Ban circumcision in San Fran???

It is not a matter of opinion but a matter of fact that it is for aesthetic reasons. It is done to change the appearance of the penis. Whether people think god wants it changed or they just fancy it themselves doesn't matter.
However many people subscribe to the particular superstition is of no relevance. If it is wrong for one person to do it, it is wrong for 1 million people.

It is not for aesthetic reasons if done within Jewish or Islamic law. And to suggest otherwise is either dishonest, or you truly have no idea what the opposing viewpoint really is.

It is really no different than religious people plugging their ears when it comes to science.
 
What are these differences between male infant circumcision and type 1a FGM? Elaborate instead of shouting, then maybe your point will be grasped.
 
Where did I suggest I was uncomfortable in using the word circumcision? It's a meaningful term for what is done to infant boys, there isn't an equivalent term for what is done to infant girls.

I guess I must be confusing you with most other people. They seem rather uncomfortable using the term.

Some levels of FGM are more harmful than circumcision; some are arguably less harmful. But as (I think) kerikiwi stated earlier, that the cutting off of a head is more severe than the chopping off of a limb doesn't make the amputation of limbs any less illegal if done without a compelling medical reason.

That is true. But luckily for us, I am not defending the cutting off of limbs. ;)

Perhaps you could show what these claimed differences are (other than in terms of the different biological nature of an infant girl's genitals and and infant boy's) between circumcision and (to make it fair) the least invasive of FGM procedures, type 1a?

I'll look it up again soon.

From Wiki:
The WHO defines Type I FGM as the partial or total removal of the clitoris (clitoridectomy) and/or the prepuce (clitoral hood); see Diagram 1B. When it is important to distinguish between the variations of Type I cutting, the following subdivisions are proposed: Type Ia, removal of the clitoral hood or prepuce only (which some view as analogous to male circumcision and thus more acceptable); Type Ib, removal of the clitoris with the prepuce.[24]

Nevermind, you provided it here. Note the bolded: Who claims this, and what studies have they done?
 
Your arguments were torn apart on the first pages of this thread, yet you continue to repeat them as if nothing has happened. If anyone is trolling here, it's you.

I asked you to produce a quote of the words you put in my mouth.

No. Go back to the post that you just now quoted. You will notice that kerikiwi who is only taking into consideration the SIMILARITIES. Thus far, nobody wants to discuss the differences between circumcision and FGM. Why?

There most CERTAINLY must be something to it if circumcision is not banned in very many countries at all, including most Western democracies, and yet FGM is banned in nearly all. Must be something that is different that makes most nations ban one, but not the other.

And no, it has not been torn apart the first few pages. Not by a long shot. I have looked on many health organizations' websites that any studies into the harm caused are inconclusive. They all seem to suggest pretty much the same things about circumcision: Not to ban it, but the doctors should provide unbiased facts about benefits and risks, and to stay out of familiar affairs.

Unless you want to make the claim that there is a huge conspiracy theory with the health organizations such as WHO, the AMA, and so forth.
 
How should the boundaries of what they are allowed to do be set?

Why not compete infibulation, if the parents think that will get the girl a rich husband? What if parents believe that their boy's best career choice would be as a male soprano opera singer?

They sincerely believe these modifications are minor, trivial, and will be in the best interests of the child.

Are you going to prevent them doing what they think is best for their child, then?

Rolfe.

A world of straw. I already covered these point in my appeal to civility several pages ago.
 
Nevermind, you provided it here. Note the bolded: Who claims this, and what studies have they done?

If I understand your question correctly, the structures (male and female) are homologous:


NSFW:
In female human anatomy, the clitoral hood, (also called preputium clitoridis and clitoral prepuce), is a fold of skin that surrounds and protects the clitoral glans. It develops as part of the labia minora and is homologous with the foreskin (equally called prepuce) in male genitals.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clitoral_hood
 
I kind of think about circumcision in the same way I think about abortion. I would rather it not happen but I'm not going to make it illegal.

Rght, that's pretty much my position as well at this point.

I would like to know what the position that some of these people have on abortion? I would bet that most people who are opposing me in this thread probably are all for women's right to choose. Which would seem to be quite hypocritical, if you really think about it.
 
A world of straw. I already covered these point in my appeal to civility several pages ago.


You're sadly mistaken in your dismissal of "straw". And if you think I'm being uncivil, by all means report me.

You haven't even begun to take on board the fact that other people are just as horrified by what you want to do to helpless babies as you are by these other procedures. You haven't even begun to take on board the fact that the people who want to carry out these other procedures sincerely believe they are minor matters not worth getting concerned about, and are convinced they're doing the best for their child.

You breeze through this thread as if your opinion is somehow sacrosanct and correct, and you can dismiss those who want more extensive mutilations as barbarians while at the same time dismiss those who see you as a barbarian as over-reacting. Your insularity is breathtaking.

If you are allowed to decide what to do to your child, then anyone else should logically be allowed to decide what to do to their children. If all that matters is the opinion of the parents. The minute you admit that an outside party should step in and prevent the infibulation or the castration, you immediately, logically, concede that your own preferred mutilation should be subject to outside judgement as to whether it is appropriate.

This is what you have been sidestepping and ignoring for pages now, and no amount of shouting "straw" will change that.

There are many many people who regard what you want to allow as pure barbarism. Why should their opinions not be imposed on you in just the same way as similar opinions are imposed on other groups?

Rolfe.
 
If I understand your question correctly, the structures (male and female) are homologous:


NSFW:
In female human anatomy, the clitoral hood, (also called preputium clitoridis and clitoral prepuce), is a fold of skin that surrounds and protects the clitoral glans. It develops as part of the labia minora and is homologous with the foreskin (equally called prepuce) in male genitals.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clitoral_hood

Nah, not the differences between the organs. I meant the differences in the risks and harm done between circumcision, and FGM.
 
I would like to know what the position that some of these people have on abortion? I would bet that most people who are opposing me in this thread probably are all for women's right to choose. Which would seem to be quite hypocritical, if you really think about it.


And you accuse others of erecting straw men?

:id:

Rolfe.
 
Nah, not the differences between the organs. I meant the differences in the risks and harm done between circumcision, and FGM.


I am not an expert, but it seems likely that removal of the clitoral prepuce is significantly less invasive than removal of the penile prepuce.

Rolfe.
 
Rght, that's pretty much my position as well at this point.

I would like to know what the position that some of these people have on abortion? I would bet that most people who are opposing me in this thread probably are all for women's right to choose. Which would seem to be quite hypocritical, if you really think about it.

No, it wouldn't.

See, in an abortion, the woman understands the consequences. She gets to choose what happens to her own body. What you're arguing for is someone else getting to choose to perform an utterly pointless surgical procedure on a child who neither understands or even knows what is happening to them, and cannot make any choices.

Societies should be judged by how they treat their most vulnerable members, and a newborn infant is one heck of a vulnerable member of that society. To make a permanent, pointless aesthetic change to said child before the child can even understand what is going on is a really twisted thing to do, whether it's circumcision, aesthetic dental surgery or ear piercing. Once the child has grown enough to be able to make their own decisions they should be told all the necessary information and can then make an informed choice.
 
And you accuse others of erecting straw men?

:id:

Rolfe.

Oh, I knew it was a straw man, and I freely admit to such. So? Doesn't mean I can't poke holes into your character in an informal setting. Earlier you accused me of being inconsistent. Well, I happen to find pro-abortion to be inconsistent with unfounded worries of circumcision. :)
 
I am not an expert, but it seems likely that removal of the clitoral prepuce is significantly less invasive than removal of the penile prepuce.

Rolfe.

Well, that's what I want to find out. Anything more significant than "Many claim....?"
 
It is not for aesthetic reasons if done within Jewish or Islamic law. And to suggest otherwise is either dishonest, or you truly have no idea what the opposing viewpoint really is.

It is really no different than religious people plugging their ears when it comes to science.

I would suggest you truly have no idea what 'aesthetic' means.
I know what the 'opposing viewpoint' is. They believe a god wants them to change the appearance of perfectly normal, healthy penises.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom