Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Depends on how highly beneficial it turns out to be. However I don't think it is likely that foreskins are so horribly damaging to health that mandatory circumcision is necessary.

We'd have to have a serious talk with Darwin if that were the case.
 
We'd have to have a serious talk with Darwin if that were the case.

never heard of vestigial organs huh? never noticed the remnants of your third eye-lid, have ya?

the human body has many things that we no longer use nor need, but for some reason have remained. evolution missed a few things, I guess.
 
that's not what I asked you.

let's say, next year, new research suggests that circumcision is highly beneficial to male health. and the fed. govt. decides to REQUIRE all male infants be circumcised.

will you accept this new law?

Define highly beneficial.
 
never heard of vestigial organs huh? never noticed the remnants of your third eye-lid, have ya?

the human body has many things that we no longer use nor need, but for some reason have remained. evolution missed a few things, I guess.

This was not about vestigial organs but harmful organs. Never noticed the difference, have ya?
 
never heard of vestigial organs huh? never noticed the remnants of your third eye-lid, have ya?

the human body has many things that we no longer use nor need, but for some reason have remained. evolution missed a few things, I guess.

Thunder, are you seriously claiming that the foreskin is a vestigial organ?
 
that's not what I asked you.

let's say, next year, new research suggests that circumcision is highly beneficial to male health. and the fed. govt. decides to REQUIRE all male infants be circumcised.

will you accept this new law?

This question is silly beyond words. If you are going to come up with a hypothetical, at least make it remotely feasible.
 
Not at all a problem, unless you would argue that the government can never make better decisions. That would, of course, mean that parents can do whatever they choose to their children.
You are not seriously claiming that, are you?
That 'argument' is a non-starter.

So because the government is right to enforce some standards of care on parents, they should be entitled to enforce any level of care they choose? You're basically arguing that the government cannot overreach. That's not an argument I buy at all, and I don't need to take the extreme position you suggest in order to reject yours.
 
I have NO problem with the govt. preventing clearly and irrefutably dangerous and harmful actions and surgeries upon children.

male circumcision, is not one of these actions. the GREAT majority of circumcision patients live healthy and happy lives, including sex lives.

I therefore see NO reason why the govt. should step in and prevent infant circumcisions, except for reasons of bigotry and authoritarianism.
 
having a penis that looks different from one's father, could indeed cause mental health issues. especially for young boys who already have emotional issues.

what if the boy goes to a Jewish school..or a Jewish camp? all the circumcised boys may indeed laugh at and poke fun and little Joey, who still has his foreskin.
Wow. And we should also bleach the skin of black babies so that the racist white children won't make fun of them, too?

Seriously, some people might be bullied by bigoted scum, so we should surgically alter the victims to make them blend with the herd? What the hell is wrong with you?
 
So because the government is right to enforce some standards of care on parents, they should be entitled to enforce any level of care they choose? You're basically arguing that the government cannot overreach. That's not an argument I buy at all, and I don't need to take the extreme position you suggest in order to reject yours.

Read my post again, and the post it was in reponse to. You have completely misinterpreted it.
 
I have NO problem with the govt. preventing clearly and irrefutably dangerous and harmful actions and surgeries upon children.

male circumcision, is not one of these actions. the GREAT majority of circumcision patients live healthy and happy lives, including sex lives.

I therefore see NO reason why the govt. should step in and prevent infant circumcisions, except for reasons of bigotry and authoritarianism.

Well, as long as the majority survive relatively unscathed, bugger the ones who don't.
I am certainly bigoted against people who think it good to cut bits off babies for no medical reason.
 
very pathetic, stupid, and offensive strawman.

The analogy exactly followed your justification for circumcision, which was that it is a good idea because uncircumcised boys might be bullied.
Bleaching black kids is a perfect analogy.
 
The analogy exactly followed your justification for circumcision, which was that it is a good idea because uncircumcised boys might be bullied.
Bleaching black kids is a perfect analogy.

you are comparing circumcizing a Jewish baby-boy...to bleaching a black child's skin white?

wow.......the anti-Mohels are getting really desperate.
 
you are comparing circumcizing a Jewish baby-boy...to bleaching a black child's skin white?

wow.......the anti-Mohels are getting really desperate.

I am comparing circumcising a baby anything so he will not be bullied to bleaching a black baby so he will not be bullied.
It is a comment on one of your justifications for circumcision.
Do you now resile from that justification, ie do you now agree that a boy's being bullied, because he is entire, is not a good reason for cutting a bit off, to make him fit in?
 
Remember this post, Thunder?
having a penis that looks different from one's father, could indeed cause mental health issues. especially for young boys who already have emotional issues.

what if the boy goes to a Jewish school..or a Jewish camp? all the circumcised boys may indeed laugh at and poke fun and little Joey, who still has his foreskin.
 
if a set of parents wants to circumcise their baby boy, and two of the reasons is that the father is circumcised and it is likely that all of his friends, classmates, and camp mates will also be circumcised, I have no major issue with it.

I may not love the choice, but I believe that parents should have the right to make even stupid decisions for their children. AS LONG as the decision does not cause the child irreversible serious harm. Male circumcision is NOT serious harm. Nor is ear-piercings, braces, light spanking with an open hand, or taking away the TV if the kid doesn't eat his vegetables or doesn't do his homework.

Parents have the right to make poor decisions. Its not the democractic govt.'s job or society's job to prevent poor but not seriously damaging decisions. Leave that to the Communists and Fascists.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom