Ban circumcision in San Fran???

I actually stopped by my mother's house for lunch and casually mentioned this topic (maybe not fitting conversation to have over soup?). She mentioned she had me circumcised because A) I was [raised] Catholic (and that's what has always been done in our family) and B) it's easier to clean.

Do Catholics even know that they don't have to do it?
Probably better over soup than sausages. :duck:
 
http://www.faqs.org/periodicals/201004/2026622071.html

Medically speaking the major risks are

1. Exsanguination. The penis bleeds painlessly. The baby seems normal and the use of diapers can absorb a lot of blood. What is minor blood loss to us is fatal to a baby.

2. Infection. Fairly common cause of death in foreign countries. MRSA cases have been seen, the cause is not the circumcision but the circumcision helped.

3. Surgical Mishaps (Whoops!!!)

4. Anaesthetic death. ANY anaesthesia carries risk. Babies especially. It's a pointless risk.

The causes of death are very rarely the circumcision itself (Around 1/500,000 hospital related deaths) because doctors often catch the bleed quickly. You wouldn't trust a guy whose only qualifications are wicked beard and knowledge of really old book with your surgery right? Yet they are the ones who do the procedure resulting in deaths and those are harder to classify since they don't keep records of how many circumcisions they do. But the other causes of death are really obvious and go down in the appropriate slot of secondary infection, anaesthetic related death and medical error.

It has been postulated as one of the reasons as to why the US has a higher infant mortality rate than equivalent european nations despite having similar socio economic status as a nation. It's a common elective that has a sufficient amount of risks done for ***** and giggles (yes that is a medical term... :)). Even for phimosis I would rather prescribe steroid cream rather than that. Only UTI infections in the mentally ill would require the surgery outright if they cannot understand the instruction. Or if the phimosis is severe enough to cause fusion.

ok, after reading through the article, there are many problems with the conclusions:

About 1 .3 million boys are circumcised each year in the United States (HCUP, 2007); however, the number of boys who died from those surgeries has not been reported or estimated in any credible way. Some reasons include record-keeping practices, indifference, and- no doubt- concerns about liability.

The bolded is purely speculative. Perhaps it is due to record-keeping practices? The very next paragraph talks very briefly about how death certificates are incomplete, or inaccurate. Unfortunately, I do not have that publication.

This paragraph kind of makes me chuckle.:

Physicians regularly give parents information favoring circumcision, but rarely provide instructions on how to care for the intact penis. Furnishing parents with this knowledge would alleviate their anxiety concerning a body part unfamiliar to them (Bollinger, 2008). All medical textbooks and parenting guides should include intact-care information and mention death as a possible outcome.

Really? A penis is unfamiliar to parents? I don;t think they really are fit to be parents, if such a common body part is unfamiliar to them lol.

And one more quote, for fear of posting too much of the article in this post:

It is reasonable to conclude that about 117 circumcision-related deaths occur each year in the United States- approximately 1 out of every 77 male neonatal deaths- and that thousands of boys have died since this practice was first medicalized 160 years ago. These boys died because physicians have been either complicit or duplicitous, and because parents ignorantly said "Yes," or lacked the courage to say "No." Every one of these boys would have had a chance at life had he not been circumcised. Circumcision can no longer be called either a beneficial surgery or a beneficent rite of passage, but by its true designation: an unrecognized sacrifice of innocents.

Makes it more than obvious that this particular source is biased. The bolded, once again, is speculative. In fact, the entire conclusion is one big speculative piece. And obviously considering it to be an "unrecognized sacrifice of innocents" is not exactly the most accurate thing in the world to state:

wiki said:
Sacrifice is the offering of food, objects or the lives of animals or people to the gods as an act of propitiation or worship.

While sacrifice often implies ritual killing, the term offering (Latin oblatio) can be used for bloodless sacrifices of cereal food or artifacts. For offerings of liquids (beverages) by pouring, the term libation is used.

A "sacrifice" is something which is purposely given up. Obviously, circumcision is not a ritual mean to purposely give up the life of a young child. Indeed, the article even admits that the health organizations talk about just how inconclusive it is.
 
I'm not interested in making those types of arguments; I would rather just argue for the stopping of medical procedures which are not carried out for medical reasons. And that is already pretty much established in countries like the USA & UK but there are just a few exceptions left that allow medical procedures to be undertaken for irrational reasons. Male genital mutilation is one of them and since female genital mutilation has been stopped (by making it illegal in countries like the USA) there is already a precedent in place for such a change no matter what irrational reasons some parents may have for wanting their child to undergo a non-medically indicated medical procedure.

What about for religious reasons? I suppose being an atheist will probably have you say "religious people are irrational." Rationality is no reason to prohibit a religious practice.

Now, with the female circumcision situation that has been banned in the USA, was First Amendment rights invoked? If so, did anyone bring a suit against either a state, or federal government, or any other agency after said law went into effect? If they had, what was the judgement in such a case?

You may not be interested in providing incontrovertible, unbiased, purely scientific proof that infants do, indeed, die or are in some way totally incapacitated due to circumcision. But that is the only thing which will satisfy the case I am making in defense of the First Amendment.
 
You are mistaken - there is already precedent for it in the USA where female genital mutilation has been criminalised.

Did they define that term in the law? Did they include the word "circumcision" anywhere within the defined term?
 
In his case, it isn't even an invisible sky daddy. His religoin does not mandate circumcision, and indeed banned the practice until quite recently. He seems to be going to bat for people of religions other than his own.

Rolfe.

So, defending the rights of religious people that have nothing to do with my religion shouldn't be done? Does that mean that I should not defend your right to NOT be told by society what religious practice you must do, even though you are of a "non-religious faith?"

Does that mean I cannot defend the rights of free speech for the WBC, even though I literally HATE their message with all of my heart?

I would hardly think that should matter.
 
I am still waiting for the proof that earlobe cutting is exactly the same as circumcision. I am waiting for the proof that there is a religion that cuts off ears of their newborns. I am waiting for the confirmed reports that circumcisions are the direct cause of deaths.

1. Of course it's not: it's an ear!!
2. My religion prsecribes the amputation of the left ear lobe. Why is my religion less worthy than any other religion?
3. Are you seriously claiming that no deaths have ever resulted from circumcisions?
4. How are we doing with the list of Christian sects...?
 
And here is an example, doesn't seem to be bothered by claims that mutilation is too subjective, that the supreme court couldn't deal with it and so on:



I would say it would be even easier to create a similar definition for male genital mutilation.

AH! But they did, indeed, define the term "mutilation."

Nobody in here has yet done so. This was the closest definition I have seen yet.

So, going WAY back to the early part of this thread, where someone asked me the infamous question:

"So, do you think male genital mutilation is ok?"

I asked for the term to be defined, and to narrow down what the person meant by the term "mutilation." I got no response to this, and only received obfuscation and spin tactics instead. It is not like I am asking dishonest questions here. I am being 100% forthright when I ask a specific question, in order to have better clarification on what you mean.

Of course, if you include taking a "cheese grater and shredding the penis, circumcision, or total destruction of the penis by any other means" as your definition, that does not help anything a whole lot either, especially in regards to the question of whether or not you think "mutilation" is ok.
 
Did they define that term in the law? Did they include the word "circumcision" anywhere within the defined term?

I believe this is the law in the US:

Title 18 – Crimes and Criminal Procedure

Part I - Crimes

Chapter 7 - Assault

Section 116 - Female genital mutilation

(a) Except as provided in subsection (b), whoever knowingly circumcises, excises, or infibulates the whole or any part of the labia majora or labia minora or clitoris of another person who has not attained the age of 18 years shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than 5 years, or both. (b) A surgical operation is not a violation of this section if the operation is--
(1) necessary to the health of the person on whom it is performed, and is performed by a person licensed in the place of its performance as a medical practitioner; or
(2) performed on a person in labor or who has just given birth and is performed for medical purposes connected with that labor or birth by a person licensed in the place it is performed as a medical practitioner, midwife, or person in training to become such a practitioner or midwife.

(c) In applying subsection (b)(1), no account shall be taken of the effect on the person on whom the operation is to be performed of any belief on the part of that person, or any other person, that the operation is required as a matter of custom or ritual.

(Added Pub. L. 104-208, div. C, title VI, Sec. 645(b)(1), Sept. 30, 1996, 110 Stat. 3009-709.)

http://www.mgmbill.org/usfgmlaw.htm
 
Did they define that term in the law? Did they include the word "circumcision" anywhere within the defined term?

Why would the term 'circumcision' be used when referring to female genital mutilation, of any degree?
That's a bit rich coming from someone who has been lecturing us on the precise use of language and how mutilation cannot be used when referring to circumcision.
 
I asked for the term to be defined, and to narrow down what the person meant by the term "mutilation." I got no response to this, and only received obfuscation and spin tactics instead.

Anybody who claims to not understand what is meant by 'mutilation' in a discussion of circumcision is being disingenuous at best and downright dishonest at worst.
 
No, it means "mutilation". Circumcision is a form of mutilation. That you don't want this to be pointed out doesn't change that.

You must understand. I have no problem with you guys using the term "mutilation." That is your opinion, of which you are most abundantly entitled to. However, I refuse to have that word be thrown around in a dishonest manner. I just want to hear, in your own words, what you mean by "mutilation," and what it entails. If you happen to mention anything worse than a simple circumcion of the foreskin, then I will continue to be cautious with dealing with your terminology.




Yes. It is. Because it can pretty much mean anything you want it to mean. A minor alteration of something can be considered "mutilation" by some people. But most people think of the term "mutilation" as total destruction. And of course, the definitions as provided by Meriam Webster, Wikipedia, and etc. doesn't exactly help matters either.

But I ask this again, which has gone completely ignored and unanswered: What are you afraid of by using the proper technical terminology? Is it really all that different from a surgeon asking for a scalpel, or a catcher asking for a split-fingered fastball, or a mechanic asking for a monkey wrench?

Are you really this desperate now?

so, that is your response in proving how it is subjective? By accusing me in a rhetorical question that I am desperate?



... since you are not being rational and since you fail to grasp even the most basic concepts being discussed here that should hardly matter.

You're right. That is what I have said. I want some proof, instead of subjective arguments. Because subjective arguments hardly matter.
 
I actually stopped by my mother's house for lunch and casually mentioned this topic (maybe not fitting conversation to have over soup?). She mentioned she had me circumcised because A) I was [raised] Catholic (and that's what has always been done in our family) and B) it's easier to clean.

Do Catholics even know that they don't have to do it?

It depends on the diocese, and parish. Some Catholics, just like the Jews, do believe that circumcision is a sign of the covenant between Abraham and God.
 
1. Of course it's not: it's an ear!!
2. My religion prsecribes the amputation of the left ear lobe. Why is my religion less worthy than any other religion?

Was it brought up as a prohibition on unnecessary medical procedures were being written? If not, did you file a claim in court that your First Amendment rights were violated? If so, what was the final verdict?

3. Are you seriously claiming that no deaths have ever resulted from circumcisions?

I am not making that claim. I am asking for proof that it is a major concern if done in a professional, clinical environment.


4. How are we doing with the list of Christian sects...?

You're still on about this? :rolleyes:

I have already stated that Catholics do have it performed because of their faith numerous times. I have also admitted that the Vatican could care less one way or the other. But that doesn't mean that there are many Catholics who do it because they have that particular faith.
 
I believe this is the law in the US:



http://www.mgmbill.org/usfgmlaw.htm

ok, I can accept this. But is there a clinical reason to deny a religious custom or ritual? I mean, are the risks much greater, to the point that it is a very real threat to the girl? As I understand thus far, it seems as though female cutting has far worse consequences than males. Especially for infant females.
 
Why would the term 'circumcision' be used when referring to female genital mutilation, of any degree?
That's a bit rich coming from someone who has been lecturing us on the precise use of language and how mutilation cannot be used when referring to circumcision.

But it was, as provided in a post by someone else a few posts back.
 
So, defending the rights of religious people that have nothing to do with my religion shouldn't be done?


Did I say you shouldn't do that? I merely think we should be clear about the position.

Does that mean that I should not defend your right to NOT be told by society what religious practice you must do, even though you are of a "non-religious faith?"


There, you see, that's what happens when you put people on ignore. You make entirely unwarranted assumptions.

Does that mean I cannot defend the rights of free speech for the WBC, even though I literally HATE their message with all of my heart?

I would hardly think that should matter.


As I said, I just think we should be clear about the position, in view of all the falsehoods you posted about circumcision being a religious obligation on Christians.

Rolfe.
 
Anybody who claims to not understand what is meant by 'mutilation' in a discussion of circumcision is being disingenuous at best and downright dishonest at worst.

I am not being "dishonest." I am merely guarding against dishonesty.

I know it is probably not going to be easy to ask you to pretend to take the opposing view for a moment. But if you can, and truly remain unbiased in this demonstration I have been doing all along, you would see my point. Pretending to have the POV of the opposing side is a matter of vital skill to have when engaged in debate.

Now, pretend, if you will, that you do have my POV on the matter of circumcision. That you do believe that it is the person's right to perform circumcision.

Someone asks you this question:

"Do you think that male genital mutilation is fine?"

How would you answer this question, if you had to defend the position that circumcision is OK? Would you think this is an honest question? Would you think that is an honest term to use?
 
Did I say you shouldn't do that? I merely think we should be clear about the position.

This was the sentence you used in the post that I quoted:

"He seems to be going to bat for people of religions other than his own."

I was merely asking you if it should matter. I do believe in God, but no way in the world would I want atheists' First Amendment rights to be violated in any way.



There, you see, that's what happens when you put people on ignore. You make entirely unwarranted assumptions.

Well, I do apologize for making the assumption that you are an atheist. I just assumed you were, because you used the term "sky-daddy" in the post that I quoted. I think that is a rather derogatory way of expressing the word "God/god."




As I said, I just think we should be clear about the position, in view of all the falsehoods you posted about circumcision being a religious obligation on Christians.

Rolfe.

Since you cannot believe that there are Catholics, and break-away Amish, and so forth who circumcise based on their belief in the covenant between God and Abraham, I have dropped the argument for Christians a long time ago. I just don't feel that is a very constructive conversation to have, for it has nothing to do with the OP. The fact that there are other religions (Judaism, and Islam) that do practice the custom because of their belief system does not at all change the inherent nature of what I am arguing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom