Ban circumcision in San Fran???

I therefore see NO reason why the govt. should step in and prevent infant circumcisions, except for reasons of bigotry and authoritarianism.


United States
Federal law prohibiting FGC was enacted in 1996. Seventeen states enacted similar laws between 1994 and 2006.[139]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_genital_cutting#Other_regions

Care to respond, Thunder?

FGC=FGM=Female genital cutting=Female circumcision=Female genital mutilation
 
Care to respond, Thunder?

FGC=FGM=Female genital cutting=Female circumcision=Female genital mutilation

FGM does serious physical and psychological harm to the child. This serious harm stays with the woman for the rest of her life.

Got any research on the serious psychological, emotional, and physical harm done to ALL boys/men who are circumcised?

...I um.....yeah I thought now. ;)
 
Male circumcision is NOT serious harm. Nor is ear-piercings, braces, light spanking with an open hand, or taking away the TV if the kid doesn't eat his vegetables or doesn't do his homework.

Except where there is an infection or death, you are right. Circumcision only cause the baby intense pain, for absolutely no medical reason. So, that's all right then. How would you feel about parents being entitled to stick needles in their babies? It doesn't cause serious harm.

Ear-piercings: should not be done until the child can give informed consent.
Braces should not be used without medical reason, or until the child can give informed consent.
Hitting a child should not be done. If you feel the need to hit your child, you have failed.
Forcing a child to eat certain foods is a bad idea.
Homework as an imposition and punishment is a bad idea.
But the above, while good questions about decent parenting, are not realistic comparisons to performing minor surgery for absolutely no medical reason.
 
FGM does serious physical and psychological harm to the child. This serious harm stays with the woman for the rest of her life.

Got any research on the serious psychological, emotional, and physical harm done to ALL boys/men who are circumcised?

...I um.....yeah I thought now. ;)
Minor FGM does not cause serious physical and psychological harm. Even major FGM can prevent psychological harm because it allows the girl to fit in to her social milieu. She might feel left out if she is not cut.
 
very pathetic, stupid, and offensive strawman.

It's an exact analogy of the argument you made.

If I were trying to be offensive I'd say that the "parents have a right to do what they like with their children" argument would also logically make the sexual abuse of children legal. Which, whilst it is offensive, is also true.
 
Wow. And we should also bleach the skin of black babies so that the racist white children won't make fun of them, too?

Seriously, some people might be bullied by bigoted scum, so we should surgically alter the victims to make them blend with the herd? What the hell is wrong with you?

I'm just using your post as a jumping off point.

I find Thunder's argument laughable as well. However, it is interesting that so many have relied on arguing that a circumcised penis is 'mutilated' and it's wrong to do. This basically tells people who have a circumcised penis that they have been a victim, that their penis isn't right, and that they should make sure this horrible thing doesn't happen to other men. When they look down and reject that they are a victim and that what was done to them was a horrible thing, they reject the argument. This doesn't extend to just to men who have been cut, but to those who know them. Dad's/brother's/husband's/etc penis had a horrible thing done to it and is mutilated. Some people are going to accept this argument and feel horrible about their or their loved one's penis. Most are just going to reject the argument outright, turning what could have been allies into people dismissing the advocates as loons. It's a losing strategy because circumcision just isn't that horrible to the vast majority of the population. Note this says nothing about if it's actually a horrible thing or not.


Hyperbole doesn't work this time.
 
Ear-piercings: should not be done until the child can give informed consent.
Braces should not be used without medical reason, or until the child can give informed consent.
Hitting a child should not be done. If you feel the need to hit your child, you have failed.
Forcing a child to eat certain foods is a bad idea.
Homework as an imposition and punishment is a bad idea.

and you want YOUR government to enforce these opinions of yours, under penalty of fine or even prison?
 
FGM does serious physical and psychological harm to the child. This serious harm stays with the woman for the rest of her life.

Type 1a is analogous to male circumcision--yet it is illegal in the US.
 
However, it is interesting that so many have relied on arguing that a circumcised penis is 'mutilated' and it's wrong to do. This basically tells people who have a circumcised penis that they have been a victim, that their penis isn't right, and that they should make sure this horrible thing doesn't happen to other men. When they look down and reject that they are a victim and that what was done to them was a horrible thing, they reject the argument.

I really don't see myself as a victim. I'm just different.

:)



....oh, and btw, have any of you actually witnessed a circumcision?

baby stops crying in about 10 seconds. then life goes on.
 
Last edited:
I'm just using your post as a jumping off point.

I find Thunder's argument laughable as well. However, it is interesting that so many have relied on arguing that a circumcised penis is 'mutilated' and it's wrong to do. This basically tells people who have a circumcised penis that they have been a victim, that their penis isn't right, and that they should make sure this horrible thing doesn't happen to other men. When they look down and reject that they are a victim and that what was done to them was a horrible thing, they reject the argument. This doesn't extend to just to men who have been cut, but to those who know them. Dad's/brother's/husband's/etc penis had a horrible thing done to it and is mutilated. Some people are going to accept this argument and feel horrible about their or their loved one's penis. Most are just going to reject the argument outright, turning what could have been allies into people dismissing the advocates as loons. It's a losing strategy because circumcision just isn't that horrible to the vast majority of the population. Note this says nothing about if it's actually a horrible thing or not.


Hyperbole doesn't work this time.

You realize that the same argument can be used for FEMALE circumcision in some country where it is socially accepted, where the women socially feels OK, and would feels like reject if not circumcised ? Because the majority are OK with something , does not mean it is ethically or morally OK. I mean come on, I could come up with many more example of things which are abhorrent, but a majority supported and could easily godwin the thread.
 
it is interesting that so many have relied on arguing that a circumcised penis is 'mutilated' and it's wrong to do. This basically tells people who have a circumcised penis that they have been a victim, that their penis isn't right, and that they should make sure this horrible thing doesn't happen to other men. When they look down and reject that they are a victim and that what was done to them was a horrible thing, they reject the argument. This doesn't extend to just to men who have been cut, but to those who know them. Dad's/brother's/husband's/etc penis had a horrible thing done to it and is mutilated. Some people are going to accept this argument and feel horrible about their or their loved one's penis. Most are just going to reject the argument outright, turning what could have been allies into people dismissing the advocates as loons. It's a losing strategy because circumcision just isn't that horrible to the vast majority of the population. Note this says nothing about if it's actually a horrible thing or not.
That's a perfectly fine point, if one's aim in the discussion is merely to convince people to adopt a certain course of action. It's essentially how a professional advocate like a lawyer or politician operates - their concern is not to discuss the truth, but rather to present whatever argument will best convince people to do what they want them to do.

There's nothing inherently wrong with that approach, but it's certainly not my intent.

In my opinion, circumcision simply is a mutilation that serves no real useful purpose. It really is no different from having a culture where parents chop a toe off the foot of a child, say, on the basis that losing a little toe isn't really a big deal in terms of loss of functionality, that it reduces a child's chance of getting an ingrowing toenail, and since most people have been doing it a long time then feet with all ten toes on them look a bit odd anyway. I'd accept that all those things are true, and if they went on to argue that since it's so culturally accepted, very few kids really grew up to look at themselves as victims for having lost the toe, I'd accept that as well. But I'd still say that none of those things come remotely close to a justification.

Hyperbole doesn't work this time.
It genuinely astonishes me that people can think that comparing circumcision to bleaching of skin or removal of a toe or finger is hyperbole. The argument seems to be that removal of body parts is fine... just so long as the body parts in question are particular ones.

I should say, as a UK resident I come from a culture in which only 3.8% of under 15 year olds are circumcised. To me it really genuinely does fit into the same ethical category as clitoral removal and such - and actually, very similar arguments are being used to defend it, now I think about it.
 
we already know that one of the main proponents of this referendum in San Fran is motivated by his hatred of Jews & Judaism.

but for everyone else, what is the big deal? what is the major crisis that this new law would tackle?

San Fran is rot with homelessness, hunger, poverty, crime, drugs, etc etc...

and yet they actually are considering spending more rare govt. funds on pressing charges against Jews, Muslims, and other people...because they perform circumcisions???

is this really the best way to be spending The People's time & money?
 
we already know that one of the main proponents of this referendum in San Fran is motivated by his hatred of Jews & Judaism.

It appear to be; it is still unknown if that is his primary motivation.

but for everyone else, what is the big deal? what is the major crisis that this new law would tackle?

Many people believe that circumcision should be banned. Remember, Type 1a FGM is already illegal in the US, and is analogous to male circumcision.

San Fran is rot with homelessness, hunger, poverty, crime, drugs, etc etc...

Irrelevant. Laws protecting people are often passed, regardless of the circumstances of the aforementioned issues.

and yet they actually are considering spending more rare govt. funds on pressing charges against Jews, Muslims, and other people...because they perform circumcisions???

is this really the best way to be spending The People's time & money?

Already addressed above. Should we stop enforcing laws or not continue passing laws to protect the welfare of people when times are tough?
 
....oh, and btw, have any of you actually witnessed a circumcision?

baby stops crying in about 10 seconds. then life goes on.
10 seconds? Rubbish.
You seem to simply leap from one justification to another without actually meeting any of the arguments put against you.
Inflicting unnecessary, avoidable pain on a baby is disgusting.
But, as long as the baby only cries for a short time, you think it is okay.
You would, therefore, support the right of parents to stick needles in their babies as long as it causes no longterm harm and the baby only cries for a short time.
 
Many people believe that circumcision should be banned. Remember, Type 1a FGM is already illegal in the US, and is analogous to male circumcision.

Type 1 removes the clitoris. And the foreskin is not analogous to the clitoris, the entire penis is.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clitoris

Unlike the penis, which is homologous to the clitoris,



...oh, and THIS:

the clitoris is the most sensitive erogenous zone of the female, the stimulation of which may produce sexual excitement and clitoral erection; its continuing stimulation may produce sexual pleasure and orgasm, and is considered the key to females' sexual pleasure.


...does the penis foreskin have the same absolute role???????


your argument is a major fail.
 
Last edited:
but for everyone else, what is the big deal? what is the major crisis that this new law would tackle?
It would tackle a form of child abuse which is being inflicted on children.

San Fran is rot with homelessness, hunger, poverty, crime, drugs, etc etc...

and yet they actually are considering spending more rare govt. funds on pressing charges against Jews, Muslims, and other people...because they perform circumcisions???

is this really the best way to be spending The People's time & money?
The best way? Possibly, possibly not - a subjective judgment call really. But I've never been a fan of the government model where problems deemed important receive all of the attention, whilst every lesser problem is ignored completely. I'd rather the government make attempts to tackle homelessness, hunger, poverty, crime, drugs, AND child mutilation.
 
You realize that the same argument can be used for FEMALE circumcision in some country where it is socially accepted, where the women socially feels OK, and would feels like reject if not circumcised ? Because the majority are OK with something , does not mean it is ethically or morally OK. I mean come on, I could come up with many more example of things which are abhorrent, but a majority supported and could easily godwin the thread.

And you do realize that the clitoris is not the equivalent of foreskin? Of course you do, but it's a lot easier to make extreme comparisons than accurate ones.

But the majority does decide what is mutilation, and what is modification. Without clear, unambiguous harm of noticeable degree, people aren't simply going to get behind it.

Simply because the majority supports something doesn't make it moral, true, neither does it make it immoral.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom