Ban circumcision in San Fran???

contracting STDs. foreskins are marvelous for that.

http://health.usnews.com/health-new...s/2009/03/25/circumcision-guards-against-stds

In a study of more than 5,000 uncircumcised adult Ugandan males, researchers found that after circumcision, the rates of infection with the virus that causes herpes went down by 28 percent, and the transmission of human papillomavirus (HPV) -- the virus that can cause cervical cancer and genital warts -- was reduced by 35 percent

In a previous study, the same researchers found that circumcision reduced infection with the HIV virus by 60 percent. Two other research groups -- one working in Kenya and the other in South Africa -- have also had similar findings.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/35407224/ns/health-aids/t/circumcision-ring-cuts-aids-risk-africa/

Kim Dickson, an AIDS expert at the World Health Organization, said mass circumcision could prevent about 4 million adult HIV infections between 2009 and 2025.

http://bodywart.com/hpv-news/hpv-strains-found-in-the-foreskin/

An Australian cohort study reveals that in close to one third of the cases, the participants’ foreskin contained HPV strains, which cause 70 percent of the cervical cancer cases. The results of the study were announced at the meeting of the American Urological Association last Tuesday. The research is in its preliminary stage and has not been published in a peer-reviewed journal yet.

This research gives new evidence that circumcision is beneficial. It has already been established that circumcision helps reduce the risk of developing penile cancer, which is not a common condition. In a previous research study, the team has established that circumcision reduces the risk of infection with HPV.

http://www.thebody.com/content/art23101.html

According to a study in this week's New England Journal of Medicine (No. 346; Vol. 15), women whose sex partners are circumcised may be less likely to get cervical cancer. The study found that men with intact foreskins were three times more likely than circumcised men to be infected with human papillomavirus. That, in turn, may increase the risk of passing the virus on to their sex partners.

The theory is that the foreskin's inner lining is especially vulnerable to the virus. This also raises questions about whether circumcision can reduce the spread of HIV. Studies dating back to at least 1988 have suggested that circumcision offers some protection against AIDS, but the research does not prove it, and more definitive studies are underway.

Call me when the same study is done comparing average male american folk uncircumcised and circumcised and using condom. As for HPV , well there is vaccine which do not need mutilation.
 
Call me when the same study is done comparing average male american folk uncircumcised and circumcised and using condom. As for HPV , well there is vaccine which do not need mutilation.


you want to compare circumcised & uncircumcised sex...WITH a condom....to analyse STD transmission? wow, that's total genius.


...and nice use of scare-words. keep poisoning the debate.

maybe I'll start calling any new law to ban religious circumcision "religious persecution" or "Nazism".
 
Regarding MGM and HIV:
http://www.cirp.org/library/disease/HIV/
http://www.circumstitions.com/HIV.html
http://www.circumstitions.com/HIV-SA.html
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2064110/
http://www.healthrights.am/eng/more/501/

FGM does serious physical and psychological harm to the child. This serious harm stays with the woman for the rest of her life.

Got any research on the serious psychological, emotional, and physical harm done to ALL boys/men who are circumcised?

...I um.....yeah I thought now. ;)
Wait, did you just claim that amputating a bodypart is no serious harm? :jaw-dropp

Anyway, here's some stuff regarding MGM:

EFFECT OF NEONATAL CIRCUMCISION ON PAIN RESPONSE
DURING SUBSEQUENT ROUTINE VACCINATION
http://www.cirp.org/library/pain/taddio2/

Circumcision and Pain
http://www.circumstitions.com/Pain.html


Circumcision and Psychological Harm
http://www.norm-uk.org/circumcision_psychological_effects.html

The prepuce:
Specialized mucosa of the penis and its loss to circumcision
http://www.cirp.org/library/anatomy/taylor/


circumcision deaths
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/3069491.stm

A BARBARIC METHOD OF CIRCUMCISION AMONGST SOME OF THE ARAB TRIBES OF YEMEN.
http://www.circumstitions.com/yemen.html


The Foreskin, Circumcision and Sexuality
http://www.circumstitions.com/Sexuality.html



http://www.sexasnatureintendedit.com/

For Man & Mate, Which Sex is Better
-- Cut or Uncut?
http://www.mothersagainstcirc.org/sex-cut-uncut.htm

HOW MALE CIRCUMCISION MAY BE AFFECTING YOUR LOVE LIFE
http://mensightmagazine.com/Articles/Northrup/lovecirc.htm



Cut is a documentary film by Eliyahu Ungar-Sargon which examines the subject of male circumcision from a religious, scientific and ethical perspective. Using cutting-edge research, in addition to interview footage of rabbis, philosophers, and scientists, Cut challenges the viewer to confront their biases by asking difficult questions about this long-standing practice.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bx89xECfHG4
http://www.youtube.com/user/eliungar
http://www.cutthefilm.com/Cut_Website/Home.html


Pics, NSFW:
A Gallery of Circumcisions

baby-boy circumcision is child abuse.



circumcising baby-boys is evil



.....wow....a whole lot of extremism, lies, and hyperbole in the thread tonight.

if circumcising baby boys is evil child abuse, does that make most Jews.......evil child abusers??
...and mohammedans and everyone else who cuts parts of their children of. :mad: All of them evil ***** as far as I am concerned.


Regarding FGM:

What proponents of FGM say:



Statement by African Women Are Free to Choose (AWA-FC), Washington DC, USA

...Though we do not condone the use of violence or intimidation we are also deeply affected by the inflammatory impact of language such as Female Genital Mutilation (FGM). We declare categorically that this language is offensive, demeaning and an assault against our identities as women, our prerogatives to uphold our cultural definitions of womanhood including determining for ourselves what bodily integrity means to us African women from ethnic groups that practice female and male initiation as parallel and mutually constitutive processes in our societies.

We declare that thus far the representation of female circumcision (FC) - its social and ideological meaning in terms of gender and female sexuality and impact, if any, on reproductive health and psychosexual wellbeing has been over the last thirty years dominated by a small but vocal number of African women that make up the Inter-African Committee (IAC) with the enormous backing, if not outright instigation of powerful western feminist organizations and media personalities. Through aggressive use of the media to portray African women as passive and powerless victims of barbaric, patriarchal African societies, their efforts have succeeded in influencing and tainting the objectivity of such institutions as WHO and UNICEF, among other international organizations that have taken the lead role in promulgating anti-FGM policies and legislation worldwide.

Through political pressure from first world countries on whose aid they continue to depend as well as internal political expediency, several African countries have introduced anti-FGM legislation over against the full knowledge, participation and desires of the majority of affected women. This will not happen in Sierra Leone....
source

"Circumcision is cleanliness if used moderately and is useful to women as well as men."

[Mohammed Tantawi, leading Islamic religious scholar, quoted in the Arabic newspaper Asharq Al-Aswat, reported by Miriam Sami, Associated Press Writer in "Cleric Eases Stand on Female Circumcision, Alarming Activists," April 9, 1996]


"There are problems of such tremendous magnitude in our society and in our lives, that it (female circumcision) is not a primary problem to us."

[28 year old Sudanese maternity hospital resident, interview p. 155, Prisoners of Ritual: Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, Hanny Lightfoot-Klein, 1989]


"Our mothers, aunts and sisters have been doing this for years and no one was complaining."

[Dr. Munir Fawzi, Gynecologist at Cairo’s Ain Shams University, Dallas Morning News, 12/25/96]


Many here dispute claims that there is any health risk associated with the age-old operation..."Circumcision has no negative effects as (the government) claims and today, with the progress of medicine, the operation can be done without any danger."

[Khaled al-Sharif, Abnob tribe member, quoted in news report, "Egyptian fundamentalists ignoring female circumcision ban," 6 January 1998, Agence France-Presse]


The ruling bans circumcision unless deemed necessary for a female's health - swelling of the labia or clitoris, for instance. "I'm a university professor and I can decide whether a patient needs to be reduced or not. I will do it for medical reasons," he said with a smile.

[Dr.Munir Fawzi, gynecologist, in news report, "Egypt court bans female mutilation," 7 February 1998, Associated Press]


"God forbid!" Sakina Ibrahim, a 60-year-old village exclaimed in disbelief when she heard of the ban. "This ruling won't work here, it won't be obeyed," she said. ..."It's an evil ruling," interjected Abdel-Maguid Hagar, 36. "It will continue in secret," declared Hamam Mahmoud Ali, 26.

[Egyptian citizens, quoted in news report, "Egypt court bans female mutilation," 7 February 1998, Associated Press]


"How can we leave our daughters uncircumcised? The government can do what it wants and we, too, will do what we want. We will all circumcise our daughters, no matter what the punishments."

[Osman Antar, mayor of Sabee (Egypt), quoted in news report, "Egyptian fundamentalists ignoring female circumcision ban," 6 January 1998, Agence France-Presse]


"I do see a few cases (of emotional disturbance from circumcision), but when you compare their number to that of the number of women that are circumcised, they are very trivial indeed."

[Dr. Yahia Oun Alla, Sudanese psychiatrist, interview, p. 137, Prisoners of Ritual: Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, Hanny Lightfoot-Klein, 1989]


She says that she thinks pharaonic circumcision is a good practice, and feels she has lost nothing by her own circumcision.

[From "Interviews with Women" History #5, p. 253, Prisoners of Ritual: Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, Hanny Lightfoot-Klein, 1989]


She claims there was no pain whatsoever (when she was circumcised without anesthetic at age 6). She says she has had "no problems at all" because of her circumcision, and is very happy about it. She feels that circumcision is a good practice.

[50-year-old Sudanese village housewife. From "Interviews with Women" History #1, p. 247, Prisoners of Ritual: Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, Hanny Lightfoot-Klein, 1989]


According to a government study earlier this year, 97 percent of 14,779 Egyptian women polled had been circumcised…Eighty percent of those circumcised said they were pleased with the results.

[Excerpt from news report "Egyptian Court Allows Female Circumcision," Toronto Globe & Mail, June 25, 1997]


To defend themselves from feelings of inferiority, many women deny that FGM damages their bodies or their sexuality.

[Excerpt from booklet "FGM: A Call for Global Action," p. 37, published by RAINBO, 1995]

"Until recently, it never occurred to me that there was anything strange about women’s circumcision."

[Ahmed, 32-year-old Sudanese veterinarian, interview, p.124, Prisoners of Ritual: Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, Hanny Lightfoot-Klein, 1989]


"They (parents) do not want her to suffer the stigma of being different from other girls. She…comes to accept that what has been done is in her best interest."

[Dr. Hassabo, 40-year-old male psychiatrist, interview, p. 143, Prisoners of Ritual: Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, Hanny Lightfoot-Klein, 1989]


"We are brought up to believe that all sorts of evil things will happen to us if we are not circumcised."

[Eclas, 43-year-old Sudanese biology professor, interview, p. 116, Prisoners of Ritual: Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, Hanny Lightfoot-Klein, 1989]


"Both Islam and medicine agree on its benefits. Uncircumcised girls…are more liable to infections and cancers."

[Dr. Saed Thabet, professor gynecology at Cairo’s Kasr El Aini Teaching Hospital, quoted in "Female Circumcision is Curbed in Egypt," British Medical Journal, August 3, 1996]


"It's our religion. We pray, we do fasting, we do circumcision. For 14 centuries of Islam, our mothers and grandmothers have performed this operation. Those who are not circumcised get AIDS easily."

[Sheik Yusef Badry, in news report "Egyptian Court Allows Female Circumcision," Toronto Globe & Mail, June 25, 1997]


"I did not know anything about the operation at the time, except that it was very simple, and that it was done to all the girls for purposes of cleanliness…"

[Research worker, interview, p.165, Prisoners of Ritual: Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, Hanny Lightfoot-Klein, 1989]


She was one of the first girls to be circumcised in her village, which until then had not practiced circumcision at all. Her mother told her that this was "the new way," and that it would keep her clean and free from disease.

[From "Interviews with Women" History #4, p. 250, Prisoners of Ritual: Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, Hanny Lightfoot-Klein, 1989]


"To the girls here (Sudan) circumcision does not mean taking away part of their bodies. It is a normal occurrence that happens to everyone."

[Dr. Yahia Oun Alla, Sudanese psychiatrist, interview, p. 139, Prisoners of Ritual: Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, Hanny Lightfoot-Klein, 1989]


Question: "Do you ever feel angry when you…realize how you have been deprived?" Answer: "No, because that is the culture here. They do it to everybody." Question: "Do you know other women who feel the way you do?" Answer: "No…they feel they have to follow custom. Even educated people still do it as before."

[Fahtma, U.S.-educated Sudanese mother of four children, interview, p. 134, Prisoners of Ritual: Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, Hanny Lightfoot-Klein, 1989]


She plans to take only half the clitoris (from her daughter). She must have some sort of circumcision, she says, or people will look down on her.

[32-year-old Sudanese practical nurse with 9 years of education in the capital. From "Interviews with Women" History #6, p. 254, Prisoners of Ritual: Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, Hanny Lightfoot-Klein, 1989]


"It is done at such a young age and in no time at all they are well again and go back to playing their games. It doesn’t really sink in, what has been done, and the problems later when you are a woman, seem to have no connection to it."

[Eclas, 43-year-old Sudanese biology professor, interview, p. 118, Prisoners of Ritual: Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, Hanny Lightfoot-Klein, 1989]


"With the older women there is often the element of: ‘If it was done to me, why should it not be done to the young girls?’"

[Dr. Saida, Sudanese physician, interview, p.127, Prisoners of Ritual: Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, Hanny Lightfoot-Klein, 1989]


"One (doctor) said that he talked to every woman who came to him for this purpose (circumcision of their daughter), explaining the consequences and saying that it was unnecessary, but found they insisted upon having it done, so he complies. His justification was that he did it in a hygienic way and lost nothing by it, on the contrary, he gained money. But he overlooked the fact that he is acting unethically…instead of being a model of enlightenment for others; one can only assume that he is simply pursuing his own interests. The negative effect of this is that when we try to convince women that this operation is not necessary, they immediately reply that doctors do it, therefore it must be a good thing."

[Dr. Asma El Dareer, Sudanese physician, interview, p. 99, Prisoners of Ritual: Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, Hanny Lightfoot-Klein, 1989]


She accepts it as everyone else accepts it. "Most African women have still not developed the sensitivity to feel deprived or to see in many cultural practices a violation of their human rights."

[O. Koso-Thomas, quoted, p. 75, Prisoners of Ritual: Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, Hanny Lightfoot-Klein, 1989]


Tens of thousands of women marched in the (Sierra Leone) capital Freetown and various other towns early this year protesting foreign and domestic campaigns against the practice (of female circumcision).

[Excerpt from news report "Sierra Leone Army Chief Backs Female Circumcision," Tribune News, July 2, 1997]
source

Does that sound familiar or what?


A nigerian study says:

Female circumcision does not reduce sexual activity

Circumcised women experience sexual arousal and orgasm as frequently as uncircumcised women, according to a study in Nigeria.

The researchers also found no difference in the frequency of intercourse or age of first sexual experience between the two groups of women. These findings remove key arguments used to defend the practice, they say.

Friday Okonofua and colleagues at the Women's Health and Action Research Centre in Benin City studied 1836 women, 45 per cent of whom had been circumcised.

During the operation, all or part of the clitoris and the labia are removed. Proponents of female circumcision claim it makes virginity at marriage and marital fidelity more likely. Opponents condemn it as dangerous and painful.

The women filled in questionnaires, asking about their sexual history. The results show "female genital cutting cannot be justified by arguments that suggest it reduces sexual activity in women," write the team in BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology.

Two million women

Circumcision is common in Kenya, Ethiopia, Somalia, Nigeria and Sudan. It is often performed using crude, non-sterilised instruments.

Okonofua's team also found that the circumcised women were more likely to have lower abdominal pain, genital ulcers and urinary tract infections.

An estimated two million women and girls undergo genital mutilation every year. But in some regions, it is the women themselves who must be persuaded the practice is undesirable, say local health workers.

Circumcision brings women respect from other members of the community, points out Sudanese women's health rights campaigner Nahid Toubia.

Journal reference: BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology (vol 109, p 1089)
source
This study was obviously tampered with, kind of like certain MGM-HIV studies. :rolleyes:

Though it is apparently true that FGM does not mean no sexual pleasure:

Pleasure and orgasm in women with Female Genital Mutilation/Cutting (FGM/C).

Research Center for Preventing and Curing Complications of FGM/C, Health Promotion of Immigrant Woman - Department of Gynaecology, Obstetrics, Perinatology, Human Reproduction, Florence, Italy. [email protected]

INTRODUCTION: Female genital mutilation/cutting (FGM/C) violates human rights. FGM/C women's sexuality is not well known and often it is neglected by gynecologists, urologists, and sexologists. In mutilated/cut women, some fundamental structures for orgasm have not been excised. AIM: The aim of this report is to describe and analyze the results of four investigations on sexual functioning in different groups of cut women. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Instruments: semistructured interviews and the Female Sexual Function Index (FSFI). METHODS: Sample: 137 adult women affected by different types of FGM/C; 58 young FGM/C ladies living in the West; 57 infibulated women; 15 infibulated women after the operation of defibulation. RESULTS: The group of 137 women, affected by different types of FGM/C, reported orgasm in almost 86%, always 69.23%; 58 mutilated young women reported orgasm in 91.43%, always 8.57%; after defibulation 14 out of 15 infibulated women reported orgasm; the group of 57 infibulated women investigated with the FSFI questionnaire showed significant differences between group of study and an equivalent group of control in desire, arousal, orgasm, and satisfaction with mean scores higher in the group of mutilated women. No significant differences were observed between the two groups in lubrication and pain. CONCLUSION: Embryology, anatomy, and physiology of female erectile organs are neglected in specialist textbooks. In infibulated women, some erectile structures fundamental for orgasm have not been excised. Cultural influence can change the perception of pleasure, as well as social acceptance. Every woman has the right to have sexual health and to feel sexual pleasure for full psychophysical well-being of the person. In accordance with other research, the present study reports that FGM/C women can also have the possibility of reaching an orgasm. Therefore, FGM/C women with sexual dysfunctions can and must be cured; they have the right to have an appropriate sexual therapy.
source

Btw, the clitoris does not only consist of the part showing:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clitoris

P.S. Regarding MGM I can recommend:
http://www.youtube.com/user/freedom0speech
 
Wait, did you just claim that amputating a bodypart is no serious harm? :jaw-dropp

strawman.


...and mohammedans and everyone else who cuts parts of their children of. :mad: All of them evil ***** as far as I am concerned.

Um, first of all, they are called Muslims...not "Mohammedans".

Secondly, do you consider all Jews to be evil? Cause most Jews who have sons have circumcised their sons.

What's next, you gonna accuse Jews of mixing baby-foreskin in with our kosher wine and Matzohs?


..and by the way, maybe you should try to avoid linking to clearly biased and unmedical sources, like "Circumstitions.com"
 
Last edited:
strawman.

I hope not. I really, really hope not. If it is a strawman, then you're claiming that "Removing the foreskin does no serious harm" is a misrepresentation of your position. In which case, you would at best be saying you have no interest in the question of whether removal of the foreskin constitutes serious harm in determining whether circumcision is an acceptable practice, and at worst are prepared to accept that it does constitute serious harm.

If you're advocating circumcision, there is no other morally acceptable position than to claim that removal of the foreskin does not constitute serious harm.

Dave
 
I hope not. I really, really hope not. If it is a strawman, then you're claiming that "Removing the foreskin does no serious harm" is a misrepresentation of your position.

I do not consider skin to be a "body part". I consider it to be skin.

the extremities are body parts. the eye, nose, penis, tongue, ear, is a body part.

skin...is skin. removing foreskin is no different than removing the ear-lobe, or a chunk of fat from a person's buttox, in my humble opinion

If you're advocating circumcision, there is no other morally acceptable position than to claim that removal of the foreskin does not constitute serious harm.

Yes, I have seen no evidence, and no evidence has been presented here, that the professional removal of foreskin by a trained and licensed individual, causes serious mental or physical harm to all who have the procedure.

Now, if folks want to pass a law requiring that a local seditive be provided to reduce pain, I have NO problem with that. I have no interest in babies being in pain, and we luckily have remedies for that.

But until its proven that baby-circumcision causes serious mental or physical harm in a good percentage of those who undero the procedure, I see no logical reason to oppose it.
 
I do not consider skin to be a "body part". I consider it to be skin.

And I consider anything that, when removed, doesn't grow back, to be a body part that shouldn't be removed without good reason. "We've always done it" doesn't, in my opinion, qualify even as a reason, let alone a good one.

Dave
 
"We've always done it" doesn't, in my opinion, qualify even as a reason, let alone a good one.

there is also a great deal of medical evidence that circumcision has real benefits, both to the guy and his sexual partners.

looks folks, pass a law requiring a local pain-killer.

make it illegal to perform a circumcision without a state license to do so.

I have no problem with that.
 
Last edited:
there is also a great deal of medical evidence that circumcision has real benefits, both to the guy and his sexual partners.

Link to that?


looks folks, pass a law requiring a local pain-killer.

make it illegal to perform a circumcision without a state license to do so.

I have no problem with that.

How about waiting until the kid is old enough to give informed consent before performing an unnecessary (and possibly harmful) elective surgery?


Sheesh - people are so open minded and liberal UNTIL it's their own sacred cows getting axed!
 
Link to that?

already did..with many links. look up.

How about waiting until the kid is old enough to give informed consent before performing an unnecessary (and possibly harmful) elective surgery?

are you saying we should do NOTHING to a child until they are old enough to consent to it? how about feeding him/her fruits & vegetables that they don't want to eat?

how about going to the dentist? how about getting braces?

where does the authoritarian war on parental & religious rights end?
 
Last edited:
are you saying we should do NOTHING to a child until they are old enough to consent to it? how about feeding him/her fruits & vegetables that they don't want to eat?

Frenzied strawman. People will sicken/die if not properly fed. People suffer no ill health effects from not undergoing elective penile mutilation.


how about going to the dentist? how about getting braces?

Frenzied strawman. Dentists are not irrevocably taking away all of a childs healthy teeth. If they were, it would be a problem.
 
good to know you want the govt. telling parents how to raise their children.

You have completely failed to meet the arguments against your justifications for circumcision and now resort to peurile comments.
To which the answer is: the government already tells parents how to raise their children.
 
You have completely failed to meet the arguments against your justifications for circumcision and now resort to peurile comments.


really? someone has provided real evidence of serious emotional & physical harm being done as a result of even a small but reasonable percentage of all baby circumcisions? (from what I read, the number of deaths of babies in the USA due to circumcision is around .01%. That's one-hundreth of a percent.)

someone has successfully countered all the evidence I submitted of the medical benefits of circumcision?

no. neither has occured
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom