunder old boy. My own father is circumcised and I am not. It never did me no harm and I find your desperate suppositions that such a situation can cause mental trauma to be risible. (Though, now I think of it I understand what my dad meant when he called me a total prick!)

..and as other have already stated, if it circumcisions on minors can be made illegal, will ear-piercings on babies be next?

As has been countered numerous times, most people here don't advocate that either. I say, sure make ear-piercings on babies illegal. I think it's fine to do that.

haircuts for infants?

:bwall

braces for 13 year-olds who don't want them?

Fine.

forcing kids to eat their vegetables?

Parents can and should force their children to eat vegetables, yes.

parents do all sorts of things to their children, that the kids don't want to do. our society has decided that parents have the right to raise their children the way they see fit, to a certain extent. perhaps we should now have the GOVERNMENT make all the decisions instead?

No, best off have Thunder be the arbiter of what parents are allowed to do with their kids.:teacher:
 
Minor FGM does not cause serious physical and psychological harm. Even major FGM can prevent psychological harm because it allows the girl to fit in to her social milieu. She might feel left out if she is not cut.

And in the cultures that use type 3 and 4 FGM a girl who has not been mutilated will probably be unable to marry and be ostracised from her society.

It always amazes me that those that argue for genital mutilation of either sex use the same arguments, yet usually in our society those arguments only have weight when applied to male genital mutilation.
 
Hopefully this isn't off topic --

for those of you opposed to circumcision, what do you do when you find out that friends or family plan on circumcising their newborn if its a boy?

Do you try to talk them out of it, or do you keep your opinion to yourself? Just curious.

Thankfully outside some religious minorities the procedure is very uncommon here in the UK, and only undertaken for medical reasons since it is acknowledged that the operation carries a certain level of risk (http://www.bma.org.uk/ethics/consent_and_capacity/malecircumcision2006.jsp).
 
Useful for what?

contracting STDs. foreskins are marvelous for that.

http://health.usnews.com/health-new...s/2009/03/25/circumcision-guards-against-stds

In a study of more than 5,000 uncircumcised adult Ugandan males, researchers found that after circumcision, the rates of infection with the virus that causes herpes went down by 28 percent, and the transmission of human papillomavirus (HPV) -- the virus that can cause cervical cancer and genital warts -- was reduced by 35 percent

In a previous study, the same researchers found that circumcision reduced infection with the HIV virus by 60 percent. Two other research groups -- one working in Kenya and the other in South Africa -- have also had similar findings.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/35407224/ns/health-aids/t/circumcision-ring-cuts-aids-risk-africa/

Kim Dickson, an AIDS expert at the World Health Organization, said mass circumcision could prevent about 4 million adult HIV infections between 2009 and 2025.

http://bodywart.com/hpv-news/hpv-strains-found-in-the-foreskin/

An Australian cohort study reveals that in close to one third of the cases, the participants’ foreskin contained HPV strains, which cause 70 percent of the cervical cancer cases. The results of the study were announced at the meeting of the American Urological Association last Tuesday. The research is in its preliminary stage and has not been published in a peer-reviewed journal yet.

This research gives new evidence that circumcision is beneficial. It has already been established that circumcision helps reduce the risk of developing penile cancer, which is not a common condition. In a previous research study, the team has established that circumcision reduces the risk of infection with HPV.

http://www.thebody.com/content/art23101.html

According to a study in this week's New England Journal of Medicine (No. 346; Vol. 15), women whose sex partners are circumcised may be less likely to get cervical cancer. The study found that men with intact foreskins were three times more likely than circumcised men to be infected with human papillomavirus. That, in turn, may increase the risk of passing the virus on to their sex partners.

The theory is that the foreskin's inner lining is especially vulnerable to the virus. This also raises questions about whether circumcision can reduce the spread of HIV. Studies dating back to at least 1988 have suggested that circumcision offers some protection against AIDS, but the research does not prove it, and more definitive studies are underway.
 
Last edited:
It always amazes me that those that argue for genital mutilation of either sex use the same arguments, yet usually in our society those arguments only have weight when applied to male genital mutilation.


And the proponents of MGM use the same "arguments" over and over again, regardless of how many times they were corrected. Thunder now acts like the first thirty-something pages of this thread never happened.
 
I suggest we stick to the medical benefits vs. the medical harm caused by circumcision.

The use of words like "mutilation", "evil", "child abuse", and other scare-tactics really doesn't help the debate much.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom