Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Childlike Empress said "The hypothetical would be exactly the same situation as circumcision." Do you know what my answer was?


I'm quite sure that i didn't say this. Provide a direct quote or retract your statement. What i said IIRC was that cutting off earlobes is slightly less harmful than cutting off foreskins. Now that you are educated on the function of the foreskin - involving protection, penetration and pleasure, it's on you to show how your left earlobe (which looks silly, btw) has a comparable value.
 
Really? You're too lazy to google?

http://www.circumstitions.com/death-exsang.html

(1) Immediate cause of death: a) Multi-organ ischemia, due to or as a consequence of b) exsangination [loss of blood], due to or as a consequence of c) circumcision

Me? Too lazy? Not my job to prove your point. In fact, I did a lot of the homework in this thread the pro side. lol.

All I asked for, was proof. At least one thing. Just one shred of evidence that didn't have the word "inconclusive" in it. That was not pinned to a conspiracy theory website. That was unbiased. Well, the report you provided was on a biased website. But this place does seem rather trustworthy, and I couldnt find any dirt on this website.

1 thing though: I do wish they hadn't added their own red words, and brackets with their own comments. But it isn't terribly bad. At least they kept the whole thing intact, in it's entirety, and indicated their own thoughts.

Now, with this report, I can shift my opinion from being against any bans, to instituting some regulations. I have noted one part that showed that there was some irresponsibility on the part of the doctor and the parents:

The nurse stated that the information pamphlet normally given to parents was not given to Ryleigh's mother. The pamphlet was given only when a Plastibell circumcision procedure was performed. Ryleigh had a Gomko circumcision procedure. The Gomko procedure was rarely performed in PRH and instructions for it were not included in the pamphlet, therefore it was not offered to Ryleigh's parents. Verbal instructions were given instead.

Part of any regulations should include that the hospital MUST give information. No excuses.

Although Mrs. McWillis noted "a look of concern" on the nurse's face, she states she was never informed there was an excessive amount of bleeding on the diaper or of any other concern. Mrs. McWillis noted she was given no written or verbal instructions for Ryleigh's at-home care and that "at no time was (she) advised by the nurse that 'if further bleeding occurred, they were to contact the physician or return to the hospital' ". She has no recollection of being told to leave the Jelonet on for 48 hours after the procedure or to leave it alone
Same with above.

Part of the conclusion:
Since this incident, Penticton Regional Hospital has altered the information pamphlet given to parents regarding circumcision. The form states precisely when a parent should seek medical attention if postoperative bleeding occurs; how often the child should be voiding; and the directions for care for both Plastibell and Gomco procedures. They have also amended their policy to ensure parents are given written information regarding circumcision. PRH also has developed a follow up protocol in which parents are to telephone the pediatric unit after the surgery (at 1700 hours) and discuss their baby's feeding, wet diapers, amount of bleeding and swelling, and present any questions or concerns the parent may have. The information given and advice offered is to be documented.

Now, this is only one case, which is true that I asked for. But unfortunately, I do not think that one case is enough to convince me that an outright ban of circumcision should be done. I do believe it is enough to rectify some regulations, however.
 
I'm quite sure that i didn't say this. Provide a direct quote or retract your statement. What i said IIRC was that cutting off earlobes is slightly less harmful than cutting off foreskins. Now that you are educated on the function of the foreskin - involving protection, penetration and pleasure, it's on you to show how your left earlobe (which looks silly, btw) has a comparable value.

And if it were about disease prevention why aren't doctors removing appendics on every infant? Appendics are of no use and removing them would prevent a lot of future health issues. :rolleyes:
 
Part of any regulations should include that the hospital MUST give information. No excuses.


"This procedure has no known medical benefit, will cause your son pain and distress immediately, will reduce the pleasure he feels in sex as an adolescent and adult, may make him feel mutilated and incomplete as an adult, and may kill him."

That should about cover it.

Rolfe.
 
Right, so long as it isn't invoked in a dishonest manner. Which is exactly why I am against that term.

In any case, I am still wondering why the specific term "circumcision" is so hard to use, in order to reduce the risk of dishonesty. I really don't care that you use the word "mutilation." So long as it is used with the understanding that we are talking specifically about circumcision here. there are still people trying to make the comparison of lopping off earlobes. :D

Prove to me that amputating the earlobe is different from amputating the foreskin, and, if one is more acceptable than the other, which one and why.
 
I suppose an answer could have been as easy as that. I pretty much said the same thing, only more wordy. It only got twisted to suit the questioner's purpose. I believe it was Scum way back when he was trying to explain his logic of using three "yes/no" questions as a way to logically explain why my position is illogical.

Unfortunately, the "yes" part is dishonest as a standalone answer. You still need the qualifier of the "but...", thereby making such an exercise in logic useless. Because it is not a simple yes/no answer. Or else he asked the wrong question in the wrong way, thereby distorting the logic he was using.
The logic was impeccable. You failed to understand it.
 
What part of "religious obligations" do you not understand?

Not trying to be a smart-ass here too much. But the point is, there are religious folks who think it a religious obligation to perform circumcision. The First Amendment protects the rights of religious people to perform their religious obligations.

I fully understand where you are coming from. I honestly do. But I don't think you fully understand just how important it is to the Jews. This is the very reason why the First Amendment was written to include the "religion" clause. It serves to protect the religions, just as much as it serves to protect the atheists.

If the 1st amendment protects the rights of religious people to perform unnecessary surgery on people incapable of consenting, the 1st amendment is a ass!
 
Prove to me that amputating the earlobe is different from amputating the foreskin, and, if one is more acceptable than the other, which one and why.


I'm not convinced Nihilianth knows what an earlobe actually is, and may be thinking the suggestion is to amputate the entire pinna.

Earlobes have no significant function other than for hanging earrings from.

Rolfe.
 
I have noted one part that showed that there was some irresponsibility on the part of the doctor and the parents:

Part of any regulations should include that the hospital MUST give information. No excuses.

But unfortunately, I do not think that one case is enough to convince me that an outright ban of circumcision should be done. I do believe it is enough to rectify some regulations, however.


OMG the hospital didn't give the parents a FREAKING LEAFLET!!! As if that would have saved the baby's life!!!

WHAT DO YOU THINK MIGHT HAVE BEEN WRITTEN IN THE LEAFLET YOU THINK THEY SHOULD HAVE HAD THAT WOULD HAVE ALTERED THE OUTCOME FOR GOD'S SAKE?????

This one case isn't enough for you, even though that was what you asked for. Brian/Brenda/David Reimer was mentioned too, of course.

RECTIFY SOME REGULATIONS??? Will you just listen to yourself??? A BABY, actually DIED, in PAIN, from a COMPLETELY UNNECESSARY OPERATION. And you want to change some regulations. All you've suggested is giving the parents a freaking leaflet!!!!

Like, give them a leaflet as I outlined above, telling them the procedure might kill their baby, that might do it?

Maybe. If they have half a heart, which I question if you possess on the basis of your arguments.

Rolfe.
 
What part of "religious obligations" do you not understand?

Not trying to be a smart-ass here too much. But the point is, there are religious folks who think it a religious obligation to perform circumcision. The First Amendment protects the rights of religious people to perform their religious obligations.

I fully understand where you are coming from. I honestly do. But I don't think you fully understand just how important it is to the Jews. This is the very reason why the First Amendment was written to include the "religion" clause. It serves to protect the religions, just as much as it serves to protect the atheists.
I don't think you understand how important not letting parents kill their children is to those of us not hampered by ridiculous beliefs. So no, you don't understand where I'm coming from. Your precious First Amendment was not created to allow parents to risk the lives of their children. Hell, I'd argue that circumcising a child is impeding it's right to practice another religion in later life.
 
If the 1st amendment protects the rights of religious people to perform unnecessary surgery on people incapable of consenting, the 1st amendment is a ass!

Good thing then that it doesn't.

All it does in that respect is to make it illegal to ban a religious practice of group x on the grounds that it is a religious practice of group x.

So, it would be illegal to forbid the ritual slaughter of animals because you don't want those pesky heathens doing things their way. But you can forbid it for reasons of animal protection even if the actual consequences in both cases would be identical and result only in a religious practice being outlawed.

This is why Thunder keeps going on about discriminating Jews and Muslims: If that was the point of the exercise it would indeed be illegal to ban circumcision. But especially in the USA the practice is not predominantly religious - or at least not to the degree it would be elsewhere. It doesn't even make sense to assume it was targeting religion here. (If there was a law that made it illegal for Rabbis and Imams specifically to perform circumcisions but allowed it everyone else things would be different.)
 
(If there was a law that made it illegal for Rabbis and Imams specifically to perform circumcisions but allowed it everyone else things would be different.)

(But not, of course, if there was a law that made it illegal for anyone without a recognised medical qualification to perform circumcisions.)

Dave
 
lol, you people are unbelievable. I am not going to respond to every single post up to this point.

You all have failed the test in giving me proof that there should be an outright ban. I had one case, with one coroner's report to go on. Whoopdee damn doo.

Now, unless you give some statistics and actual hard proof done by a respected organization that isn't "inconclusive," you have no reason to pass a prohibition against something which is protected in the Constitution.

Until such time as the proof comes, I shall not be coming back to this thread any longer. Good day! :)
 
You all have failed the test in giving me proof that there should be an outright ban.

You realise that this is standard woo procedure, don't you? "Prove me that you're right; sorry, I'm not convinced by your proof, therefore I win." Since you've never given an objective standard of proof, your declaration of victory is worthless.

Until such time as the proof comes, I shall not be coming back to this thread any longer.

Then how will you know it's been posted?

Dave
 
(But not, of course, if there was a law that made it illegal for anyone without a recognised medical qualification to perform circumcisions.)

Dave

Exactly.

And of course the law could go further and demand sound medical reasons or a patient who was able to give informed consent to the procedure.
 
No, he means the doctor could refuse to do the procedure unless there was either a sound medical indication, or the patient was able to give informed consent to the procedure.

Sounds like a damn good idea to me. Not gonna happen so long as there are Jewish and Arab doctors, for a start.

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom