Ban circumcision in San Fran???

So what is the magic number of deaths or complications at which an unnecessary surgical procedure on newborns becomes unacceptable? I'd have thought it would be 1.

Close, but no cigar.

Turns out the number is 50,000.

Over four million births per year in the USA, half of those male and (roughly) half of those still being circumcised. 5% of that Million is still acceptable.

ETA: And that would be enough for governmental regulation, not an outright ban, mind you ...
 
Last edited:
Medical procedures should be carried out for medical reasons only..

People can also say that you can only cover your face for emergency situations only. The First Amendment is still a factor, unless you can provide the proof I am asking for.
 
I would use the same type of definition as they used for female genital mutilation - as can be seen in the post I quoted the actual legislation the law doesn't seem to have the problem you do with such definitions.

Right, so long as it isn't invoked in a dishonest manner. Which is exactly why I am against that term.

In any case, I am still wondering why the specific term "circumcision" is so hard to use, in order to reduce the risk of dishonesty. I really don't care that you use the word "mutilation." So long as it is used with the understanding that we are talking specifically about circumcision here. there are still people trying to make the comparison of lopping off earlobes. :D
 
Right, so long as it isn't invoked in a dishonest manner. Which is exactly why I am against that term.

In any case, I am still wondering why the specific term "circumcision" is so hard to use, in order to reduce the risk of dishonesty. I really don't care that you use the word "mutilation." So long as it is used with the understanding that we are talking specifically about circumcision here. there are still people trying to make the comparison of lopping off earlobes. :D

And that comparison remains valid.
 
If it were demonstrated that circumcising babies(done for religious reasons) was sufficiently harmful, would you be in favor of banning it?

edit: and if so, why?

Yes. For the same reasons that lopping off earlobes, and arms, and whatnot is sufficiently harmful. This is why I am asking for proof of sufficient harm.
 
Yes. For the same reasons that lopping off earlobes, and arms, and whatnot is sufficiently harmful. This is why I am asking for proof of sufficient harm.

Except "sufficient" is subjective. Apparently Thunder's idea of sufficient is greater than 5%, or something like 50k injurious surgeries.

Mine is 1, because this is an unnecessary aesthetic mutilation practiced only by tradition that doesn't have anything close to the religious backing you've been claiming.
 
Circumcision is a mutilation, it may be one that society accepts but that does not change what it is when it is carried out for non-medical reasons.

I would have thought a simple answer for someone who is for circumcision would be "Yes but only to the extent of a circumcision".

I suppose an answer could have been as easy as that. I pretty much said the same thing, only more wordy. It only got twisted to suit the questioner's purpose. I believe it was Scum way back when he was trying to explain his logic of using three "yes/no" questions as a way to logically explain why my position is illogical.

Unfortunately, the "yes" part is dishonest as a standalone answer. You still need the qualifier of the "but...", thereby making such an exercise in logic useless. Because it is not a simple yes/no answer. Or else he asked the wrong question in the wrong way, thereby distorting the logic he was using.
 
You make it sound as if 5% would be a miniscule rate.
5% would be absolutely appallingly bad.

I would totally agree with this assessment. But in reality, it is less than one half of one percent. And most of those are highly questionable as to the actual cause of death.
 
So what is the magic number of deaths or complications at which an unnecessary surgical procedure on newborns becomes unacceptable? I'd have thought it would be 1.

If it were just one out of a million, most likely the cause of that death would not be attributable to the circumcision itself.
 
And that comparison remains valid.

How so? You have yet to demonstrate this. I asked about which religion does this. Who challenged the law that prohibits the lopping off earlobes, and what the verdict was.

You have also failed to mention what the risks and benefits were to the individual, and just how risky such an operation was. You have also failed to demonstrate that this would not at all affect the person's life.

It is hardly valid by any means.

Childlike Empress said "The hypothetical would be exactly the same situation as circumcision." Do you know what my answer was?
 
I would totally agree with this assessment. But in reality, it is less than one half of one percent. And most of those are highly questionable as to the actual cause of death.


If it were just one out of a million, most likely the cause of that death would not be attributable to the circumcision itself.


:hb:

Have you any concept of what you just said there?

People question whether vaccines should be given, with all their known benefits, if they cause death at the rate of one in a million. And yes, one in a million is a perfectly possible death rate caused by a procedure. It's absolutely ridiculous to hand-wave this away as "probably not attributable to the procedure" Any medical professional trying to pull that one would be run out of town.

One death is 100% of your children, if it happens to your only child. And it's precisely one too many if the procedure is being done only for cosmetic and ideological reasons.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Except "sufficient" is subjective. Apparently Thunder's idea of sufficient is greater than 5%, or something like 50k injurious surgeries.

Mine is 1, because this is an unnecessary aesthetic mutilation practiced only by tradition that doesn't have anything close to the religious backing you've been claiming.

Show me one coroner's report that definitely, 100% confirms that one child died strictly because of his circumcision, or an infection that ensued ONLY from the circumcision, with no other possibilities or variables involved.

And an opinion piece written in a blog hardly counts.
 
:hb:

Have you any concept of what you just said there?

People question whether vaccines should be given, with all their known benefits, if they cause death at the rate of one in a million. And yes, one in a million is a perfectly possible death rate caused by a procedure. It's absolutely ridiculous to hand-wave this away as "probably not attributable to the procedure" Any medical professional trying to pull that one would be run out of town.

Rolfe.

Show a coroner's report. Not an opinion piece.
 
What part of "unnecessary surgical procedure" do you not understand?

What part of "religious obligations" do you not understand?

Not trying to be a smart-ass here too much. But the point is, there are religious folks who think it a religious obligation to perform circumcision. The First Amendment protects the rights of religious people to perform their religious obligations.

I fully understand where you are coming from. I honestly do. But I don't think you fully understand just how important it is to the Jews. This is the very reason why the First Amendment was written to include the "religion" clause. It serves to protect the religions, just as much as it serves to protect the atheists.
 
Oh my God, just read that.

After the procedure, Ryleigh was diaphoretic [perspiring] and distressed

He [the surgeon] thought excessive movement due to his pain may have caused Ryleigh's bleeding

On observation, Ryleigh was found to be in shock, breathing spontaneously but with an expiratory grunt;


Even before it all began to go horribly wrong (the first two lines there) the baby was in pain and distressed. Then...

Oh, that poor wee mite. I could cry, just reading that.

Rolfe.
 
Not trying to be a smart-ass here too much. But the point is, there are religious folks who think it a religious obligation to perform circumcision. The First Amendment protects the rights of religious people to perform their religious obligations.

No, the first amendment did not protect female circumcision. It takes a sick person to cause an infant the amount of pain, and risk to health, that goes along with male, or female, circumcision. Not that that level of crazy hasn't been a hallmark of religion for ages.
 
What part of "unnecessary surgical procedure" do you not understand?

Half the procedure isn't even surgical, it's sexual, with rabbis often sucking the foreskin off with their mouths which has cause babies to be infected with herpes and other diseases.

I wonder, if I was a practicing Norse, would it be okay to temper my new sword by running it, while red hot, through from the shoulder into the chest and abdominal cavity of an enemy tied to a horizontal post? Would that be protected by the first amendment?

No, but mutilating infants is. :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom