Ban circumcision in San Fran???

This was the sentence you used in the post that I quoted:

"He seems to be going to bat for people of religions other than his own."

I was merely asking you if it should matter. I do believe in God, but no way in the world would I want atheists' First Amendment rights to be violated in any way.


You assumed I was criticising you for going to bat for other people's religions. I expressed no criticism, I merely want to be clear about the position.

Well, I do apologize for making the assumption that you are an atheist. I just assumed you were, because you used the term "sky-daddy" in the post that I quoted. I think that is a rather derogatory way of expressing the word "God/god."


If you read for comprehension, you might have noticed that I was quoting another poster, albeit without the quote marks.

Since you cannot believe that there are Catholics, and break-away Amish, and so forth who circumcise based on their belief in the covenant between God and Abraham, I have dropped the argument for Christians a long time ago. I just don't feel that is a very constructive conversation to have, for it has nothing to do with the OP. The fact that there are other religions (Judaism, and Islam) that do practice the custom because of their belief system does not at all change the inherent nature of what I am arguing.


Like everyone else, I'm waiting for evidence about these Catholics who perform circumcision for religious reasons. As someone else said, does the Pope know?

Rolfe.
 
This paragraph kind of makes me chuckle.:
Physicians regularly give parents information favoring circumcision, but rarely provide instructions on how to care for the intact penis. Furnishing parents with this knowledge would alleviate their anxiety concerning a body part unfamiliar to them (Bollinger, 2008). All medical textbooks and parenting guides should include intact-care information and mention death as a possible outcome.

Really? A penis is unfamiliar to parents? I don;t think they really are fit to be parents, if such a common body part is unfamiliar to them lol.
I think it is possible that you may have misread this paragraph; it's talking about an intact penis being unfamiliar to [some] parents in a culture where circumcision has been a societal norm, and that parents should be given advice on how to promote good hygiene with their sons if an intact penis is outwith their experience.
 
You assumed I was criticising you for going to bat for other people's religions. I expressed no criticism, I merely want to be clear about the position.




If you read for comprehension, you might have noticed that I was quoting another poster, albeit without the quote marks.

OH! LOL! My fault! Sorry bout that. I got ya. :)




Like everyone else, I'm waiting for evidence about these Catholics who perform circumcision for religious reasons. As someone else said, does the Pope know?

Rolfe.

It's not like break away Amish, and other brethren groups and Catholics in my area publish books on it or anything. And if there are such groups who do it in Pennsylvania, I am sure there are others across the nation.
 
I think it is possible that you may have misread this paragraph; it's talking about an intact penis being unfamiliar to [some] parents in a culture where circumcision has been a societal norm, and that parents should be given advice on how to promote good hygiene with their sons if an intact penis is outwith their experience.

Phew! ok. I was gonna say. Had me kinda scared there for a while. :D
 
Where did these priests train, I wonder? What are they teaching their flocks? Does the Vatican know about this?

You know, you haven't a clue.

ETA: I'm not a Catholic, but to the best of my belief Catholicism is pretty centralised and prescriptive. You don't get to choose to introduce major doctrinal initiatives unilaterally. And circumcision as a religious obligation is about as major a doctrinal initiative as I can think of.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
What about for religious reasons? I suppose being an atheist will probably have you say "religious people are irrational." Rationality is no reason to prohibit a religious practice.

...snip...

Medical procedures should be carried out for medical reasons only.


Now, with the female circumcision situation that has been banned in the USA, was First Amendment rights invoked? If so, did anyone bring a suit against either a state, or federal government, or any other agency after said law went into effect? If they had, what was the judgement in such a case?

I have no idea.

You may not be interested in providing incontrovertible, unbiased, purely scientific proof that infants do, indeed, die or are in some way totally incapacitated due to circumcision. But that is the only thing which will satisfy the case I am making in defense of the First Amendment.

No it isn't.
 
AH! But they did, indeed, define the term "mutilation."

Nobody in here has yet done so. This was the closest definition I have seen yet.

...snip...

I would use the same type of definition as they used for female genital mutilation - as can be seen in the post I quoted the actual legislation the law doesn't seem to have the problem you do with such definitions.
 
How many infants? Because even if you dispute the 117 deaths due to circumcision in the US asserted earlier in the thread, or you dispute the statistics given earlier about a greater incidence of UTIs, the damage done to David Reimer due to a botched circumcision is incontrovertible. If one isn't enough, how many infants is acceptable collateral damage?
 
And the "harm" you are talking about is rather quite minimal at most.
If it were demonstrated that circumcising babies(done for religious reasons) was sufficiently harmful, would you be in favor of banning it?

edit: and if so, why?
 
Last edited:
...snip...
Someone asks you this question:

"Do you think that male genital mutilation is fine?"

How would you answer this question, if you had to defend the position that circumcision is OK? Would you think this is an honest question? Would you think that is an honest term to use?

Circumcision is a mutilation, it may be one that society accepts but that does not change what it is when it is carried out for non-medical reasons.

I would have thought a simple answer for someone who is for circumcision would be "Yes but only to the extent of a circumcision".
 
Where did these priests train, I wonder? What are they teaching their flocks? Does the Vatican know about this?

You know, you haven't a clue.

ETA: I'm not a Catholic, but to the best of my belief Catholicism is pretty centralised and prescriptive. You don't get to choose to introduce major doctrinal initiatives unilaterally. And circumcision as a religious obligation is about as major a doctrinal initiative as I can think of.

Rolfe.

And although the RCC is very practised at changing its mind whilst saying it hasn't it seems very unlikely that they would have gone from outlawing circumcision to making it a matter of doctrine.
 
I doubt that as that would heretical (unless it was Roman Catholic doctrine).


Yes, that's what I've been saying for pages now. I strongly suspect any RC priest counselling his flock that circumcision of their male infants was a religious obligation would find himself being forcibly re-educated with extreme prejudice.

Nihilianth seems to have begun his participation in this thread under some major misapprehensions with respect to the teachings of his own religious faith. I hope once he's had time to reflect he'll think about how much he has learned in these pages.

Rolfe.
 
If it were demonstrated that circumcising babies(done for religious reasons) was sufficiently harmful, would you be in favor of banning it?

edit: and if so, why?

if it was indeed a fact that even 5% of baby-boy circumcisions were indeed causing harm and had serious complications, I would support it being regulated by the gov.

but since this is not the case, I see no reason to ban the practise.
 
if it was indeed a fact that even 5% of baby-boy circumcisions were indeed causing harm and had serious complications, I would support it being regulated by the gov.

but since this is not the case, I see no reason to ban the practise.

You make it sound as if 5% would be a miniscule rate.
5% would be absolutely appallingly bad.
 
5% would be unconscionable. I think the figure I saw on the way past somewhere was about 0.35% complications of some sort.

Still doubleplus ungood.

Rolfe.
 
So what is the magic number of deaths or complications at which an unnecessary surgical procedure on newborns becomes unacceptable? I'd have thought it would be 1.
 
You make it sound as if 5% would be a miniscule rate.
5% would be absolutely appallingly bad.

Were you expecting any sort of reasonable standard?

Operating on a appendicitis carries a < 0.001% risk of death, and only goes up to 1% if the appendix is ruptured before operating. (German Wikipedia)

Now, this is for actual surgery on infected organs in a non-critical case. He's expecting a 500% increase in risk before it matters.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom