Ban circumcision in San Fran???

we already know that one of the main proponents of this referendum in San Fran is motivated by his hatred of Jews & Judaism.

but for everyone else, what is the big deal? what is the major crisis that this new law would tackle?

San Fran is rot with homelessness, hunger, poverty, crime, drugs, etc etc...

and yet they actually are considering spending more rare govt. funds on pressing charges against Jews, Muslims, and other people...because they perform circumcisions???

is this really the best way to be spending The People's time & money?

It's certainly one good way of spending time and money.
The fact that other evils exist does not mean lesser evils should be ignored. The fact that one person is a racist does not mean that nobody else can argue against the unnecessary cutting off of baby bits
Your arguments are shot down time and time again and you just keep coming up with more specious excuses.
Try following your own logic and see if this argument passes muster with you:
people commit murder, therefore assault should not be illegal.
It's like your social acceptance argument: it just fails.
 
we already know that one of the main proponents of this referendum in San Fran is motivated by his hatred of Jews & Judaism.

This makes non-medical circumcision acceptable because...?
but for everyone else, what is the big deal? what is the major crisis that this new law would tackle?

Again, this makes the practice acceptable because...?

San Fran is rot with homelessness, hunger, poverty, crime, drugs, etc etc...
So is the rest of the world. I mean hell, the USA is lousy with all those terrible things and Obama spends his time and effort removing DADT? The bastard! How dare he! etc. etc.

Stating that some things are worse doesn't make the thing being fought against better. If I randomly stabbed you in the arm, making sure to miss major blood vessels, that would be better than the guy who randomly stabs you in the kidney! Why waste time prosecuting ME just because I'm easier to catch and will become a less costly problem to remove?

and yet they actually are considering spending more rare govt. funds on pressing charges against Jews, Muslims, and other people...because they perform circumcisions???

They slice off a perfectly useful and functional portion of the anatomy of their child for absolutely no good reason. I'd say that's pretty damn good justification to ban the practice when not medically necessary, yes.
is this really the best way to be spending The People's time & money?
It may not be the best way, but it's a good way. Why repair roads when people are homeless? Why try to catch robbers and burglars when there are rapists and murderers? Why try to stop people performing a totally unnecessary and unpleasant permanent surgical procedure on an infant if people are doing drugs?
 
Type 1 removes the clitoris. And the foreskin is not analogous to the clitoris, the entire penis is.

...snip...

your argument is a major fail.

I wrote Type 1a.

Type Ia, removal of the clitoral hood or prepuce only (which some view as analogous to male circumcision and thus more acceptable).
 
I wrote Type 1a.

Type Ia, removal of the clitoral hood or prepuce only (which some view as analogous to male circumcision and thus more acceptable).

It's more acceptable in the same way that knocking someone out is more acceptable than hacking all their limbs off.
 
And you do realize that the clitoris is not the equivalent of foreskin? Of course you do, but it's a lot easier to make extreme comparisons than accurate ones.

The comparison was perfectly accurate, it was just not what you think it is. The comparison was of examples of doing things for the reason of social acceptance, which is one justification which has been proposed.
 
It would tackle a form of child abuse which is being inflicted on children.

baby-boy circumcision is child abuse.

The fact that other evils exist does not mean lesser evils should be ignored.

circumcising baby-boys is evil



.....wow....a whole lot of extremism, lies, and hyperbole in the thread tonight.

if circumcising baby boys is evil child abuse, does that make most Jews.......evil child abusers??
 
Last edited:
baby-boy circumcision is child abuse.



removal of the clitoris is the same thing as removal of the penile foreskin



circumcising baby-boys is evil



.....wow....a whole lot of garbage in this thread tonight.
Yes. From you.


Type 1a isn't removal of the clitoris. You either know this and are lying to troll, or you can't read.

Choose.
 
It genuinely astonishes me that people can think that comparing circumcision to bleaching of skin or removal of a toe or finger is hyperbole. The argument seems to be that removal of body parts is fine... just so long as the body parts in question are particular ones.


Well duh, yes, that is the argument. The piercing of certain body parts is acceptable as well, but not other ones. Different parts of the body are different. Foreskin isn't a toe, it isn't an ear, it isn't a body part in and of itself. That's why the ear lobe analogy is the only accurate one I've seen so far. Another might be a toe nail.

So yes, equating removing a small patch of otherwise unused skin to the removal of a digit is hyperbole.


I should say, as a UK resident I come from a culture in which only 3.8% of under 15 year olds are circumcised. To me it really genuinely does fit into the same ethical category as clitoral removal and such - and actually, very similar arguments are being used to defend it, now I think about it.

Just because some arguments can be employed fallaciously, or to bad ends, doesn't mean that the argument itself is always wrong. I've seen similar arguments made for banning sugar as were made to ban smoking in enclosed public spaces. In one case, the arguments are justified, and in another they are not. Ignoring why, and just saying, 'they're similar' doesn't help refine the discussion and is really just guilt by association.
 
child abuse?

;):p:D:):rolleyes:

talk about hyperbole.


Cutting bits off a baby is a form of abuse.
Would you agree with that if the part the parents chose to cut off was the little toe?
Try to answer that simple question without all the avoidance tactics you have been using.
 
It's more acceptable in the same way that knocking someone out is more acceptable than hacking all their limbs off.

I was quoting the Wiki page for Thunder's benefit, and in response to his reply to mine claiming my post was a fail. I am against all genital mutilation.

Perhaps I should have made that clearer.
 
baby-boy circumcision is child abuse.



removal of the clitoris is the same thing as removal of the penile foreskin



circumcising baby-boys is evil



.....wow....a whole lot of extremism, lies, and hyperbole in the thread tonight.

Are you deliberately dishonest, or did you genuinely miss the definition of type 1A?
 
The comparison was perfectly accurate, it was just not what you think it is. The comparison was of examples of doing things for the reason of social acceptance, which is one justification which has been proposed.

I'm not saying that it should be done because it has social acceptance, but that you're not going to convince people that their loved ones have mutilated dicks because it has social acceptance. And that's one reason that right now the government shouldn't ban it. It's telling people that there is something horribly wrong with their penis, which is wrong with either cut or uncut.
 
I was quoting the Wiki page for Thunder's benefit, and in response to his reply to mine claiming my post was a fail. I am against all genital mutilation.

Perhaps I should have made that clearer.

Oh no, I totally know what you meant. I just wanted to say that. :p

Well duh, yes, that is the argument. The piercing of certain body parts is acceptable as well, but not other ones. Different parts of the body are different. Foreskin isn't a toe, it isn't an ear, it isn't a body part in and of itself.

That's why the ear lobe analogy is the only accurate one I've seen so far. Another might be a toe nail.

So yes, equating removing a small patch of otherwise unused skin to the removal of a digit is hyperbole.
(my bolding)

Yeah the bolded part? Not so much. The foreskin is very useful.
 
Type 1a isn't removal of the clitoris. You either know this and are lying to troll, or you can't read.

I select the third option: I read too fast.

I also want to remind the audience that at least for most Jews, circumcision has NOTHING to do with social-acceptance. It is part of our religious and cultural heritage, going back at least 3,000 years.

If someone can show me how very necessary the foreskin is, or how dangerous removal of the foreskin is, or how soo many boys are permanently injured, infected, or even killed by circumcision, I see no reason to bring in Big Brother to ban it.

The govt. has a role in parenting....but its role is NOT to prevent parents from doing things that pose no significant danger or harm to their children.

And as there is no evidence of any significant harm or danger being done to a child, by having a professional circumcision performed on an infant, the govt. has no business getting involved.

Let the govt. stick to saving children from parents who sexually abuse them, or beat them mercilessly, or don't send them to school. They do a horrible job so far...and could use all the funds that would be spent prosecuting circumcision "crimes".
 
Last edited:
and btw, if some tribe from Africa comes to the USA, and they have a cultural practise of removing the entire ear-lobe from their 8-day-old baby girls, I may find it a bit repugnant, but as such a surgery does no real harm to the child...it should remain legal.

again, this debate should be about whether circumcision truly does serious physical or mental DAMAGE to a human being. and so far no evidence has been presented that suggests such.

you show me real evidence that circumcision does serious physical or mental harm, and I will change my position.
 
Last edited:
I select the third option: I read too fast.

I also want to remind the audience that at least for most Jews, circumcision has NOTHING to do with social-acceptance. It is part of our religious and cultural heritage, going back at least 3,000 years.

You don't think culture is about social acceptance?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom