Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Once again: The first amendment does not mean that the voices in your head carry any weight whatsoever in a legal debate.

You continue to utterly, utterly misunderstand what the amendment means and how it is applied.

Apparently, it is the other way around. You are the one that has the burden of proof, in order to end a religious practice.

And continuing to offend those who believe in something does nothing for your image.

And yes, your religion most certainly DOES carry quite a bit of weight in a legal debate, because of the First Amendment protections of said religions. (an non-religions.)

You seem all hung up on the fact that you don't like religions and how they operate. This, based on your rude remarks towards same. But what you seem to fail to realize, the very same protections afforded the right to freely practice once's religion, affords you the right to not be forced to practice a religion against your will.

And invoking the argument, once again, that the government can restrict religious practices is a non-starter. We have been through this already, FAR more times than I care to even estimate. You invoke that argument, and I invoke the argument that libel/slander are also illegal. That doesn't mean that the WBC can't protest at funerals.

Just because it is illegal to offer human sacrifices, and chop off limbs, does not mean that circumcision should likewise be illegal without conclusive statistical harm done.

Now, you do have proof that it can cause harm. Even death in one or two cases out of a million. So maybe regulations should be instituted.
 
I understand you think it is for aesthetic reasons. I can even agree to seeing a ban for non-religious reasons. But I would hardly call Judaism and Islam "fringe religions." In fact, Islam is the second largest religion in the world, and I think that Judaism is the third.

As accurate as so many other things you "think". Judaism is a very minor religion by world standards.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Major_religious_groups

Now about that those christian sects which practice circumcision as a rite..........
 
I don't know why you are putting scare quotes around FGM; I have, in the course of this discussion, been extremely careful to use the neutral language you requested and have exclusively referred to circumcision on boys rather than mutilation. However, there isn't a neutral term for what is done to some infant girls in the name of religion and culture, and FGM is understood to encompass a wide range of mutilations from minor cuts to major alterations. If you have a different term which you would prefer, you have only to suggest it and I will give your request consideration.

Ok, I can accept the term "FGM" in regards to female "circumcision." I will say that I don't necessarily have a problem with the term "MGM," either, so long as it is being used honestly and consistently. I just want to make sure the conversation stays on track according to the OP. If you are uncomfortable in calling it "circumcision," because you are so disgusted with the practice, I don't have a problem with you saying "MGM." I only have a problem when and if it is used dishonestly, as I have demonstrated that it is easy to do so. IMHO, I just think that there is no reason that "circumcision" cannot be used in a neutral and precise manner so that everyone knows exactly what you are talking about.

I can quite see that you would wish for their to be no equivalence between FGM and circumcision, but in point of fact the similarities are such that there is an equivalence.

In both cases the surgery is performed for reasons of religion and culture. In both cases the surgery carries a risk to the life and health of the person on whom it is performed. In both cases the people on whom the surgery is performed are almost always infants and children who are incapable of consent, and who have not made a decision for themselves about what if any religion they intend to follow as adults. In both cases, many of the people who request the surgery on their infants do so because they believe there is a religious obligation on them to do so. In both cases the surgery is permanent and has consequences for the child for the rest of their lives.

The only difference, qualitatively, is that it is illegal to perform such surgery on girls (except where medically necessary) and it is not illegal to perform such surgery on boys.

I can see the point in the similarities. However, you only listed the similarities. When looking at the inherent differences, it does indeed appear that FGM is far more harmful, and carries far greater risks than circumcision. At least, as far as I am able to ascertain from what I have read thus far.
 
Last edited:
I understand you think it is for aesthetic reasons. I can even agree to seeing a ban for non-religious reasons. But I would hardly call Judaism and Islam "fringe religions." In fact, Islam is the second largest religion in the world, and I think that Judaism is the third.

It is not a matter of opinion but a matter of fact that it is for aesthetic reasons. It is done to change the appearance of the penis. Whether people think god wants it changed or they just fancy it themselves doesn't matter.
However many people subscribe to the particular superstition is of no relevance. If it is wrong for one person to do it, it is wrong for 1 million people.
 
And it was a pretty moving piece of literature. Moving enough to change my stance to seeing more regulations, and perhaps an outright ban on non-religious circumcisions.

I cannot believe you are saying this: you would accept a ban on circumcision for non-religious fashion reasons (I am giving you the benefit of the doubt and assuming you would not ban it for medical reasons), but it is still okay to risk babies for religious fashion.
 
please note post number 1247. This argument about "FGM" is a strawman.

No it is not. You show an impressive misunderstanding of logical fallacies.
The argument about FGM (quotes noted and deleted) is entirely relevant if you could only grasp it.
 
But what you seem to fail to realize, the very same protections afforded the right to freely practice once's religion, affords you the right to not be forced to practice a religion against your will.
Unless you have the misfortune to be an infant boy, circumcised and permanently marked as a member of a religion that you may not want to follow as an adult.
And invoking the argument, once again, that the government can restrict religious practices is a non-starter. We have been through this already, FAR more times than I care to even estimate. You invoke that argument, and I invoke the argument that libel/slander are also illegal. That doesn't mean that the WBC can't protest at funerals.
Free speech is restricted in some circumstances (shouting fire in a crowded theatre) where it is shown that the harm resulting from the free speech is greater than the harm of restricting it.

IMO, infant circumcisions should fall exactly into the same category; the harm it does to some babies and the risks it carries should mean it should be restricted to occasions where it is medically indicated or where a consenting adult requests the procedure. I do not feel a ban is indicated because adults should have the right to do what they wish with their own bodies, and sometimes circumcision is medically indicated. It should not be a procedure that is undertaken on an infant without compelling medical reason.
 
No it is not. You show an impressive misunderstanding of logical fallacies.
The argument about FGM (quotes noted and deleted) is entirely relevant if you could only grasp it.

No. It is not. Because you would be making the straw man of comparing apples to oranges. Similarities between the two? There are some. But the differences are far greater.
 
I understand you think it is for aesthetic reasons. I can even agree to seeing a ban for non-religious reasons. But I would hardly call Judaism and Islam "fringe religions." In fact, Islam is the second largest religion in the world, and I think that Judaism is the third.

This isn't about the world. This is about the United States, specifically California.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_the_United_States#Main_religious_preferences_of_Americans
"Christianity: (76%[4] to 82.3%[13])
Unaffiliated, including atheist or agnostic (11.6%[13] to 16.1%[12])
Judaism (1.2%[4] to 2.2%[13])
Islam (0.6%[4][5][6][13] to 2.6%[14])"

1.8-4.8% is fringe.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_California#Religion
Jewish – 2%
Muslim – 1%

3% is fringe.

But all this is irrelevant. The First Amendment is not a free license to perform inhumane acts. As kerikiwi makes clear, circumcision is aesthetic whether it's because you think it looks good or you think god thinks it looks good. It's unnecessary in a medical sense, the only one that matters. It's permanent. It's performed on an unwilling individual. It's painful, with inherent risks. It's performed in a great majority of cases purely by tradition.

There is no reason to continue allowing it.
 
it does indeed appear that FGM is far more harmful, and carries far greater risks than circumcision.

To which type of FGM are you referring?
You do know, do you not, that there are varying levels of severity from the almost totally inconsequential to the barely describable?
And how's that list of christian sects which practise circumcision?

You are wrong in so many things...
 
No. It is not. Because you would be making the straw man of comparing apples to oranges. Similarities between the two? There are some. But the differences are far greater.

Really? What are the different reasons for practising the two?
I thought your whole argument was based on religious freedom?
 
Unless you have the misfortune to be an infant boy, circumcised and permanently marked as a member of a religion that you may not want to follow as an adult.

This comes down to parents' rights to do what they think is best for their child, then.

Free speech is restricted in some circumstances (shouting fire in a crowded theatre) where it is shown that the harm resulting from the free speech is greater than the harm of restricting it.

And that is exactly why I was invoking those arguments, when people bring up "but what about the restrictions on human sacrifice, or FGM?"

IMO, infant circumcisions should fall exactly into the same category; the harm it does to some babies and the risks it carries should mean it should be restricted to occasions where it is medically indicated or where a consenting adult requests the procedure. I do not feel a ban is indicated because adults should have the right to do what they wish with their own bodies, and sometimes circumcision is medically indicated. It should not be a procedure that is undertaken on an infant without compelling medical reason.

And this is where we seem to have to agree to disagree. I can certainly agree to restrictions on circumcisions, with regulations for those who do it for religious purposes. I disagree that the harm, when done in a clinically professional environment, causes enough harm to outright ban a required religious practice.
 
This isn't about the world. This is about the United States, specifically California.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_the_United_States#Main_religious_preferences_of_Americans
"Christianity: (76%[4] to 82.3%[13])
Unaffiliated, including atheist or agnostic (11.6%[13] to 16.1%[12])
Judaism (1.2%[4] to 2.2%[13])
Islam (0.6%[4][5][6][13] to 2.6%[14])"

1.8-4.8% is fringe.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_California#Religion
Jewish – 2%
Muslim – 1%

3% is fringe.

But all this is irrelevant. The First Amendment is not a free license to perform inhumane acts. As kerikiwi makes clear, circumcision is aesthetic whether it's because you think it looks good or you think god thinks it looks good. It's unnecessary in a medical sense, the only one that matters. It's permanent. It's performed on an unwilling individual. It's painful, with inherent risks. It's performed in a great majority of cases purely by tradition.

There is no reason to continue allowing it.

No, I would have to say that Native American religions, and Scientology, are fringe. But even so, they still have rights under the Second Amendment. 2% out of 300 million is still quite a lot of people.

And the bolded, once again, is being a rude remark bordering on discounting someone's belief, just because you think they are stupid or something. What if the majority of people in this country who were religious (Christians constitutes the majority) decided to take it upon themselves to keep atheists from doing something? Or worse, to force them to do something? Since atheists are outnumbered, they could very easily be viewed as being morons for not believing in something, and to discount your belief in science as being "the fringe" or not mattering at all.

Too bad the whole reason why the First Amendment was written, was in order to prevent such things from happening in the first place. Just because you think these religious folks are all cracked up on some kind of crazy god-high, doesn't mean their opinions do not matter, and they shouldn't have rights to protect themselves against a tyranny of atheists.

Now, I can agree that it is performed on a great majority of cases for tradition, as that point has been proven. But for the minority of cases of which it is performed for religious reasons still doesn't take away the First Amendment, and parents' rights.
 
Really? What are the different reasons for practising the two?
I thought your whole argument was based on religious freedom?

Listen, this will be the very first time I "scream (use all caps on here):

I AM NOT TALKING ABOUT DIFFERENCES BETWEEN PRACTICES!!

I am TALKING about differences in the risks and harmful effects!

Are you seriously ignorant of what I have said, truly not understanding my arguments, or are you being a troll? I would really like an honest answer, so I know not to waste any more time.
 
Ok, I can accept the term "FGM" in regards to female "circumcision." I will say that I don't necessarily have a problem with the term "MGM," either, so long as it is being used honestly and consistently. I just want to make sure the conversation stays on track according to the OP. If you are uncomfortable in calling it "circumcision," because you are so disgusted with the practice, I don't have a problem with you saying "MGM." I only have a problem when and if it is used dishonestly, as I have demonstrated that it is easy to do so. IMHO, I just think that there is no reason that "circumcision" cannot be used in a neutral and precise manner so that everyone knows exactly what you are talking about.
Where did I suggest I was uncomfortable in using the word circumcision? It's a meaningful term for what is done to infant boys, there isn't an equivalent term for what is done to infant girls.

I can see the point in the similarities. However, you only listed the similarities. When looking at the inherent differences, it does indeed appear that FGM is far more harmful, and carries far greater risks than circumcision. At least, as far as I am able to ascertain from what I have read thus far.
Some levels of FGM are more harmful than circumcision; some are arguably less harmful. But as (I think) kerikiwi stated earlier, that the cutting off of a head is more severe than the chopping off of a limb doesn't make the amputation of limbs any less illegal if done without a compelling medical reason.

Perhaps you could show what these claimed differences are (other than in terms of the different biological nature of an infant girl's genitals and and infant boy's) between circumcision and (to make it fair) the least invasive of FGM procedures, type 1a?

From Wiki:
The WHO defines Type I FGM as the partial or total removal of the clitoris (clitoridectomy) and/or the prepuce (clitoral hood); see Diagram 1B. When it is important to distinguish between the variations of Type I cutting, the following subdivisions are proposed: Type Ia, removal of the clitoral hood or prepuce only (which some view as analogous to male circumcision and thus more acceptable); Type Ib, removal of the clitoris with the prepuce.[24]
 
Are you seriously ignorant of what I have said, truly not understanding my arguments, or are you being a troll? I would really like an honest answer, so I know not to waste any more time.


Your arguments were torn apart on the first pages of this thread, yet you continue to repeat them as if nothing has happened. If anyone is trolling here, it's you.

I asked you to produce a quote of the words you put in my mouth.
 
No. It is not. Because you would be making the straw man of comparing apples to oranges. Similarities between the two? There are some. But the differences are far greater.
They're both expressions of religions. I thought congress couldn't pass laws against the free exercise of religion?
 
This comes down to parents' rights to do what they think is best for their child, then.


How should the boundaries of what they are allowed to do be set?

Why not compete infibulation, if the parents think that will get the girl a rich husband? What if parents believe that their boy's best career choice would be as a male soprano opera singer?

They sincerely believe these modifications are minor, trivial, and will be in the best interests of the child.

Are you going to prevent them doing what they think is best for their child, then?

Rolfe.
 
I kind of think about circumcision in the same way I think about abortion. I would rather it not happen but I'm not going to make it illegal.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom