Ban circumcision in San Fran???

the United States of America.

http://www.sciencecodex.com/children_from_lowincome_families_sexually_active_by_12_years_old

AMES, Iowa -- As a new mother herself, Brenda Lohman admits to being shocked by the results of a new study she co-authored. It found that among nearly 1,000 low-income families in three major cities, one in four children between the ages of 11 and 16 reported having sex, with their first sexual intercourse experience occurring at the average age of 12.

"So if 12 years was the average age here, that meant that some kids were starting at 10 or younger," said Lohman, an Iowa State University associate professor of human development and family studies (HDFS). "A handful of kids reported having sex as early as 8 or 9. We know from our follow-up interviews that one boy who reported having sexual intercourse for the first time at age nine had fathered four children by the time he was 18."



...you REALLY think I would make something like that up??

So your evidence is that the most extreme sub-sub-sample reflects your statement?

I notice you did not respond to any of ixolite's presented studies.

I call this work "Confirmation Bias in Motion".
 
Not necessarily. If the procedure is considerably safer when practiced on newborns than adolescents or teenagers, then it makes sense to do it earlier rather than later.
Now that is a good point. I find it hard to think that the procedure is greatly more dangerous on adults than children, but I'm certainly no doctor. Are there studies on the subject that you know of?

There's also the issue that people don't always know in advance that they're going to be sexually active.
No, but we deal with that issue all the time. I've no doubt some 14 year olds are perfectly mature enough to engage in sexual behavior whilst some 25 year olds are not, but we can't judge individual cases so we pick and age and live with the fact that it will throw up anomalies sometimes.

Similarly, if we made 15 the age of decision for circumcision then no doubt it would be too late for some, too early for others. Too bad, it's an imperfect world. But wow, that would still be SO much better than just doing it to everyone and hoping they end up not minding.
 
8, 9, and 10 year olds are too immature & intellectually undeveloped to make such decisions for themselves.

that's why such decisions should be left to their parents.

The decision to have sex should be made by the parents? Well, okay, I hope that they tend to say "no". Can the government say whether or not an eight or nine year-old can have sex with Uncle Jamal? Or would you prefer the government leave raising kids to the parents?
 
I notice you did not respond to any of ixolite's presented studies.

you are correct.

I have utterly failed to comment on, let alone read any of his links to a site called "Circumstition.com".

I also failed to read the article about female circumcision, as it is pretty irrelevant to the issue of MALE infant circumcision.

like I said, pass a Federal law making it a crime to have anyone but a licensed & trained person perform circumcisions. even require a local anesthesia to kill the pain. I got NO problem with any of that.

but unlike others here, I'm not gonna read or post articles from clearly heavily-biased ideological websites.

link to an article from a respected medical journal or institution, and I will read it.

link to an article from a mainstream media source, and I will read it.
 
Hmmm....

So in answer to my question about the usefulness of foreskin, we have "increased sensitivity" & "pleasure"...

Evidence?
 
Hmmm....

So in answer to my question about the usefulness of foreskin, we have "increased sensitivity" & "pleasure"...

Evidence?

yes, I too would like to see this evidence for "increased sensitivity & pleasure".

I have never heard a circumcised person complain about the lack of sensitivity & pleasure from sex.

and honestly, how in the world can someone PROVE that sex with foreskin is better than sex without?

has an uncircumcised person actually had the guts to take part in a study where he has sex with 10 woman, 10 times....get circumcised..and then 6 months later have sex with the same 10 women 10 times..and compare his experiences to before he was cut?
 
Last edited:
Nihilianth says you can do anything as long as it has to do with religion

See, that may be your opinion, but if you reside in the United States of America, that opinion is factually wrong. Please refer to the First Amendment to the United States Constitution:

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

According to Nihilianth's logic, it is perfectly legal to murder someone in the United States as long as it is done as part of a religious ritual.

Thank God Nihilianth is not a supreme court justice.
 
has an uncircumcised person actually had the guts to take part in a study where he has sex with 10 woman, 10 times....get circumcised..and then 6 months later have sex with the same 10 women 10 times..and compare his experiences to before he was cut?

Of course no uncircumsized adult would do that... because no adult wants to get their junk cut up. When it comes to defenseless kids though... some adults are fine with the cut.

Monstrous.
 
Then I...am speechless.



oh..and what age is that?

16?

14?

12?

8?

You want 8-year olds deciding to or not to have surgery performed upon them?

huh. :boggled:
As opposed to 8 day olds having it performed without any possibility of consent?
Yes, 8 year olds have a better chance of giving informed consent.
 
yes, reducing the chances of STD infection and transmission is one reason for circumcision.

now, are you ACTUALLY asking me if newborns are sexually active, and if circumcision has been reducing the rate of STD infection & transmission, in baby boys?

:p

I hoped it was a strawman, but now I see it might actually be an insane & absolutely ridiculous question from you.

:D

So I take it you would support female circumcision if research showed it had the same level of reducing STD infection and transmission as it does for male circumcision?
 
Hmmm....

So in answer to my question about the usefulness of foreskin, we have "increased sensitivity" & "pleasure"...

Evidence?
Are you really asking me for evidence that I get pleasure from my foreskin? What evidence would you accept for such a claim? All the ways I can think of are absolutely not suitable for this forum!
 
So I take it you would support female circumcision if research showed it had the same level of reducing STD infection and transmission as it does for male circumcision?

male circumcision is not done to reduce or remove sexual pleasure for men, let alone make sex painful...as it is one of the main motivators for female circumcision. at least for Muslims & Jews.

I think its an unfair and incorrect comparison.
 
Are you really asking me for evidence that I get pleasure from my foreskin? What evidence would you accept for such a claim? All the ways I can think of are absolutely not suitable for this forum!

the claim has been made many times, that foreskin-equipped sex has more sensitivity & pleasure than foreskin-lacking sex.

I am fascinated to find out how exactly they came up with such a conclusion.

:D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom