Ban circumcision in San Fran???

The doctor could demand informed consent of the person undergoing the procedure, or sound medical reasons for the procedure to be undertaken if the person was too young (or whatever) to give informed consent.
 
No, he means the doctor could refuse to do the procedure unless there was either a sound medical indication, or the patient was able to give informed consent to the procedure.

Yep.

Sounds like a damn good idea to me. Not gonna happen so long as there are Jewish and Arab doctors, for a start.

Jewish and Arab doctors are equally subject to the possibility of malpractice suits...

Dave
 
lol, you people are unbelievable. I am not going to respond to every single post up to this point.

You all have failed the test in giving me proof that there should be an outright ban. I had one case, with one coroner's report to go on. Whoopdee damn doo.

Now, unless you give some statistics and actual hard proof done by a respected organization that isn't "inconclusive," you have no reason to pass a prohibition against something which is protected in the Constitution.

Until such time as the proof comes, I shall not be coming back to this thread any longer. Good day! :)
I couldn't finish reading that coroner's report - that poor child, it's heartbreaking. If the completely pointless and avoidable death of a baby isn't enough to persuade you that this unnecessary procedure shouldn't be undertaken on infants incapable of consent, then I wonder why you have asked for test cases. You also seem to have ignored the case of David Reimer, which has been brought up a couple of times already.

However, I don't think anyone here is agitating for a ban on circumcision, but we are proposing that such an operation should only be carried out for sound and compelling medical reasons, and/or with the informed consent of the person being operated on.

In fact, this would bring the law exactly into line with the law on FGM. At the moment, infant girls have more and better protection under the law than do infant boys. That does not seem to me to be right - I have three sons and one daughter and I would expect that in a civilised Western democracy, my children should have equal protection against unnecessary medical procedures undertaken without their consent.
 
Last edited:
As a response to a heartbreaking report on the completely avoidable death of an innocent baby, that leaves something to be desired.

Rolfe.

It's okay, he's not a doctor or a priest, only a teacher, after all ...

Do we have a puking smiley?

Rasmus.
 
It's okay, he's not a doctor or a priest, only a teacher, after all ...

Do we have a puking smiley?

Rasmus.


Yep, that is the appropriate response:

156584d7f8006949c2.gif
 
So I'm coming back into this thread to raise a few questions. Let me state that I think the procedure is barbaric.

Am I correct in assuming that while circumcision is uncommon in most countries, it is not illegal. If that is correct, why have there been no bans?

As far as the US goes, I posted the opinion of one constitutional professor that believes the SF ban will be ruled unconstitutional. I know very little about the topic of the law in the US, let alone elsewhere. But I wonder why no other country (or perhaps very few) have banned the procedure, as has been done with FGM. And whether anyone with knowledge about the US law can speak directly to the legal question.

Thanks.
 
To be perfectly honest, I think it's because of the number of Jewish people in very high-up, respectable positions in most professions, including medicine and the law. I realise this sounds like "Jewish conspiracy", but it's the obvious explanation. Not a conspiracy, but just a sufficient number of people who are in a position to influence such matters who have a very definite viewpoint, plus a lot of other people who don't want to be labelled as antisemitic for opposing that viewpoint.

Much the same reason as we can't get legislation proposed to outlaw ritual slaughter of animals that aren't pre-stunned.

Rolfe.
 
To be perfectly honest, I think it's because of the number of Jewish people in very high-up, respectable positions in most professions, including medicine and the law. I realise this sounds like "Jewish conspiracy", but it's the obvious explanation. Not a conspiracy, but just a sufficient number of people who are in a position to influence such matters who have a very definite viewpoint, plus a lot of other people who don't want to be labelled as antisemitic for opposing that viewpoint.

Much the same reason as we can't get legislation proposed to outlaw ritual slaughter of animals that aren't pre-stunned.

Rolfe.

This.

Being called an anti-semite in Germany is not the best of career moves a politician could ever make.
 
Antisemitic AND Islamophobic. Denmark tried, i don't know what came out of it (but suspect it was dropped):

Israelnationalnews said:
Furor over Proposed Ban of Circumcision in Denmark
Reported: 00:11 AM - Nov/21/08

Jews and Muslims in Denmark are in an uproar about a bill to ban circumcision for boys under the age of 15, according to Yediot Ahronot. The country's National Council for Children and Ethics Council have both endorsed the proposal and only the parliament's medical committee can prevent it from being heard.

The National Council for Children argued that, "Circumcision is the irreversible damage to a child's body before he is given the chance to object." It also said the ban was a matter of equality, in the wake of a five-year-old ban on female circumscion.

Denmark's Chief Rabbi Bent Lexner – who is also a certified mohel (circumciser) in the community – told Yediot Ahronot, "The comparison between circumcision and the intentional mutilation of the female sex organ in certain societies is simply complete nonsense." He added, "If the law forbidding circumcision is ever passed in Denmark, Jews will have to leave the place they have been living in for hundreds of years."
 
So, after being presented with the exact evidence that he demanded, Nihilianth flounced out with a dismissive toss of the head? Classy.
 
A dismissive toss of the head and a cheer for the dead baby.
 
So I'm coming back into this thread to raise a few questions. Let me state that I think the procedure is barbaric.

Am I correct in assuming that while circumcision is uncommon in most countries, it is not illegal. If that is correct, why have there been no bans?

As far as the US goes, I posted the opinion of one constitutional professor that believes the SF ban will be ruled unconstitutional. I know very little about the topic of the law in the US, let alone elsewhere. But I wonder why no other country (or perhaps very few) have banned the procedure, as has been done with FGM. And whether anyone with knowledge about the US law can speak directly to the legal question.

Thanks.

Reasonable post deserves a reasonable response.

I think the reason is, the fear of provoking religious freedom activists, and the lack of evidence of just how harmful circumcision is. I know someone posted one case of a child (well, two children mentioned) which are quite compelling. But those are just single cases. There are no real statistics which confirms this to be more than just an anomaly.

In order to create a ban or make an act illegal, you must provide a very compelling reason to do so. Voters are not inclined to vote for a ban, just because they feel like it. Congresspeople will not pass a law just because they feel like it. People in Congress would like to see proof that a law is justified, before they are willing to vote on the measure. It's just the proof/evidence that is out there is just simply not good enough atm to justify banning a religious practice.
 
So, after being presented with the exact evidence that he demanded, Nihilianth flounced out with a dismissive toss of the head? Classy.

Nope. It was because people took it to be complete gospel. I asked for that, yes. Because I was curious to see if it was, indeed, a possibility. I was proven that it was. But before I could respond, people started making all kinds of crazy posts with rude and sarcastic responses. Even after I said I would be willing to see tighter restrictions.

In any case, it is still only one case that seemed pretty extraordinary. The baby's family had a history of bleeding heavily. The hospital did not provide any pamphlets of information on the procedure that was used, and how to take care of it. The hospital quickly rectified this.

After pointing this out, the response was just a terribly sarcastic "OooohhhOOOOooo000......so a tiny little pamphlet would have made all the difference, I see!?" or something to that effect.

Yes. It could very easily have made all the difference.

In any case, there is still a lack of confirmed statistics. I did admit to agreeing to seeing tighter restrictions after that coroner's report was posted. But that comment was quickly dismissed out of hand with rude and sarcastic responses. At which point, I decided enough was enough. The conversation had pretty much come to an end, as it just broke down into nothing but "I think...." "Yes, I agree...!" and "I agree as well....!" I am not terribly fond of a lot of people patting themselves on the back for a job well done after swarming someone with ridiculous comparisons that were nothing but straw men.

Especially in light of the fact that the larger society seems to disagree with a ban on circumcision.
 
Nope. It was because people took it to be complete gospel. I asked for that, yes. Because I was curious to see if it was, indeed, a possibility.

All surgeries have an inherent risk of death. This one is no different.

We're not against it because of that risk, we're against it because it's unnecessary and aesthetic, with no reasoning behind it except tradition and a small number of fringe religions.

You made the claim that it was safe, seemingly having forgotten that all surgeries have risks of complications. I looked up a coroner's report for you, showing that on at least one occasion this procedure had killed someone. My level of "significant risk" for an unnecessary aesthetic surgery on an unwilling participant is 1 injurious surgery. I'm not alone in that opinion. So for me at the very least, and certainly many others, this one death is enough to call for the procedure to be banned in unnecessary cases on unwilling babies.

Religion has nothing to do with my claim. It's medically unnecessary and performed on babies with no say in the matter. The fact that it's dangerous is coincidental. The fact that it's permanent is additional. The fact that some claim it to be a religious practice is meaningless.
 
All surgeries have an inherent risk of death. This one is no different.

We're not against it because of that risk, we're against it because it's unnecessary and aesthetic, with no reasoning behind it except tradition and a small number of fringe religions.

I understand you think it is for aesthetic reasons. I can even agree to seeing a ban for non-religious reasons. But I would hardly call Judaism and Islam "fringe religions." In fact, Islam is the second largest religion in the world, and I think that Judaism is the third.

What I take issue with, is that you keep saying it is "unnecessary, and aesthetic." Not for the religious folks, it isn't. It is quite necessary, and is far from aesthetics.

You made the claim that it was safe, seemingly having forgotten that all surgeries have risks of complications. I looked up a coroner's report for you, showing that on at least one occasion this procedure had killed someone. My level of "significant risk" for an unnecessary aesthetic surgery on an unwilling participant is 1 injurious surgery. I'm not alone in that opinion. So for me at the very least, and certainly many others, this one death is enough to call for the procedure to be banned in unnecessary cases on unwilling babies.

And for that, I do appreciate that you took the time out to find what I had asked for. And it was a pretty moving piece of literature. Moving enough to change my stance to seeing more regulations, and perhaps an outright ban on non-religious circumcisions.

Religion has nothing to do with my claim. It's medically unnecessary and performed on babies with no say in the matter. The fact that it's dangerous is coincidental. The fact that it's permanent is additional. The fact that some claim it to be a religious practice is meaningless.

And this is where you lose in the conversation. All the previous points are credible points which I have taken into consideration all along. But you fail to take into consideration the religious aspect. You even admit as much. I certainly respect your opinion that religious claims are meaningless. But objectively, that statement is false. If you can make this claim, then you can make the same claim when banning the covering of faces, or the praying in public parks at noontime. Slippery slope, yes. But the religious freedom is in the Constitution for the reasons of instilling some form of tolerance in society.
 
But as people keep noting, the same freedom to circumcise infant girls is not permitted, religious requirement notwithstanding. Your law is giving a greater protection to girls than it does to boys.
 
What I take issue with, is that you keep saying it is "unnecessary, and aesthetic." Not for the religious folks, it isn't. It is quite necessary, and is far from aesthetics.

Once again: The first amendment does not mean that the voices in your head carry any weight whatsoever in a legal debate.

You continue to utterly, utterly misunderstand what the amendment means and how it is applied.
 
But as people keep noting, the same freedom to circumcise infant girls is not permitted, religious requirement notwithstanding. Your law is giving a greater protection to girls than it does to boys.

please note post number 1247. This argument about "FGM" is a strawman.
 
I don't know why you are putting scare quotes around FGM; I have, in the course of this discussion, been extremely careful to use the neutral language you requested and have exclusively referred to circumcision on boys rather than mutilation. However, there isn't a neutral term for what is done to some infant girls in the name of religion and culture, and FGM is understood to encompass a wide range of mutilations from minor cuts to major alterations. If you have a different term which you would prefer, you have only to suggest it and I will give your request consideration.

I can quite see that you would wish for their to be no equivalence between FGM and circumcision, but in point of fact the similarities are such that there is an equivalence.

In both cases the surgery is performed for reasons of religion and culture. In both cases the surgery carries a risk to the life and health of the person on whom it is performed. In both cases the people on whom the surgery is performed are almost always infants and children who are incapable of consent, and who have not made a decision for themselves about what if any religion they intend to follow as adults. In both cases, many of the people who request the surgery on their infants do so because they believe there is a religious obligation on them to do so. In both cases the surgery is permanent and has consequences for the child for the rest of their lives.

The only difference, qualitatively, is that it is illegal to perform such surgery on girls (except where medically necessary) and it is not illegal to perform such surgery on boys.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom