Ban circumcision in San Fran???

Some things parents wish to do to their child in the name of religious ritual are benign and should be allowed. Others are barbaric and should be prohibited.

I just want to know who gets to decide which is which.

Rolfe.
 
That seems like an internal contradiction. At the moment the interested parties are allowed to make the decision based on the assumption that their children are their property to do with as they wish.

And I think that is wrong.

It's only "working out mostly right" if you think it's OK for boys to be deprived of the choice whether or not to be circumcised.

I meant it works fairly well for adults that are temporarily unable to communicate their decisions to their care takers. So we should apply the same principles with regard to children: Nobody should be allowed to do something to children that they would not also be allowed to do to an adult that they are temporarily responsible for.

You will always have the problem that if the majority of people are insane then some pretty bad stuff will be allowed. But we seem to mostly manage by simply setting up abstract principles for that kind of decisions where adults are concerned.

Nobody would have a right to chop of my earlobes or circumcise me if I was brought into a hospital after a car accident unconsciously: Having a foreskin or earlobes is not outright dangerous to me or my environemtn, it will not negatively effect my recovery and I could always decide in favor of the procedure at a later time should i be so inclined.
 
It seems to me the argument goes like this.

Religious group: What we do to our children is so minor and insignificant there's no reason to ban it. And besides, it's our tradition.

Everybody else: You call that minor? It's barbaric!

Religious group: You're just bigoted. It's nothing.

This could go on all week.

So who gets to decide whether something is minor enough to be acceptable, or not?

The religious group believe it should be for them and them only to make that decision. None of anybody else's business.

But if you go down that road, you're going to have circumcision, pharonisation, castration, tattooing, scarification, cutting off little fingers and virgin sacrifice being condoned.

The pro-circumcision arguments will serve just as well for any of these, because the proponents sincerely believe what they are doing is only minor, and justified by tradition and religion.

So - do we let the religious groups themselves decide what is OK, or do we impose an outside arbiter?

Rolfe.

It's simple. We let the children decide when they're old enough. Say 18.
 
It's simple. We let the children decide when they're old enough. Say 18.

Fine with me but Thunder already shot that one down with the observation that it's far easier to have part of your willy chopped off when you're a helpless baby.

As I wondered at the time, why would that be? Too obviously painful to consciously put yourself through? The fact that effectively you're wishing it on someone else long gone because you have no memory of being a helpless baby?

Doesn't this show that anyone who can choose would be far less (to the point of almost none existent) likely to actually go through with it?

Oh no! I'm told that many fully-grown men will volunteer to have the op done then.

So, I guess that confirms it. There is no problem with circumcisions being performed at 18 and I concur with Rolfe, that you win the thread.

Also extra points for Menalitus as I know exactly what he means and it is something that I now realize had disturbed me too:

You guys crack me up, you have got to be nuts to try and suggest that circumcision does not reduce sensitivity. I know this is not exactly a controlled experiment but I am not circumcised, if I pull back my foreskin and walk around with my old fella going commando in my underwear it is uncomfortable due to the sensitivity of the exposed head.
 
It's simple. We let the children decide when they're old enough. Say 18.

Seriously you do have to wonder why this doesn't strike those who are for circumcising babies who do not even have a religious "reason" as the sensible approach once they learn that the so-called benefits are so slight at the absolute best.
 
Who gives their kids ear piercings against their will?

You'd be surprised. I used to do ear piercings in a mall, and we wouldn't do it on children under the age of 3 months. People came up with children just out of the hospital looking to get it done. Three month olds didn't know what was going on, but surely they had no input about it. Those were the easy ones. It's the 4-7 year olds who said they wanted it but when the gun came close they would scream like crazy that were awful.
 
Seriously you do have to wonder why this doesn't strike those who are for circumcising babies who do not even have a religious "reason" as the sensible approach once they learn that the so-called benefits are so slight at the absolute best.

I think it's for reasons I outlined in my first post. They are trying to "prove" that it's ok so that they don't have to live with the fact that they have been mutilated. It's the same issues as life-after-death for people who are scared to live in the real world. I can completely understand why they would want to convince themselves it's ok. I would be horrified if someone had chopped of part of my willy.

Where I draw the line is in forcing children to have this done to them. At least in african tribal society they make them do it themselves with a sharp stone when they transition to manhood.
 
Who gives their kids ear piercings against their will?
Many people, unfortunately. Thunder and Nihilianth [has] been using this argument repeatedly from the beginning, despite the obvious logical fallacy. Even while ignoring other people's comparisons of comparable behavior, they use this as validation for circumcision. It's the equivalent of a 5 year old girl saying "Suzy gets to do it, why can't I?"

Before you bring it up, Thunder, I've been reading this thread from the beginning. I'm just now posting because I thought you two would've given up by now.

Fixed it for ya. ;)
 
Who gives their kids ear piercings against their will?
Many people, unfortunately. Thunder and Nihilianth [has] been using this argument repeatedly from the beginning, despite the obvious logical fallacy. Even while ignoring other people's comparisons of comparable behavior, they use this as validation for circumcision. It's the equivalent of a 5 year old girl saying "Suzy gets to do it, why can't I?"

Before you bring it up, Thunder, I've been reading this thread from the beginning. I'm just now posting because I thought you two would've given up by now.

Fixed it for ya. ;)

About the bolded:

So cutting off arms, legs, hands, feet, and stabbing babies are comparable behaviors, but ear-piercings are not?

Ok. :boggled:
 
Because you think that religion is an acceptable excuse for needlessly committing harm to babies, even though you admit it's morally unacceptable.

First, I didn;t necessarily say it was "morally unacecptable." That was the conclusion you came to. I did say I can accept the idea of it being morally unacceptable. But my personal opinions on the situation (which doesn't matter at all. Nobody's does, really,) is that I kinda sit on the fence about it. It isn't all that big a deal, really.



You're the one who keeps pointing out how everyone else's comparisons are flawed; this one is no better. Freedom of speech is not the same as a license to cut bits off children.

Dave

That wasn't the comparison I was making. I was making the comparison between two moral dilemmas. You and others were making the argument that "it is immoral." I was making the argument that morality doesn't matter, and is not an argument to use when making and enforcing laws.
 
You guys crack me up, you have got to be nuts to try and suggest that circumcision does not reduce sensitivity. I know this is not exactly a controlled experiment but I am not circumcised, if I pull back my foreskin and walk around with my old fella going commando in my underwear it is uncomfortable due to the sensitivity of the exposed head.

Uh, it's called "underwear."

I assume that someone who is cut is not continually in discomfort, ergo the sensitivity is reduced from being continually exposed. Either way you can be sure it is not MORE sensitive so ha ha on you for having a numb knob :)

It makes the glans "numb? " Ok. Care to defend this?

Additionally it is pathetic to try and insist that cutting a bit of flesh from the end of a non anesthetized baby's penis is somehow acceptable. The fact that a baby does not remember it and somehow trying to call parental choice is an outrageous non-justification. How many of you would volunteer for this same procedure if you were given the choice (and I mean the SAME procedure, no anesthetic)? If you would not then you should be ashamed of yourselves for trying to justify its application to anyone else of any age.

:mad:

It wouldn't be the same procedure then. :rolleyes:
 
Who does make the decision now? It seems to be working out mostly right. We just have to stop pretending that children are property of their parents and all would be good.

Likewise. We have to not pretend that parents and private families are not properties of the state and society either.
 
Seriously you do have to wonder why this doesn't strike those who are for circumcising babies who do not even have a religious "reason" as the sensible approach once they learn that the so-called benefits are so slight at the absolute best.

Which is why we probably won't circumcise our kids when they are born. We have no religious reason to do so.
 
I think it's for reasons I outlined in my first post. They are trying to "prove" that it's ok so that they don't have to live with the fact that they have been mutilated.

Non-sequitor. Prove this is true.

It's the same issues as life-after-death for people who are scared to live in the real world. I can completely understand why they would want to convince themselves it's ok. I would be horrified if someone had chopped of part of my willy.

If you say so.

Where I draw the line is in forcing children to have this done to them. At least in african tribal society they make them do it themselves with a sharp stone when they transition to manhood.

Different cultures. Different religions. Different practices.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom